8
Department of Veterans Affairs Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development Vol . 34 No . 3, July 1997 Pages 295-302 Biomechanical properties of human tibias in long-term spinal cord injury Thay Q Lee, MS ; Todd A. Shapiro, BS ; David M . Bell, MD Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory, PACT, Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Long Beach VA Medical Center; Long Beach, CA 90822 ; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of California Irvine Medical Center, Orange, CA 92868 Abstract—Long-term spinal cord injury (SCI) profoundly alters skeletal structure and function . In this study, the biome- chanical properties of tibias from persons with SCI and from individuals closely matched in age and size but without SCI were quantified at both the structural and material levels. Nondestructive torsion tests were performed to determine apparent shear moduli for the tibia. The cortical thicknesses and polar moment of inertia were determined numerically. Four-point bending tests were performed to determine flexural modulus of elasticity on cortical bone specimens of the tibia. The apparent shear moduli of the SCI tibias were found to be lower than the non-SCI tibias (p<0 .05) . The cortical thick- nesses of the SCI tibias were significantly thinner than the con- trol tibias (p<0.05), while the polar moment of inertia showed no significant differences between control and SCI tibial cross sections (p>0.5) . The flexural modulus of elasticity of the cor- tical bone specimens were lower in the SCI tibias than the con- trols (p<0 .05) . These differences suggest that tibias may undergo micro-structural changes as well as structural adapta- tion following SCI, which alter their mechanical properties. Key words : biomechanics, bone, spinal cord injury, tibia. This material is based upon work supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs, Rehabilitation Research and Development Service, Washington, DC 20420, and the California Orthopaedic Research Institute. Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to : Thay Q Lee, MS, Biomedical Engineer/Associate Clinical Professor, Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory (151), Long Beach VA Medical Center, 5701 E . 7th Street, Long Beach, CA 90822; email : tqlee@pop.long-beach.va .gov . INTRODUCTION Permanent damage to the spinal cord is a tragic injury, with devastating manifestations in multiple organ systems, including bone structure and metabolism (1-3). Not only is motor function irreversibly lost, but signifi- cant attrition of bone mass occurs below the level of the cord lesion (4-6) . It is empirically known that the osteo- porosis below the level of the spinal cord injury (SCI) far exceeds the normal attrition of bone mass associated with aging, bed rest, immobilization, or disuse due to disorders other than paralysis (7) . In persons with SCI, bone under- goes resorption as evidenced by increased urinary excre- tion of calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, and hydrox- yproline immediately after injury (8-10) . Bone mineral and density studies have shown that most bone loss occurs in the lower limbs . Loss of bone mass is most rapid in the first 4 months following complete SCI, and falls to two-thirds of the original bone mass at 16 months (11) . Other density studies have shown that bone mineral content in persons with chronic SCI falls to 25 percent less than normal in the proximal femur, and 50 percent less in the proximal tibia (12). This loss of bone mass results in significant decrease in the structural integrity of the skeleton, and the risk of pathologic fractures is greatly increased . Investigations of bone mineral density using dual photon absorptiometry indicate a much higher incidence of fractures among per- sons with SCI, with fracture rates reaching 10 times that 295

Karakteristike Tibije Rad

  • Upload
    edin

  • View
    9

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Karakteristike Tibije Rad

Citation preview

Page 1: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

Department ofVeterans Affairs

Journal of Rehabilitation Research andDevelopment Vol . 34 No . 3, July 1997Pages 295-302

Biomechanical properties of human tibias in long-term spinalcord injury

Thay Q Lee, MS ; Todd A. Shapiro, BS ; David M. Bell, MDOrthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory, PACT, Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Long Beach VAMedical Center; Long Beach, CA 90822 ; Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of California Irvine MedicalCenter, Orange, CA 92868

Abstract—Long-term spinal cord injury (SCI) profoundlyalters skeletal structure and function . In this study, the biome-chanical properties of tibias from persons with SCI and fromindividuals closely matched in age and size but without SCIwere quantified at both the structural and material levels.Nondestructive torsion tests were performed to determineapparent shear moduli for the tibia. The cortical thicknessesand polar moment of inertia were determined numerically.Four-point bending tests were performed to determine flexuralmodulus of elasticity on cortical bone specimens of the tibia.The apparent shear moduli of the SCI tibias were found to belower than the non-SCI tibias (p<0 .05) . The cortical thick-nesses of the SCI tibias were significantly thinner than the con-trol tibias (p<0.05), while the polar moment of inertia showedno significant differences between control and SCI tibial crosssections (p>0.5) . The flexural modulus of elasticity of the cor-tical bone specimens were lower in the SCI tibias than the con-trols (p<0.05) . These differences suggest that tibias mayundergo micro-structural changes as well as structural adapta-tion following SCI, which alter their mechanical properties.

Key words : biomechanics, bone, spinal cord injury, tibia.

This material is based upon work supported by the Department ofVeterans Affairs, Rehabilitation Research and Development Service,Washington, DC 20420, and the California Orthopaedic ResearchInstitute.Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to : Thay Q Lee, MS,Biomedical Engineer/Associate Clinical Professor, Orthopaedic BiomechanicsLaboratory (151), Long Beach VA Medical Center, 5701 E . 7th Street, LongBeach, CA 90822; email : [email protected] .gov .

INTRODUCTION

Permanent damage to the spinal cord is a tragicinjury, with devastating manifestations in multiple organsystems, including bone structure and metabolism (1-3).Not only is motor function irreversibly lost, but signifi-cant attrition of bone mass occurs below the level of thecord lesion (4-6) . It is empirically known that the osteo-porosis below the level of the spinal cord injury (SCI) farexceeds the normal attrition of bone mass associated withaging, bed rest, immobilization, or disuse due to disordersother than paralysis (7) . In persons with SCI, bone under-goes resorption as evidenced by increased urinary excre-tion of calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, and hydrox-yproline immediately after injury (8-10) . Bone mineraland density studies have shown that most bone lossoccurs in the lower limbs . Loss of bone mass is mostrapid in the first 4 months following complete SCI, andfalls to two-thirds of the original bone mass at 16 months(11) . Other density studies have shown that bone mineralcontent in persons with chronic SCI falls to 25 percentless than normal in the proximal femur, and 50 percentless in the proximal tibia (12).

This loss of bone mass results in significant decreasein the structural integrity of the skeleton, and the risk ofpathologic fractures is greatly increased . Investigations ofbone mineral density using dual photon absorptiometryindicate a much higher incidence of fractures among per-sons with SCI, with fracture rates reaching 10 times that

295

Page 2: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

296

Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Deve'opment Vol . 340o 31997

of the general population (13) . For the remainder of theirlives, these persons are susceptible to bony injury fromthe trivial forces encountered in daily living . Fracturesare a serious additional disability to the persons withchronic SCI, whose remaining abilities are already maxi-mized to retain the highest possible self-sufficiency indaily life . That margin of independence can be overcomewhen self-care and transfer capabilities are encumberedby limb immobilization or surgical procedures requiredfollowing uyudhologicu! fracture . Such pathologic frau-iuu:xoouy also lead to long-tenn complications such asskin breakdown, malunion, and deformity, and in somecases, infection and gangrene.

Investigations into the severe osteoporosis of per-sons with SCI have focused on the specific characteristicsof the fractures and the persons affected, and on metabol-ic and bone density alterations found in these persons(10.13-10) . To date, the biomechanical changes in theindividual bones of persons with SCI have not beendescribed or quantified in the literature . The hypothesisof this study was that the bone in persons with chronicSCI undergoes alterations that severely degrade itubio-oueohouical properties. The tibia provides an excellentspecimen for study of pathologic bone in SCI, since themost severe osteopenia is found in the lower limbs ofboth persons with quadriplegia and paraplegia (11,12).Also, 18 percent (13) to 41 percent (16) of all the frac-tures in persons with SCI occur in the tibia. The objec-tives of this study were to quantify the structural, geo-metric, and material properties of human tibias of persons

with chronic SCI and compare them to control specimensclosely matched in age and size.

METHODS

OverviewThree types of biomechanical properties were inves-

tigated. Structural properties were determined using anondestructive torsion test . Geometric properties, includ-ing cortical thicknesses and polar moment of inertia, weremeasured at four different levels of tibial cross sections.Material properties of the cortical bone were determinedfor each quadrant at three different levels of the tibiausing a four-point bending test.

Specimens

Four pairs of fresh frozen whole tibias closelymatched in size and age were used for this study (Table

&) .AJ!tibias were macroscopically intact with no appar-ontuhuonna0dea. Specimens were also radiographed toscreen for previous fractures or destructive lesions . Fourof the tibias were amputated from persons with long-termSCI, and four (controls) from persons without SCI . Allspecimens were male, and all amputations were due toperipheral vascular disease.

Nondestructive Torsion TestsNondestructive torsion tests were perfoll ied to

determine apparent shear moduli for the entire diaphyseal

Table 1.Specimen information.

Age Years Length Weight Weight/Length

60 42 39.5 351 8 .968 48 44.5 536 12 .068 48 44.5 535 12 .068 36 39.0 425 10 .9

Mean 66 .0 43.5 41 .9 461.8 11 .0SEM 2 .0 2.9 1 .5 45.2 0 .7

Control70 N/A 36.0 318 8 .869 N/A 42 .0 581 13 .862 N/A 41 .0 615 15 .068 N/A 36 .5 392 10 .7

Mean 67 .3 N/A 38 .9 476.5 12.1SEM 1 .8 N/A 1 .5 72.1 1 .4

Years = since SCI; length in cm ; weight (wet) in g ; weight/length in :/cm ; SEM = standard error of the mean.

Page 3: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

297

LEE et al . Biomechanics of Bone in SCI

region of the tibia as well as for its proximal middle anddistal regions . Each tibia was thoroughly cleaned of allsoft tissue and was kept moist by regular irrigation with0.9 percent saline . The total length of each tibia wasdetermined by measuring from the intercondylar emi-nence to the tip of the medial malleolus . Tibias weredivided into five regions, each consisting of 20 percent ofthe total length (Figure 1) . Between each region, 0 .889mm threaded Kirschner wires (K-wires) were insertedinto the bone to measure the regional angular deforma-tion of the tibia. The tibia was then mounted onto a cus-tom jig specifically designed to hold the specimen so thatthe axis of rotation coincided with the long axis of thebone (Figure 2) . The proximal and distal ends of the tib-ias were rigidly fixed in the jig using fixation screws andthen potted using dental stone . Before each of the torsiontests was performed, a pre-load of 3 N-m was applied intorsion and then cycled 10 times from 0 .5° to 2 .5° at a fre-quency of 0 .125 Hz for pre-conditioning . The specimenwas allowed to recover for 30 min in an unloaded state.

distal

region 3

-I-- cross section 3

region 2

Length of the tibia

-t(-- cross section 2

region 1

E- cross section 1

proximal

Figure 1.A schematic drawing showing the geometric proportions used to spec-ify each region of the tibia . Each region was 20% of the total length.The four cross-sectional slices used for geometric assessment yieldedthree mid-diaphyseal regions (proximal, middle, and distal) for bio-mechanical testing .

MTS Actuator

K-Wire

ReflectiveMarker

Video Processor

Video CassetteRecorder

486 P.C.

Video DigitizingSystem (VDS)

Macintosh IlciLabView

Figure 2.A schematic drawing showing the testing setup . Note the MTS and thetibial fixation jig used for application of angular deformation and mea-surement of torque . Kirschner wires and the video digitizing system(VDS) used for the measurement of angular deformation at the proxi-mal, middle, and distal diaphyseal region are also shown.

At the end of the recovery period, a pre-torque of 3 N-mwas again applied to the tibia and then cycled 10 timesfrom 1 .0° to 5 .0° at the same frequency of 0 .125 Hz.Torsion tests were performed for both internal and exter-nal rotation, using the MTS machine (MTS SystemsCorporation, Minneapolis, MN) with a 30-min recoveryperiod between each test.

Measurements of torque, rotation, and time wererecorded at a frequency of 5 Hz by LabVIEW® (NationalInstruments, Austin, TX), an analog-to-digital programinstalled on a Macintosh Ilci (Apple Computer,Cupertino, CA) . Angular deformation was measuredusing a video digitizing system that recorded the move-ment of reflective markers attached to the K-wires insert-ed into the bone (17) . The video digitizing system (VDS)utilizes a high-resolution video camera, a studio-gradevideo cassette recorder (Panasonic AG-6300), a high-res-olution monitor (Panasonic TR-124MA), a microproces-sor (Motion Analysis VP-320) and a 486 PC computer torun the data acquisition software . The VDS software cal-culates the centroid of the reflective markers, and digi-tizes their displacement within ±5 R m . Previous testshave documented the accuracy of the VDS (17).

rF- cross section 4

DistalFixationCylinder

Fixation

ZPlaster

ProximalFixationCylinder

" glaMl"...011WMTS Load Cell

Page 4: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

298

Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development Vol . 34 No . 3 1997

Geometric AssessmentTransverse sections of the tibia were cut perpendic-

ular to the long axis of the bone using an ISOMET(Buehler, Lake Bluff, IL) low speed diamond wheel sawin constant 0 .9 percent saline lubrication . After section-ing, trabecular bone was removed from the center of thecross section . These bone cross sections were directlyscanned using a Hewlett Packard Scan Jet IIC scanner(Hewlett Packard, Palo Alto, CA) . The scanned imageswere then analyzed using a modified SLICER program,developed by Nagurka and Hayes, to determine the corti-cal thicknesses in the anterior, posterior, medial, and lat-eral quadrants, and to calculate the polar moment of iner-tia of the tibial cross sections (18) .

InstronCrosshead

Moment of Inertia Flexural Modulus of ElasticityI= b

12

E_ PPa (a +

2Y

Lat

Calculation of the Apparent Shear ModulusThe data from the nondestructive torsion test and

the geometric cross-section data were then used to cal-culate the apparent shear moduli for the proximal, mid-dle, and distal regions of the tibia using the followingequation:

Equation : G = (T)(L)/(4))(J)

G = apparent shear modulus(I) = angle of twist measured by the video digitiz-

ing systemT = torque measured by the MTSL = length of the region,J = polar moment of inertia measured by Slicer

program

Four-Point Bending TestsThe flexural modulus of elasticity of the cortical

bone specimens were determined by performing four-point bending test to failure (Figure 3) . Match-stick typestrips were obtained from the 4 quadrants (anterior, pos-terior, medial, lateral) at each of the 3 mid-diaphysealregions, yielding a total of 12 match sticks per tibia . Thestrips were cut from cortical bone using an ISOMET dia-mond saw, then sanded using an ISOMET grinder/pol-isher to produce the match-stick-type specimen measur-ing 3 X 3X 60 mm . Each was subjected to a four-pointbending test to failure, using an Instron machine at aloading rate of 50 mm/min in a constant temperaturesaline bath. The direction of loading was from theendosteal cortex to the periosteal cortex, and all testswere performed at 22 °C .

I = moment of inertiab = width of the beamh = height of the beamE = Flexural modulus of elasticityP = Pressure of crosshead

Figure 3.A schematic drawing showing the origin of the matchstick type spec-imen representing each quadrant . These specimens were used for four-point bending tests and the configuration of the four-point bending testused for the calculation of flexural modulus of elasticity is also shown.

Statistical AnalysisThe data were analyzed using multivariate ANOVA

with a significance level of 0 .05.

RESULTS

Nondestructive Torsion TestAs indicated in Figure 4, the apparent shear moduli

of the SCI tibias were found to be smaller than that of thecontrol tibias (p<0 .05) . The individual comparisonbetween the SCI tibias and the control tibias for regionone (proximal), region two (middle), and region three(distal) of the tibial diaphysis showed a statistically sig-nificant decrease in apparent shear moduli of the SCI tib-ias only for the proximal region during internal rotation(p<0.05) . The mean values for the apparent shear moduliof the control tibias exceeded those of SCI tibias for all

Page 5: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

299

LEE et al. Biomechanics of Bone in SCI

Figure 4.A graph showing the apparent shear moduli for proximal, middle, anddistal region of the tibial diaphysis . The apparent shear moduli mea-sured from both the internal and external torsion are shown . Note thatthe values for SCI specimens are consistently lower than those of thecontrol specimens.

regions in both internal and external rotation; however,these differences were not statistically significant(p>0.2).

Geometric AssessmentThe anterior, posterior, medial, and lateral cortical

thicknesses for both the SCI and control tibias are shownin Table 2. Overall, the cortical thicknesses were signifi-cantly thinner for SCI tibias compared to the controls(P<0.05) . The cortical thicknesses of the tibial cross sec-tions for both groups decreased significantly from cross

N

EXTERNAL ROTATION

—!— CONTROL

q SCI

I

IProximal Middle

Distal

INTERNAL ROTATION

I

I

L.

Proximal Middle

Distala)

section one (proximal) to cross section four (distal) of thetibia (p<0.05) . Individual comparison of the cross sec-tions and quadrants between SCI and control tibias onlydemonstrated statistical significance in the posteriorquadrant of cross section one, three (middle/distal), andfour, and in the anterior and medial quadrants of crosssection four (p<0.05).

In both SCI and control tibias, the polar moment ofinertia decreased from the proximal to the distal crosssection (p<0.05) . However, no significant differences(p>0.5) were found between SCI and control tibias in thepolar moment of inertia measurements at each cross sec-tional level (Figure 5).

Four-Point Bending TestAs shown in Figure 6, the flexural modulus of elas-

ticity of all quadrants was lower for SCI tibias when com-pared to controls (p<0 .05). Region and quadrant com-parison between groups only showed a statistical signifi-cance between SCI and control tibias in the medial andlateral quadrants of region 2 (p<0 .05).

DISCUSSION

Pathophysiology of Spinal Cord Injury OsteoporosisCurrent understanding of the pathophysiology of

osteoporosis following SCI is based upon considerationsof mechanical stress deprivation, metabolic and hormon-al changes, and neurological and autonomic alterations . It

( -~-' CONTROL , --O-- SCI )

Figure 5.A graph showing the flexural modulus of elasticity for each quadrantat proximal, middle, and distal region of the tibial diaphysis areshown . Note that the values for SCI specimens are consistently lowerthan those of the control specimens .

Proximal

Middle

Distal

ANTERIOR MEDIAL

Proximal

Middle

Distal

POSTERIOR

Proximal

Middle

Distal i

LATERAL

5.

0"

4-

Page 6: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

300

Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development Vol . 34 No . 3 1997

Table 2.Cortical thickness .

Anterior Posterior Medial Lateral

SCISlice 1 4 .6±1 .7 2 .6±0 .2* 2 .8±0 .8 2 .7±0 .6Slice 2 5 .9± 1 .8 3 .6±0 .1 3 .5±0.2 3 .9±0 .7Slice 3 7 .1±2 .0 3 .7±0 .6* 3 .4±0 .3 3 .9±0 .7Slice 4 3 .3±0 .7* 2 .4±0 .4* 2 .4±0.2* 3 .0±0 .6

ControlSlice 1 6 .7 ± 1 .7 4 .3±0 .6* 3 .3±0 .5 2 .7±0 .1Slice 2 9 .7± 1 .1 5 .4±0 .6 4 .1 ±0 .4 3 .7±0 .2Slice 3 9 .8± 1 .4 6 .2±0 .6* 4 .5±0 .5 4 .6±0 .4Slice 4 5 .3±0 .4* 4 .7±0 .2* 3 .5±0 .1* 4 .3±0 .5

Thickness in mm; means ± SE

strandard error of the mean) ; * = statistically significant difference between groups (p<0 .05).

Figure 6.A histogram showing the polar moment of inertia (7) for each of thefour tibial cross-sections . Note that the values for SCI specimens arenot statistically different from those of the control specimens.

is well known that mechanical forces influence the struc-ture and function of bone . According to Wolff's law, boneremodels over time in response to mechanical loading,and dependent on its direction, rate, and magnitude (19).Thus, the structural integrity of the skeleton is maintainedin response to gravity and mechanical loading, anddiminished in response to immobilization or disuse . Inpersons with paraplegia and quadriplegia, who are unableto bear weight on their lower limbs and who are sitting or

recumbent the majority of the time, the limbs are notexposed to the forces that are required to stimulate boneformation . Some investigators have speculated that theabsence of muscle tension and weight bearing may notonly fail to stimulate any osteoblastic activity, but mayalso trigger massive osteoclastic resorption (11) . Treat-ments and preventative measures based on these mechan-ical factors, however, have not been effective in reversingSCI osteoporosis (12).

In addition to mechanical factors, metabolic andholtuonal alterations may be responsible for the SCIosteoporosis . There is direct evidence of bone mineraland matrix resorption in urinary excretion studies of cal-cium, phosphorus, hydroxyproline, and other compo-nents (1,3,8,9) . Documented alterations in hormones,such as parathyroid hormone, calcitonin, and glucocorti-coids, potentially contribute to bone mass attrition, yet itis unclear if the alterations are primary or secondarymechanisms (1,2) . Abnormal hydroxylation of proline inbone collagen also has been demonstrated (8) . Treatmentsto modify bone metabolism, such as disphosphonates andcalcium supplementation, however, have not significant-ly altered the bony resorption. Also, changes in the auto-nomic nervous system are proposed to cause attrition ofSCI bone, via changes in vascular tone and flow (1,9).Sympathetic denervation in SCI may cause arterio-venous shunts and a slowdown of intraosseous bloodflow, thus increasing bone resorption.

Despite many causative factors, bone loss followingSCI is severe and rapid. Bone mineral and density studieshave demonstrated that most bone loss is in the lowerlimbs and occurs rapidly in the first 4 months after com-plete cord injury, falling to two-thirds of the original bone

® CONTROL

0 SCI

a

a

1

a

a

a

a

l

t

a

a

a

I5

10

15

POLAR MOMENT OF INERTIA

(1 O mm4)

Page 7: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

301

LEE et al . Biomechanics of Bone in SCI

mass at 16 months (11) . Other density studies showedthat bone mineral content in persons with chronic SCIfalls to 25 percent lower than normal in the proximalfemur, and 50 percent lower in the proximal tibia (12).This loss of bone mass results in significant weakness inthe structural integrity of the skeleton, and the risk ofpathologic fractures is greatly increased . The high inci-dence of fractures in persons with complete SCI is welldemonstrated, with their fracture rate being 10 times thatof the general population (13).

Pathologic Fractures in Persons with Spinal CordInjury

Clinical data on fractures in persons with SCIbecame more evident in the literature in the 1950s and1960s as survival beyond the acute spinal injury becamepossible . In 1963, Eichenholtz reported 4 percent of theirentire SCI population had long bone fractures (15).Treatments acceptable to "normal" persons resulted inserious complications, such as skin slough, pressuresores, and amputation . Comarr et al . found that over halfof all of fractures occurred in the lower limbs (14).Freehafer et al . found an overall incidence of fractures of3 percent (16,20) . McMaster and Stauffer classified sub-jects into three categories : acute fractures concomitantwith the SCI, pathologic fractures in osteoporotic limbs,and the relatively uncommon high energy injuries inosteoporotic extremities (10) . Nottage found a majorityof SCI fractures in chronically pathologic bone (21).

Ragnarsson et al . noted long bone fractures in 4 per-cent of their SCI population, most commonly in thesupracondylar distal femur (33 percent), femoral shaft(30 percent) and tibial shaft (18 percent) . The study alsonoted a tenfold higher risk of pathologic fractures in com-plete SCI compared to incomplete injury, and that sub-jects with paraplegia had an even higher rate than thosewith quadriplegia (13) . Sex, age, time from injury, orspastic versus flaccid paralysis had no bearing on theincidence of fractures . Garland et al . found that nonoper-ative treatment of acute fractures concomitant to theacute spinal injury resulted in a higher complication ratesuch as deformities, nonunions, and pressure sores (22).

Results of Biomechanical InvestigationThe research in the SCI osteoporosis has been

focused on the specific characteristics of the fracturesalong with persons affected, and on metabolic and bonedensity alterations found in almost all persons with SCI.To date, the biomechanical changes in the individual

bones of persons with SCI have not been well describedor quantified . With the affiliation of a large SCI center atthe VA Medical Center, Long Beach, this study had theopportunity to examine in detail the biomechanical prop-erties of tibias from persons with SCI . This study presentsthe structural, geometric, and material properties of thesetibias and their comparison with control specimens close-ly matched in age and size.

The results of this biomechanical study are consis-tent with the basic science and clinical research into thebone atrophy following SCI . Both the structural andmaterial properties and cortical thicknesses of SCI tibiaswere significantly inferior to control specimens, andappear to be consistent with the high incidence of loss ofbone density and pathologic fractures . The apparent shearmoduli showed greater difference in the proximal regionbetween the SCI tibias and the control tibias . Although itcannot be delineated whether this is an adaptation at thestructural level or the material level, the adaptive changesdue to SCI were greater in the the proximal tibia as com-pared to the distal tibia . The cortical thicknesses of SCIspecimens were significantly thinner that the controls(p<0.05) . However, in region-specific analyses, the sta-tistically significant differences were seen in slice four,the most distal cross section for anterior, posterior, andmedial quadrants . The remaining differences were seen inthe posterior quadrant, of cross-sectional slices one andthree . The data show that the posterior quadrant under-went the greatest amount of cortical thinning due to SCIas compared to the other regions . Also, anterior and pos-terior cortical thickness were no more inferior distallythan proximally, again demonstrating no regional differ-ences in level of bone atrophy . The polar moments ofinertia were neither inferior nor superior to controls . Thisindicates that some cortical thinning was compensatedfor by the increase in the cortical diameters to achievesimilar value in polar moment of inertia . The proximalregions of the tibial diaphysis of the SCI specimens werenot any less affected than distal regions in material prop-erties as indicated by the flexural modulus of elasticity. Ifthe alterations in blood flow are a causative factor in SCIbone atrophy, one might assume that variations in perfu-sion across proximal-to-distal segments might causeincreased atrophy proximally. No such regional differ-ence in bone strength was apparent in this investigation.

It is hoped that this baseline information on the tib-ias of persons with SCI will advance the understanding ofthe mechanisms behind the profound bony changes ofSCI. Further basic science and clinical investigation may

Page 8: Karakteristike Tibije Rad

302

Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development Vol . 34 No . 3 1997

bring progress toward the effective prevention and treat-ment of this difficult complication of a devastating injury.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors would like to acknowledge the contributionsof Harry B . Skinner, MD, PhD; Elizabeth A . Yetzer, MA, MSN,CRRN; Alvin C. Lin, BS ; and Richard Kim, BS.

REFERENCES

1. Bergmann P, Heilporn A . Longitudinal study of calcium andbone metabolism in paraplegic patients . Paraplegia 1977-78 :15 :147-59.

2. Claus-Walker J, Halstead L . Metabolic and endocrine changesin spinal cord injury : consequences of partial decentralizationof the autonomic nervous system . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1982 :63 :569-75.

3. Naftchi NE, Viau AT, Heiner Sell G, Lowman EW. Mineralmetabolism in spinal cord injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil1980 :61 :139-42.

4. Elias AN, Gwinup G. Immobilization osteoporosis in paraple-gia . J Am Paraplegia Soc 1985 :15 :3.

5. Kaplan PE, Gandhavadi B, Richards L, Goldschmidt J.Calcium balance in paraplegic patients : influence of injuryduration and ambulation . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1978 :59 :447-50.

6. Riggs BL . Differential changes in bone mineral density in theappendicular and axial skeleton with aging : relationship tospinal osteoporosis . J Clin Invest 1981 :67 :328-35.

7. Albright F, Burnett CH . Acute atrophy of bone (osteoporosis)simulating hyperparathyroidism . J Clin Endocrinol Metab1941 :1 :711-6.

8. Chantraine A. Actual concept of osteoporosis in paraplegia.Paraplegia 1978-79 :16 :51-8.

9. Chantraine A. Clinical investigation of bone metabolism inspinal cord lesions . Paraplegia 1970-71 :8 :253-9.

10. McMaster W, Stauffer ES . The management of long bone frac-ture in the spinal cord injured patient . Clin Orthop1975 :112 :44-52.

11. Garland DE, Stewart CA, Adkins RH, et al . Osteoporosis afterspinal cord injury. J Orthop Res 1992 :10 :371-8.

12. Biering-Sorensen F, Bohr H, Schaadt O . Bone mineral contentof the lumbar spine and lower extremities years after spinalcord lesion. Paraplegia 1988 :26 :293-301.

13. Ragnarsson KT, Heiner Sell G. Lower extremity fractures afterspinal cord injury . Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1981 :62 :418-23.

14. Comarr AE, Hutchinson RH, Bors E . Extremity fractures ofpatients with spinal cord injuries Am J Surg 1962 :103 :732-9.

15. Eichenholtz SN. Management of long-bone fractures in para-plegic patients . J Bone Joint Surg 1963 :2(45A) :299-310.

16. Freehafer AA, Hazel CM, Becker CL. Lower extremity frac-tures in patients with spinal cord injury. Paraplegia 1981:19:367-72.

17. Lee TQ, Lewis DA, Kim WC, Anzel SH . Nondestructive bio-mechanical assessment of intact and reconstructed hips . In:Vossoughi J, ed . Biomedical engineering and recent develop-ments . Proceedings of the 13th Southern Biomedical Engi-neering Conference ; 1994, Washington, DC . Washington,DC:University of Washington, DC, 1994 :13 :427-9.

18. Nagurka ML, Hayes WC . An interactive graphics package forcalculating cross-sectional properties of complex shapes . JBiomech 1980 :13 :59-64.

19. Woo SL, Kuei SC, Amiel D, et al . The effect of prolonged phys-ical training on the properties of long bone : a study of Wolff'sLaw. J Bone Joint Surg 1981 :5(63A) :780-6.

20. Freehafer AA, Mast WA . Lower extremity fractures in patientswith spinal cord injury . J Bone Joint Surg 1965:4(47A) :683-94.

21. Nottage WM. A review of long-bone fractures in patients withspinal cord injuries . Clin Orthop 1981 :155 :65-70.

22. Garland DE, Rieser TV, Singer DI . Treatment of femoral shaftfractures associated with acute spinal cord injuries . Clin Orthop1987 :197 :191-5.

Submitted for publication July 25, 1996 . Accepted in revised formFebruary 3, 1997 .