8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

1/77

!"#$%& ()*+,-./ $0122345678 9:7; *+,

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

2/77

,X8 D:\8-V]8VT 5:]]ZV.[6T.:V7 486^_Z6-T8-7 FTX8-7

G87a:V^8VT7

3 6V^ 3

E]V87TW *VT8-V6T.:V6Y K.].T8^

S:Z-TX5Y6.]6VT

3 6V^ 3,X8 C8[Z-.TW C8-\.[8 FTX8-7 G87a:V^8VT7

3 6V^ 3

JWT87 S:- EYY S.LTX 5Y6.]6VT3 6V^ 3

,X8 C8[-8T6-W :L CT6T8 L:- S:-8.bV 6V^5:]]:VU86YTX ELL6.-7 FTX8-7

G87a:V^8VT7

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = == = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

M- M6TTX8U GW^8- R5= P- A-.[ M8T[6YL8 6V^ M- A^U6-^ 5-6\8V >?,@7ABC78- DE N6]87I8Y[X :L K./8-TW F G&A 7H8S.-7T 6V^ ,X.-^ 5Y6.]6VT7 6V^ FTX8-7

M- P6V C_Z.-87 6V^ M- J8V N6LL8W >?,@7ABC78- DE JX6TT MZ-aXW C:Y.[.T:-7 F G&A 7H8C8[:V^6V^ S.LTX 5Y6.]6VT7

M7 ).-7TW J-.]8Y:U R5 6V^ M- NZ^8 JZVT.Vb >?,@7ABC78- DE E]V87TW *VT8-V6T.:V6Y KTFG&A 7H8S:Z-TX 5Y6.]6VT

M- N6]87 A6^.8 R5= M- J8V 4::a8- 6V^ M- NZY.6V M.YL:-^ >?,@7ABC78- DE TX8 ,-867Z-WC:Y.[.T:- F G&A EYY G87a:V^8VT7

M- M6-T.V 5X6]/8-Y6.V R5 6V^ M- P6\.^ M6VcV8YY >?,@7ABC78- DE TX8 ,-867Z-W C:Y.[.T:- F6@ 5:ZV78Y T: TX8 ,-./ZV6Y

186A?,I -678@9 0

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

3/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

M- NZ7T.[8 JZ-T:V O+-87.^8VTQ ;

0" \H?@ ?@ 7H8 _B-IQ8,7 &G 7H8 \A?DB,6P"

)" \H8 TP6?Q6,7@ D8G&A8 7H8 \A?DB,6P 6A8 6PP ^&,=`&X8A,Q8,76P #AI6,?@67?&,@

Y&AW?,I ?, 7H8 G?8P- &G -8G8,-?,I HBQ6, A?IH7@ 67 D&7H 7H8 ,67?&,6P 6,-;&A ?,78A,67?&,6P P8X8P@" \HA88 &G 7H8QJ !A?X6CE R,78A,67?&,6P >a!A?X6CEbFJ +?D8A7E 6,-VQ,8@7E R,78A,67?&,6P +?Q?78- >aVQ,8@7EbF 6A8 D6@8- ?, 7H8 [,?78- c?,I-&Q" \H8&7H8A &AI6,?@67?&,@J YH?CH 6A8 ,6Q8- ?, 7H8 7?7P8 7& 7H8 6C7?&, DB7 YH?CH Y8 -& ,&7,88- 7& ?-8,7?GE @8S6A678PE ?, 7H?@ _B-IQ8,7J 6A8 ?,78A,67?&,6P &AI6,?@67?&,@ D6@8- ?,6 X6A?87E &G C&B,7A?8@J ?,CPB-?,I 7H8 [,?78- .7678@J T6,6-6J ]IES7J !6W?@76, 6,-RA8P6,-" \H8 C6@8 SB7 G&AY6A- DE 7H8 X6A?&B@ TP6?Q6,7@ Y6@ @H6A8- &B7 6Q&,I@7 7HC&B,@8P A8SA8@8,7?,I 7H8Q ?, &A-8A 7& Q6W8 7H8 D8@7 B@8 &G 7H8 G?X8 -6E@ &G &S8H86A?,I YH?CH H6- D88, @87 6@?-8J 6,- G&BA C&B,@8P ?, 7H8 8,- Q6-8 7H8 X6A?&B@@BDQ?@@?&,@ &, 7H8?A D8H6PGJ ZA Z677H8Y UE-8A 4TJ P86-?,I C&B,@8P G&A +?D8A7E 6,-&7H8A@J ZA %8, O6GG8E 6,- ZA 56, .dB?A8@ &, D8H6PG &G !A?X6CE 6,- %E78@ e&A VPPJ

7H8 !6W?@76,? &AI6,?@67?&,J 6,- Z@ c?A@7E %A?Q8P&Y 4T &, D8H6PG &G VQ,8@7EJ ?,86CH C6@8 @BSS&A78- DE GBA7H8A _B,?&A C&B,@8P 6,- @&P?C?7&A@" \H8 U8@S&,-8,X6A?&B@PE ,6Q8- 6@ \H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678 G&A e&A8?I, 6,- T&QQ&,Y86P7H VGG6?A@6,- G&A 7H8 1&Q8 58S6A7Q8,7 6,- X6A?&B@ &7H8A D&-?8@J H6X8 6PP D88, A8SA8@8,78-

DE ZA O6Q8@ ]6-?8 4T Y?7H ZA %8, 1&&S8A 6,- ZA OBP?6, Z?PG&A-J ?,@7ABC78- DE7H8 \A86@BAE .&P?C?7&A"

(" \H8 TP6?Q6,7@f C&QSP6?,7@ 6PP8I8 7H8 B,P6YGBP,8@@ SBA@B6,7 7& VA7?CP8 N >6,-C&PP678A6PPE VA7?CP8 0*F &G 7H8 ]BA&S86, T&,X8,7?&, &G 1BQ6, U?IH7@ >a7H8T&,X8,7?&,bF &G C8A76?, 6@@BQ8- 6C7?X?7?8@ &G 7H8 .8CBA?7E .8AX?C8 >6P@&J 6,-C&PP&dB?6PPEJ W,&Y, 6@ ZR:FJ 7H8 .8CA87 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8 >6,- @?Q?P6APE 6P@&

W,&Y, 6@ ZRKF 6,- 7H8 `&X8A,Q8,7 T&QQB,?C67?&,@ 186-dB6A78A@ >a`T14bFJYH?CH Y8 @H6PP C&PP8C7?X8PE -8@CA?D8 6@ 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ &A U8@S&,-8,VPP C&B,@8P C&&S8A678- 7& @P?Q -&Y, YH67 Y6@ 6 @BD@76,7?6P @87 &G DB,-P8@ &G S6S86,- 6 C&,@?-8A6DP8 6Q&B,7 &G 6AIBQ8,7 ?,7& 6 G?X8 -6E H86A?,I ?, YH?CH 6PP 7H8,8C8@@6AE 6,- 6SSA&SA?678 S&?,7@ &, 6PP @?-8@ Y8A8 GBPPE C6,X6@@8-" /8 6A8 IA678GBPG&A 7H8 S8A@B6@?X8,8@@ 6,- @BCC?,C7,8@@ &G C&B,@8P@f @BDQ?@@?&,@" /8 H6X8

D88, 6@@?@78- DE 7H8 C&,7A?DB7?&,J D&7H ?, YA?7?,I 6,- &A6PPEJ &G T&B,@8P 7& 7H8\A?DB,6PJ ZA Z6A7?, TH6QD8AP6?, 4T 6,- ZA 56X?- Z6,W,8PP"

a^.VbF &G 7H8 [,?78- .7678@J DEYH&Q 6 X8AE @BD@76,7?6P dB6,7?7E &G -&CBQ8,767?&, H6@ D88, P86W8- 6,- QBCH

SB7 ?,7& 7H8 SBDP?C -&Q6?," \H?@ H6@ A8@BP78- ?, 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6@@8A7?,I 7H8?A D8P?8G 7H67 ?,X8@7?I67?&, &G 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ Y&BP- @H&Y 7H67 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@f SA?X6CE H6@ D88, B,P6YGBPPE ?,X6-8-" 18,C8 7H8 \A?DB,6Pf@ -876?P8- @CAB7?,E ?@67 7H?@ @76I8 C6AA?8- &B7 BS&, 7H8 D6@?@ &G 6@@BQ?,I 7H8 A8P8X6,7 6PP8I67?&,@

D8 -8A?X8- GA&Q ZA .,&Y-8,f@ P86W@ 7& D8 7AB8" \H8 @87 &G 6@@BQ8- G6C7@ ?@ @8&B7 D8P&YJ 6,- 7H8 6AIBQ8,7@ &G P6Y H6X8 SA&C88-8- &, 7H8 D6@?@ &G 7H&@86@@BQ8- G6C7@J YH?CH H6X8 8,6DP8- 7H8 Q6?, H86A?,I 7& 76W8 SP6C8 8,7?A8PE ?,

SBDP?C Y?7H&B7 SB77?,I 67 A?@W 6,E ,67?&,6P @8CBA?7E ?,78A8@7" .6X8 G&A 7H

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

4/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

8'?@78,C8 &G 7Y& SA&IA6QQ8@ ?, 7H8 [,?78- .7678@ C6PP8- !A?@Q 6,- [S@7A86QJYH?CH H6X8 D88, SBDP?CPE 6-Q?778- ?, 7H8 [,?78- .7678@ DE 7H8 ^.VJ 6,- G&A C&,G?AQ67?&, 7H67 `T14 H6@ &D76?,8- ?,G&AQ67?&, GA&Q 7H8 [,?78- .7678@`&X8A,Q8,7 7H67 7H8 [,?78- .7678@ `&X8A,Q8,7 &D76?,8- X?6 !A?@QJ ,&,8 &G 7H8 Q6778A@ 7H8 @BD_8C7 &G 7H8 6@@BQ8- G6C7@ 6A8 6-Q?778- DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7

>?"8" 7H8E G6PP Y?7H?, 7H8 ^8?7H8A T&,G?AQ ^&A 58,E >a^T^5bF S&P?CE 7& YH?CHY8 @H6PP A8G8A D8P&YFJ 6,- 6A8 &,PE 6@@BQ8- G&A 7H8 SBAS&@8@ &G 7H?@ H86A.&Q8 GBA7H8A 8X?-8,C8 H6@ D88, SB7 ?, DE D&7H TP6?Q6,7@ 6,- U8@S&,-8,7@ DEY6E &G D6CWIA&B,-J YH?CH H6@ ,&7 D88, @BD_8C7 7& CA&@@=8'6Q?,67?&,J 6,-YH?CH -?- ,&7 -87A6C7 GA&Q 7H8 ^T^5 S&P?CE ,&A 7H8 Q6,,8A ?, YH?CH 7H8H86A?,I H6@ D88, C&,-BC78-"

??F V@ G&A 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@J 7H8E H6X8 ,&7 ,88-8- 7& SA&X8 6,E &G 7H8 6C7?X?7?8@JYH?CH 6A8 6@@BQ8- 7& H6X8 &CCBAA8-J 6,- DE X?A7B8 &G YH?CH ?,78AG8A8,C8 Y?7H7H8?A SA?X6CE H6@ D88, 6@@BQ8-" \H?@ ?@ C&,@?@78,7 Y?7H 7H8 ,&AQ6P SA6C7?C87H?@ \A?DB,6PJ YH?CH 8,6DP8@ CP6?Q6,7@ 7& DA?,I CP6?Q@ Y?7H&B7 H6X?,I 7H8 W?,-&G 6AIB6DP8 C6@8 YH?CH 7H8E Y&BP- ,88- 7& SBA@B8 6 C6@8 ?, 7H8 1?IH T&BA7J6,- 6P@& Y?7H 7H8 _BA?@SAB-8,C8 &G 7H8 ]BA&S86, T&BA7 &G 1BQ6, U?IH7@>g]T71UbFJ YH?CH S8AQ?7@ 6,- 8,C&BA6I8@ @BCH HES&7H87?C6P C6@8@ &, 7H8

D6@?@ 7H67 ?G 7H8A8 H6@ D88, 6, B,P6YGBP ?,78AG8A8,C8 6 CP6?Q6,7 Q6E H6X8 D88,6 X?C7?Q" \HB@ !"#$% ?@ 8@76DP?@H8- @& 6@ 7& S8AQ?7 a &'(')*! #,*!!'(&'% -" -,')'!'.*(- !'&/%!*-/.' )'&/0' b >)8VV8^W \ (V.T8^ ).Vb^:] h)*00i :) ]1UU ")'%''*1/!/-4 J &G P6Y@JABP8@ 6,- 6AA6,I8Q8,7@ 8@76DP?@H8- DE -8Q&CA6C?8@ ?, 7H67 A8I6A- Q6E D86SSA&6CH8- -?GG8A8,7PE GA&Q 7H&@8 @?7B67?&,@ YH8A8 ,67?&,6P @8CBA?7E ?@ ,&7 6, ?@R, S6A7?CBP6AJ 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6CC8S7 7H67 -?GG8A8,7 G&AQ@ &G ?,78PP?I8,C8 I67H8A?,I -&

A6?@8 -?GG8A8,7 SA?X6CE ?,78A8@7@J 6,- 7H8 H86A?,I D8G&A8 B@ H6@ ?,CPB-8-C&,@?-8A67?&, &G YH8A8 6,- H&Y 7& SP6C8 6,- 8X6PB678 7H&@8 D8G&A8 B@"

L" VG78A 7H8 G?X8 -6E SBDP?C H86A?,IJ Y8 H8P- 6 &,8 -6E CP&@8- H86A?,I 7& C&,@?-8A C8A76?, Q6778A@ YH?CH Y8A8J ?, 7H8 C&,@?-8A8- _B-IQ8,7 &G 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@J 7&&C&,G?-8,7?6P 6,- @8,@?7?X8 G&A -?@CB@@?&, ?, &S8, C&BA7 ?, 7H8 ?,78A8@7@ &G SA8@8AX,67?&,6P @8CBA?7EJ 6,- ?, 6CC&A-6,C8 Y?7H &BA _BA?@-?C7?&, 7& H&P- @BCH 6 CP&@8H86A?,I SBA@B6,7 7& UBP8 2 &G 7H8 R,X8@7?I67&AE !&Y8A@ \A?DB,6P UBP8@ )***" V@Y?PP 6SS86AJ Y8 C&,@?-8A8- ?, S6A7?CBP6A 7H8 6AA6,I8Q8,7@J YH?CH ZA ]6-?8 4T-8@CA?D8- -BA?,I 7H8 SBDP?C H86A?,I 6@ a1'!"? -,' ?*-')!/(' bJ A8IBP67?,I 7H8 C&,-BC76,- SA6C7?C8 &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@J ?, &A-8A 7& C&,@?-8A >?F 7H8?A 6-8dB6CE 6,->??F YH87H8A 6,E &G 7H8Q C&BP- 6,- @H&BP- D8 SBDP?CPE -?@CP&@8- ?, &A-8A 7& C&QSPEY?7H 7H8 A8dB?A8Q8,7@ &G VA7?CP8@ N 6,- 0* &G 7H8 T&,X8,7?&, 6@ ?,78ASA878- DE 7H8]T71UJ 7& YH?CH Y8 Y?PP A8G8A GBA7H8A D8P&Y"

N" V7 7H67 H86A?,IJ 67 YH?CH 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ Y8A8 ,&7 A8SA8@8,78-J C&B,@8P G&A 7H8\A?DB,6P SP6E8- 6 GBPP S6A7" /8 H86A- @BDQ?@@?&,@J D&7H &A6P 6,- ?, YA?7?,IJ -BA?,I6,- @BD@8dB8,7 7& 7H8 &S8, H86A?,I 6@ 7& 7H8 A&P8 &G C&B,@8P 7& 7H8 \A?DB,6P 6,- 6@ 7&YH87H8A 6 .S8C?6P V-X&C678 @H&BP- D8 6SS&?,78- 7& A8SA8@8,7 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6,- D8?,@7ABC78- DE 7H8Q" V7 &BA ?,X?767?&,J T&B,@8P 7& 7H8 \A?DB,6P Q6-8 YA?778,@BDQ?@@?&,@ 7& B@J YH?CH C&,76?,8- 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I S6@@6I8 DE Y6E &G -?@7?,IB?@H?

D87Y88, 7H8 A&P8 &G .S8C?6P V-X&C678 6,- T&B,@8P 7& 7H8 \A?DB,6P9

a@A9@ B 73'#/*! B2."#*-' /% *33"/(-'2 ;(")0*!!4C 1$- ("- ('#'%%*)/!4C 3$)%$*(- -" %-*-$-'= -" )'3)'%'(- -,' /(-')'%-% "> *

3*)-4 *- ,'*)/(&% >)"0 ?,/#, -,*- 3*)-4 /% 'D#!$2'29 B 73'#/*! B2."#*-' /% )'E$/)'2 -" 1' 3*)-/%*(9 F' ") %,' 0*G'% %$#, %$10/%%/"(% ;/> *(4= *% ,' #"(%/2')% ?/!! *2.*(#' -,' /(-')'%-%"> -,' 'D#!$2'2 3*)-49 6> -,' 73'#/*! B2."#*-' )'*#,'% -,' ./'?-,*- /- ?"$!2 ("- *2.*(#' -,' /(-')'%-% "> -,' 'D#!$2'2 3*)-4 -"0*G' %$10/%%/"(% *- *!! ;*% ,*% ,*33'('2 /( * >'? #*%'%=C -,'(-,' 3)"3') #"$)%' /% -" 2'#!/(' -" 0*G' %$10/%%/"(% *- *!!C '.'(-,"$&, -,/% !'*.'% -,' -)/1$(*! ?/-,"$- *%%/%-*(#'9

@A9H I"$(%'! -" -,' 8)/1$(*! 3')>")0% * 2/>>')'(- >$(#-/"(C *G/(-" -,*- "> *0/#$% #$)/*'9 F/% ") ,') >$(#-/"( /% -" *%%/%- -,'-)/1$(*! /( ?,*-'.') ?*4 -,' -)/1$(*! 2/)'#-%9 7"0'-/0'% ;'& /()'!*-/"( -" /%%$'% "( ?,/#, *!! 3*)-/'% *)' )'3)'%'(-'2=C -,'8)/1$(*! ?/!! ("- %3'#/>4 >)"0 ?,*- 3')%3'#-/.' %$10/%%/"(% *)'-" 1' 0*2'9 6( -,'%' #/)#$0%-*(#'%C #"$(%'! ?/!! 0*G'

%$10/%%/"(% *##")2/(& -" ,/% ") ,') "?( *(*!4%/% "> -,')'!'.*(- !'&*! ") >*#-$*! /%%$'%C %''G/(& -" &/.' 3*)-/#$!*) '03,*%/% -" 3"/(-% ("- >$!!4 2'.'!"3'2 14 -,' 3*)-/'%9 B- "-,') -/0'% ;/( 3*)-/#$!*) ?,')' "(' ") 0")' /(-')'%-% *)' ("- )'3)'%'(-'2=C -,' 8)/1$(*! 0*4 /(./-' /-% #"$(%'! -" 0*G'

%$10/%%/"(% >)"0 * 3*)-/#$!*) 3')%3'#-/.' ;(")0*!!4 -,'

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

6/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

3')%3'#-/.' "> -,' 3*)-4 ") 3*)-/'% ?,"%' /(-')'%-% *)' ("- "-,')?/%' )'3)'%'(-'2=9 b

2" V@ 7H8 \A?DB,6P H6- H6- 7H8 D8,8G?7 &G X8AE GBPP P8I6P 6AIBQ8,7@ &, 6@@BQ8- G6C7@ 677H8 &S8, H86A?,IJ Y8 I6?,8- 6 GBPP B,-8A@76,-?,I &G 7H8 C6@8 6@ GBPPE C6,X6@@8-

D87Y88, C&B,@8P DE A8G8A8,C8 7& Q&A8 7H6, 0$(#-/"( "> -,' >")0') /% -"

*%%/%- -,' 8)/1$(*! 14 3')>")0/(& %$#, >$(#-/"(% *% ,' ") %,' /%2/)'#-'2 14 -,' 8)/1$(*! -" 3')>")09 8,' 3)'#/%' )"!'% 3!*4'2 14 #"$(%'! -" -,' 8)/1$(*! 0*4 -,')'>")' .*)4 2'3'(2/(& "( -,'#/)#$0%-*(#'%9

@J9H F"?'.')9 /( -,' 3)'%'(- #/)#$0%-*(#'%C -,')' /% * 1)"*2 0'*%$)' "> *&)''0'(- 1'-?''( -,' I!*/0*(-% *(2 -,'

K'%3"(2'(-% -,*- #"$(%'! -" -,' 8)/1$(*! #*( 1'%- *%%/%- -,'8)/1$(*! 14 3')>")0/(& -,' >"!!"?/(& )"!'%L ;/= /2'(-/>4/(& 2"#$0'(-%C 3*)-% "> 2"#$0'(-% ") &/%-% -,*- "$&,- 3)"3')!4 -"1' 2/%#!"%'2M9 ;//= 0*G/(& %$#, %$10/%%/"(% -" -,' 8)/1$(*! /(

>*."$) "> 2/%#!"%$)' *% *)' /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> -,' I!*/0*(-% *(2 "3'( N$%-/#'M *(2 ;///= '(%$)/(& -,*- *!! -,' )'!'.*(- *)&$0'(-%"( -,' >*#-% *(2 -,' !*? *)' 3$- 1'>")' -,' 8)/1$(*!9 6( )'!*-/"(-" ;///=C -,' 8)/1$(*! ?/!! 'D3'#- /-% #"$(%'! -" 0*G' %$10/%%/"(%

>)"0 -,' 3')%3'#-/.' "> -,' I!*/0*(-%O /(-')'%-% ;%/(#' -,' K'%3"(2'(-% ?/!! 1' *1!' -" 0*G' -,'/) "?( %$10/%%/"(%=9 6> -,' 8)/1$(*! 2'#/2'% -" )'#'/.' #!"%'2 ")*! './2'(#' >)"0 "('") 0")' "> -,' K'%3"(2'(-O% ?/-('%%'%C /- 0*4 *!%" 2/)'#- /-%#"$(%'! -" #)"%%P'D*0/(' -,'09 6( 3)*#-/#'C -,' )"!'%

3')>")0'2 14 #"$(%'! -" -,' 8)/1$(*! *- -,/% %-*&' "> -,'#$))'(- 3)"#''2/(&% ?/!! 1' %/0/!*) -" -,"%' 3')>")0'2 14 *73'#/*! B2."#*-' /( #!"%'2 0*-')/*! 3)"#''2/(&%9

@J9Q 6>C *- -,' #!"%'2 ,'*)/(&C -,' 8)/1$(*! #"(#!$2'% -,*- -,'#!"%'2 0*-')/*! )'!/'2 $3"( 14 -,' K'%3"(2'(-% #"$!2 ("- 1'

3)"3')!4 1' 0*2' "3'(C -,')' ?/!! 1' (" (''2 >") *(4 0")' -,*("(' #!"%'2 ,'*)/(&L #"$(%'! -" -,' 8)/1$(*! ?/!! 1' *1!' -"0*G' %$10/%%/"(% "( -,' #!"%'2 0*-')/*!9 6>C "( -,' "-,') ,*(2C/- #"(#!$2'% -,*- -,' #!"%'2 0*-')/*! )'!/'2 $3"( 14 -,'

K'%3"(2'(-% #"$!2 1' 2/%#!"%'2 -" -,' 3*)-/'%9 /- ?/!! /(./-' -,' K'%3"(2'(-% -" #"(%'(- -" %$#, 2/%#!"%$)'9 6> -,' K'%3"(2'(-%*&)''C /- ?/!! *>>")2 -,' 3*)-/'% *( "33")-$(/-4 -" 0*G' "3'(

%$10/%%/"(% "( -,' 2/%#!"%'2 0*-')/*!9 6> -,' K'%3"(2'(-%2'#!/('C /- ?/!! &/.' 2/)'#-/"(% >") h6 GBA7H8Ai"3'( ,'*)/(& 9 9 9 b

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

7/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

\H8 \A?DB,6P C&,@?-8A8- 6,- C&,CPB-8 7H67 7H?@ Y6@ 7H8 C&AA8C7 6,6PE@?@ 6,-6SSA&6CH" V@ Y?PP D8 @88,J ?, 7H8 C&,78'7 &G 6 CP&@8- H86A?,I 7H8A8 Y8A8 Q6778A@-8A?X8- GA&Q 7H8 8X?-8,C8 ?, 7H8 CP&@8- H86A?,I YH?CH 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ Y8A8

SA8S6A8- 7& C&,@8,7 7& -?@CP&@8J 6,- 7H8A8 Y8A8 ,& Q6778A@ YH?CH 7H8 \A?DB,6PC&,@?-8A8- @H&BP- D8 -?@CP&@8- YH?CH 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ -8CP?,8- 7& -?@CP&@8" /A?778,

@BDQ?@@?&,@ DE 7H8 S6A7?8@ 6,- 6 GBA7H8A CP&@8- 6,- &S8, H86A?,I 7H8, G&PP&Y8-J 6,-@&Q8 GBA7H8A Q6778A@ Y8A8 -?@CP&@8- X&PB,76A?PE DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@" .BCH &S-?@CP&@BA8@ 6SS86A ?, S6A6IA6SH@ *0/!4!/>'C ,/% ,"0' *(2 ,/% #"))'%3"(2'(#'9

H9 8,')' %,*!! 1' (" /(-')>')'(#' 14 * 3$1!/# *$-,")/-4 ?/-, -,''D')#/%' "> -,/% )/&,- 'D#'3- %$#, *% /% /( *##")2*(#' ?/-, -,'!*? *(2 /% ('#'%%*)4 /( * 2'0"#)*-/# %"#/'-4 /( -,' /(-')'%-% ">

(*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4C 3$1!/# %*>'-4 ") -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!1'/(& "> -,' #"$(-)4C >") -,' 3)'.'(-/"( "> 2/%")2') ") #)/0'C >") -,'

3)"-'#-/"( "> ,'*!-, ") 0")*!%C ") >") -,' 3)"-'#-/"( "> -,')/&,-% *(2 >)''2"0% "> "-,')%9 b

+?D8A7EJ !A?X6CE 6,- VQ,8@7E R,78A,67?&,6P 6P@& A8PE BS&, VA7?CP8 0* a R)''2"0 "> TD3)'%%/"(bJ &, 7H8 D6@?@ 7H67J 6@ C6QS6?I,?,I &AI6,?@67?&,@J 7H8E 6A8 6P@& 8,7?7P8-7& 7H8 SA&78C7?&, &G 7H67 VA7?CP8 YH?CH SA?Q6A?PE A8P678@ 7& 7H8 GA88-&Q &G 7H8 R7 ?@ C&QQ&, IA&B,- 7H67J @BD_8C7 7& &,8 S&@@?DP8 8'C8S7?&, 7& YH?CH Y8 @H6PP A87BP678AJ ,& -?GG8A8,7 dB8@7?&,@ G6PP 7& D8 -8C?-8- DE A8G8A8,C8 7& VA7?CP8 0* 7H6, 6A8A6?@8- DE VA7?CP8 NJ 6,- Y8 @H6PP 7H8A8G&A8 P86X8 6@?-8 7H8 Q6778A &G VA7?CP8 0

YH?CH B,-8AP?8@ VIA88- R@@B8@ >??FJ >???FJ >X?F 6,- >X??F"

0(" \H8A8 Y8A8 6P@& C8A76?, &G 7H8 VIA88- R@@B8@ >R@@B8 '??FJ >'???F 6,- >'?XF YH?CH Y8A-8@CA?D8- 6@ a 6%%$'% "> !*? )'!*-/(& -" 3)"#'2$)' bJ 6,- YH?CHJ DE 6IA88Q8,7J H6X8,&7 G6PP8, G&A -8C?@?&, 67 7H?@ H86A?,I" \H8E A8P678 ?, S6A7 7& 7H8 ^T^5 S&P?CEJ 7H8?QS&A76,C8 &G YH?CH ?@ 8QSH6@?@8- DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ ?, 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I S6A6IA6SH@&G 7H8?A #S8, U8@S&,@89

aA9 7'#)'#4 /% '%%'(-/*! -" -,' ('#'%%*)/!4 #".')- ?")G *(2 "3')*-/"(*! '>>'#-/.'('%% "> -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'%C ?,"%'

3)/0*)4 >$(#-/"( /% -" 3)"-'#- (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-49 7'' '9&9

!""#$%&' )&%&$*+ ,- ).*$/0*% 1&234*4&$3 5"/ ;U"9H=V@JJWX @ BI @WJC 3') S")2 Y)/>>/-,% *- HZJR9

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

8/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

Z9 B% * )'%$!-C -,' 0')' >*#- -,*- -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% *)'#*))4/(& "$- *( /(.'%-/&*-/"( ") "3')*-/"( /( )'!*-/"( -"C %*4C *-'))")/%- &)"$3C ") ,"!2 /(>")0*-/"( "( * %$%3'#-'2 -'))")/%-C?/!! /-%'!> 1' %'(%/-/.'9 6>C >") 'D*03!'C * ,"%-/!' /(2/./2$*! ")

&)"$3 ?')' -" 1'#"0' *?*)' -,*- -,'4 ?')' -,' %$1N'#- ">

/(-')'%- 14 -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'%C -,'4 #"$!2 ("- "(!4 -*G' %-'3% -" -,?*)- *(4 ;#".')-= /(.'%-/&*-/"( ") "3')*-/"( 1$- *!%"*--'03- -" 2/%#".')C *(2 3'),*3% 3$1!/#!4 )'.'*!C -,' 0'-,"2%$%'2 14 -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% ") -,' /2'(-/-/'% "> -,' ">>/#')%") *&'(-% /(."!.'29 I"(.')%'!4C /> * ,"%-/!' /(2/./2$*! ") &)"$3?')' -" 1'#"0' *?*)' -,*- -,'4 ?')' ("- -,' %$1N'#- ">

6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#' /(-')'%-C -,'4 ?"$!2 -,'( G("? -,*- -,'4#"$!2 '(&*&' ") #"(-/($' -" '(&*&' /( -,'/) $(2'%/)*1!'*#-/./-/'% ?/-, /(#)'*%'2 ./&"$) *(2 /(#)'*%'2 #"(>/2'(#' -,*- -,'4 ?/!! ("- 1' 2'-'#-'29

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

:9 6- ,*% -,$% 1''( -,' 3"!/#4 "> %$##'%%/.' \] Y".')(0'(-% -"('/-,') #"(>/)0 (") 2'(4 ?,'-,') -,'4 *)' 0"(/-")/(& -,'*#-/./-/'% "> * 3*)-/#$!*) &)"$3 ") /(2/./2$*!C ") ,"!2 /(>")0*-/"( "( * 3*)-/#$!*) &)"$3 ") /(2/./2$*!C ") ,*.' ,*2 #"(-*#- ?/-, * 3*)-/#$!*) /(2/./2$*!9 7/0/!*)!4C -,' !"(&P

%-*(2/(& 3"!/#4 "> -,' \] Y".')(0'(- /% -" ('/-,') #"(>/)0 (") 2'(4 -,' -)$-, "> #!*/0% *1"$- -,' "3')*-/"(*! *#-/./-/'% "> -,'

6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'%C /(#!$2/(& -,'/) /(-'!!/&'(#'P&*-,')/(& #*3*1/!/-/'% *(2 -'#,(/E$'%9

J9 R$)-,')C -,' ^('/-,') #"(>/)0 (") 2'(4_ 3)/(#/3!' ?"$!2 1')'(2')'2 ($&*-")4C *(2 (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4 -,')'14 %')/"$%!42*0*&'2C /> '.')4 -/0' -,*- %'(%/-/.' /(>")0*-/"( ?')'2/%#!"%'2 ?/-,"$- *$-,")/-4 ;/9'9 ^!'*G'2_=C ") /- ?*% *!!'&'2 -,*- -,')' ,*2 1''( %$#, $(*$-,")/%'2 2/%#!"%$)' "> %$#,/(>")0*-/"(C -,' \] Y".')(0'(- ?')' -,'( "1!/&'2 -" #"(>/)0") 2'(4 -,' .')*#/-4 "> -,' /(>")0*-/"( /( E$'%-/"(9

@W9 6- ,*% -,$% 1''( -,' 3"!/#4 "> %$##'%%/.' Y".')(0'(-% -"*2"3- * ('/-,') #"(>/)0 (") 2'(4 %-*(#' /( )'!*-/"( -" *(4/(>")0*-/"( 2')/.'2 >)"0 *(4 *!!'&'2 !'*G )'&*)2/(& -,'*#-/./-/'% ") "3')*-/"(% "> -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% /(%">*) *%-,*- /(>")0*-/"( ,*% ("- 1''( %'3*)*-'!4 #"(>/)0'2 14 *(">>/#/*! %-*-'0'(- 14 -,' \] Y".')(0'(-9 8,*- !"(&P%-*(2/(&

3"!/#4 /% *33!/'2 /( -,/% `3'( K'%3"(%'9_

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

9/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

%8C6B@8 7H?@ H86A?,I H6@ D88, H8P- &, 7H8 D6@?@ &G 6IA88- 6@@BQ8- G6C7@J ?7 H6@ , D88, ,8C8@@6AE 7& 6--A8@@ 7H?@ S&P?CE &A ?7@ C&,@8dB8,C8@"

678 9:;")'/&(/(-'!!/&'(#' /(>")0*-/"( >)"0 '!'#-)"(/# #"00$(/#*-/"( %')./#'

3)"./2')% $(2') \7 #"$)- %$3')./%/"(9 8,' \7 Y".')(0'(-O%^$3%-)'*0 #"!!'#-/"(_ 3)"&)*00' "1-*/(% /(-')('- #"00$(/#*-/"(% $(2') \7 #"$)- %$3')./%/"( *% -,'4 -)*(%/- -,'/(-')('-9

H9 8,' I!*/0*(-%O #"00$(/#*-/"(% *(2a") #"00$(/#*-/"(%

2*-* ;/= 0/&,- /( 3)/(#/3!' ,*.' 1''( "1-*/('2 14 -,' \7 Y".')(0'(- ./* 5)/%0 ;*(2a")C "( -,' I!*/0*(-%O #*%'C 3$)%$*(- -" -,' ^$3%-)'*0 #"!!'#-/"(_ 3)"&)*00'= *(2 ;//=0/&,- /( 3)/(#/3!' ,*.' -,')'*>-') 1''( "1-*/('2 14 -,'

6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% >)"0 -,' \7 Y".')(0'(-9 8,')'*>-')C -,'I!*/0*(-%O #"00$(/#*-/"(% *(2a") #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* 0/&,- /( 3)/(#/3!' ,*.' 1''( )'-*/('2C $%'2 ") 2/%#!"%'2 14 -,'

6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% ;*= 3$)%$*(- -" * %3'#/>/# )'E$'%- >)"0 -,'/(-'!!/&'(#' %')./#'% *(2a") ;1= ("- 3$)%$*(- -" * %3'#/>/#)'E$'%- >)"0 -,' /(-'!!/&'(#' %')./#'%9 b

\H8 ?@@B8 ?7@8PG ?@ G&AQBP678- 6@ G&PP&Y@9

a 6( -,' !/&,- "> >*#-$*! 3)'0/%'% ;@= *(2 ;H= *1".'C 2"'% -,' %-*-$-")4 )'&/0' *% %'- "$- /( 3*)*&)*3,% QZP[Z "> -,' K'%3"(2'(-%O 3'( K'%3"(%' -" -,' I!*/0% 1)"$&,- 14 S/1')-4*(2 5)/.*#4 %*-/%>4 -,' B)-9 :;H= ^/( *##")2*(#' ?/-, -,' !*?_)'E$/)'0'(-b b

0:" \H8 G&PP&Y?,I Q6778A@ 6A8 6P@& ?, SA6C7?C8 6IA88- D87Y88, 7H8 S6A7?8@ 6@ S6A7 &G 7H6IA88- 6@@BQS7?&,@9

?F \H8 ^.V H6@ 6 P6YGBP D6@?@ G&A 76AI878- ?,78AC8S7?&, SBA@B6,7 7& @"L*) &G 7H8e&A8?I, R,78PP?I8,C8 .BAX8?PP6,C8 VC7 02LN >6@ 6Q8,-8-F >a R67BbFJ 6,- 7&]'8CB7?X8 #A-8A 0)(((J SBA@B6,7 7& YH?CH !A?@Q 6,- a[S@7A86Qb 6A8 P6YGBPPE@6,C7?&,8- G&A a-,' -*)&'-/(& "> 3')%"(% )'*%"(*1!4 1'!/'.'2 -" 1' !"#*-'2 "$-%/2' -,' \(/-'2 7-*-'% -" *#E$/)' >")'/&( /(-'!!/&'(#' /(>")0*-/"( b"VCC&A-?,I 7& 7H8 ^.Vf@ jZ?@@?&, .7678Q8,7f &G 2 VBIB@7 )*0( a-,' #"!!'#-/"($(2') 9 9 9 %9[WH /% -,' 0"%- %/&(/>/#*(- -""! /( -,' U7B #"!!'#-/"( *)%'(*! >") -,' 2'-'#-/"(C /2'(-/>/#*-/"( *(2 2/%)$3-/"( "> -'))")/%- -,)'*-% -" -,' \979 *(2 )"$(2 -,' ?")!2 b9 6,- 6CC&A-?,I 7& 7H8 ^.Vf@ 5?A8C7&A &G T?X?P +?D8A7?8@ 6,-!A?X6CE #GG?C8 U8S&A7 &G VSA?P 0NJ )*0< a U7B /% %$1N'#- -" )/&")"$% /(-')(*! #"03!/*(#' *(2 'D-')(*! ".')%/&,- b" e&A 7H8 SBAS&@8 &G 7H?@ H86A?,I 7H8

?,G&AQ67?&, 6@@BQ8- 7& D8 @BSSP?8- 7& 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ DE 7H8 ^.V ?@ 6@@BQ8-7& H6X8 D88, P6YGBPPE &D76?,8-"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

10/77

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

11/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;//= B 2'#!*)*-/"( -,*- -,' %"!/#/-/(&C )'#'/3-C %-")*&' *(2 -)*(%0/%%/"( "> %$#, /(>")0*-/"( 14 -,' 7'#$)/-4 7')./#'C-,' 7'#)'- 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#' *(2a") YIFc /% $(!*?>$!9

;///= B( ")2') -,*- -,' 7'#$)/-4 7')./#'C -,' 7'#)'- 6(-'!!/&'(#'

7')./#' *(2a") YIFc ?/!! ("- %"!/#/-C )'#'/.'C %-")' ") -)*(%0/- %$#, /(>")0*-/"( $(!'%% *(2 $(-/! %$#, *#-/./-/'%*)' &".')('2 14 * !'&*! )'&/0' ?,/#, %*-/%>/'% TIFK B)- : *(2 @W *(2 ?/!! 2'%-)"4 *(4 0*-')/*! $(!*?>$!!4"1-*/('29 b

0L" R7 ?@ C&QQ&, IA&B,- 7H67 UR!V ?@ ,&7 6SSP?C6DP8 7& 6 C6@8 YH8A8 7H8A8 H6@ ,&7 D88,?,78AC8S7?&, &G C&QQB,?C67?&,@ DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@J DB7 A8C8?S7 &G ?,78AC8S78-C&QQB,?C67?&,@ DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ GA&Q 7H8 ^.V -8A?X8- GA&Q !A?@Q &A [S@7A86QJ YH?CH Q?IH7J DE -?,7 &G 7H8 -8IA88 &G C&X8A6I8 DE [. ?,78AC8S7?&,J?,CPB-8 ?,78AC8S78- SA&-BC7 &G 6, 8Q6?P YH?CH C&BP- H6X8 D88, @8,7 6,-;&A A8C8?X8-

?, 7H8 [,?78- c?,I-&Q"

0N" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ A8PE &, 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I @767B7&AE GA6Q8Y&AW 7& S8AQ?7 7H8Q 7&A8C8?X8 6,- B@8 @BCH ?,G&AQ67?&,9

?F ."0 &G 7H8 .8CBA?7E .8AX?C8 VC7 02N2 >a..VbF SA&X?-8@ ?, A8P8X6,7 S6A79

a;H= 8,' >$(#-/"( "> Vd6AX %,*!! 1' -,' 3)"-'#-/"( "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4 *(2C/( 3*)-/#$!*)C /-% 3)"-'#-/"( *&*/(%- -,)'*-% >)"0 '%3/"(*&'C -'))")/%0 *(2

%*1"-*&'C >)"0 -,' *#-/./-/'% "> *&'(-% "> >")'/&( 3"?')% *(2 >)"0 *#-/"(%/(-'(2'2 -" ".')-,)"? ") $(2')0/(' 3*)!/*0'(-*)4 2'0"#)*#4 14 3"!/-/#*!C

/(2$%-)/*! ") ./"!'(- 0'*(%9;Q= 6- %,*!! *!%" 1' -,' >$(#-/"( "> Vd6AX -" %*>'&$*)2 -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!P1'/(& "> -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0 *&*/(%- -,)'*-% 3"%'2 14 -,' *#-/"(% ") /(-'(-/"(% "> 3')%"(% "$-%/2' -,' e)/-/%, 6%!*(2%9; -,' *#-/./-/'% ">

3"!/#' >")#'%C -,' U*-/"(*! I)/0' B&'(#4 *(2 "-,') !*? '(>")#'0'(- *&'(#/'% /( -,' 3)'.'(-/"( *(2 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0' "b

??F \H8 &S8A67?&,@ &G ZR: 6A8 B,-8A 7H8 C&,7A&P &G 7H8 5?A8C7&A=`8,8A6PJ YH& ?@6SS&?,78- DE 7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678 >@" )>0F &G ..VF" %E @" )>)F>6FJ ?7 ?@ 7H8-B7E &G 7H8 5?A8C7&A=`8,8A6P 7& 8,@BA89

a" " " -,*- -,')' *)' *))*(&'0'(-% >") %'#$)/(& -,*- (" /(>")0*-/"( /%"1-*/('2 14 -,' 7')./#' 'D#'3- %" >*) *% ('#'%%*)4 >") -,' 3)"3') 2/%#,*)&'"> /-% >$(#-/"(% ") 2/%#!"%'2 14 /- 'D#'3- %" >*) *% ('#'%%*)4 >") -,*- 3$)3"%'") >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> -,' 3)'.'(-/"( ") 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0' ") >") -,'

3$)3"%' "> *(4 #)/0/(*! 3)"#''2/(&% " " "b

???F .BD_8C7 7& @" 0>)F &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ VC7 022< >aR.VbFJ 7H8 GB,C7?&,@&G ZRK 6A8J DE @" 0>0F9

a;*= -" "1-*/( *(2 3)"./2' /(>")0*-/"( )'!*-/(& -" -,' *#-/"(% ") /(-'(-/"(%

"> 3')%"(% "$-%/2' -,' e)/-/%, 6%!*(2%M *(2 ;1= -" 3')>")0 "-,') -*%G% )'!*-/(& -" -,' *#-/"(% ") /(-'(-/"(% "> %$#,

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

12/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

3')%"(%9b

?XF %E @" 0>)F &G R.V9

a8,' >$(#-/"(% "> Vd6ZX %,*!! 1' 'D')#/%*1!' "(!4f

;*= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4C ?/-, 3*)-/#$!*) )'>')'(#' -" -,'2'>'(#' *(2 >")'/&( 3"!/#/'% "> F') d*N'%-4O% Y".')(0'(- /( -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0M ") ;1= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!P1'/(& "> -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0M ") ;#= /( %$33")- "> -,' 3)'.'(-/"( ") 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0' "_

XF \H8 &S8A67?&,@ &G ZRK 6A8 B,-8A 7H8 C&,7A&P &G 7H8 TH?8G &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8.8AX?C8J YH& ?@ 6SS&?,78- DE 7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678 >@" )>0F &G R.VF" %E @" )>)F>6FJ ?7 ?@ 7H8 -B7E &G 7H8 TH?8G &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8 7& 8,@BA89

^9 9 9 -,*- -,')' *)' *))*(&'0'(-% >") %'#$)/(& -,*- (" /(>")0*-/"( /%

"1-*/('2 14 Vd6ZX 'D#'3- %" >*) *% ('#'%%*)4 >") -,' 3)"3') 2/%#,*)&' "> /-% >$(#-/"(% *(2 -,*- (" /(>")0*-/"( /% 2/%#!"%'2 14 /- 'D#'3- %" >*) *%('#'%%*)4f ;/= >") -,*- 3$)3"%'M;//= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4M;///= >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> -,' 3)'.'(-/"( ") 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0'M ") ;/.= >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> *(4 #)/0/(*! 3)"#''2/(&%9 9 9_

X?F %E @" (>0F>6F &G R.VJ 7H8 GB,C7?&,@ &G `T14 ?,CPB-8 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I9

^9 9 9 -" 0"(/-") ") /(-')>')' ?/-, '!'#-)"0*&('-/#C *#"$%-/# *(2 "-,')

'0/%%/"(% *(2 *(4 'E$/30'(- 3)"2$#/(& %$#, '0/%%/"(% *(2 -" "1-*/( *(2 3)"./2' /(>")0*-/"( 2')/.'2 >)"0 ") )'!*-'2 -" %$#, '0/%%/"(% ") 'E$/30'(- *(2 >)"0 '(#)43-'2 0*-')/*! 9 9 9_

X??F %E @" (>)F &G R.VJ 7H8@8 GB,C7?&,@ 6A8 &,PE 8'8AC?@6DP89

^;*= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4C ?/-, 3*)-/#$!*) )'>')'(#' -" -,'2'>'(#' *(2 >")'/&( 3"!/#/'% "> F') d*N'%-4O% Y".')(0'(- /( -,' \(/-'2

]/(&2"0M ") ;1= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!P1'/(& "> -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0 /()'!*-/"( -" -,' *#-/"(% ") /(-'(-/"(% "> 3')%"(% "$-%/2' -,' e)/-/%, 6%!*(2%M

") ;#= /( %$33")- "> -,' 3)'.'(-/"( ") 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0'9 b

X???F `T14f@ &S8A67?&,@ 6A8 B,-8A 7H8 C&,7A&P &G 6 5?A8C7&AJ YH& ?@ 6SS&?,78- DE7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678 >@" 0FF" %E @" )F>6FJ ?7 ?@ 7H8 -B7E &G 7H8 5?A8C7&A8,@BA89

^9 9 9 -,*- -,')' *)' *))*(&'0'(-% >") %'#$)/(& -,*- (" /(>")0*-/"( /%"1-*/('2 14 YIFc 'D#'3- %" >*) *% ('#'%%*)4 >") -,' 3)"3') 2/%#,*)&' "> /-% >$(#-/"(% *(2 -,*- (" /(>")0*-/"( /% 2/%#!"%'2 14 /- 'D#'3- %" >*) *%('#'%%*)4 >") -,*- 3$)3"%' ") >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> *(4 #)/0/(*!

3)"#''2/(&% 9 9 9_

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

13/77

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

14/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

??F V Q8QD8A &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ C&QQ?7@ 6, &GG8,C8 B,-8A @"0>0F &G 7H8#GG?C?6P .8CA87@ VC7 02N2 >a#.VbF ?G ^?/-,"$- !*?>$! *$-,")/-4 ,' 2/%#!"%'%*(4 /(>")0*-/"(C 2"#$0'(- ") "-,') *)-/#!' )'!*-/(& -" %'#$)/-4 ") /(-'!!/&'(#'?,/#, /%C ") ,*% 1''(C /( ,/% 3"%%'%%/"( 14 ./)-$' "> ,/% 3"%/-/"( *% * 0'01') "> *(4 "> -,"%' %')./#'%_ " \H?@ -?@CP&@BA8 C6, &,PE D8 Q6-8 Y?7H P6YGBP

6B7H&A?7E ?G ?7 ?@ Q6-8 ?, 6CC&A-6,C8 Y?7H H?@ &GG?C?6P -B7E DE X?A7B8 &G @"L>07H8 #.V" \HB@J ZA ]6-?8 S&?,7@ &B7 7H67 -?@CP&@BA8 &G ?,G&AQ67?&, DE 6Q8QD8A &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ ?, Q678A?6P DA86CH &G 7H8 A8P8X6,7^*))*(&'0'(-%_ Q6-8 B,-8A @")>)F>6F &G ..V &A R.V &A @")F>6F &G R.V Y&BP-

D8 6 CA?Q?,6P &GG8,C8J 6,- 7H8A8 6A8 &7H8A CA?Q?,6P &DP?I67?&,@ ?, A8P67?&, 7&-?@CP&@BA8 B,-8A 7H8 #.V"

???F \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 6A8 6P@& D&B,- DE 7H8?A &DP?I67?&,@ B,-8A @"K>0F &G 7H81BQ6, U?IH7@ VC7 022NJ YH?CHJ ?, A8P67?&, 7& DA86CH &G VA7?CP8@ N 6,- 0* &G 7H8 T&,X8,7?&,J ?@ 6,&7H8A S&@?7?X8 &DP?I67?&, YH?CH C6, D8 8,G&AC8- ?, 6C&BA7J &A ?, 7H?@ C6@8J ?, 7H?@ \A?DB,6P"

)*" \HB@ 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ C6, &D76?, ?,G&AQ67?&, >?,CPB-?,I C&QQB,?C67?&,@6,- C&QQB,?C67?&,@ -676F GA&Q 6 G&A8?I, ?,78PP?I8,C8 6I8,CE G6PP?,I Y?7H?, 7H8?A A8P8X6,7 A8Q?7J DB7 DE A8G8A8,C8 7& *))*(&'0'(-% G&A @8CBA?,I 7H67 7H8 ?,G&AQ67?&, ?@&,PE &D76?,8- @& G6A 6@ ,8C8@@6AE G&A &,8 &G 7H8 @S8C?G?8- SBAS&@8@ >6@ @87

S6A6IA6SH 0N>??FJ >XF 6,- >X??F 6D&X8FJ YH?CH SBAS&@8@ 6A8 ?-8,7?C6P 7& 7H&@@S8C?G?8- G&A 7H8 &D76?,?,I &G 6 Y6AA6,7 B,-8A @"N &G UR!VJ 6,- ?,@&G6A 6@

SA&S&A7?&,678 G&A 7H67 SBAS&@8 SBA@B6,7 7& @"K>0F &G 7H8 1UV"

)0" \H8 TP6?Q6,7@f A8@S&,@8 ?@ 7H8?A C&QSP6?,7 7H67 7H8A8 ?@ &, 7H8 G6C8 &G 7H&@8 @767> 8 ' C 8 S 7 7 H 8 5 ! V F , & & A , & @ B G G ? C ? 8 , 7 A 8 I B P 6 7 ? & , 6 @ 7 & 7 H 8

A8C8?S7;H6,-P?,I;A878,7?&,;-8@7ABC7?&, &G 7H8 ?,G&AQ67?&, @& @BSSP?8-J @BCH 6@ 7H8Y&BP- D8 ?, A8@S8C7 &G ?,78AC8S78- ?,G&AQ67?&, &D76?,8- SBA@B6,7 7& 6 Y6AA6,7 B,-8A @"N &G UR!V >YH87H8A ?@@B8- B,-8A @"N>0F &A @"N>)F>a/( *##")2*(#' ?/-, -,' !*? bF"

))" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ A8PE BS&, @?I,?G?C6,7 &X8A@?IH7 &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ 6@ SA&78C7?&, 6I6?,@7 6AD?7A6AE ?,78AG8A8,C8 &A B,P6YGBP B@8 &G S&Y8A@ DE 7H8Q" e7H8A8 ?@ &X8A@?IH7 DE 7H8 R.TJ ,&Y A8IBP678- B,-8A 7H8 OB@7?C8 6,- .8CBA?7E VC7 )*0(>a7H8 O.VbF" \H?@ ?@ 6 T&QQ?7788 &G Z8QD8A@ &G !6AP?6Q8,7J GA&Q D&7H 1&B@8@ 6,-CA&@@=S6A7EJ YH&@8 TH6?AQ6, ?@ .?A Z6PC&PQ U?GW?,- 4TJ 6 G&AQ8A e&A8?I,.8CA876AE" \H8 R.T H6@J 6,- 8'8AC?@8@J Y?-8 S&Y8A@J 6,- 7H8 `&X8A,Q8,7 >?,CPB-?,I86CH &G 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@F QB@7 Q6W8 6X6?P6DP8 7& 7H8 R.T ?,G&AQ67?&, 7H67 ?A8dB8@7@ ?, 7H8 8'8AC?@8 &G ?7@ GB,C7?&,@J @BD_8C7 7& 6 S&Y8A &G X87& B,-8A C8A7&G 7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678" R7 H6@ 6 @BSS&A7 @76GG Y?7H 7H8 H?IH8@7 P8X8P &G @CP86A6,C8J 6,- QB@7 Q6W8 6, 6,,B6P A8S&A7 7& !6AP?6Q8,7J 6,- @BCH &7H8A A8S&A7@ 7&!6AP?6Q8,7 6@ ?7 C&,@?-8A@ 6SSA&SA?678"

)(" #, 0L OBPE )*0( 7H8 R.T Q6-8 6 ^7-*-'0'(- "( YIFcO% B!!'&'2 6(-')#'3-/"( "> I"00$(/#*-/"(% $(2') -,' \7 5)/%0 5)"&)*0_ " R7 H6- C6AA?8- &B7 6, ?,X8@7?I67?&,J6,- ?7 A86CH8- C&,CPB@?&,@ YH?CH ?7 @87 &B7 6@ G&PP&Y@9

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

15/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

^A9 `$) /(.'%-/&*-/"( ,*% /(#!$2'2 %#)$-/(4 "> YIFcO% *##'%%-" -,' #"(-'(- "> #"00$(/#*-/"(%C -,' !'&*! >)*0'?")G ?,/#,

&".')(% -,*- *##'%%C *(2 -,' *))*(&'0'(-% YIFc ,*% ?/-, /-%".')%'*% #"$(-')3*)-% >") %,*)/(& %$#, /(>")0*-/"(9 h' ,*.')'#'/.'2 %$1%-*(-/.' )'3")-% >)"0 YIFcC /(#!$2/(&L

! * !/%- "> #"$(-')P-'))")/%- "3')*-/"(% >") ?,/#, YIFc ?*%*1!' -" "1-*/( /(-'!!/&'(#' >)"0 -,' \7 /( *(4 )'!'.*(- *)'*M

! * !/%- "> *!! -,' /(2/./2$*!% ?," ?')' %$1N'#- -" 0"(/-")/(& ./* %$#, *))*(&'0'(-% ?," ?')' '/-,') 1'!/'.'2 -" 1' /(-,' \] ") ?')' /2'(-/>/'2 *% \] (*-/"(*!%M

! * !/%- "> '.')4 i%'!'#-")O ;%$#, *% *( '0*/! *22)'%%= >") -,'%' /(2/./2$*!% "( ?,/#, -,' /(-'!!/&'(#' ?*% )'E$'%-'2M

! * !/%- "> -,' ?*))*(-% *(2 /(-')(*! *$-,")/%*-/"(% -,*- ?')'/( 3!*#' >") '*#, "> -,'%' /(2/./2$*!% 1'/(& -*)&'-'2M

! * ($01') ;*% %'!'#-'2 14 $%= "> -,' /(-'!!/&'(#' )'3")-% -,*- ?')' 3)"2$#'2 *% * )'%$!- "> -,/% *#-/./-4M *(2

! -,' >")0*! *&)''0'(-% -,*- )'&$!*-'2 *##'%% -" -,/%0*-')/*!9

h' 2/%#$%%'2 -,' 3)"&)*00' ?/-, -,' U7B *(2 "$)

I"(&)'%%/"(*! #"$(-')3*)-% 2$)/(& "$) )'#'(- ./%/- -" -,'\(/-'2 7-*-'%9 h' ,*.' *!%" -*G'( ")*! './2'(#' >)"0 -,' j/)'#-") "> YIFc *(2 E$'%-/"('2 ,/0 /( 2'-*/!9

! 6- ,*% 1''( *!!'&'2 -,*- YIFc #/)#$0.'(-'2 \] !*? 14$%/(& -,' U7BO% 5K67d 3)"&)*00' -" *##'%% -,' #"(-'(- ">

3)/.*-' #"00$(/#*-/"(%9 R)"0 -,' './2'(#' ?' ,*.' %''(C?' ,*.' #"(#!$2'2 -,*- -,/% /% $(>"$(2'29

! h' ,*.' )'./'?'2 -,' )'3")-% -,*- YIFc 3)"2$#'2 "( -,'

1*%/% "> /(-'!!/&'(#' %"$&,- >)"0 -,' \7C *(2 ?' *)' %*-/%>/'2 -,*- -,'4 #"(>")0'2 ?/-, YIFcO% %-*-$-")4 2$-/'%98,' !'&*! *$-,")/-4 >") -,/% /% #"(-*/('2 /( -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#'7')./#'% B#- @JJ") /(-')#'3-/"(C %/&('2 14 * d/(/%-')C ?*% *!)'*24 /( 3!*#'C /( *##")2*(#' ?/-, -,' !'&*! %*>'&$*)2% #"(-*/('2 /( -,' K'&$!*-/"( "> 6(.'%-/&*-")4 5"?')% B#- HWWW9

U'D- 7-'3%

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

16/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

Z9 B!-,"$&, ?' ,*.' #"(#!$2'2 -,*- YIFc ,*% ("- #/)#$0.'(-'2 ") *--'03-'2 -" #/)#$0.'(- \] !*?C /- /% 3)"3') -" #"(%/2') >$)-,') ?,'-,') -,' #$))'(- %-*-$-")4 >)*0'?")G

&".')(/(& *##'%% -" 3)/.*-' #"00$(/#*-/"(% )'0*/(% *2'E$*-'9

[9 6( %"0' *)'*% -,' !'&/%!*-/"( /% 'D3)'%%'2 /( &'(')*! -')0%*(2 0")' 2'-*/!'2 3"!/#/'% *(2 3)"#'2$)'% ,*.'C )/&,-!4C 1''( 3$- /( 3!*#' *)"$(2 -,/% ?")G 14 YIFc /( ")2') -" '(%$)'#"03!/*(#' ?/-, -,'/) %-*-$-")4 "1!/&*-/"(% $(2') -,' F$0*(

K/&,-% B#- @JJ:9 h' *)' -,')'>")' 'D*0/(/(& -,' #"03!'D/(-')*#-/"( 1'-?''( -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% B#-C -,' F$0*(

K/&,-% B#- *(2 -,' K'&$!*-/"( "> 6(.'%-/&*-")4 5"?')% B#-C *(2 -,' 3"!/#/'% *(2 3)"#'2$)'% -,*- $(2')3/( -,'0C >$)-,')9 h'("-' -,*- -,' 6(-')#'3-/"( "> I"00$(/#*-/"(% I"00/%%/"(') /%*!%" #"(%/2')/(& -,/% /%%$'9_

)0F &G UR!VJ ?,-8S8,-8,7 GA&Q `&X8A,Q8,7 6,- 7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@" 187&& H6@ 6 @76GG 7& 6@@?@7 H?Q Y?7H H?@ GB,C7?&,@J YH?CH ?,CPB-8 6 C&,@76,7 A8X?7H8 R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@J 6,- H8 ?@ B,-8A 6 -B7E DE @":N>)"0 \7 *&'(#/'%/(-')#'3- 0*-')/*! *1"$- e)/-/%, #/-/k'(% ?,/#, #"$!2 ("- !*?>$!!4 1' *#E$/)'2 14 /(-')#'3- /( -,' \] *(2 ./#' .')%* *(2 -,')'14 #/)#$0.'(- 2"0'%-/# ".')%/&,- )'&/0'%b b

18 @87 &B7 H?@ X?8Y@ >67 S6A6IA6SH K"N"0=:F DE A8G8A8,C8 7& 7H8 6@@BQS7?&,J YH?

H6@ 6P@& D88, Q6-8 G&A 7H8 SBAS&@8@ &G 7H8 C6@8 D8G&A8 B@ >S6A6IA6SH 0:>?F 6D7H67 7H8 ?,78AC8S7 Q678A?6P ?, dB8@7?&, H6@ D88, P6YGBPPE 6CdB?A8- DE 7H8 [,?78-.7678@ VI8,C?8@" R, 7H8 P?IH7 &G H?@ &Y, ?,X8@7?I67?&,@J 6@ 7H8A8 A8G8AA8- 7&J H6,@Y8A8- H?@ dB8@7?&, ?, 7H8 ,8I67?X8" 18 C&,CPB-8- 6@ G&PP&Y@9

aZ9:9Z 9 9 9 /(>")0*-/"( !*?>$!!4 "1-*/('2 14 /(-')#'3-/"( *1)"*2 /% ("- ('#'%%*)/!4 *.*/!*1!' 14 /(-')#'3-/"( -" *( /(-')#'3-/"(*&'(#4 ,')'9 6( 0*(4 #*%'% /- ?/!! ("- 1' *.*/!*1!'9 6> /- /% -" 1'!*?>$!!4 3)"./2'2 >)"0 *1)"*2C /- /% %"0'-/0'% *33)"3)/*-' >") -,' /(-')#'3-/"( *&'(#/'% -" *33!4 'D3!/#/-!4 14 *(*!"&4 -,'

K65B HWWW 5*)- 6 3)/(#/3!'% "> ('#'%%/-4 *(2 3)"3")-/"(*!/-4 -"/-% )'#'/3- ,')' '.'( -,"$&, K65B HWWW 5*)- 6 2"'% ("- %-)/#-!4*33!4C 1'#*$%' -,' /(-')#'3-/"( 2/2 ("- -*G' 3!*#' /( -,' \] 14

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

17/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

*( \] *&'(#49 8,/% /% )'%3"(%/1!4 2"(' /( * ($01') "> *33)"3)/*-' #/)#$0%-*(#'% 14 .*)/"$% "> -,' *&'(#/'%C *(2 6 *0*%G'2 -" )'./'? -,' #"(%'E$'(- *))*(&'0'(-%C *!-,"$&, -,/%0*4 ("- 1' ?/-,/( 04 %-*-$-")4 )'0/-9_

):" VPP S6A7?8@ D8G&A8 B@ 6CC8S7J 6,- ?,-88- 6@@8A7J 7H67J DE A8G8A8,C8 7& 7H8 _BA?@SAB-8,C8 &G 7H8 ]T71UJ 7H8 ?,78AG8A8,C8 B,-8A VA7?CP8 N ?@ ,&7 7& D8 _B-I8- &,8'6C7PE 7H8 @6Q8 D6@?@ ?, A8P67?&, 7& 7H8 A8C8?S7 DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ &G SA&-BCYH?CH H6@ 6PA86-E D88, ?,78AC8S78- DE 6,&7H8A S6A7E 6@ ?7 ?@ YH8, 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@6A8 A8@S&,@?DP8 G&A @BCH ?,78AC8S7?&," \H8 TP6?Q6,7@ @BDQ?7 7H67 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7G6?P DE A8G8A8,C8 7& 6,E 78@7" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ @BDQ?7 7H67 A8C8?S7 DE 7H8Q &G?,G&AQ67?&, YH?CH Q6E >&A Q6E ,&7F D8 -8A?X8- GA&Q ?,78AC8S7 @?QSPE G&AQ@ S6A7 &P6YGBP6(-'!!/&'(#' 7,*)/(&_ J 6@ -?@CB@@8- 6D&X8J 6,- 7H67 @BGG?C?8,7 @6G8IB6A-@ 6A8?, SP6C8"

)K" ZA e6AA -8@CA?D8@ 7H?@ 6@ G&PP&Y@ ?, H?@ Y?7,8@@ @7678Q8,79

aH[9 h\H8 -8@CA?S7?&,@ H8 I?X8@ &G @H6A?,I &G ?,78PP?I8,C8 Y?7HG&A8?I, @7678@i 2" ("- N$%- *33!4 -" /(-'!!/&'(#' "1-*/('2 -,)"$&, /(-')#'3-/"(9 8,'%' 3*)*&)*3,% *33!4 -" *!! >")0% "> /(-'!!/&'(#'C /(#!$2/(& /(-'!!/&'(#' ;/= 2')/.'2 >)"0 #".')- ,$0*( /(-'!!/&'(#' %"$)#'% ;*% -,'4 ?"$!2 1' -')0'2 $(2')

K65B=C ;//= 2')/.'2 >)"0 ") #"(%-/-$-/(& )'#")2% "> *$2/" *(2a") ./%$*! %$).'/!!*(#' *(2 ;///= "1-*/('2 ") 2')/.'2 >)"0 #".')-

3)"3')-4 %'*)#,'%9

H:9 6 *0 *2./%'2 -,*- * 3"-'(-/*! /%%$' /( -,'%' 3)"#''2/(&% /%

?,'-,') -,' %,*)/(& "> /(-'!!/&'(#' /( -,' >")0 "> ;") -,*- /%2')/.'2 >)"0= #"00$(/#*-/"(% *(2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-*1'-?''( -,' \] *(2 >")'/&( &".')(0'(-% %,"$!2 /( %"0' %'(%'1' %'3*)*-'!4 )'&$!*-'29

HJ9 R)"0 -,' 3"/(- "> ./'? "> -,' 3)/.*#4 /(-')'%-% "> -,"%'/(2/./2$*!% ?," *)' %$1N'#- -" /(.'%-/&*-/.' 0'*%$)'%C 6 2" ("- #"(%/2') -,*- * ?")G*1!' 2/%-/(#-/"( #*( 1' 2)*?( 1'-?''(

%$#, /(-'!!/&'(#' *(2 -,' "-,') -,)'' >")0% "> /(-'!!/&'(#')'>'))'2 -" /( 3*)*&)*3, H[ *1".'9 6( 3*)-/#$!*)C 6 2" ("- #"(%/2') -,*- /(-'!!/&'(#' /( -,' >")0 "> ;") -,*- /% 2')/.'2

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

>$)-,') 'D*03!'C * #".')- ,$0*( /(-'!!/&'(#' %"$)#' 0*4 1'*1!' -" 3)"./2' /(>")0*-/"( *1"$- * -*)&'- *% * )'%$!- "> ,/% ") ,') >)/'(2%,/3 ;") 0")' /(-/0*-' )'!*-/"(%,/3= ?/-, -,' -*)&'-

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

18/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

-,*- /% 0")' 3)/.*-' -,*( /(>")0*-/"( -,*- #"$!2 1' "1-*/('2 >)"0C >") /(%-*(#'C /(-')#'3-/(& -,' -*)&'-O% '0*/!%9

QW9 U") #*( %"0' &'(')*! 2/%-/(#-/"( 1' 2)*?( 1'-?''(/(-'!!/&'(#' >)"0 /(-')#'3-/"( *(2 -,' "-,') >")0% "> #".')-

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

%$).'/!!*(#' ") -,' $%' "> #".')- ,$0*( /(-'!!/&'(#' %"$)#'%9 b

)L" ZA ]6-?8 @BDQ?7@ 7H67 ?7 Y&BP- D8 ?,6SSA&SA?678 6,- B,,8C8@@6AE 7& -?GG8A8,7?678

D87Y88, 7H8 -?GG8A8,7 W?,-@ &G ?,G&AQ67?&, YH?CH Q?IH7 D8 @BSSP?8- 8"I" 7& G&?P 6 D&QD SP&7 ?, +&,-&,J 6,- ?QSA6C7?C6DP8 7& 7AE 7& -A6Y 6 -?@7?,C7?&, D87Y88,?,G&AQ67?&, -8A?X8- GA&Q ?,78AC8S7 6,- ,&7 @& -8A?X8- &A 7& @88W 8'SP6,67?&,@ &A Q6W8 8,dB?A?8@ GA&Q ^.V &A 6,E &7H8A 6I8,CE 6@ 7& YH87H8A ?,G&AQ67?&, @BSSP?8--?- &A -?- ,&7 -8A?X8 GA&Q !A?@Q &A 6,E &7H8A @E@78Q &G ?,78AC8S7?&,"

)N" ZA .dB?A8@J G&A !A?X6CEJ YH& C6AA?8- 7H8 DBA-8, &G 7H8 6AIBQ8,7 &, 7H?@ ?@@B8 &, 7H S6A7 &G 6PP 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@J A8@S&,-8- DE Q6W?,I CP86A 7H67 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6A8 ,&7C&,78,-?,I 7H67 7H8 @BDQ?@@?&,@ H8 ?@ Q6W?,I ?, 7H?@ C6@8 6SSPE 7& 6,E ?,G&AQ67?&,,&7 &D76?,8- DE ?,78AC8S7 DE 7H8 ^.V" R7 6SS86A8- 7& B@ GA&Q H?@ @BDQ?@@?&,@ 7H6?,G&AQ67?&, GA&Q 7H8 ^.V Y&BP- G6PP ?,7& 7HA88 C678I&A?8@9

?F Q678A?6P YH?CH &, ?7@ G6C8 -8A?X8@ GA&Q ?,78AC8S7J SA&X?-8- B,@&P?C?78-k

??F C&QQB,?C67?&,@ YH?CH 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ H6X8 A8dB8@78- 7H8 ^.V 7& ?,78AC8S7J&A 7& Q6W8 6X6?P6DP8 7& 7H8Q 6@ ?,78AC8S7J D8C6B@8 7H8E 6A8 7H8Q@8PX8@ B,6D7& -& @& >j@&P?C?78- ?,78AC8S7fFk

???F 6PP &7H8A ?,G&AQ67?&, &A C&QQB,?C67?&,@ &D76?,8- GA&Q 7H8 ^.V DE Y6E &G @H6A8- ?,G&AQ67?&,J 6@ -?@CB@@8- DE ZA e6AA"

)2" .& G6A 6@ 7H8 G?A@7 C678I&AE ?@ C&,C8A,8-J ZA UE-8A 4T S&?,78- DE Y6E &G 6,6P&IE 7&

@"0:>NF &G UR!VJ YH?CH SA&X?-8@9

a 6( -,/% %'#-/"( ^#"34_C /( )'!*-/"( -" /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! ") )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-*C 0'*(% *(4 "> -,' >"!!"?/(& ;?,'-,') ") ("- /( 2"#$0'(-*)4 >")0= g

;*= *(4 #"34C 'D-)*#- ") %$00*)4 "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* ?,/#,/2'(-/>/'% /-%'!> *% -,' 3)"2$#- "> *( /(-')#'3-/"(9_

\H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6A8 ,&7 6--A8@@?,I 6,E ?,G&AQ67?&, YH?CH -&8@ ,&7 j/2'(-/>4 /-%'!> *%-,' 3)"2$#- "> *( /(-')#'3-/"( fJ 6,- H8 A8G8A@ 7& 7H?@ @BD@8C7?&, 6@ ?,-?C67?,I 7H67 7H?@

?@ 6 G86@?DP8 -?GG8A8,7?67?&,J A8C&I,?@8- 6@ @BCH >G&A &7H8A SBAS&@8@F ?, UR!V"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

19/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

(*" V@ G&A 7H8 @8C&,- C678I&AEJ 7H8A8 Y6@ @&Q8 -?@CB@@?&, &G 7H8 +6^L.8Y SA?,C?SP8>+6^L.8Y^ \ M.V.7T-W :L Eb-.[ZYTZ-8= S.7X8-.87 6V^ S::^ h02KNi VT 22LFJ ,6Q8PE7H67 6 SBDP?C D&-E ?@ A8dB?A8- 7& 8'8AC?@8 ?7@ -?@CA87?&,6AE S&Y8A@ 7& SA&Q&78 ,&7 7& C?ACBQX8,7F 7H8 S&P?CE 6,- &D_8C7@ &G 7H8 P8I?@P67?&, YH?CH CA8678- 7H&@

S&Y8A@" \H8A8 Y6@ 6P@& -?@CB@@?&,J 8Q6,67?,I GA&Q 6 dB8@7?&, GA&Q 7H8 \A?DB,6P

&G YH87H8A 7H8A8 Y6@ 6 A&P8 G&A 6 C&,C8S7 &G j6I8,CEf" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ SP86- ?, S6A6IA6SH :N &G 7H8?A U8@S&,@8 6@ G&PP&Y@9

^6( 3*)-/#$!*)C ("- !'*%- &/.'( -,' %*>'&$*)2% *(2 ".')%/&,- 0'#,*(/%0% -,*- 5*)!/*0'(- %*? >/- -" /03"%' /( -,' #*%' "> /(-')#'3-/"( 3$)%$*(- -" * K65B /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- 9 9 9 *(2 /(-,' !/&,- "> -,' ?'!! '%-*1!/%,'2 5*2>/'!2 3)/(#/3!'C /- /%*##'3-'2 -,*- /- ?"$!2 *% * 0*--') "> 2"0'%-/# 3$1!/# !*? 1'$(!*?>$! >") *(4 "> -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% -" 2'!/1')*-'!4#/)#$0.'(- -,"%' %*>'&$*)2% *(2 0'#,*(/%0% ;*(2 *--'03- -"*."/2 -,' (''2 -" *33!4 >") *( /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- $(2')

K65B= 14 *%G/(& * >")'/&( /(-'!!/&'(#' *&'(#4 -" /(-')#'3- #')-*/( %3'#/>/'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% *(2 2/%#!"%' -,'09 8,*- /%("- -" %*4 -,*- -,')' ?/!! ("- 1' #/)#$0%-*(#'% ?,')' -,')' *)'!'&/-/0*-' )'*%"(% -" *%G * >")'/&( /(-'!!/&'(#' *&'(#4 -"/(-')#'3- 3*)-/#$!*) #"00$(/#*-/"(%C >") 'D*03!'C ?,')' /- /%("- -'#,(/#*!!4 >'*%/1!' >") -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% -,'0%'!.'%-" $(2')-*G' -,' /(-')#'3-/"( /( E$'%-/"(9_

\H8 TP6?Q6,7@ -& ,&7 @BII8@7 7H67 @BCH 6 A8dB8@7 7& 7H8 ^.V G&A @&P?C?78- ?,78AC8S7Y&BP- G6PP G&BP &G 7H8 +6^L.8Y SA?,C?SP8J &A >?, 6,@Y8A 7& 7H8 S&?,7 A6?@8- DE 7H8\A?DB,6PF Y&BP- A8,-8A 7H8 ^.V 6, 6I8,7 G&A 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@" 1&Y8X8A 7H8E@BDQ?7 7H67J ?G 7H67 &CCBA@J 7H8, 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ Y?PP W,&Y 7H67 YH67 ?@ @BD@8dB

SA&-BC8- ?@ 7H8 SA&-BC7 &G ?,78AC8S7"

(0" V@ 7& 7H8@8 7Y& C678I&A?8@J Y8 @BQQ6A?@8- ZA .dB?A8@f @BDQ?@@?&,@ ?, 7H8 C&B&G 6AIBQ8,7 6@ G&PP&Y@ >6$*%3?$04" @ABCDQ9

ah,'-,') /- /% %"!/#/-'2C ") ?,'-,') /- /% ("- %"!/#/-'2C 2'*!/(& ?/-, -,' 3)"2$#- "> /(-')#'3- /%C *- %"0' !'.'! ") "-,')C *(/(-')>')'(#' ?/-, B)-/#!' : ?,/#, (''2% %"0' !'&*! 1*#G/(&C*(2 -,')' "$&,- -" 1'C *- ,"?'.') ,/&, * !'.'!C * 3$1!/%,'2

3)"#'2$)' /( )'!*-/"( -" /-9 b

()" V@ 7& 7H8 7H?A- C678I&AEJ 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ Q6W8 ,& @BDQ?@@?&,@J DB7 @BII8@7 7H67 78'8AC?@8 &G -?GG8A8,7?67?,I &B7 7H8 G?A@7 7Y& C678I&A?8@ @H&BP- ,&7 D8 -?GG?CBP7C8A76?,PE -&8@ ,&7 A8dB?A8 Q6W?,I ?,X8@7?I67?&,J YH87H8A &G 7H8 ^.V &A &7H8AY?@8J6@ 7& YH87H8A ?,G&AQ67?&, @BSSP?8- DE 7H8 ^.V -&8@ A8@BP7 GA&Q ?,78AC8S7"]GG8C7?X8PE G&A 7H8 SBAS&@8@ &G 7H?@ H86A?,I 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6A8 6CC8S7?,I 7H67 77H?A- C678I&AE &G ?,G&AQ67?&,J 6,- 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@f -86P?,I@ Y?7H ?7J Y&BP- ,&7 ,88-

_B@7?G?C67?&, DE A8G8A8,C8 7& VA7?CP8 N"

((" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 6CC8S7 7H67 7H8 &D76?,?,I &G ?,78AC8S7 Q678A?6P Y?7H?, 7H8 G?A@7 7Y&C678I&A?8@ GA&Q ^.V X?6 !A?@Q 7A?II8A@ 6, ?,78AG8A8,C8 Y?7H VA7?CP8 N" 1&Y8X8A ZA ]6-?8f@ @BDQ?@@?&, ?@ 7H67 7H8A8 ?@ ,& 6B7H&A?7E ?, .7A6@D&BAI 7& -678 7& @BII8@7 &@BSS&A7 7H8 SA&S&@?7?&, 7H67 7H8 aI8/8- A8dB?A8Q8,7@b Y&BP- 6SSPE 7& 7H8

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

20/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

&D76?,?,IJ H6,-P?,IJ B@8J -?@CP&@BA8 &A -8@7ABC7?&, &G G&A8?I, ?,78PP?I8,C8 Q678A?6P &@BCH W?,-" \H?@ ?@ 6 A8G8A8,C8 7& 7H8 -8C?@?&, &G 7H8 ]T71U A8G8AA8- 7& ?, S6A6IA6SH??F 6D&X8J YH8A8 7H8 T&BA7J ?, 6 C6@8 -86P?,I Y?7H 7H8 A8C&A-?,I &G 78P8C&QQB,?C67?&,@ ?, 7H8 C&BA@8 &G j@7A678I?C Q&,?7&A?,If >,&7 IA867PE -?GG8A8,7 7&?,78AC8S7?&, SBA@B6,7 7& 6 @"N>)FJ ,&7 G&A 7H8 G?A@7 7?Q8J 67 S6A6IA6SH N/)%-!4C-,*- -,' /03$&('2 0'*%$)' %,"$!2 ,*.' %"0' 1*%/% /( 2"0'%-/#!*?M /- *!%" )'>')% -" -,' E$*!/-4 "> -,' !*? /( E$'%-/"(C)'E$/)/(& -,*- /- %,"$!2 1' *##'%%/1!' -" -,' 3')%"( #"(#')('2C?," 0$%-C 0")'".') 1' *1!' -" >")'%'' /-% #"(%'E$'(#'% >") ,/0C *(2 #"03*-/1!' ?/-, -,' )$!' "> !*?9 b

\H8 T&BA7 7H8, SA&C88-8- 7& @87 &B7 ?, A8P67?&, 7& 6, ?,78AC8S7?&, C6@8 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I

SA&S&@?7?&,@J YH?CH H6X8 D8C&Q8 W,&Y, 6@ 7H8 I8/8- A8dB?A8Q8,7@9 Y8 H6X8,BQD8A8- 7H8@8 GA&Q 0=K G&A C&,X8,?8,C8"

a2:" 6( /-% #*%'P!*? "( %'#)'- 0'*%$)'% "> %$).'/!!*(#'C -,'I"$)- ,*% 2'.'!"3'2 -,' >"!!"?/(& 0/(/0$0 %*>'&$*)2% -,*-

%,"$!2 1' %'- "$- /( %-*-$-' !*? /( ")2') -" *."/2 *1$%'% "> 3"?')L ;@= -,' (*-$)' "> -,' ">>'(#'% ?,/#, 0*4 &/.' )/%' -" *(/(-')#'3-/"( ")2')M ;H= * 2'>/(/-/"( "> -,' #*-'&")/'% "> 3'"3!'!/*1!' -" ,*.' -,'/) -'!'3,"('% -*33'2M ;Q= * !/0/- "( -,'2$)*-/"( "> -'!'3,"(' -*33/(&M ;"!!"?'2

>") 'D*0/(/(&C $%/(& *(2 %-")/(& -,' 2*-* "1-*/('2M ;A= -,'

3)'#*$-/"(% -" 1' -*G'( ?,'( #"00$(/#*-/(& -,' 2*-* -" "-,') 3*)-/'%M *(2 ;Z= -,' #/)#$0%-*(#'% /( ?,/#, )'#")2/(&% 0*4 ") 0$%- 1' ')*%'2 ") -,' -*3'% 2'%-)"4'29 b

()"0 &*/(/(& /(%3/)*-/"( >)"0-,'%' 3)/(#/3!'%C /- >/(2% -,*- -,'%' )*-,') %-)/#- %-*(2*)2%C %'- $3 *(2 *33!/'2 /( -,' %3'#/>/# #"(-'D- "> %$).'/!!*(#' "> -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"(% 9 9 9 *)' ("- *33!/#*1!' *% %$#, -" #*%'%

%$#, *% -,' 3)'%'(- "('C #"(#')(/(& %$).'/!!*(#' ./* Y57 "> 0".'0'(-% /( 3$1!/# 3!*#'%C *(2 -,$% * 0'*%$)' ?,/#, 0$%- 1'#"(%/2')'2 -" /(-')>')' !'%% ?/-, -,' 3)/.*-' !/>' "> -,' 3')%"(#"(#')('2 -,*( -,' /(-')#'3-/"( "> ,/% ") ,') -'!'3,"('#"(.')%*-/"(% 9 9 9 6- ?/!! -,')'>")' *33!4 -,' 0")' &'(')*!

3) /(#/3!'% "( *2 'E$*-' 3)"- '# -/ "( *&*/(% - *) 1/ -) *)4/(-')>')'(#' ?/-, B)-/#!' : )/&,-% *% %$00*)/%'2 *1".'9 b

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

21/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

ZA ]6-?8 @BDQ?778- >6@ A8G8AA8- 7& ?, S6A6IA6SH ): 6D&X8F 7H67 7H?@ ?@ @?QSPE 6@S8C?8@ &G ?,78PP?I8,C8 I67H8A?,IJ ,&7 7& D8 8dB678- Y?7H 7H8 S&@?7?&, YH8A8 7H8 [c ?7@8PG ?,78AC8S7@" ZA UE-8A C&,78,-8- 7H67 7H?@ ?I,&A8- 7H8 G6C7 7H67 7H8 SA&-BC7 &7H8 ?,78AC8S7 Y&BP- 7H8, D8 @7&A8-J B@8- 6,- 6,6PE@8- ?, 7H8 @6Q8 Y6E 6@ ?,78AC8S78-Q678A?6P &D76?,8- DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7f@ 7H8Q@8PX8@ l 6P7H&BIH &G C&BA@8 7H67 Y&BP

6P@& 6SSPE 7& 7H8 ?,G&AQ67?&, Y?7H?, 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@f 7H?A- C678I&AE A8G8AA8- 7& ? S6A6IA6SH )N>???F 6D&X8"

(:" %&7H 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 6,- 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ 6CC8S7 7H67 .7A6@D&BAI _BA?@SAB-8,C8 SP6C8@@S8C?6P 8QSH6@?@ BS&, ?,78AC8S7?&," ]@@8,7?6PPE ZA .dB?A8@f @BDQ?@@?&, Y6@ 7H7H8A8 6A8 ^2/>>')'(- !'.'!% "> ^3)'%#)/1'2 14 !*? bJ 6,- 7H67J 6@ H8 SB7 ?7J a?' 2"(O- ('#'%%*)/!4 %*4 'D*#-!4 -,' %*0' V!'.'!XC 1$- "(' V,*%X -" ,*.' %"0'-,/(& *- !'*%- *33)"*#,/(& -,' ^3)'%#)/1'2 14 !*?_ %-*(2*)2%C %'- "$- /( E&F&$ '-#C ?,'( /- /%#"00$(/#*-/"(% /(-')#'3-'2 14 -,' \7 *(2 -,'( *##'%%'2 ,')'C )'#'/.'2 ,')'C*(*!4%'2 ,')'9_

(K" /8 6IA88 7H67 7H8 !A?@Q R@@B8 8,I6I8@ VA7?CP8 N 6,- 7H67 8X8, 67 6 jP&Y8A P8X8Pf 7H6,I8/8- 7H8A8 Y?PP ,88- 7& D8 6 C&QSP?6,C8 Y?7H A8dB?A8Q8,7@ DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@J

S6A7?CBP6APE ?, A8P67?&, 7& @7&A6I8J @H6A?,I 6,- A878,7?&,;-8@7ABC7?&," /8 H6X8 @87 &B7H8 @767B7&AE GA6Q8Y&AW YH?CH ?QS&@8@ &DP?I67?&,@ BS&, 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ A8P67?&, 7& ?7@ &D76?,?,I ?,G&AQ67?&, GA&Q 7H8 ^.VJ YH87H8A -8A?X8- GA&Q ?,78AC8S7&A &7H8AY?@8J DB7 Q&A8 ?@ A8dB?A8- DE 7H8 _BA?@SAB-8,C8 &G 7H8 ]T71UJ 6PD8?7 67jP8@@8A P8X8PfJ 6@ 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ SB7 ?7"

(L" \H8 A8P8X6,7 SA?,C?SP8@ 6SS86A 7& B@ 7& D8 7H67 ?, &A-8A G&A ?,78AG8A8,C8 Y?7H VA7?CP7& D8 ?,*##")2*(#' ?/-, -,' !*? 9

?F 7H8A8 QB@7 ,&7 D8 6, B,G8778A8- -?@CA87?&, G&A 8'8CB7?X8 6C7?&," \H8A8 QB@7 D8C&,7A&P@ &, 7H8 6AD?7A6A?,8@@ &G 7H67 6C7?&,"

??F 7H8 ,67BA8 &G 7H8 ABP8@ QB@7 D8 CP86A 6,- 7H8 6QD?7 &G 7H8Q QB@7 D8 ?, 7H8 SBDP?C -&Q6?, @& G6A 6@ S&@@?DP8J 6, a*2'E$*-' /(2/#*-/"( b I?X8, >M6Y:V8 \() h02N:i L ]1UU 0< 67 S6A6IA6SH KLFJ @& 7H67 7H8 8'?@78,C8 &G ?,78AG8A8,C8Y?7H SA?X6CE Q6E ?, I8,8A6P 78AQ@ D8 G&A8@886DP8"

V CP86A A8?78A67?&, &G 7H8@8 SA?,C?SP8@ ?@ C&,76?,8- ?, 7H8 _B-IQ8,7 &G 7H8 T&BA7 ?,JWc:\ \ GZ77.6 #".')-

%$).'/!!*(#' 14 3$1!/# *$-,")/-/'%C /( -,/% /(%-*(#' -,' 3"!/#'C2"0'%-/# !*? 0$%- 3)"./2' 3)"-'#-/"( *&*/(%- *)1/-)*)4/(-')>')'(#' ?/-, *( /(2/./2$*!l% )/&,- $(2') B)-/#!' :9

d")'".')C -,' !*? 0$%- 1' %$>>/#/'(-!4 #!'*) /( /-% -')0% -" &/.'/(2/./2$*!% *( *2'E$*-' /(2/#*-/"( *% -" -,' #/)#$0%-*(#'% /(?,/#, *(2 -,' #"(2/-/"(% "( ?,/#, 3$1!/# *$-,")/-/'% *)''(-/-!'2 -" )'%")- -" %$#, #".')- 0'*%$)'% 9 9 9

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

22/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

[:9 9 9 9 6( 3*)-/#$!*)C /( ")2') -" #"03!4 ?/-, -,' )'E$/)'0'(- "> -,' ^E$*!/-4 "> -,' !*?_C * !*? ?,/#, #"(>')% 2/%#)'-/"( 0$%- /(2/#*-' -,' %#"3' "> -,*- 2/%#)'-/"(C *!-,"$&, -,' 2'-*/!'2

3)"#'2$)'% *(2 #"(2/-/"(% -" 1' "1%').'2 2" ("- ('#'%%*)/!4,*.' -" 1' /(#")3")*-'2 /( )$!'% "> %$1%-*(-/.' !*?9 8,' 2'&)''

"> 3)'#/%/"( )'E$/)'2 "> -,' ^!*?_ /( -,/% #"(('#-/"( ?/!! 2'3'(2 $3"( -,' 3*)-/#$!*) %$1N'#-P0*--')9 7/(#' -,'/03!'0'(-*-/"( /( 3)*#-/#' "> 0'*%$)'% "> %'#)'- %$).'/!!*(#'"> #"00$(/#*-/"(% /% ("- "3'( -" %#)$-/(4 14 -,' /(2/./2$*!%#"(#')('2 ") -,' 3$1!/# *- !*)&'C /- ?"$!2 1' #"(-)*)4 -" -,')$!' "> !*? >") -,' !'&*! 2/%#)'-/"( &)*(-'2 -" -,' 'D'#$-/.' g ") -" * N$2&' g -" 1' 'D3)'%%'2 /( -')0% "> *( $(>'--')'2 3"?')9I"(%'E$'(-!4C -,' !*? 0$%- /(2/#*-' -,' %#"3' "> *(4 %$#,2/%#)'-/"( #"(>'))'2 "( -,' #"03'-'(- *$-,")/-/'% *(2 -,'0*((') "> /-% 'D')#/%' ?/-, %$>>/#/'(- #!*)/-4 -" &/.' -,'/(2/./2$*! *2'E$*-' 3)"-'#-/"( *&*/(%- *)1/-)*)4 /(-')>')'(#'9 b

(N" R7 ?@ dB?78 SP6?,J 6@ Y8 H6X8 @6?- 67 S6A6IA6SH K 6D&X8J 7H67 ?, 7H8 G?8P- &G ,67?&,6P@8CBA?7E QBCH P8@@ ?@ A8dB?A8- 7& D8 SB7 ?, 7H8 SBDP?C -&Q6?,J 6,- 7H8 -8IA88 &G G&A8@886D?P?7E QB@7 D8 A8-BC8-J D8C6B@8 &7H8AY?@8 7H8 YH&P8 SBAS&@8 &G 7H8 76W8, 7& SA&78C7 ,67?&,6P @8CBA?7E Y&BP- D8 67 A?@W" \H8 X?8Y@ &G 7H8 T&BA7 7& 8GG8C7 ?, S6A6IA6SH@ KL 6,- KN &G M6Y:V8 6A8 8,C6S@BP678- DE 7H8 T&BA7 ?, K86V^8-\ CU8^8V h02NLi 2 ]1UU >")'%''*1/!/-4 /( -,' %3'#/*! #"(-'D- "> %'#)'- #"(-)"!% "> %-*>> /( %'#-")% *>>'#-/(& (*-/"(*!

%'#$)/-4 #*(("- 1' -,' %*0' *% /( 0*(4 "-,') >/'!2%9 8,$%C /- #*(("- 0'*( -,*- *( /(2/./2$*! %,"$!2 1' '(*1!'2 -" >")'%''

3)'#/%'!4 ?,*- #,'#G% ?/!! 1' 0*2' /( ,/% )'&*)2 14 -,'7?'2/%, %3'#/*! 3"!/#' %')./#' /( /-% '>>")-% -" 3)"-'#- (*-/"(*!

%'#$)/-49 U'.')-,'!'%%C /( * %4%-'0 *33!/#*1!' -" #/-/k'(% &'(')*!!4C *% $(2') -,' 5')%"(('! I"(-)"! `)2/(*(#'C -,' !*?,*% -" 1' %$>>/#/'(-!4 #!'*) /( /-% -')0% -" &/.' -,'0 *(*2'E$*-' /(2/#*-/"( *% -" -,' #/)#$0%-*(#'% /( ?,/#, *(2 -,'#"(2/-/"(% "( ?,/#, -,' 3$1!/# *$-,")/-/'% *)' '03"?')'2 -")'%")- -" -,/% G/(2 "> %'#)'- *(2 3"-'(-/*!!4 2*(&')"$%/(-')>')'(#' ?/-, 3)/.*-' !/>'9

6( *%%'%%/(& ?,'-,') -,' #)/-')/"( "> >")'%''*1/!/-4 /% %*-/%>/'2C*##"$(- 0*4 1' -*G'( *!%" "> /(%-)$#-/"(% ") *20/(/%-)*-/.'

3)*#-/#'% ?,/#, 2" ("- ,*.' -,' %-*-$% "> %$1%-*(-/.' !*?C /( %" >*) *% -,"%' #"(#')('2 *)' 0*2' %$>>/#/'(-!4 *?*)' "> -,'/) #"(-'(-%9

6( *22/-/"(C ?,')' -,' /03!'0'(-*-/"( "> -,' !*? #"(%/%-% "> %'#)'- 0'*%$)'%C ("- "3'( -" %#)$-/(4 14 -,' /(2/./2$*!%#"(#')('2 ") 14 -,' 3$1!/# *- !*)&'C -,' !*? /-%'!>C *% "33"%'2 -" -,' *##"03*(4/(& *20/(/%-)*-/.' 3)*#-/#'C 0$%- /(2/#*-' -,'

%#"3' "> *(4 2/%#)'-/"( #"(>'))'2 "( -,' #"03'-'(- *$-,")/-4?/-, %$>>/#/'(- #!*)/-4C ,*./(& )'&*)2 -" -,' !'&/-/0*-' */0 ">

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

23/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

-,' 0'*%$)' /( E$'%-/"(C -" &/.' -,' /(2/./2$*! *2'E$*-' 3)"-'#-/"( *&*/(%- *)1/-)*)4 /(-')>')'(#'9 b

(2" /8 C&,@8dB8,7PE D86A C6A8GBPPE ?, Q?,- 7H8 A8dB?A8Q8,7 7& I?X8 6-8dB678 SA&78C7?&,6I6?,@7 6AD?7A6AE ?,78AG8A8,C8 &, 7H8 &,8 H6,-J DB7 &, 7H8 &7H8A H6,- 7H67

G&A8@886D?P?7E -&8@ ,&7 A8dB?A8 6PP 7H8 ABP8@ YH?CH I&X8A, &A 8'CPB-8 7H6AD?7A6A?,8@@ 7& D8 -?@CP&@8-J S6A7?CBP6APE ?, 7H8 G?8P- &G ,67?&,6P @8CBA?7E" /86SSA&6CH 7H?@ !A?@Q R@@B8J ?, YH?CH ?7 ?@J 6@ Y8 H6X8 @87 &B7J P6AI8PE C&QQ&, IA&7H67 7H8 I8/8- A8dB?A8Q8,7@ -& ,&7 ,88- 7& D8 8,G&AC8- ?, 6PP 7H8?A A?I&BAJ ?,A8P67?&, 7& 6 C6@8 YH8A8 7H8 ?,78AC8S7?&, H6@ 6PA86-E D88, C6AA?8- &B7 DE &7H8A@"

67 T5 L -,' B#- )'!*-' "(!4 -" -,' *20/(/%-)*-/.' /03!'0'(-*-/"( ">

3)'#'2/(& 3)"./%/"(%C ?,/#, 'D3)'%%!4 !/0/- -,' $%' "> /(>")0*-/"( 14 -,' 7')./#' -" -,*- ('#'%%*)4 -" >$!>/! /-%

>$(#-/"(%9

9 9 9

6( !/&,- "> -,' *1".'C -,' I"00/%%/"( #"(%/2')% -,*- /( -,' 3)'%'(- #*%' -,' !*? /% >")0$!*-'2 ?/-, %$>>/#/'(- 3)'#/%/"( -"'(*1!' -,' *33!/#*(- -" *(-/#/3*-' -,' *33!/#*-/"( "> .'--/(&

3)"#'2$)'% *(2 -" -,' !/G'!4 (*-$)' "> -,' /(."!.'0'(- "> -,'7'#$)/-4 7')./#' *(2 3"!/#' 73'#/*! e)*(#,'% ?/-, )'&*)2 -" -,'#"!!'#-/"(C )'#")2/(& *(2 )'!'*%' "> /(>")0*-/"( )'!*-/(& -",/0%'!>9b

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

24/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

')'(#' /% 0*2' /( %'#-/"( H "> -,' 7'#$)/-4 7')./#' B#- @J:J *(2 %'#-/"(% H *(2 < "> -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% B#- @JJ -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% >") -,' ,*(2!/(& *(2 $%' "> /(-'!!/&'(#'"1-*/('2 *% * )'%$!-C *)' ;*(2 ,*.' *!?*4% 1''(= G'3- #"(>/2'(-/*!9 6 *0 %*-/%>/'2 -,*- -,'4 #*(("- %*>'!4 1' 3$1!/%,'2 ?/-,"$- $(2')0/(/(& -,' /(-')'%-% "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4 *(2 -,'

3)'.'(-/"( *(2 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0'9 8,')' *)' >"$) 0*/(

)'*%"(% >") -,/%9b

ZA ]6-?8 &, ?,@7ABC7?&,@ @7678- ?, &S8, H86A?,I 7H67 @BCH *))*(&'0'(-% 6P@&?,CPB-8- SA&X?@?&, G&A -8@7ABC7?&," ZA e6AA 6P@& A8G8AA8- ?, S6A6IA6SH L< &G HY?7,8@@ @7678Q8,7 7& YH67 7H8 R.T H6- @6?- ?, S6A6IA6SH L &G ?7@ .7678Q8,7J @87 &B7 ?,

S6A6IA6SH )( 6D&X8J 6@ 7& `T14 H6X?,I SB7 ?, SP6C8 S&P?C?8@ 6,- SA&C8-BA8@ 7&B,-8AS?, 7H8 @767B7&AE SA&X?@?&,@"

-,' *))*(&'0'(- 1'-?''( -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% *(2 -,' \]O%

R")'/&( 6(-'!!/&'(#' 5*)-(')% >") -,' %,*)/(& "> /(-'!!/&'(#'C *(2 -,' /(-')(*!

&$/2*(#' "> -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% >") -,' ,*(2!/(& *(2 $%' "> /(-'!!/&'(#'"1-*/('2 *% * )'%$!- *)' ;*(2 ,*.' *!?*4% 1''(= G'3- #"(>/2'(-/*! 9 9 9 *(2 #*(("-

%*>'!4 1' 3$1!/%,'2 ?/-,"$- $(2')0/(/(& -,' /(-')'%- "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4 *(2 -,' 3)'.'(-/"( *(2 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0' b" 18 I?X8@ G&BA -876?P8- A86@&,@J 7&YH?CH Y8 A8G8A"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

25/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

KF &G UR!V" \H8 \A?DB,6P H6@ 7H8 S&Y8A 7& &S8A678 ?7&Y, SA&C8-BA8@ SBA@B6,7 7& 7H8 UBP8@ >7H8 R,X8@7?I67&AE !&Y8A@ \A?DB,6P UBP8)***F YH?CH H6X8 D88, Q6-8 B,-8A @"K2>KF &G UR!VJ YH?CH H6X8 A8I6A-J ?,

S6A7?CBP6AJ 7&9

a;*= -,' (''2 -" %'#$)' -,*- 0*--')% ?,/#, *)' -,' %$1N'#- "> 3)"#''2/(&%C #"03!*/(-% ") )'>')'(#'% 1)"$&,- 1'>")' ") 0*2'-" -,' 8)/1$(*! *)' 3)"3')!4 ,'*)2 *(2 #"(%/2')'2M *(2

;1= -,' (''2 -" %'#$)' -,*- /(>")0*-/"( /% ("- 2/%#!"%'2 -" *('D-'(-C ") /( * 0*((')C -,*- /% #"(-)*)4 -" -,' 3$1!/# /(-')'%- ")

3)'N$2/#/*! -" (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4C -,' 3)'.'(-/"( ") 2'-'#-/"( "> %')/"$% #)/0'C -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!P1'/(& "> -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0") -,' #"(-/($'2 2/%#,*)&' "> -,' >$(#-/"(% "> *(4 "> -,'/(-'!!/&'(#' %')./#'%9_

UBP8@ K 6,- 2 S8AQ?778- 6,- G6C?P?7678- 7H8 G&PP&Y?,I &G 7H8 SA&C8-BA8 @87 &B7 ?, S6A6IA6SH 0* 6D&X8 >S6A7?CBP6APE 6@ @87 &B7 ?, S6A6IA6SH 02"( 7H8A8 C?78-F"

@88 S6A6IA6SH ??F 6D&X8F"

???F R7 H6@ 6CC8@@ 7& 6PP @8CA87 ?,G&AQ67?&,J 6,- C6, 6-_&BA, ?,7& CP&@8- H86A?,I ?&A-8A 7& 6@@8@@ YH87H8A 7H8 *))*(&'0'(-% >6F -& ?,-88- 8'?@7 6@ 6@@8A78- DE ZA e6AAJ >DF 6A8 6-8dB678 7& -& 7H8 _&D &G I?X?,I 7H8 ?,-?X?-B6P a*2'E$*-'

3)"-'#-/"( *&*/(%- *)1/-)*)4 /(-')>')'(#' b"

?XF R7 H6@J 6,- 76W8@J 7H8 &SS&A7B,?7EJ Y?7H 7H8 D8,8G?7 &G GBPP 6AIBQ8,7J 7& SA&GBPPE YH87H8A Q6778A@ -?@CP&@8- 7& ?7 ?, CP&@8- H86A?,IJ SBA@B6,7 7& 7

U8@S&,-8,7@f &DP?I67?&, 7& -& @& SBA@B6,7 7& @"KN>KF &G UR!VJ C6, 6,- @H&BP- D8 -?@CP&@8- ?, &S8, 6,- 7H8A8DE SBDP?C?@8-"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

26/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

-,' >")'/&( &".')(0'(- /% ('#'%%*)4 -""1-*/( -,' #"00$(/#*-/"(% *- /%%$' 1'#*$%' -,'4#*(("- 1' "1-*/('2 $(2') -,' )'!'.*(- K65B/(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- *(2 /- /% ('#'%%*)4 *(2

3)"3")-/"(*-' >") -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% -" "1-*/(-,"%' #"00$(/#*-/"(%M ")

19 0*G/(& -,' )'E$'%- >") -,' #"00$(/#*-/"(% *- /%%$' /(-,' *1%'(#' "> * )'!'.*(- K65B /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- 2"'% ("- *0"$(- -" * 2'!/1')*-' #/)#$0.'(-/"( "> K65B") "-,')?/%' #"(-)*.'(' -,' 3)/(#/3!' '%-*1!/%,'2 /(

5*2>/'!2 .9 d/(/%-') "> B&)/#$!-$)'C R/%,')/'% *(2 R""2 V@JZ:X BI JJ[ ;>") 'D*03!'C 1'#*$%' /- /% ("- -'#,(/#*!!4 >'*%/1!' -" "1-*/( -,' #"00$(/#*-/"(% ./*

K65B /(- ')# '3- /"(=C *(2 /- /% (' #'%%*)4 *(2 3)"3")-/"(*-' >") -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#' 7')./#'% -" "1-*/(-,"%' #"00$(/#*-/"(%9 6( -,'%' #/)#$0%-*(#'%C -,'E$'%-/"( ?,'-,') -,' )'E$'%- %,"$!2 1' 0*2' ?"$!2 1'#"(%/2')'2 *(2 2'#/2'2 $3"( 14 -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-'

3')%"(*!!49

R") -,'%' 3$)3"%'% * ^)'!'.*(- K65B /(-')#'3-/"(?*))*(-_ 0'*(% '/-,') ;/= * %:;@= ?*))*(- /( )'!*-/"( -"-,' -*)&'- *- /%%$'M ;//= * %:;

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

27/77

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

28/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

J,)= 3"*1 #%2"%3- :4"'9 4)'= 6% 0(9% &) %A*%/-&4)('**"03-()*%3. ()9 1(3 )4- 4**"##%9 (3 (- -1% 9(-% 45 -1&33-(-%0%)-?b

??F \H8E @BDQ?778- 7H67 7H8 5?@CP&@BA8 YH?CH Y6@ SA&-BC8- 6G78A 7H8 G?ACP&@8- H86A?,I 6,- 7H8, 6Q8,-8- ?, 7H8 P?IH7 &G 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@f YA?778,

@BDQ?@@?&,@ 6,- 7H8 GBA7H8A CP&@8- 6,- &S8, H86A?,I@J Y6@ B,@67?@G6C7&AE7H67 ?7 -?- ,&7 -?@CP&@8 ?7@ @&BAC8@ ,&A &G YH67 ?7 Y6@ 6 I?@7 &A @BQQ6AE"

>???F \H8 -8@CA?S7?&, &G C?ACBQ@76,C8@ ?, YH?CH @BCH 6 A8dB8@7 C&BP- D8 Q6-YH8A8 6 @"N>

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

29/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

6,- 6CCBA678 @BQQ6AE &A Am@BQm &G 7H67 S6A7 &G 7H8 8X?-8,C8 I?X8, ?, 7H8CP&@8- H86A?,I YH?CH &BIH7 7& D8 -?@CP&@8-9 6,- 7H67 7H8 D6P6,C8 &G 7H88X?-8,C8 6,- @BDQ?@@?&,@ I?X8, ?, CP&@8- H86A?,I Y6@ 7&& @8,@?7?X8 G&A -?@CP&@BA8 Y?7H&B7 A?@W 7& ,67?&,6P @8CBA?7E &A 7& 7H8 ^T^5 SA?,C?SP8"

>?XF /8 6A8 @67?@G?8- 7H67 7H8 -8@CA?S7?&, &G 7H8 C?ACBQ@76,C8@ ?, YH?CHJ YH8, A8dB8@7 ?@ Q6-8J 7H8A8 ?@ 6, 8'?@7?,I Y6AA6,7 ?@ CP86A" VP7H&BIH 7H8 A86-8A &G7H?@ _B-IQ8,7 Y?PP D8 8,6DP8- 7& B,-8A@76,- 7H8 S&@?7?&, D8778A YH8,J ?,A8P67?&, 7& 7H8 @"N>??F D8P&YJ 7H8 @6Q8 C&,@?-8A67?&,@Y?PP 6SSPE"

>??F V@ ZA .dB?A8@ 6CC8S78-J 7H8 CP6A?G?C67?&, I?X8, Y?7H?, S6A6IA6SH 0 &G 7H85?@CP&@BA8J 7H67 7H8A8 Y?PP &,PE D8 6 A8dB8@7 B,-8A !A?@Q 6,-;&A [S@7A86QJ

DE A8G8A8,C8 7& 7H8 8'?@78,C8 &G 6 @"N>-86P7 Y?7H?, -876?P D8P&YF ?, G6C7 6SSPE9 8'C8S7 6@ H8 S&?,78- &B7J ?, A8@S8C7 &G 6 0>DFU8dB8@7 @& G6A 6@ @"0K @6G8IB6A-@ 6A8 C&,C8A,8-"

:(" \H8 &,8 Q6778A &G C&,C8A, ?@ 7H?@" VP7H&BIH ?7 ?@ 7H8 C6@8 7H67 6,E A8dB8@7 G&AJ A8C8?S7 &GJ ?,78AC8S7 &A C&QQB,?C67?&,@ -676 SBA@B6,7 7& !A?@Q 6,-;&A [S@7A86Q ?@&A-?,6A?PE @BD_8C7 7& 7H8 @6Q8 @6G8IB6A-@ 6@ ?, 6 C6@8 YH8A8 ?,78AC8S7 &C&QQB,?C67?&, -676 6A8 &D76?,8- -?A8C7PE DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@J ?G 7H8A8 Y8A8 6 0>DFA8dB8@7J 6PD8?7 7H67 @BCH A8dB8@7 QB@7 I& 7& 7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678J 6,- 7H67 6,Q678A?6P @& &D76?,8- QB@7 D8 -86P7 Y?7H SBA@B6,7 7& UR!VJ 7H8A8 ?@ 7H8 S&@@?D?P7H67 7H8 @"0K SA&78C7?&, Q?IH7 ,&7 6SSPE" V@ 6PA86-E ?,-?C678-J ,& 0>DF A8dB8@7 H6@ ?,G6C7 8X8A &CCBAA8-J 6,- 7H8A8 H6@ 7HB@ D88, ,& SA&DP8Q H?7H8A7&" /8 6A8 H&Y8X8A@67?@G?8- 7H67 7H8A8 &BIH7 7& D8 ?,7A&-BC8- 6 SA&C8-BA8 YH8A8DE 6,E @BCH A8dB8@7?7 D8 Q6-8J YH8, A8G8AA8- 7& 7H8 .8CA876AE &G .7678J QB@7 6--A8@@ 7H8 ?@@B8 &G@"0K>(F"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

30/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

:??F \H?@ ?@ &G C&BA@8 &G ?7@8PG ,&7 @BGG?C?8,7J D8C6B@8 7H8 *))*(&'0'(-% QB@7 D8@BGG?C?8,7PE 6CC8@@?DP8 7& 7H8 SBDP?C" /8 6A8 @67?@G?8- 7H67 7H8E 6A8 @BGG?@?I,S&@78- DE X?A7B8 &G 7H8 @767B7&AE GA6Q8Y&AW 7& YH?CH Y8 H6X8 A8G8AA8- 7H8 .7678Q8,7@ &G 7H8 R.T 6,- 7H8 T&QQ?@@?&,8A dB&78- 6D&X8J 6,- 6@ ,&YJ 6G78A

7H8 7Y& CP&@8- H86A?,I@ 7H67 Y8 H6X8 H8P-J SBDP?CPE -?@CP&@8- DE 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@6,- A8C&A-8- ?, 7H?@ _B-IQ8,7"

>???F \H8@8*))*(&'0'(-% 6A8 @BD_8C7 7& &X8A@?IH7"

>?XF \ H8 %#"3' "> -,' 2/%#)'-/"( #"(>'))'2 &, 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 7& A8C8?X8 6,-H6,-P8 ?,78AC8S78- Q678A?6P 6,- C&QQB,?C67?&,@ -676 6,- >@BD_8C7 7& 7H8 @"N>

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

31/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

a T.')4"(' ,*% -,' )/&,- -" -,' 3)"-'#-/"( "> -,' !*? *&*/(%- %$#, /(-')>')'(#' "b

:L" VQ,8@7Ef@ C6@8 ?@ 7H67 7H8 [,?78- c?,I-&Q 7H8A8DE &Y8@ 6 S&@?7?X8 &DP?I67?&, 7& SA8X8,7 &A G&A8@76PP 7H8 [,?78- .7678@ GA&Q ?,78AC8S7?,I @BCH C&QQB,?C67?&,@k 7H?

Y&BP- 8'78,- 7& ,&7 6CdB?8@C?,I ?, @BCH C&BA@8 DE A8C8?X?,I 7H8 SA&-BC7" \H8A8 6A8,BQ8A&B@ -?GG?CBP7?8@ 6D&B7 @BCH 6, 6AIBQ8,7" \H8 G?A@7 ?@ 7H67 @BCH 6PP8I8- S&@-B7E Y&BP- ,88- 7& D8 8,G&AC86DP8 6I6?,@7 7H8 ["c" DE 7H?@ TP6?Q6,7 >VQ,8@7ER,78A,67?&,6PF" \H8, ?7 Y&BP- @88Q X8AE B,P?W8PE 7H67 @BCH 6 C&,78,7?&, Y&BP- G6PPY?7H?, 7H8 6QD?7 &G 7H8 ?@@B8 D8?,I -8C?-8- 67 7H?@ H86A?,IJ 6@ @87 &B7 ?, S6A6IA6SH 0J8-T-6V^ GZ778YY +86[8 S:ZV^6T.:V \ (V.T8^).Vb^:] h02LNi 0< 5U 00L 6,- 7H8 &7H8A T&QQ?@@?&, C6@8@ A8C?78- Y?7H6IA88Q8,7 ?, OGQEY3G6U. \ S:-8.bV C8[-8T6-W h)**Ni 4% )N2 67 S6A6IA6SH@ 2K 7&22F" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 6P@& A8G8A 7& M \ *T6YW h)*0(i :L ]1UU )2 67 S6A6IA6SH 0)LJYH8A8 7H8 ]T71U @6?- 7H679

a@H[ 9 9 9 -,' I"(.'(-/"( ")&*(% ,*.' )'3'*-'2!4 %-*-'2 -,*- -,'I"(.'(-/"( 2"'% ("- #"(-*/( * )/&,- ?,/#, )'E$/)'% * F/&,I"(-)*#-/(& 5*)-4 -" 'D')#/%' 2/3!"0*-/# 3)"-'#-/"(C ") '%3"$%'*( *33!/#*(-O% #"03!*/(-% $(2') /(-')(*-/"(*! !*?C ") "-,')?/%'-" /(-').'(' ?/-, -,' *$-,")/-/'% "> *("-,') %-*-' "( ,/% ") ,') 1',*!>9 b

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eR.V 6,- ]'8CB7?X8 #A-8A 0)((( Y8A8 ,&7 ?PP8I6P"

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

32/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

K*" /8 -?- ,&7 C6PP BS&, 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 7& A8@S&,- 7& 7H?@ 6--?7?&,6P @BDQ?@@?&,J 6,-Y8 -& ,&7 6CC8S7 ?7J G&A 7H8 A86@&,@ Y8 H6X8 @87 &B7 6D&X8"

,4A Ce@O%Q *CC(A

K0" /8 QB@7 D8I?, DE @877?,I &B7 6 P?77P8 &G 7H8 @767B7&AE @7ABC7BA8 C&,76?,8- ?, UR!V"%E @"0>0FJ ?,78AC8S7?&, &G 6,E C&QQB,?C67?&, ?, 7H8 C&BA@8 &G ?7@ 7A6,@Q?@@?&, DQ86,@ &G 6 SBDP?C 78P8C&QQB,?C67?&, @E@78Q ?@ B,P6YGBP B,P8@@J A8P8X6,7PE 7& 7HC6@8J ?7 76W8@ SP6C8 6@ SA&X?-8- G&A DE @"0>:F>DF &G 7H8 VC7 ?, 6CC&A-6,C8 Y?7HY6AA6,7 B,-8A @": >a6, ?,78AC8S7?&, Y6AA6,7bF" %E @")>)F 6 S8A@&, ?,78AC8S7@ 6C&QQB,?C67?&, ?, 7H8 C&BA@8 &G ?7@ 7A6,@Q?@@?&, DE Q86,@ &G 6 78P8C&QQB,?C67?&@E@78Q ?G >Q678A?6PPEF H8 @& Q&-?G?8@ &A ?,78AG8A8@ Y?7H 7H8 @E@78Q &A ?7@ &&A @& Q&,?7&A@ 7A6,@Q?@@?&,@ Q6-8 DE Q86,@ &G 7H8 @E@78Q 6@ 7& Q6W8 a %"0' ") *!! "> -,' #"(-'(-% "> -,' #"00$(/#*-/"( *.*/!*1!'C ?,/!' 1'/(& -)*(%0/--'2C -" * 3')%"("-,') -,*( -,' %'(2') ") /(-'(2'2 )'#/3/'(- "> -,' #"00$(/#*-/"( b" %E @")>LF 7H87?Q8@ YH?P8 6 C&QQB,?C67?&, ?@ D8?,I 7A6,@Q?778- DE Q86,@ &G 6 78P8C&QQB,?C67?&,

@E@78Q a %,*!! 1' -*G'( -" /(#!$2' *(4 -/0' ?,'( -,' %4%-'0 14 0'*(% "> ?,/#, -,'#"00$(/#*-/"( /% 1'/(&C ") ,*% 1''(C -)*(%0/--'2 /% $%'2 >") %-")/(& /- /( * 0*((') -,*- '(*1!'% -,' /(-'(2'2 )'#/3/'(- -" #"!!'#- /- ") "-,')?/%' -" ,*.' *##'%% -" /- b"

K)" R7 ?@ C&QQ&, IA&B,- 7H67 ?,78AC8S7?&, C6, @?QSPE C&QSA?@8 7H8 &D76?,?,I 6,-A8C&A-?,I &G 6 C&QQB,?C67?&, >6@ ?7 ?@ D8?,I 7A6,@Q?778-FJ @& 6@ 7& Q6W8 ?7 6X6?P6DP@BD@8dB8,7PE 7& D8 A86-J P&&W8- 67 &A P?@78,8- 7& DE 6 S8A@&,9 ,& &,8 ?, G6C7 ,88-@6C7B6PPE 7& H6X8 A86-J P&&W8- 67 &A P?@78,8- 7& 7H8 C&QQB,?C67?&, G&A ?,78AC8S7?&, 7&CCBA"

K(" .": &G 7H8 VC7 SA&X?-8@ ?, Q678A?6P S6A7 6@ G&PP&Y@9

aG ;%"&$?&4"0#% 20"H * 2*$$*%"-

;@= 7$1N'#- -" -,' >"!!"?/(& 3)"./%/"(% "> -,/% I,*3-')C -,'7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' 0*4 /%%$' * ?*))*(- *$-,")/%/(& ") )'E$/)/(& -,' 3')%"( -" ?,"0 /- /% *22)'%%'2C 14 *(4 %$#, #"(2$#- *%0*4 1' 2'%#)/1'2 /( -,' ?*))*(-C -" %'#$)' *(4 "(' ") 0")' "> -,' >"!!"?/(&f

;*= -,' /(-')#'3-/"( /( -,' #"$)%' "> -,'/) -)*(%0/%%/"( 140'*(% "> * 3"%-*! %')./#' ") -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"( %4%-'0 ">

-,' #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2'%#)/1'2 /( -,' ?*))*(-M

9 9 9

9 9 9

;2= -,' 2/%#!"%$)'C /( %$#, 0*((') *% 0*4 1' %" 2'%#)/1'2C"> /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! "1-*/('2 14 *(4 /(-')#'3-/"(*$-,")/%'2 ") )'E$/)'2 14 -,' ?*))*(-C *(2 "> )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-*9

;H= 8,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' %,*!! ("- /%%$' *( /(-')#'3-/"(?*))*(- $(!'%% ,' 1'!/'.'%f

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

33/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;*= -,*- -,' ?*))*(- /% ('#'%%*)4 "( &)"$(2% >*!!/(& ?/-,/( %$1%'#-/"( ;Q=M *(2

;1= -,*- -,' #"(2$#- *$-,")/%'2 14 -,' ?*))*(- /% 3)"3")-/"(*-' -" ?,*- /% %"$&,- -" 1' *#,/'.'2 14 -,*-

#"(2$#-9

;Q= 7$1N'#- -" -,' >"!!"?/(& 3)"./%/"(% "> -,/% %'#-/"(C *?*))*(- /% ('#'%%*)4 "( &)"$(2% >*!!/(& ?/-,/( -,/% %$1%'#-/"(/> /- /% ('#'%%*)4f

;*= /( -,' /(-')'%-% "> (*-/"(*! %'#$)/-4M

;1= >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> 3)'.'(-/(& ") 2'-'#-/(& %')/"$% #)/0'Mh&Ai

;#= >") -,' 3$)3"%' "> %*>'&$*)2/(& -,' '#"("0/# ?'!!P1'/(& "> -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0M

" " "

; *(4 ?*))*(- %,*!! /(#!$2' ?,'-,') -,' /(>")0*-/"(?,/#, /- /% -,"$&,- ('#'%%*)4 -" "1-*/( $(2') -,' ?*))*(- #"$!2 )'*%"(*1!4 1' "1-*/('2 14 "-,') 0'*(%9

;A= B ?*))*(- %,*!! ("- 1' #"(%/2')'2 ('#'%%*)4 "( -,' &)"$(2 >*!!/(& ?/-,/( %$1%'#-/"( ;Q=;#= $(!'%% -,' /(>")0*-/"( ?,/#, /- /% -,"$&,- ('#'%%*)4 -" "1-*/( /% /(>")0*-/"( )'!*-/(& -" -,'*#-% ") /(-'(-/"(% "> 3')%"(% "$-%/2' -,' e)/-/%, 6%!*(2%9

;Z= 8,' #"(2$#- *$-,")/%'2 14 *( /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- %,*!! 1'-*G'( -" /(#!$2'f

;*= *!! %$#, #"(2$#- ;/(#!$2/(& -,' /(-')#'3-/"( "> #"00$(/#*-/"(% ("- /2'(-/>/'2 14 -,' ?*))*(-= *% /- /%('#'%%*)4 -" $(2')-*G' /( ")2') -" 2" ?,*- /% 'D3)'%%!4*$-,")/%'2 ") )'E$/)'2 14 -,' ?*))*(-M

;1= #"(2$#- >") "1-*/(/(& )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-*M *(2

;#= #"(2$#- 14 *(4 3')%"( ?,/#, /% #"(2$#- /( 3$)%$*(#' "> * )'E$/)'0'(- /03"%'2 14 ") "( 1',*!> "> -,' 3')%"( -"?,"0 -,' ?*))*(- /% *22)'%%'2 -" 1' 3)"./2'2 ?/-,*%%/%-*(#' ?/-, &/./(& '>>'#- -" -,' ?*))*(-9 b

KQ678A?6PPE G&A &BA SBAS&@8FJ 7H8 5?A8C7&A `8,8A6P &G ZR:J 7TH?8G &G ZRK 6,- 7H8 5?A8C7&A &G `T14" .6X8 ?, 8'C8S7?&,6P C?ACBQ@76,C8@J 6,?,78AC8S7?&, Y6AA6,7 C6,,&7 D8 ?@@B8- 8'C8S7 B,-8A 7H8 H6,- &G 7H8 .8CA876AE &G

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

34/77

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

35/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;//= -,*- ,' #"(%/2')% -,' 'D*0/(*-/"( "> 0*-')/*! "> -,"%' 2'%#)/3-/"(% ('#'%%*)4 *% 0'(-/"('2 /( %'#-/"(A;Q=;*=C ;1= ") ;#=9

;A= I"(2$#- >*!!% ?/-,/( -,/% %$1%'#-/"( /> /- #"(%/%-% /(f

;*= -,' /(-')#'3-/"( "> 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% /( -,'#"$)%' "> - , ' / ) - )*(%0/%%/"( 14 0 '*(% "> *-'!'#"00$(/#*-/"( %4%-'0M *(2

;1= *(4 #"(2$#- *$-,")/%'2 /( )'!*-/"( -" *(4 %$#,/(-')#'3-/"( 14 %'#-/"( A;Z=9

;Z= B #')-/>/#*-' >") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> %$1%'#-/"( ; -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-'9 b

KK" ."N>:F ?@ &G @&Q8 @?I,?G?C6,C8 ?, 7H?@ H86A?,I" V@ SA&X?-8- ?, @"N>:F>6FJ 7H8?,78AC8S7?&, &G i'D-')(*!O C&QQB,?C67?&,@J 7& YH?CH Y8 Y?PP A87BA,J ?@ 8'SA8@@PE6B7H&A?@8-k DB7 DE X?A7B8 &G @"N>:F>DF @& 6P@& ?@ C&,-BC7 G6PP?,I Y?7H?, @":>KF >?, S6A6IA6SH K( 6D&X8F" \HB@J 6S6A7 GA&Q 7H8 8'SA8@@ A8G8A8,C8 ?, @":>KF>DF 7&a"1-*/(/(& )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* bJ 7H8A8 ?@ 6P@& ?, @":>KF>6F CP86A 6B7H&A?@67?&, 7& ?,78AC8S7 C&QQB,?C67?&,@ a("- /2'(-/>/'2 14 -,' ?*))*(- bJ ?"8"C&QQB,?C67?&,@ &7H8A 7H6 , 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(%C 7HB@ ?,CPB-?,I /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% J YH8A8 ?7 ?@ ,8C8@@6AE 7& -& @& a/( ")2') -" 2" ?,*- /% 'D3)'%%!4*$-,")/%'2 ") )'E$/)'2 14 -,' ?*))*(- b"

KL" .")* ?@ 7H8 ?,78ASA8767?&, @8C7?&, G&A 7H8 SBAS&@8@ &G TH6S78A 0 &G UR!VJ YH?CH ?@

A8P8X6,7 TH6S78A9?F e&A 7H8 Q86,?,I &G #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* CA&@@=A8G8A8,C8 ?@ Q6-8 7& @")0>>/# 2*-* #"03)/%'2 /( ") *--*#,'2 -" *#"00$(/#*-/"( ;?,'-,') 14 -,' %'(2') ") "-,')?/%'= >") -,'

3$)3"%'% "> *(4 3"%-*! %')./#' ") -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"( %4%-'014 0'*(% "> ?,/#, /- /% 1'/(& ") 0*4 1' -)*(%0/--'2M

;1= *(4 /(>")0*-/"( ?,/#, /(#!$2'% ("(' "> -,' #"(-'(-% "> *#"00$(/#*-/"( ;*3*)- >)"0 *(4 /(>")0*-/"( >*!!/(& ?/-,/(

3*)*&)*3, ;*== *(2 /% *1"$- -,' $%' 0*2' 14 *(4 3')%"(f

;/= "> *(4 3"%-*! %')./#' ") -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"(% %')./#'M ")

;//= /( #"(('#-/"( ?/-, -,' 3)"./%/"( -" ") $%' 14 *(4 3')%"( "> *(4 -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"(% %')./#'C "> *(4 3*)- "> * -'!'#"00$(/#*-/"( %4%-'09 b

V@ @87 &B7 ?, !6A6IA6SH 0N>?'F 6D&X8J @BCH C&QQB,?C67?&,@ -676 6A8C&PP&dB?6PPE C6PP8- jQ876-676f"

??F R7 ?@)'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* ?G ?79

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

36/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

a*= /% "1-*/('2 14C ") /( #"(('#-/"( ?/-,C -,' /(-')#'3-/"(M *(2

;1= )'!*-'% -" -,' #"00$(/#*-/"( ") -" -,' %'(2') ") )'#/3/'(-C") /(-'(2'2 )'#/3/'(-C "> -,' #"00$(/#*-/"(M b

???F a 6(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! b C a/( )'!*-/"( -" *( /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(- 0'*(% -,'#"(-'(-% "> *(4 #"00$(/#*-/"(% /(-')#'3-'2 14 *( /(-')#'3-/"( -" ?,/#, -,'?*))*(- )'!*-'% b" R7 ?@ C&QQ&, IA&B,- 7H67 7H?@ -8G?,?7?&, -&8@ ,&7 ?,CPB-8a)'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* bJ @8S6A678PE -8G?,8- 6@ @87 &B7 6D&X8"

?XF a TD-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"( b Q86,@ 6 C&QQB,?C67?&, @8,7 &A A8C8?X8- &B7@?-87H8 %A?7?@H R@P6,-@"

KN" VPP S6A7?8@ A8G8A 7& 6 S6@@6I8 ?, 46V76-^ J YH8, UR!V Y6@ -8D678- ?, !6AP?6Q8,7"+&A- %6@@6Q &G %A?IH7&,J 7H8 A8P8X6,7 Z?,?@78AJ ?, 6 @S88CH YH?CH P8- 7& 7H8Y?7H-A6Y6P &G 6 SA&S&@8- 6Q8,-Q8,7J YH?CH H6- D88, SA&S&@8- D8C6B@8 +&A-

!H?PP?S@ &G .B-DBAE H6- C&,78,-8- 7H67 a/- ?/!! 1' 'D-)*")2/(*)/!4 2/>>/#$!-C /> ("- /03"%%/1!'C -" #*3-$)' %/03!4 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% bJ @6?- 6@ G&PP&Y@9

a 6- /% N$%- ("- 3"%%/1!' -" '(%$)' -,*- "(!4 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% *)' /(-')#'3-'29 8,*- /% 1'#*$%' 0"2')(#"00$(/#*-/"(% *)' ">-'( )"$-'2 /( ?*4% -,*- *)' ("- *!! /(-$/-/.'!4 "1./"$%9 U"1!' S")2% ?," ,*.' #"(-)/1$-'2 -" -,'2'1*-' $(2')%-*(2 -,*-9 B( /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"( %*4C *0'%%*&' >)"0 S"(2"( -" e/)0/(&,*0f0*4 1' ,*(2!'2 "(/-% N"$)('4 14 6(-')('- %')./#' 3)"./2')% /(C 3'),*3%C -?"2/>>')'(- #"$(-)/'% "$-%/2' -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"09 h'

$(2')%-*(2 -,*-9 8,' #"00$(/#*-/"( 0/&,- -,')'>")' 1' >"$(2 "( * !/(G 1'-?''( -,"%' -?" >")'/&( #"$(-)/'%9 7$#, *!/(G %,"$!2 #!'*)!4 1' -)'*-'2 *% 'D-')(*!C 4'- /- ?"$!2 #"(-*/( *- !'*%- -,/% "(' /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(9 8,')' /% ("?*4 "> >/!-')/(& -,*- "$- ?/-,"$- /(-')#'3-/(& -,' ?,"!' !/(GC/(#!$2/(& -,' /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(9

T.'( *>-') /(-')#'3-/"(C /- 0*4 ("- 1' 3)*#-/#*1!4 3"%%/1!' -" &$*)*(-'' -" >/!-') "$- *!! /(-')(*! 0'%%*&'%9 d'%%*&'% 0*4?'!! 1' %3!/- /(-" %'3*)*-' 3*)-% ?,/#, *)' %'(- 14 2/>>')'(- )"$-'%9 `(!4 %"0' "> -,'%' ?/!! #"(-*/( -,' ")/&/(*-") *(2

-,' /(-'(2'2 >/(*! )'#/3/'(-9 h/-,"$- -,/% /(>")0*-/"( /- ?/!! ("- 1' 3"%%/1!' -" 2/%-/(&$/%, /(-')(*! 0'%%*&'% >)"0'D-')(*!9 6( %"0' #*%'% /- 0*4 ("- 1' 3"%%/1!' '.'( /> -,/%/(>")0*-/"( /% *.*/!*1!'9 R") 'D*03!'C * 0'%%*&' 1'-?''(-?" >")'/&( )'&/%-')'2 0"1/!' 3,"('%C /> 1"-, ,*33'('2 -" 1')"*0/(& /( -,' \]C ?"$!2 1' *( /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(C1$- -,')' ?"$!2 1' ("-,/(& /( -,' 0'%%*&' -" /(2/#*-' -,*-9

6- /% %-/!! -,' /(-'(-/"( -,*- I!*$%' :;

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

37/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

%$#, * ?*))*(- /% %/&('2C -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' 0$%- 1'#"(./(#'2 -,*- -,' #"(2$#- /- ?/!! *$-,")/%' *% * ?,"!' /%

3)"3")-/"(*-'f04 >*."$)/-' ?")2f-" -,' "1N'#-% -" 1'*#,/'.'29 F/% 2'#/%/"( -" %/&( ?/!! 1' ".')%''( 14 -,'

6(-')#'3-/"( "> I"00$(/#*-/"(% I"00/%%/"(')9 b

K2" R, 7H8 R,78AC8S7?&, &G T&QQB,?C67?&,@ T&-8 &G !A6C7?C8 >a7H8 T&-8bF ?@@B8- SBA@B6,7 7& @"L0 &G UR!VJ 7& YH?CH Y8 Y?PP A87BA,J 7H8 -8G?,?7?&, &G TD-')(*! I"00$(/#*-/"(% Y6@ 8,C6S@BP678- ?, S6A6IA6SH :"0J B,-8A aI,*3-') AM 6(-')#'3-/"(h*))*(-% ;%9:; * ?*))*(- #"03!4/(& ?/-,

%'#-/"( :; * %'!'#-/"( 3)"#'%% -" /2'(-/>4 * %0*!!') ."!$0' ">

/(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! -,*- #*( *#-$*!!4 1' 'D*0/('2 14 3')%"(%C ?/-, * 3)",/1/-/"("( -,' )'0*/(2') 1'/(& %" 'D*0/('2 9 9 9 8" -,/% 'D-'(-C /- 2/>>')% >)"0 -,' )'&/0'-,*- *33!/'% $(2') %9 :;@= "> K65BC $(2') ?,/#, /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(-% -*)&'- *

%3'#/>/'2 3')%"( ") %/(&!' %'- "> 3)'0/%'%9 b

L0" \H8 \A?DB,6P 6IA88@ Y?7H 7H8 @7678Q8,7 &G 7H8 T&QQ?@@?&,8A ?, S6A6IA6SH K":"(N &G H?@ U8S&A7 7H679

a8,' %'#-/"( :;')*1!' -" /(2/./2$*!% -,'

'D*0/(*-/"( "> ?,"%' #"00$(/#*-/"(% *)' #')-/>/'2 *%('#'%%*)4 >") * %-*-$-")4 3$)3"%'9 b

L)" VP7H&BIH VQ,8@7E ?, ?7@ @W8P87&, 6AIBQ8,7 HES8AD&P?C6PPE -8@CA?D8@ 7H8U8@S&,-8,7@f SBAS&@8 6@ a-" "1-*/( 2*-* ?,"!'%*!' >)"0 '.')4 !/./(& ,$0*( 1'/(& ?/-, * ?")G/(& /(-')('- #"(('#-/"( bJ 7H67 ?@ ,&7 7H8 C6@8 6@ SB7 &A6PPE DE 7H8TP6?Q6,7@J 6,- Y8 6A8 8,7?A8PE CP86A 7H67 7H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ 6A8 ,&7 @88W?,IJ ,&A 6@@8A7?,I 7H67 7H8 @E@78Q 8,7?7P8@ 7H8Q 7& @88WJ 7& C6AAE &B7 YH67 H6@ D88, -8@C6@ a0*%%b &A a1$!G b @BAX8?PP6,C8" ZA UE-8A Q6-8 CP86A 7H67 H8 ?@ ,&7 6PP8I?,I?,-?@CA?Q?,678 7A6YP?,IJ DB7 A67H8A a2/%#)/0/(*-' ;/( -,' %'(%' -,*- /- /% ?/-,/( .')41)"*2 %'!'#-")%= 1$- .*%- b" \H8 U8@S&,-8,7@ -8@CA?D8 7H8?A C6@8 ?, S6A6IA6SH@ L* 7&L0 &G 7H8?A @W8P87&,J 7H67 7H8 &,PE Y6E 7& ?,78AC8S7 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% D8?,I@8,7 7&J G&A 8'6QSP8J 6, ?,-?X?-B6P ?, .EA?6 YH&@8 6--A8@@ 7H8E -& ,&7 H6X8 ?@ 7&9

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

38/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

a L * 9 9 9 /(-')#'3- * %$1%-*(-/*!!4 &)'*-') ."!$0' "> #"00$(/#*-/"(% ;/(#!$2/(&C 3"-'(-/*!!4C * ."!$0' "> /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(%=C *(2 -,'( *33!4 * %'!'#-/"( %-*&' -" /2'(-/>4-,' #"00$(/#*-/"(% /( E$'%-/"(9 6( "-,') ?")2%C /- /% #"00"(

&)"$(2 -,*- -,' "(!4 3)*#-/#*! ?*4 -" >/(2 *(2 )'#"(%-)$#- 0"%-

'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"( ^(''2!'%_ /% -" !""G -,)"$&, -,'#"00$(/#*-/"(% ,*4%-*#G_9

[@9 9 9 \(!'%% -,' I!*/0*(-% ?/%, -" %$10/- -,*- -,' 6(-'!!/&'(#'7')./#'% %,"$!2 ("- 1' *1!' -" "1-*/( -,' 'D-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(% -,*- *)' (''2'2 >") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> (*-/"(*!

%'#$)/-4C '-#9C -,'4 0$%- *##'3- %"0' >")0 "> /(-')#'3-/"()'&/0' -,*- 3')0/-% %$1%-*(-/*!!4 0")' #"00$(/#*-/"(% -" 1'/(-')#'3-'2 ;/(#!$2/(&C 3"-'(-/*!!4C /(-')(*! #"00$(/#*-/"(%=-,*( *)' *#-$*!!4 1'/(& %"$&,-9 b

L(" ZA UE-8A ?, H?@ CP&@?,I @BDQ?@@?&,@ Q6-8 ?7 6D@&PB78PE CP86A 7H67 7H8 TP6?Q6,7@ -,&7 ?,78,- ?, 6,E Y6E 7& P?Q?7J H?,-8A &A &D@7ABC7 7H8 ?QS&A76,7 Y&AW 7H67 7H8R,78PP?I8,C8 .8AX?C8@ -&" \H8?A @BDQ?@@?&,@J H8 Q6-8 CP86AJ Y8A8 IB?-8- 67 SB77?,IYH67 7H8 .8AX?C8@ -& Y?7H?, 6 GA6Q8Y&AW 6,- 6@W?,I 7H8 \A?DB,6P 7& -& ,& Q&A87H6, YH67 !6AP?6Q8,7 Y6,78- 7H8 \A?DB,6P 7& -&J ,6Q8PE 7& ?,-?C678 7& `&X8A,Q8,7YH8, @&Q87H?,I ?@ ,&7 ?, 6CC&A-6,C8 Y?7H 7H8 P6YJ ?, &A-8A 7& 8,@BA8 7H67`&X8A,Q8,7 6C7?&, Y6@ -&,8 ?, 7H8 Q&@7 8GG8C7?X8 Y6E 6,- ?, 6CC&A-6,C8 Y?7H

SA&S8A P8I6P SA?,C?SP8"

L 6(-')#'3-'2 d*-')/*! '-# b 7H8A8 6A8 7H8G&PP&Y?,I 7Y& @8C7?&,@ &G UR!VJ YH?CH ?, Q678A?6P S6A7 6A8 6@ G&PP&Y@9

a@A ;@= 7$1N'#- -" %$1%'#-/"( ;Z=C /- %,*!! 1' -,' 2$-4 "> -,'7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' -" '(%$)'C /( )'!*-/"( -" *!! /(-')#'3-/"(?*))*(-%C -,*- %$#, *))*(&'0'(-% *)' /( >")#' *% ,' #"(%/2')%('#'%%*)4 >") %'#$)/(&f

;*= -,*- -,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> %$1%'#-/"(% ;H= *(2 ;Q= *)' %*-/%>/'2 /( )'!*-/"( -" -,' /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! *(2 *(4)'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-*M *(2

;1= /( -,' #*%' "> ?*))*(-% /( )'!*-/"( -" ?,/#, -,')' *)'

%'#-/"( :; '*#, "> -,' >"!!"?/(&f

;*= -,' ($01') "> 3')%"(% -" ?,"0 *(4 "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* /% 2/%#!"%'2 ") "-,')?/%' 0*2' *.*/!*1!'C

;1= -,' 'D-'(- -" ?,/#, *(4 "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* /%

2/%#!"%'2 ") "-,')?/%' 0*2' *.*/!*1!'C

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

39/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;#= -,' 'D-'(- -" ?,/#, *(4 "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* /% #"3/'2C*(2

;2= -,' ($01') "> #"3/'% -,*- *)' 0*2'C

/% !/0/-'2 -" -,' 0/(/0$0 -,*- /% ('#'%%*)4 >") -,' *$-,")/%'2 3$)3"%'%9

;Q= 8,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> -,/% %$1%'#-/"( *)' %*-/%>/'2 /( )'!*-/"(-" -,' /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! *(2 *(4 )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(%2*-* /> '*#, #"34 0*2' "> *(4 "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* ;/> ("- 2'%-)"4'2 '*)!/')= /% 2'%-)"4'2 *% %""( *% -,')' *)' (" !"(&') *(4 &)"$(2% >") )'-*/(/(& /- *% ('#'%%*)4 >") *(4 "> -,'*$-,")/%'2 3$)3"%'%9

; -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* -,*- /% 0*2' /% %-")'2C >") %" !"(& *% /- /% )'-*/('2C /( * %'#$)' 0*((')9

;Z= B))*(&'0'(-% /( )'!*-/"( -" /(-')#'3-/"( ?*))*(-% ?,/#,*)' 0*2' >") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> %$1%'#-/"( ;@=f

;*= %,*!! ("- 1' )'E$/)'2 -" %'#$)' -,*- -,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> %$1%'#-/"(% ;H= *(2 ;Q= *)' %*-/%>/'2 /( %" >*) *% -,'4 )'!*-'-" *(4 "> -,' /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! ") )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(%2*-*C ") *(4 #"34 "> *(4 %$#, 0*-')/*! ") 2*-*C 3"%%'%%/"( "> ?,/#, ,*% 1''( %$))'(2')'2 -" *(4 *$-,")/-/'% "> * #"$(-)4") -'))/-")4 "$-%/2' -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0M 1$-

;1= %,*!! 1' )'E$/)'2 -" %'#$)'C /( -,' #*%' "> '.')4 %$#,?*))*(-C -,*- 3"%%'%%/"( "> -,' /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! *(2 2*-* *(2 "> #"3/'% "> -,' 0*-')/*! ") 2*-* /% %$))'(2')'2 -"*$-,")/-/'% "> * #"$(-)4 ") -'))/-")4 "$-%/2' -,' \(/-'2

]/(&2"0 "(!4 /> -,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> %$1%'#-/"( ;[= *)' %*-/%>/'29

;[= 8,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> -,/% %$1%'#-/"( *)' %*-/%>/'2 /( -,' #*%'"> * ?*))*(- /> /- *33'*)% -" -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-'f

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

40/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;*= -,*- )'E$/)'0'(-% #"))'%3"(2/(& -" -,"%' "> %$1%'#-/"(%;H= *(2 ;Q= ?/!! *33!4C -" %$#, 'D-'(- ;/> *(4= *% -,' 7'#)'-*)4"> 7-*-' -,/(G% >/-C /( )'!*-/"( -" *(4 "> -,' /(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! ") )'!*-'2 #"00$(/#*-/"(% 2*-* 3"%%'%%/"( "> ?,/#,C ") "> *(4 #"34 "> ?,/#,C /% %$))'(2')'2 -" -,'

*$-,")/-/'% /( E$'%-/"(M *(2

;1= -,*- )'%-)/#-/"(% *)' /( >")#' ?,/#, ?"$!2 3)'.'(-C -" %$#, 'D-'(- ;/> *(4= *% -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' -,/(G% >/-C -,'2"/(& "> *(4-,/(& /(C >") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> ") /( #"(('#-/"(?/-, *(4 3)"#''2/(&% "$-%/2' -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"0 ?,/#,?"$!2 )'%$!- /( %$#, * 2/%#!"%$)' *%C 14 ./)-$' "> %'#-/"( @[C#"$!2 ("- 1' 0*2' /( -,' \(/-'2 ]/(&2"09 b

/8 H6X8 6PA86-E A8G8AA8- 7& @"0:>NF ?, S6A6IA6SH )2 6D&X8"

a@Z9 ;@= R") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> %'#-/"( @A -,' )'E$/)'0'(-% "> -,/% %'#-/"(C /( -,' #*%' "> * ?*))*(- /( )'!*-/"( -" ?,/#, -,')' /% * %'#-/"( :;") -,'-/0' 1'/(& /( -,' e)/-/%, 6%!*(2%M *(2

;1= ,*% *% /-% 3$)3"%'C ") "(' "> /-% 3$)3"%'%C -,'/2'(-/>/#*-/"( "> 0*-')/*! #"(-*/('2 /( #"00$(/#*-/"(% %'(-

14 ,/0C ") /(-'(2'2 >") ,/09;Q= 6(-')#'3-'2 0*-')/*! >*!!% ?/-,/( %$1%'#-/"( ;H=C("-?/-,%-*(2/(& -,*- /- /% %'!'#-'2 14 )'>')'(#' -" *(4 %$#,

>*#-") *% /% 0'(-/"('2 /( 3*)*&)*3, ;*= *(2 ;1= "> -,*- %$1%'#-/"(C />f

;*= /- /% #')-/>/'2 14 -,' 7'#)'-*)4 "> 7-*-' >") -,' 3$)3"%'% "> %'#-/"( :; 0*-')/*! %'!'#-'2 *##")2/(& -" >*#-")% )'>')*1!' -" -,' /(2/./2$*! /( E$'%-/"( /%('#'%%*)4 *% 0'(-/"('2 /( %$1%'#-/"( A;Q=;*=C ;1= ") ;#=M *(2

8/10/2019 Investigatory Powers Tribunal Tempora ruling

41/77

MG N(C,*5A J(G,F9Eaa-:\8^ NZ^b]8VT

;1= -,' 0*-')/*! )'!*-'% "(!4 -" #"00$(/#*-/"(% %'(-