9
Ilyas Asaad Deputy Minister for Environmental Compliance MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA

Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Asian Judges Symposium on Environmental Decision Making, the Rule of Law, and Environmental JusticeAsian Development Bank Headquarters, Manila, Philippines; 28-29 July 2010http://www.adb.org/documents/events/2010/asian-judges-symposium/default.asp

Citation preview

Page 1: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

Ilyas AsaadDeputy Minister for Environmental Compliance

MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENTREPUBLIC OF INDONESIA

Page 2: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

POLLUTION AND ENVIRONMENTAL DEGRADATION INCREASED

TRANSBOUNDARY HAZARDOUS WASTES LACK OF COORDINATION LACK OF ENVIRONMENTAL KNOWLEDGE

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Page 3: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

Prevention and

Mitigation

Deterrent effects and

Suffered effects

Compensationsand

EnvironmentalRecovery

ADMINISTRATIVE(article 76 sd 83)

CRIMINAL(article 93 sd 120)

CIVIL(article 83 sd 93)

FUNCTIONFUNCTION FUNCTION

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Page 4: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

PUBLIC COMPLAINTS : 200 ADMINISTRATIVE SANCTIONS : 18 SANCTIONS ENVIRONMENTAL DISPUTE SETTLEMENTS: 30 CASES CRIMINAL ENFORCEMENT : 33 CASES

Page 5: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

PUBLIC COMPLAINTS

CIVIL ENFORCEMENT

CRIMINALENFORCEMENT

ON LINE SYSTEM

ORES

Certified of Judges

Service Provider on EDR

MEDIATORs

SPECIALISEDINVESTIGATORS

POLICE

PROSECUTORS

JUDGES

COMPLAINTMANAGER

SYSTEM CASES HANDLING CAPACITY BUILDING

STRENGTHENING OF ENVIRONMENTAL ENFORCEMENT

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Page 6: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

ProsecutorsGeneral attorney

Investigators Police

Environmental investigators;1. Specialized Investigators

2. Police

Letter of investigationcommencement

INVESTIGATING DOCUMENTS

Other authorities

Arrest and detention

confiscate

raid

Stop the investigation

investigation

COORDINATION

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Environmental Criminal Law Enforcement Chain

Page 7: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

ONE ROOF ENFORCEMENT SISTEM (ORES)

Special task force for environmental cases-CENTRAL-PROVINCE-DISTRICT

Coordination

•Capacity building•Institutional Arrangement• Finances support • Regulation support

SPECIALISEDINVESTIGATORS

POLICE PROSECUTORS

SPECIALICED INVESTIGATORs

MOU

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Page 8: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

PUBLIC COMPLAINT

VERIFICATION/RECOMENDATION

ADMINISTRATIVEENFORCEMENT

CIVIL ENFORCEMENT

CRIMINALENFORCEMENT

ORES

MOU BETWEEN MOE & SUPREME COURT

ESTABLISHMENT OF WORKING GROUP UNDER CHIEF JUSTICE DECREECERTIFIED JUDGES

GREEN BENCH

LINKAGE BETWEENORES AND GREEN BENCH

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment

Page 9: Ilyas Asaad - Environmental Enforcement in Indonesia

TERIMAKASIH

Environmental Compliance

Ministry of Environment