34
Intersections: Where Art and Science MeetBach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher " recursion in art", Gödel " incompleteness requires recursion," and Heisenberg "uncertainty in the universe" Wednesday, January 25, 2012 first time offered at noon in The Morris and Gwendolyn Cafritz Foundation Art Center, CF101 at the Takoma Park/Silver Spring Campus of Montgomery College by Rupert Chappelle, IT person and Musician extraordinaire Dr. Harold Alden Williams, Planetarium Director

Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Intersections: Where Art and Science MeetBach "

The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "

incompleteness requires recursion," and Heisenberg "uncertainty in the universe"

Wednesday, January 25, 2012 first time offered at noonin The Morris and Gwendolyn Cafritz Foundation Art

Center, CF101 at the Takoma Park/Silver Spring Campus of Montgomery College by

Rupert Chappelle, IT person and Musician extraordinaire Dr. Harold Alden Williams, Planetarium Director

Page 2: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Some music

• Bach: Endlessly Rising Modulation Canon (with score!) 8 minutes and 18 seconds.

• J.S. Bach - Crab Canon on a Möbius Strip 3 minutes and 7 seconds.

Page 3: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Crab Canon

Page 4: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Canons 14th Century Music• Here are three canons from the 14th century both image and in notation• http://www.sca.org.au/bardic/rbom/O_Virgo_splendens.PDF• http://www2.cpdl.org/wiki/index.php/File:LV_21v.jpg • O virgo splendens.• three note motif inverted, pitch shifted and varied - obvious in the original

notation•

http://www.lluisvives.com/servlet/SirveObras/jlv/08140629733581728654480/ima0046.htm

• http://www.sca.org.au/bardic/rbom/Laudemus_Virginem.PDF• http://www.sca.org.au/bardic/rbom/Splendens_Ceptigera.PDF• Laudemus Virginem • http://www.lebrecht.co.uk/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/36174_cano

n-in-the-unison1.jpg

jaques clemens

Page 5: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

O virgo splendens

Page 6: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Jaques Clemens

Page 7: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

In Escher's picture Circle Limit III, 1959, the map from a given fish to the one in front of it is a

hyperbolic transformation.

Page 8: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Mathematics and Art

• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics_and_art • Some of Escher's tessellation drawings were

inspired by conversations with the mathematician H. S. M. Coxeter concerning hyperbolic geometry.[54] Relationships between the works of mathematician Kurt Gödel, artist M. C. Escher and composer Johann Sebastian Bach are explored in Gödel, Escher, Bach, a Pulitzer Prize-winning book.

Page 9: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Drawing Hands strange loop

Page 10: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Hand with Reflecting Globe, Self-portrait lithograph 1935

Page 11: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Metamorphosis II woodcut 1930-1931 (3 panels 19.5 cm x 400 cm)

Page 14: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Medieval Education (community college, first two years)

• Trivium• Grammar: thing as it is symbolized: EN101• Logic: thing as it is known: PL190• Rhetoric: thing as it is communicated: RD120, SP108• Quadrivium• Arithmetic: Numbers, Counting what: MA101• Geometry: Numbers in Space, Shape, Where is it?

MA105• Music: Numbers in Time, When: MU110• Astronomy/Cosmology: Number in Space & Time,

became Science in general. AS101, BI101, CH100A, GL101, ME101, PC101, and PH105

Page 15: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Gödel

• Recursively axiomatizable first-order theories that are rich enough to allow general mathematical reasoning to be formulated cannot be complete, as demonstrated by Gödel's incompleteness theorem.

Page 16: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic• In number theory, the fundamental theorem of

arithmetic (or the unique-prime-factorization theorem) states that any integer greater than 1 can be written as a unique product (up to ordering of the factors) of prime numbers.

• For example: 6936=23x31x172 • and 1200=24x31x52

• are two numbers satisfying the hypothesis of the theorem that can be written as the product of prime numbers.

Page 17: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Fundamental Theorem of Algebra

• Every non-zero single-variable polynomial with complex coefficients has exactly as many complex roots as its degree, if each root is counted up to its multiplicity.

• Or every non-constant single-variable polynomial with complex coefficients has at least one complex root. Equivalently, the field of complex numbers is algebraically closed.

Page 18: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Geometry

• Euclidian• Hyperbolic• Spherical and Elliptic• Geometric Algebra • Clifford/Geometric Algebra study group at Mo

ntgomery College meeting since 2007 faculty and students together transforming the understanding of the universe at the college, the Cliffhangers!

Page 19: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Medieval Education (community college, first two years)

• Trivium• Grammar: thing as it is symbolized: EN101• Logic: thing as it is known: PL190• Rhetoric: thing as it is communicated : RD120, SP108• Quadrivium• Arithmetic: Numbers, Counting what: MA101• Geometry: Numbers in Space, Shape, Where is it?

MA105• Music: Numbers in Time, When: MU110• Astronomy/Cosmology: Number in Space & Time,

became Science in general. AS101, BI101, CH100A, GL101, ME101, PC101, and PH105

Page 20: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Romantic/Quantum Uncertainty

Page 21: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Page 22: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

What is knowable and measurable

• Interaction is what is important not consciousness, the universe continues now whether you are conscious of it or not.

• You can not know where something is and know at what momentum (velocity with attitude) to arbitrary precession at the same time.

• You can not know what the energy is and know what it time of emission or absorption is to arbitrary precession.

• The universe is pixilated around Planck’s constant, h or ħ.

Page 23: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Chapter 5 Opener

Page 24: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 5.8 Annotated

Page 25: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 5.12 Unannotated

Page 26: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 5.15

Page 27: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 5.18

Page 28: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure S4.7

Page 29: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 16.1 Unannotated

Page 30: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Figure 16.1 Annotated

Page 31: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Horse Head Nebulae in Orion

Page 33: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Astronomers Use Photoshop

Page 34: Intersections: Where Art and Science Meet Bach "The Musical Offering recursion in music", Escher "recursion in art", Gödel "incompleteness requires recursion,"

Interest Rates

• 1.02^33=1.92223• 1.0233=1.92223• 1.022^33=2.050• 1.02233=2.050