49
Hip Hop Therapy 1 Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration Comfort Agboola Applied Research Project The Chicago School of Professional Psychology

Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Currently, most of the United States population has immigrated or been born of immigrant parent(s) making them the new face of American society. Immigrants can be documented immigrants, undocumented immigrants, refugees, unaccompanied refugee minors, and victims of human trafficking. Immigrants, however, are constantly confronted with the lack of access to resources because they wrongly accused of being “undeserving foreigners”. Immigrant and refugee youth experience multiple challenges in their adaption to a new country and culture making them vulnerable. Many studies address the difficulties of marginalized natural born citizens but few addressing how to lessen the strain on the immigrant adolescent. Moreover, there is a lack of program development that addresses acculturation needs, migration stressors, and culturally responsive practices. Hip Hop therapy, specifically for immigrant youth, can unite immigrant youth through shared experiences, educate youth on social activism, and providing a therapeutic outlet for individual development prior to English language acquisition.

Citation preview

Page 1: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 1

Hip Hop Therapy:

Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Comfort Agboola

Applied Research Project

The Chicago School of Professional Psychology

Page 2: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 2

ARP Signature Page

Project Title: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee

Youth through Art Integration _

Student Name: ______________ ___Comfort Agboola__________________________

By checking this box I confirm that the content of this project was authored by the student listed

on this form and approved by the assigned advisor. I also confirm that the content was gathered and

processed in an academically honest way, not plagiarized in any fashion, and will be used for the

purposes outlined in this project. I understand that by checking this box I am electronically signing

this document and initiating the review of its contents by The Chicago School of Professional

Psychology as fulfillment of the Applied Research Project requirement.

Was Institutional Review Board approval required?

Yes No

Was Institutional Review Board approval obtained?

Yes No N/A

Advisor Name: _____________Michele Pesiri_______________________________

Page 3: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 3

Acknowledgment

To my parents, Olalekan and Leonia Agboola, and family for their constant support

To the teachers that have opened the world to me

To the children who inspire and motivate me

Page 4: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 4

Abstract

Currently, most of the United States population has immigrated or been born of

immigrant parent(s) making them the new face of American society. Immigrants can be

documented immigrants, undocumented immigrants, refugees, unaccompanied refugee minors,

and victims of human trafficking. Immigrants, however, are constantly confronted with the lack

of access to resources because they wrongly accused of being “undeserving foreigners”.

Immigrant and refugee youth experience multiple challenges in their adaption to a new country

and culture making them vulnerable. Many studies address the difficulties of marginalized

natural born citizens but few addressing how to lessen the strain on the immigrant adolescent.

Moreover, there is a lack of program development that addresses acculturation needs, migration

stressors, and culturally responsive practices. Hip Hop therapy, specifically for immigrant youth,

can unite immigrant youth through shared experiences, educate youth on social activism, and

providing a therapeutic outlet for individual development prior to English language acquisition.

Page 5: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 5

Table of Contents

List of Illustrations, Tables and Figures ........................................................................................................ 6

Proposal/Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 7

Literature Review ........................................................................................................................................ 10

Methodology ............................................................................................................................................... 29

Discussion ................................................................................................................................................... 34

Peripheral Documents ................................................................................................................................. 37

Flyer ........................................................................................................................................................ 37

Figure 1 ................................................................................................................................................... 37

Budget Proposal ...................................................................................................................................... 38

Participant Survey Form ......................................................................................................................... 39

Confidentiality Statement ....................................................................................................................... 41

Pilot Activities Handout .......................................................................................................................... 43

References ................................................................................................................................................... 46

Page 6: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 6

List of Illustrations, Tables and Figures

Figure 1: Illustration of Flyer …………………………………………………………………. 36

Figure 2: Table of Budget ……..……………………………………………………………... 37

Figure 3: Table of Program Schedule ………………………………………………………… 43

Page 7: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 7

Proposal/Introduction

Topic

Title: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth

through Art Integration

Research Questions

How can artistic creation support one's cultural identity especially in situations of conflict?

How can Hip Hop be used to help immigrant youth reach positive self-image and

empowerment?

Hip Hop has been related to youth voice, how can Hip Hop elements be used to strengthen

the immigrant youth voice?

Purpose

The adolescent years can be a dynamic period in a person’s development. Young people

develop a psychological identity seeking out independence. This can spawn recklessness and

risk-taking behaviors. In general, youth need adult assistance, nurturing, supervision and

resources, because developmentally they are at a pivotal point for their future successes or

failures. However, there is a tool that has been stigmatized but has the ability to bring positive

change. Hip Hop, as a culture, has always been a means to insight the youth. Hip Hop is often

viewed negatively only focusing on destructive messages; however, Hip Hop originates from

low income minority adolescents who created art with their words, bodies and talent in order to

fight social injustices. Hip Hop can be used as a therapeutic form to motivate immigrant

Page 8: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 8

adolescents. The purpose of this program is to foster creative expression, self-actualization,

positive social interaction, and emotional identification.

Problem Statement

Youth in America represent a movement that includes all races, ethnicities, gender, and

social-economic statuses. World views are often hard to discern for adults mainly because their

unique culture is sometimes ignored and viewed negatively. Youth world view is advertised in

their clothing, art, attitude, style, movement, music, social mediums and words. This is part of

who they are. One of the most related aspects is Hip Hop culture and how youth identify with it.

Many are struggling for their attention from teachers to politicians, but Hip Hop has captivated it

for the last 30 years. Tinajero (2009) states that Hip Hop is "the world's favorite youth culture"

with "just about every country on the planet seems to have developed its own local rap scene"

(Tinajero 2009, p. 6)

In general, youth need adult assistance, nurturing, supervision and resources, because

developmentally they are at a pivotal point for their future successes or failures. These stakes are

even higher for immigrant youths, many of which identify with Hip Hop culture. Focusing on

immigrant youth, over the last 30 years, the United States has seen a wave of international racial

and ethnic groups making it necessary for there to be a development in communication and

therapy. There should be an urgency to understand their ethnic culture and youth culture.

The statistics on immigrant youth in America shows a need for a program that is

adaptable to a society that is changing. Shields and Behrman (2004) state that “1 of every 5

children in the United States was a child of immigrants” (Sheilds & Behrman 2004, p. 4). This

includes children who are immigrants. No matter how people feel about immigration and policy,

Page 9: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 9

it is a reality that many Americans will be immigrants. Adolescents in the immigration debate

still need to become adjusted adults and it is necessary for a program to be formed addressing

their unique needs.

Page 10: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 10

Literature Review

Youth in America represent a movement that includes all races, ethnicities, gender, and

social-economic statuses. World views are often hard to discern for adults mainly because their

unique culture is sometimes ignored and viewed negatively. Youth world view is advertised in

their clothing, art, attitude, style, movement, music, social mediums and words. This is part of

who they are. One of the most related aspects is Hip Hop culture and how youth identify with

it. Many are struggling for their attention from teachers to politicians, but Hip Hop has

captivated it for the last 30 years. Tinajero (2009) states that Hip Hop is "the world's favorite

youth culture" with "just about every country on the planet seems to have developed its own

local rap scene" (Tinajero, 2009, p. 6).

Hip Hop is often viewed negatively only focusing on destructive messages; however, Hip

Hop originates from low income minority adolescents who created art with their words, bodies

and talent in order to fight social injustices. Hip Hop can be best defined as “an urban

mainstream culture driven by youth and young adults” (Tillie Allen, 2005, p 30). The last 30

years has propelled Hip Hop music and culture into popular youth culture. Hip Hop displays a

facet of emotions, beats, styles and words.

Hip Hop was born in the African-American and Latino communities of New York City in

the late 1970s. The early development of this culture was underground, obscure and not widely

accepted but thriving in minority, low income neighborhoods. The music and style provided

empowerment to groups that had been previously unheard: poor, minority youth. The pioneers

that established the music also established the 4 elements of Hip Hop. Artists such as Afrika

Bambaataa, Sugar Hill Gang, Run DMC and Public Enemy were instrumental in creating the

culture of Hip Hop. The four elements are: MCs (emcees), Djs (deejays), Break-dancing, and

Page 11: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 11

Graffiti Art (Tillie Allen, 2009).

Although these four are the root of Hip Hop culture, the culture has expanded to

incorporate fashion, film, and poetry. Often it is confused with mainstream rap lyrics that

objectify women, promote violence, and display little self-awareness. Rap deals with the ability

to deliver lyrics. Hip Hop is an emotion and self- reflective in nature. KRS- One, a Hip Hop

artist, is quoted as saying “Rap is something you do. Hip Hop is something you feel” (Tillie

Allen, 2009, p 31).

Talib Kweli, a Hip Hop artist, states that “art isn't supposed to just acknowledge how

things are but show a better vision for the future” (DJ Kosher, 2010). Hip Hop addresses issues

of race, self-awareness, world cultures/history, current events, and other topics concerning

youth. Individuals, especially in this age range, seek to create an identity, meaning and find a

community. Hip Hop operates as a venue for discovery and understanding of other people's

ideas but also the individual's ideas.

Hip Hop discusses the Civil Rights gains of the 1950s but addresses the losses of the Hip

Hop generation. Hip Hop lyrics address crime, poverty, disenfranchisement, and racism. Youth

of color have become empowered through lyrics like Nas', song “One Mic”, “All I need is one

mic to spread my voice to the whole world.” This representation of power to the powerless and

that one does not need to be a socially conscious artist to have message and a voice.

Theorist from the social sciences and humanities observed that there is an important

connection to youth development and Hip Hop. The idea of identity is developed through

narrative and other forms of artistic representation. The key part of Hip Hop is the fact that Hip

Hop artists write and perform lyrics from their own personal experiences that youth can relate to.

This is true for the United States and the world of Hip Hop artists. World Hip Hop artists, in a

Page 12: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 12

variety of languages, convey a message, style and culture to its young audiences. Tupac, a

famous Hip Hop artist, lyrics have been heard around the world, and he is the most recognizable

face of Hip Hop. His story was one that was relatable to many dealing with racial discrimination,

government injustice, drugs and living in poverty. (Clay, 2006, p. 106).

Micheal Eric Dyson stated that “this type of honesty secured Tupac's place as one of the

most respected rappers in Hip Hop” (Clay, 2006, p. 106). Dyson further connects his popularity

to the global success of Hip Hop, as Tupac's voice helped shape Hip Hop global culture and “his

voice rings through the cultural landscape” (Clay, 2006, p. 106). Tupac, along with other artists,

found success in the candidness of their message. Public narration, discourse or display builds a

community and focuses the community on a common goal. In Hip Hop, there have been

movements for ending gang warfare, fighting against AIDS/HIV, and provided food for the

impoverished. These movements began because of a common voice and identifiable message.

Hip Hop's ability to unite, especially the young, leads to answering the question “What

are we fighting for?” by presenting the world as it is and the world as it could be. This has been

done through words, images and movement. Many artists of all mediums hope for equity in their

communities and world. Their audiences become more self-aware but also more aware of their

world. This is commonly called conscious raising (Clay, 2006). The individual and community

are made aware of their existence as being marginalized because it is addressed publicly and

honestly.

An individual’s understands of themselves and the world they live in leads toward self-

actualization. Self-actualization refers to the propensity for people to move towards growth and

self-improvement. Self-actualization also includes pro-social attitudes; people are concerned

with the well-being of others. Carl Rogers, who is the founder of person-centered therapy and

Page 13: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 13

ideas about self-actualization, believed that negative views of self and others blocks self-

actualization and consequentially self-image. This idea has also been adopted by other

therapeutic approaches, including a new form called Hip Hop Therapy. (Tillie Allen, 2005).

Hip Hop Therapy was coined by Tyson, a therapist and social worker, who saw that

common day approaches to therapy, did not reach inner city youth. This form also erased the

stigma associated with receiving mental health care. Tyson determined that “Hip Hop's

influence and its social, political, and cultural content, exploring its musical form in therapy can

be effective in engaging youth” (Tillie Allen, 2005). He first explored his concept as a form of

bibliotherapy and music therapy while examining the sociocultural and political context of the

lyrics. Tyson discovered that Hip Hop therapy is diverse in language, message and mediums that

any racial or ethnic group is familiar with Hip Hop culture. Tillie Allen (2005) states that this

form of therapy was more effective with high risk youth because traditional methods did not

address or understand youth backgrounds. Hip Hop therapy is uniquely youth centered but it is

also culturally centered.

Hip Hop has been used to connect to African and Latino American youth discussing

violence, drugs, teen pregnancy, and abuse. All are issues that an individual can relate to or has

seen in their community. There is another population that can benefit from this therapy:

immigrant youth. Hip Hop can be used as a therapeutic form to motivate immigrant adolescents

because of its message that one does not have to be a “conscious rapper” to have a voice or idea.

Hip Hop culture works with many different mediums so an individual does not need to be fluent

in the language to begin therapy or seek assistance. Hip Hop culture has transcended many social

barriers of ethnicity, religion and even geographic boundaries. Other mediums have failed where

Hip Hop has prospered (Tinajero, 2009).

Page 14: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 14

Adolescents are a particular population that can benefit from Hip Hop therapy. Art

therapy offers a nonthreatening way for adolescents to express their inner feelings and provides a

support system (Riley 2001). In the areas of cognitive and socio-emotional development, Hip

Hop therapy can assist in the therapist-client relationship because of its built in cross-cultural

aspects. Culture plays a major role in development during adolescents. Cognitive development

research from two psychologists: Piaget and Kohlberg. Piaget’s stage theory of cognitive

development states that adolescents develop formal operations from concrete operations. In the

previous stage, children ages seven to eleven develop ability to reason with concrete events. In

the adolescent stage, youth are developing formal operations or the ability to think abstractly.

This development continues into adulthood but this formative stage youth are discovering ideas

and developing their own from personal experience (Chen & Farruggia, 2002).

Culturally, some youth do not develop formal operations at this stage. In unindustrial

societies this stage could occur later than Piaget prescribed (Chen & Farruggia, 2002). Along

with this point of cultural contention is Kohlberg’s theory on moral reasoning. Morality is often

decided by cultural norms but the sequence in which youth develop morality is universal. The

major difference is the society in which the child is raised in. Individualistic societies tend to

value justice or law and collectivist societies place value in care and concern for others over

justice (Chen & Farruggia, 2002).

In these two developmental stages, by Piaget and Kohlberg, Hip Hop therapy can address

issues in abstract thinking and morality. Hip Hop uses lyrics, colors, and sound to address

concrete issues such as discrimination and poverty. Specifically, Hip Hop introduces youth to

issues of past and current generations by “thinking outside of the box”. Morally, Hip Hop has

been criticized for sexualizing young girls, homophobic references and violence. However, this is

Page 15: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 15

true of rap but Hip Hop is more conscious. Lyrics and image display struggle and strength. There

is not only self-motivation but also concern for community. For immigrant youth, who may not

have developed cognitively at the same rate as youth from industrialized societies, Hip Hop can

be used to expand ability to think about abstract issues of poverty and discrimination while

developing further moral concern.

Hip Hop also addresses the area of socio-emotional development. This area focuses on

parental involvement and peer acceptance (Chen & Farruggia, 2002). In general, youth need

adult assistance, nurturing, supervision and resources, because developmentally they are at a

pivotal point for their future successes or failures. Stakes are even higher for immigrant youths,

many of which identify with Hip Hop culture. Focusing on immigrant youth, over the last 30

years, the United States has seen a wave of international racial and ethnic groups (Suarez-

Oroszco, Gaytan, Bang, Pakes, O'Connor & Rhodes 2010) making it necessary for there to be a

development in communication and therapy. There should be an urgency to understand their

ethnic culture and youth culture.

The statistics on immigrant youths in America shows a need for a program that is

adaptable to a society that is changing. Shields and Behrman (2004) state that “1 of every 5

children in the United States was a child of immigrants” (Shields & Behrman 2004) Most of the

country would have immigrated or be born of immigrant parent(s) making them the new face of

American society. Immigrants can be legal residents, refugees, and some are undocumented

(most immigrants are legal citizens). The children often share the similar hardships of low-

income families, but they do not have the unique understanding of these hardships as other low-

income families.

There are many studies addressing the difficulties of marginalized natural born citizens

Page 16: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 16

but few addressing how to lessen the strain on the immigrant adolescent. Immigrants entering

the country at adolescence can be increasingly more complicated because of the major social

changes occurring at this stage. Adolescents are already facing the developmental issue of

identity versus role confusion. Immigrant parents have strong work ethic and value hard work

even for low wages; they expect their children to value hard work and achieve a better life

(Sheilds & Behrman 2004).

Current social norms value quick money without hard work. These conflicting values, as

adolescents are developing identity, can cause strain within in the family and culture. During

adolescence there is a conflict between the origin culture and dominant culture (Sheilds &

Behrman 2004). Acculturation can play a beneficial role in blending the positives of both

cultures. It is not a complete assimilation but borrowing valued traits which may ease the identity

formation process for adolescent immigrants. Hip Hop culture uses personal experiences and is

self-reflective which bridges the gap between dominant culture and origin culture (Clay, 2006).

Immigrants possess a number of strengths that can be surprising to therapist who use

traditional modes of treatment. For instance, on average, children born to immigrant mothers are

healthier than those born to U.S. mothers. This includes infant mortality rates and fewer health

conditions, such as injuries, physical impairments, infectious disease and asthma (Sheilds &

Behrman 2004). Children are also more likely to come from intact families (two parents in the

home); commonly the father would be employed and the mother is a stay-at-home mother.

Immigrant families living in single parent homes is 16% compared to U.S. born families with

26% living in single parent homes (Sheilds & Behrman 2004). In the home environment, there is

more stability and a larger extended family, sometimes with non-blood relatives. There are both

social and economic benefits to this that immigrant families have unique access to this.

Page 17: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 17

As previous mentioned immigrant families may have a strong work ethic because many

come to the United States with the intention of improving their livelihood. Parents value hard

work and expect their children to as well, including in school. Immigrant children are more

likely to have working parents even if the wages are lower despite achievement of higher

education. Immigrant parents despite their educational background expect their children to

achieve high levels of education. In many immigrant communities, educational completion is a

major achievement and is celebrated. On average, despite language barriers, 8th

grade children of

immigrants have higher grades and math scores than their counterparts of the same ethnicity in

U.S. born families (Sheilds & Behrman 2004).

Another aspect of immigrant success is community cohesion. When immigrants arrive,

they try to locate to areas of familiarity. People from similar countries of origin tend to live in the

same areas. Fellow immigrants help “facilitate a new family’s adjustment, helping them learn to

navigate new systems and institutions (such as schools) and to find jobs” (Sheilds & Behrman

2004, p. 6). These communities also help in a child's adjustment by providing emotional support

and reinforcement of tradition and parental authority. All of these strengths help in the

newcomers feeling welcomed and supported; however, there are still areas of weakness that can

appear insurmountable forcing immigrant families into deeper poverty.

Three of the most important concerns for immigrant youth are language barriers, racism

and discrimination, and poverty (Sheilds & Behrman 2004). With lack of supports these three

barriers make acculturation a difficult process and many do not become fully accepted into

society, as born United States citizens would. Sheilds & Behrman (2004) research suggests that

children are resilient to one risk factor but multiple risk factors can undermine a child's

development. Language barriers are often tackled in academic institutions.

Page 18: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 18

Early Childhood Educational programs have struggled to make education for immigrant

families affordable, available and accessible (Tienda & Haskins, 2011). In the United States,

18% of children speak a language other than English in their home, but among immigrant

families, 72% of children speak a language other than English at home (Sheilds & Behrman

2004). Bilingualism is beneficial in society however many immigrant youth have little mastery

of the English language because they live in linguistically isolated communities. This drawback

in development leads to lower waged jobs and continued poverty.

Another concern for immigrants and their families is discrimination and racism.

Discrimination is defined as the unequal treatment of different people based on the groups or

categories to which they belong (Baumeister & Bushman, 2008). Social standing, racism and

segregation marginalize children of color and children of immigrants from the mainstream of

America (Sheilds & Behrman 2004). Discrimination has been common place in society, but in

both personal and institutional forms. Immigrants face personal discrimination from others who

feel that immigrants “steal” jobs from Americans or even how they perpetrate more criminal

acts. Neither of these statements exists in the realm of reality, but are very popular prejudices

faced by immigrants. Xenophobia causes people to want their culture and theirs alone. The

institutional injustices may be far more difficult to overcome.

Immigrants are unaware of many government assistance programs available to them.

Institutional discrimination is when an institution or dominant group promotes discrimination

(Sue & Capodilupo, 2008). Institutional discrimination there are laws created to insure the

dominance of majority. Arizona's Immigration laws for example target Latino immigrants and

profile them for proof of citizenship. American nativist press for tougher immigration laws and

border control mainly the United States-Mexico border. This discrimination pushes for fewer

Page 19: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 19

resources for immigrant families and their children.

Young immigrants are trying to find ways to combat nativism and discover their voice. A

Hip Hop group, Rebel Diaz, uses music to help immigrant youth express themselves. Hip Hop

has an ability to give marginalized communities a voice against institutional injustices resonates

with all races. Community Roots member and Students for Justice in Palestine President Samira

Farah, a Somali-American, said “I was born in Somalia, which is war-torn...A lot of people are

drawn to Hip Hop because it explains their struggles and reflects what's going on in their

communities" (Elbasha, 2010, p. 1). This statement reflects the necessity to use Hip Hop as a

form of Art Therapy.

A large number of immigrant and refugee families have in experienced organized

violence and disparity in their country of origin and they can still be in an unstable environment

even after migration (Rousseau, Lacroix, Singh, Gauthier & Benoit, 2005). Dealing with both

past and current hardships, many families do not utilize mental health care and mental health

care practitioners are not always culturally sensitive enough to reach immigrant clients. For

immigrant youth much of their support is found within the school system but conventional

therapy does not always reach past the cultural divide. Rousseau, Lacroix, Singh, Gauthier

and Benoit (2005) state that “Artistic activities, as a mean of expression, have come to be

considered a good way of helping immigrant children elaborate identity issues and construct

meaning around the experience (Rousseau, et. al., 2005 p. 77).

Hip Hop, as previously discussed, uses artistic mediums of graffiti art, dance, storytelling

and music; these four elements are also essential in art therapy. Hip Hop therapy, as a subset of

art therapy, can help immigrant youth express their thoughts on migration and social structures

of the United States. Furthermore, Hip Hop therapy as a form of art therapy is cross-cultural and

Page 20: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 20

is universal in the modes of dance, drama, music and poetry (McNiff & Barlow, 2009). The

linguistic isolation many immigrants struggle with can hinder therapy. Language based therapy

often represents the cultural values of the host country or psychologist, which tends to be

predominately Anglo-Saxon. In contrast, art therapy approaches developed in the United States

can be easily adapted to other cultures in the United States. Hip Hop therapy allows the

performer (client) to express themselves uniquely.

Hip Hop therapy can be used for immigrant youth who struggle even more with

developing identity by including four elements that are key to successful art therapy: “the

construction of a safe space, the acknowledgement and appreciation of diversity, the

establishment of continuity, and the transformation of adversity” (Rousseau et. al., 2005, p. 80).

Hip Hop therapy stimulates the developmental desire to be expressive without being destructive

(Riley 2001). Riley (2001) elaborates on art therapy and Hip Hop by comparing graffiti art and

drawings. Various cities have an abundance in graffiti representing youth need to make their

mark and be heard.

Immigrant youth have made their mark in Hip Hop songs. Immigrant Youth Justice

League, a Chicago based immigrant youth empowerment organization, has used Hip Hop to

present messages by immigrant youth, many undocumented. Immigrant youth words paint a

picture of disparity and transformation from adversity. The chorus of this immigrant youth's

song represents a hope from adversity “Everybody’s got a dream; all they need is a chance,

Opportunities in need if they wish to advance, Wantin’ better lives set in a wonderland, But they

can only get it if we give them helping hands” (Nguyen & Tu, 2011, p. 1).

This is a narrative form of therapy were the client expresses feelings of conflict and

resolution. Hip Hop therapy uses music and culture to engage immigrant youth by addressing

Page 21: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 21

issues that concern them. Hip Hop culture combines visual and verbal expression of the youths’

and popular artist. Youth find the connection from known Hip Hop artist to their own message.

Hip Hop lyrics and art help unite immigrant youth through shared experiences in home countries

and acculturation processes (Elligan, 2004). Hip Hop therapy incorporates immigrant youth

backgrounds, experiences and environment (Tillie-Allen, 2005) in order to address concerns for

the individual and the group (in this instance immigrant youth).

Part of therapy is being able to understand immigrant youth view of their migration; this

can be best displayed through Hip Hop cultural representations. Hip Hop serves as a coping

mechanism for youth that are lacking support from traditional forms of therapy. It works as a

healing art form that immigrant youth can find affirmation, inspiration and clarity in the face of

adversity and change (Tyson & Baffour, 2004). Hip Hop therapy can shed light on immigrant

youth view of migration.

Moving from a different city can be difficult for a child to absorb. Everything is new and

they left behind everything that was familiar. This can be increasingly jarring for a child moving

from a different country and culture. Everything is new and difficult; without the appropriate

services acculturation can be a frustrating process. Understanding how immigrant and refugee

youth view migration is an important part of therapy. Hip Hop therapy provides a medium for

this to be expressed. Emotions that immigrant youth have expressed are feelings of intolerance,

prejudice, lack of support, loneliness, and truly feeling “alien” trying to fit in society and youth

culture (Chung, Bemak, and Grabosky, 2010).

Immigrants face multiple challenges in their adaption to a new country and culture. Pre-

migration stressors (trauma, family, extreme poverty, etc.) to post-migration issues (culture

Page 22: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 22

shock, finding employment, language, changing in family dynamics, etc.) can cause

acculturation to be difficult (Chung, Bemak, & Grabosky, 2010). Given this it is important that

immigrants receive culturally responsive services and for youth this is increasingly important as

they are adapting to both society and youth culture. Youth desire a need to feel safe in their new

environment which is often met with emotions of a life “on hold” (Brinegar 2010).

Immigrant youth view their migration and lives within the United States as “on hold”.

Licia, an undocumented immigrant from St. Vincent, initially felt that she did not have rights so

she did not have the right to plan for her future or set goals beyond her $4.30 an hour job

(Alienated, 2005). Many immigrant youth, like Lucia, echo these same feelings that their life is

limited and isolated due to the fact that they are undocumented despite living here most of their

lives. They are met with stereotypes, fear, intolerance and xenophobia to the point that their

mentality accepts it, decreasing their own self-image (Chung, Bemak, & Grabosky, 2010).

Immigrant Youth Justice League provides a means for undocumented immigrant youth

to vocalize, connect, and mobilize for change. Children of immigrants and children who are

immigrants are the largest sector of growth in the United States of America. Alienated:

Undocumented Immigrant Youth (Fauntleroy, 2005) stated that without the immigrant population

our economic system would collapse, but many children are unaware of this. They only see

themselves as illegal, the perpetual foreigner, or the terrorist, but never actually fitting in with

the entire community. This directly creates the situation, defined by Hegel, as “the other”.

Although, Hegel was a philosopher, this term is common in social psychology. Social

Psychology based in the idea that people's thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are influenced by

the presence of others (in both the implied and actual sense).

Page 23: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 23

For immigrant youth, the actual sense is the limitation to resources and rights.

Immigrant youth express feelings for rejection, desperation, unfulfilled dreams, and having

seemingly insurmountable odds (IYJL, 2011). These feelings are influences by the actual

presence of others; the others being implied alienating legislation. Hip Hop culture has been used

to address the emotions and reality of marginalized populations. Similarly, Hip Hop can be used

to address the legislative battles faced by immigrant and refugee youths.

The United States government, at both the state and federal levels, has isolated the

neediest, immigrants who are the stabilizing force in the economy. The most influential in health

and mental health care is the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act (PRWORA)

which changed the method and goal of federal assistant to the poor. The bill encouraged

employment among the poor by adding a workforce development component. The bill will was

spearheaded by Representative Clay Shaw, Jr. as part of the “Republican Contract with

America”. Clay Shaw, Jr. believed welfare was partly responsible for The United States large

growing immigrant population. The program did change the welfare system as we know it but it

also unequally affected immigrant populations. It effectively stated that immigrant children are

not created equal under the law and decreased their access to care. Shin (2006) states that

PRWORA violates constitutional amendments. First, by making guidelines for states in regards

to recent immigrants and making federal funding based on residency guidelines; Congress

violated the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause. Additionally, Congress violated

the Fifth Amendment’s Due Process Clause by denying immigrant children a right to health care

while granting assistance to citizen children. PRWORA anti-immigrant provisions completely

disregarded assessing eligibility for Medicaid and SCHIP programs for immigrant children and

pregnant women.

Page 24: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 24

The difference between immigrant and United States born populations shows alarming

statistics. Shin states that “Since 1990, the number of children in immigrant families has grown

nearly seven times faster than the number in U.S.-born families and it continues to grow

exponentially” (Shin, 2006, p. 485). More that 26 percent of low income children in the United

States are from immigrant families. PRWORA is counterproductive when dealing with

immigrant populations and it affects this population, immensely. As previously stated,

immigrants possess a number of strengths that argue immigrant populations do not adversely

increase the amount of federal assistance. PRWORA's popularity comes from the fallacy that

immigrants have greater health costs to the nation. However, Okie states “Whether or not they

have health insurance, immigrants overall have much lower per capita health care expenditures

than native-born Americans” (Okie, 2007, p. 1).

In addition to the health legislation, there is also legislation that affects education and

family continuity. In the song “Papers Please”. Hip Hop artist, Talib Kweli, accurately depicts

the fear for immigrants of Immigration and Naturalization Services (INS) deporting them and

separating their families. Deportation is one of the main reasons immigrants do not receive

health care or become informed of their rights. This song was in reference to Arizona's

immigration law, in which several other states have duplicated.

In October 2008 the Obama Administration started Secure Communities (SComm)

which is a federal deportation program, under Immigration Customs and Enforcement. The

purpose of this program is to for local law enforcement to share information for anyone they take

in for any reason to Immigration Customs and Enforcement. Information that can be shared are

fingerprints and immigration status. There are three stages prior to being deported: identification,

Page 25: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 25

release into ICE custody, and removal from the United States. After information is shared, ICE

can initiate deportation proceedings against any undocumented immigrant.

Since May 2011, more than 260,000 people have been arrested by ICE due to Secure

Communities, but over 100,000 have been deported (National Immigration Forum, 2011).

Approximately, 25 percent of people caught through Secure Communities were not convicted of

a crime and this percentage is higher in various states. In Illinois, 78 percent of the people caught

through SComm are non-criminals or had only minor offenses (like minor traffic violations)

(National Immigration Forum, 2011). States with higher immigrant populations see larger

deportation numbers of non-criminals. This program causes families to be separated and

instability for children.

Education is another area where there is tenuous debate about whether undocumented

adolescents can receive higher education. In 2011, Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) and 32 bipartisan

cosponsors re-introduced the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act

(DREAM Act). This legislation would benefit talented immigrant youth who attend college or

serve their country. For many, the United States is the only country they are familiar with. The

argument for the DREAM Act is that denial of access to higher education does not force them to

leave our country but forces them to remain in the underground workforce. Effectively this limits

the increased economic productivity and the tax revenues achieve through educated and

competitive workforce. For many immigrants, education means a future and safety from the lives

they left in their country of origin.

In the Brinegar (2010) study, immigrant and refugee youth express a need to feel safe

again. This is a case study examining the quality of mental health resources that immigrant youth

Page 26: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 26

have available at their schools and how the lack of these resources will complicate their

transition. The case study had a population of 14 middle school students. Of the 14 students, 9

were males and 5 were females. In terms of country of origin, 3 were from Somalia, 1 from the

Congo, 6 were Bosnian, and 4 were Vietnamese. The length of time they had been in the United

States varied, with one year being the shortest amount of time and 10 years the longest. They

shared the characteristic of transitioning into a new society and being ELL (English Language

Learner) eligible.

They possessed multiple complications for acculturation. In this case study, the

researchers used traditional art therapy methods although many delve into the realm of Hip Hop

therapy, including art work and writing. Throughout the three years of the case study, both

students and teachers shared numerous thoughts on the benefits of teaming for immigrant and

refugee students. One major result showed that immigrant students need a safe space where they

can have a voice and learn to advocate for themselves comfortably (Brinegar 2010).

There are many art therapy models that can be utilized in implementing a Hip Hop

therapy model. However, since children find many of their resources in the school setting a Hip

Hop therapy program for immigrant youth should also occur within a school setting. In fact,

countries with large immigrant populations have schools that can support and implement

prevention and treatment programs that use Art therapy approaches (Rousseau, Drapeau,

Lacroix, Bagilishya, & Heusch, 2005). Implementing a Hip Hop therapy program in a school

setting can prevent psychological distress seen in newly arrived immigrant and refugee youth

(Rousseau, et. al., 2005). A Hip Hop therapy, or any therapeutic program, for immigrants can

present several challenges.

Page 27: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 27

The first of these challenges is the fact that with immigrant populations it is a very

heterogeneous mixture with various cultural and life experiences, both pre-migration and post-

migration. Second, the gap between home and school is already daunting but adding a third

component of therapy may cause more confusion. There could also be cultural conflict if therapy

is viewed adversely by origin culture. Last, very little is known about therapeutic activities that

may work best, especially in the area of Hip Hop therapy. Small scale innovative experiments

show some areas but nothing comprehensive. Designing a program would begin with pilot

activities to build a foundation to combat these challenges.

Beginning with pilot activities, Hip Hop elements to describe an immigrant youth’s

arrival, origin stories and newcomer experiences. These activities should always combine verbal

and nonverbal modes of expression. Following Rousseau, et.al. (2005) workshops, the aims of

Hip Hop therapy activities will be to create a meaningful and understandable world around their

migration, to show respect for differences within the group and community at large, to promote

self-respect, and to bridge the gap between home and school. School-based creative therapy

programs promote the mental health of immigrant youth by removing the necessity for great

verbal ability. Various modes of expression decrease emotional and behavioral symptoms

(Rousseau, et. al., 2005) and Hip Hop is built in with multiple forms of expressions.

The Hip Hop song “Hey, Young World” presents an image that at risk youth can

achieve anything in spite of obstacles. Immigrant youth populations are a specific population at

risk who often do not receive support that is culturally responsive. Due to language barriers,

cross-cultural conflicts and societal discrimination, immigrant youth have a difficult time

escaping poverty and trauma. There is a potential beneficial role within Hip Hop therapy that can

enhance the adjustment process. Still, more applied research needs to be done in this form of

Page 28: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 28

therapy, but Hip Hop therapy for immigrant youth can promote self-actualization. The United

States demographics are changing in a way that is beneficial to support this immigrant “young

world”.

Page 29: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 29

Methodology

Currently, most of the United States population would have immigrated or be born of

immigrant parent(s) making them the new face of American society. According to 2004 data, 1

of every 5 children in the United States was a child of immigrants (Shields & Behrman, 2004).

Immigrants can be legal residents, refugees, and some are undocumented (most immigrants are

legal citizens). The children often share the similar hardships of low-income families, but they

do not have the unique understanding of these hardships as other low-income families. There are

many studies addressing the difficulties of marginalized natural born citizens but few addressing

how to lessen the strain on the immigrant adolescent.

The adolescent years can be a dynamic period in a person's development. In general,

youth need adult assistance, nurturing, supervision and resources, because developmentally they

are at a pivotal point for their future successes or failures. Positive influence and support from

parents and community may ensure a healthy maturation into adult life and society. The

immigrant adolescent faces additional strains in their development which revolves around

country of origin conflicting with host country values and identity.

Psychology acculturation research is aimed at discovering methods that facilitated

bicultural development and healthy adjustments of immigrant adolescents. An area of therapy

that may prove to be beneficial is Hip Hop therapy. Hip Hop culture has transcended many social

barriers of ethnicity, religion and even geographic boundaries. Other mediums have failed where

Hip Hop has prospered (Tinajero, 2009). This form of art therapy offers a nonthreatening way

for adolescents to express their inner feelings and provides a support system (Riley 2001). In the

areas of cognitive and socio-emotional development, Hip Hop therapy can assist in the therapist-

Page 30: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 30

client relationship because of its built in cross-cultural aspects. It is cross-cultural and is

universal in the modes of dance, drama, music and poetry (McNiff & Barlow, 2009).

Traditional therapeutic methods use language based therapy which often represent the

cultural values of the host country or psychologist, which tends to be predominately Anglo-

Saxon. In contrast, art therapy approaches developed in the United States can be easily adapted

to other cultures in the United States. In essence, Hip Hop therapy can be used prior to language

acquisition and as a mode for acculturation.

The creation of a Hip Hop therapy program specifically for immigrant youth can unite

immigrants youth through shared experiences in home countries and acculturation processes

(Elligan, 2004) while providing a therapeutic outlet for individual development. The program’s

name is The Collective which stems from a Hip Hop term. Different from a typical Hip Hop

group, a collective’s members do not regularly perform together; instead they are like-minded

collaborators, believers, dreamers.

Participants

Immigrant youth are defined as children under age 18 who are either foreign-born or

U.S.-born to immigrant parents. This population is now a quarter of the nation's 75 million

children. Chicago, a major metropolitan city, has seen immigrant youth population grow over the

last decade. Chicago is a city comprised of 77 communities and each community has seen their

demographics change over time. In the 2007 census, Chicago was listed as having the fifth

largest foreign-born population. Major immigrant groups include Latinos, Africans, Middle

Eastern, and Asians.

These four ethnic groups are represented predominantly in Chicago Public Schools. Since

Page 31: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 31

The Collective's focus is immigrant youth the ideal setting would be in a Chicago Public School

that has access to ages 12-15. Two neighborhoods where all four ethnics groups are represented

in Chicago Public Schools are Albany Park and Uptown, both on Chicago's North Side. Finding

a school that is available for after school programs is not difficult, but it would be beneficial if

many of the students attended other neighborhood schools. This would allow the program to

expand to the community at large and possibly conduct youth led community meetings.

The initial participant group will consist of 14 students from the four ethnic groups. The

selected children will be chosen from client and guardian qualitative inquiries to determine

immigrant youth that will benefit most from the program. These qualitative inquiries are

voluntary and participants will be provided with information on The Collective. Children will

also be selected from English Language Learner (ELL) status and time of entry; however,

immigration status will never be asked. Modeling the Brinegar (2010) study this program will

seek to create a safe space where they can have a voice and learn to advocate for themselves

comfortably (Brinegar 2010). Safety from deportation is a major factor in immigrant

participation. This program requires participant trust, as the program developer needs the client's

frank responses.

The participants and their guardians will be informed of confidentiality for the program.

The confidentiality statement will include privacy in regards to immigration status. Participants

will be reminded that information shared is voluntary. Participants will be informed that art work

will be displayed but they choose which art form they wish to display. Community discussions

will also be part of the program, and their function and purpose will be explained. The

community discussion follows “the act of knowing” in Stein and Mankowski (2004) four acts of

qualitative research: “knowing can be represented through variety of activities such as

Page 32: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 32

writing, teaching, speaking, organizing, depending on research and action goals” ( Stein &

Mankowski, 2004).

Design and Materials

The Collective will use the four elements of Hip Hop. The four elements are: MCs

(emcees), Djs (deejays), Break-dancing, and Graffiti Art (Tillie Allen, 2009). Although these

four are the root of Hip Hop culture, the culture has expanded to incorporate film and poetry.

The immigrant youths will have an opportunity to experiment and learn how to use all of these

modes of self-expression. Hip Hop therapy, as a subset of art therapy, can help immigrant youth

express their thoughts on migration and social structures of the United States. Program products

will include art work, writing and community meetings. Advances in self-expression and

conscientious understanding of society will display whether the therapy is effective.

In addition to art work by the participants, they will also be taught by emcees, deejays,

break-dancers, and graffiti artist. The program developer will conduct poetry workshops. Hip

Hop culture has been used to address the emotions and reality of marginalized populations.

Involving others creates a connection to issues immigrant youths are familiar with. This is

increasingly important as they are adapting to both society and youth culture. In order to ensure

immigrant youth, in the program, are receiving culturally responsive services the program will

create connections with school therapist. In a similar function of an IEP, the program will be

adapted to meet the needs of the student explained by the school therapist.

The main materials of the program do require a space for art production, art display, and

group and community meetings. Break-dancing can be done in a gym or a community

organization facility. Although many of the instructors may want to volunteer time compensation

Page 33: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 33

is still an issue. The program will not be a paid program for participants like some after school

programs are in Chicago Public Schools.

Procedure

Beginning with pilot activities that use Hip Hop elements to describe an immigrant

youth’s arrival, origin stories and newcomer experiences. These activities should always

combine verbal and nonverbal modes of expression. Following Rousseau, et.al. (2005)

workshops, the aims of Hip Hop therapy activities will be to create a meaningful and

understandable world around their migration, to show respect for differences within the group

and community at large, to promote self-respect, and to bridge the gap between home and school.

School-based creative therapy programs promote the mental health of immigrant youth by

removing the necessity for great verbal ability. Various modes of expression decrease emotional

and behavioral symptoms (Rousseau, et. al., 2005) and Hip Hop is built in with multiple forms of

expressions.

Participants will meet after school completing Hip Hop art, youth led workshops,

community discussions and other forms of “edutainment”. These activities will activate

knowledge of self and society while providing therapeutic care with the assistance of a licensed

school therapist. The first series of activities will be mostly Hip Hop art and youth led

workshops. Once every month there will be a showcase and community forum held. During this

clients will display art work, spoken word, dance and music to their school and community.

Also, during the community forum information will be provided that is specific to the immigrant

community. This information will be compiled by the program developer. At this stage, the

information complied will be put into action for the guardians of the clients and community.

Page 34: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 34

Discussion

International migration is changing the social landscape of not only the United States but

also other countries. Culture is central to academic and social development. Culturally

responsive methods in teaching and psychology is becoming more and more pivotal as the

United States, and world, becomes more diverse due to global migration. Understanding various

theories of education and globalization will help teachers, psychologists, and child related

services better understand and assist refugee and immigrant students. This social transformation

is important to United States interests and growth in a global society. Despite, The United States

priding itself on being a nation of immigrants and welcoming newcomers, policy and opinion

show a division on immigration. Meanwhile, in 2009, there were 74.5 million children under the

age of 17 in the United States, constituting nearly 24% of the population (Hernandez 2004).

Nearly 24% of that population (about 16.9 million) had at least one immigrant parent (Hernandez

2004). These 16.9 million children need reform and resources that meet their socialization and

acculturation needs.

Many immigrants find there are many obstacles set in place and no way to overcome

them. By advocating for a very vulnerable population, psychologists can create culturally

responsive therapeutic treatments and services to decrease the isolation of migrant communities.

Culturally responsiveness begins with developing culturally and linguistically competent

programs and services for immigrant populations. This will lead to more coordinated and

continuous education and health care programs for immigrants. Many immigrants are unaware or

adverse to Western mental health care (Garrett 2006). These stigmas often leave immigrant

communities isolated and deficient in transitional services.

Page 35: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 35

Assisting immigrant and ethnic minority youth allows them to make a successful

transition into adulthood. Their success is fostered by their educational attainment, acquisition of

employable skills, and physical and mental health. Immigration is not preventable therefore

restriction policies are a losing battle and a waste fiscally. Immigration affects our everyday

activities- the food we consume, the people who watch our children, the entertainment we watch

are all a product of immigration. Therefore, immigration discrimination is socially detrimental to

our entire society. Immigrant youth programming can provide social development, educational

attainment, access to health services including mental health.

As an elementary teacher and someone who frequently works with adolescents, I am

aware of the social changes and needs they encounter. Immigration in the context of life span

presents a profound transition that requires adaptation and cultural survival. Immigration is

accompanied with other stress factors such as loss of family, country, economic difficulties, and

social acclimation. This combined with developmental issues can be difficult to combat in the

classroom alone. Many immigrant youth do not receive assistance until high school but without

prior access to services immigrant youth will constantly have a gap in their achievement.

Observing this gap there must be a culturally responsive method to lessen pre - and post-

immigration stressors.

Implementation of a Hip Hop therapeutic program provides a method that facilitates

bicultural development and healthy adjustments of immigrant adolescents. However, this form of

therapy is not without its flaws or limitations, as in any form of therapy. Hip Hop therapy heavily

dependent on participants’ attraction and exposure to Hip Hop culture. This is why the

participant selection survey is crucial. This could limit the population of immigrant youth,

however, most immigrant youth identify with Hip Hop lyrics, art, and messages. Therapy is not

Page 36: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 36

always seen positively in different ethnic communities. Hip Hop therapy provides both a cultural

and linguistically nonthreatening medium for therapy. Hip Hop culture has transcended many

social barriers of ethnicity, religion and even geographic boundaries. Other mediums have failed

where Hip Hop has prospered (Tinajero, 2009). This form of art therapy offers a nonthreatening

way for adolescents to express their inner feelings and provides a support system beginning prior

to full English language acquisition which is most culturally responsive (Riley 2001). It is still

necessary to include a licensed therapist and keep basic therapeutic necessities, but this therapy

program would not have any different difficulties than any group counseling settings. But with

the addition of art through Hip Hop, many conflictions can be adverted.

Psychology should not exist outside of its community and world. Awareness of culturally

responsive methods can assist people in law, education and community organizing. Immigrant

youth vary in identity, ethnicity/race, social class, gender identity, and religion. These

backgrounds do not exist outside of attainment of success. How they exist in the world directly

influences who and what they become.

Page 37: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 37

Peripheral Documents

Flyer

Figure 1

Page 38: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 38

Budget Proposal

Figure 2: Start Up Budget

Hip Hop teachers (4) $ 8,640.00 *

School Psychologists $ 2,943.72 **

Total Staff Expenses $ 8,640.00

Equipment

Mural Creation Supplies $ 800.00

Audio Equipment $ 1,400.00

Sketch Books $ 84.00

Total Equipment Expenses $ 2,284.00

Miscellaneous Expenses $ 2,000.00

Total Start Up Costs

$ 15,867.72

* Teachers: $60/week for 36 weeks = $2,160

** School Psychologists 327.08 per month (9)

Page 39: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 39

Participant Survey Form

This survey is voluntary and confidential. Participants for The Collective, a Hip Hop therapy

program, will be chosen based on the answers provided.

Child’s Name Date of Birth

Parent’s/Guardian’s Name

Home Phone Work Phone

Address

City ST ZIP Code

Alternative Emergency Contacts

Emergency Contact Name

Home Phone Work Phone

Address

City ST ZIP Code

Emergency Contact Name

Home Phone Work Phone

Address

City ST ZIP Code

Medical Information

Allergies/Special Health Considerations:

Page 40: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 40

I give permission for my child to go on field trips. I release and individuals from liability in case

of accident during activities related to, as long as normal safety procedures have been taken.

Parent’s/Guardian’s Signature

School Name

School Phone

Address

City ST ZIP Code

Program Specific Questions

Country of Origin

Languages spoken

Number of Years Living in the U.S.

Are you interested in the elements of Hip

Hop? Y N

Please attach one picture (can be from magazine or internet) that is significant to you.

Page 41: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 41

Confidentiality Statement

Overview of The Collective

Collective – (n.) different from a typical Hip Hop group, its members do not regularly perform

together, and are instead like-minded collaborators, believers, dreamers.

This program is an arts-based therapy program rooted in the elements of Hip Hop. Participants

will be creating art work facilitated by the program developer and receiving therapy through

school counselors. The goal of this program is to help with adjustment of immigrant youth and

their families. Below is a confidentiality statement outlining the rights of you, the participant and

information will be made public (in reference to art work and community building projects).

All minor clients, parents and legal guardians receiving counseling through the program are

protected by this Confidentiality Statement.

Confidentiality Statement

Your confidentiality, as a student, is important to us! In this program and counseling office, what

is said here, stays here, with the following exceptions, as required by law and/or ethical

standards:

1. Harm to self or others

Page 42: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 42

This could include things like a suicide attempt or plan, cutting or other self-injury, eating

disorders, addictions, fighting or other physical violence -anything that puts your health or

safety, or someone else's health and safety, at risk.

2. Abuse or neglect

If you talk with one of us about abuse (physical, emotional, verbal, sexual, or other abuse),

whether to yourself or to another minor, we are required by law to report it to Illinois Department

of Children and Family Services, and possibly the police. If you tell us about an abuse case that's

already been addressed by DCFS or the police, we still may need to make a call to double check.

3. Court or other legal proceedings

By law, if we are subpoenaed (required by law to attend a hearing or other court proceeding), we

cannot guarantee that your information will be kept confidential. We will always do our best to

reveal as little as possible in a legal setting, but we must cooperate with the police, DCFS, and

the courts.

If there is ever a need to reveal information (such as art work or community building projects),

we will let you know in advance, and work with you to handle the situation in a way that respects

you, you’re feelings, and your needs.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

I have read and I understand the program’s confidentiality guidelines and exceptions.

________________________________________________________ _______________

Student Signature Date

________________________________________________________ _______________

Parent/Guardian Signature Date

Page 43: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 43

Pilot Activities Handout

Overview of The Collective

Collective (n.) in Hip Hop is different from a typical Hip Hop group because its members

do not regularly perform together instead they are like-minded colleagues or collaborators. The

purpose of this program is to unite youths who have recently immigrated to the United States.

We foster immigrant youth voices, leadership and community engagement through Hip Hop

elements. Throughout the year, we will be active in the creation of safe and supportive space for

immigrant youth to share personal and political experience, strategies, and tactics to

create positive change. In addition, all of the youths in the program will receive individual

counseling with a licensed psychologist to address acculturation difficulties and any other

concerns. We will also provide you and your parents with confidentiality statements and a

weekly program calendar of events.

RhyME (telling your story)

RhyME is the time that each youth has a moment telling their point of view about the selected

group discussion topic. These will be personal and everyone’s voice will be respected. This can

be done creatively with any Hip Hop elements or just spoken words. The purpose of this time is

to engage in active coalition building and solidarity.

4 Elements Stations (experiment with the environment)

Time to spend working with the 4 stations with and instructor. This is also time to develop any

work or ideas for showcase (at the end of the semester).

Page 44: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 44

PsychTime (individual)

Individual group therapy session with licensed psychologist. Informed of confidentiality during

this time. This is free to all participants and also required.

Rap up! (group therapy with psychologist and program developer)

Rap up! is the conclusion for the session when youth have opportunity to express any emotions

and reflect on anything that they felt. This can be done through words or artistic Hip Hop

representation.

The Collective Showcase

At the end of each semester, students will showcase their voice and talents through Hip Hop

pieces they have prepared. Either Graffiti art, spoken word, EM CEEing, DJing, or

Breakdancing. This is youth led. Youths with audio tracks will be recorded for a CD. This CD

will be sold and the profits will go to the program supplies and other needs for the youth.

Community Outreach

Students will become instructors, mentors and speakers to younger students at area schools and

older generations in community settings in order to promote connection and self-empowerment.

Figure 3

Day Activities Instructor

Page 45: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 45

Monday

Overview of The Collective

RhyME (telling your story)

4 Elements Stations (experiment with the environment)

PsychTime (individual)

Rap up! (group therapy with psychologist and program developer)

Psychologist

Program

Developer

Tuesday

RhyME (telling your story)

4 Elements Stations (make something, your story)

PsychTime (individual)

Rap up! (group therapy with psychologist and program developer)

Psychologist

Program

Developer

Wednesday

RhyME (telling your story)

4 Elements Stations (small group: developing a group narrative)

PsychTime (individual)

Rap up! (group therapy with psychologist and program developer)

Psychologist

Program

Developer

Thursday

Guest Teacher

PsychTime (individual)

Rap up! (group therapy with psychologist and program developer)

Psychologist

Program

Developer

Friday

The first community outreach at area school

A narrative

Guest teacher skills learned and group performance with teacher

Psychologist

Program

Developer

Page 46: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 46

References

Berk, L. E. (2007). Development through the lifespan (4th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.

Boston, C. G., (2005). Life story of an art therapist of color. Art Therapy: Journal of the

American Art Therapy Association, 22 (4), 189-192.

Blackwell, M., George, M., Greene, B., (2005). Three voices on Multiculturalism in the art

therapy classroom. Art Therapy: Journal of the American Art Therapy Association, 22

(3), 132-138.

Brinegar, K. (2010). "I feel like I'm safe again": a discussion of middle grades organizational

structures from the perspective of immigrant youth and their teachers. Research in Middle

Level Education Online, 33(9), 1-14. Retrieved from EBSCOhost.

Clay, A. (2006). "All I need is one mic": mobilizing youth for social change in the post-civil

rights era. Social Justice, 33(2), 105-122.

DJ Kosher. (2010, January). About the Show and the Hosts . Don't Rush The Stage: What Hip

Hop Can and Should Be!

Elbasha, D. (2010, October). For Latino Hip Hop group, music is freedom – News. The

Diamondback - University of Maryland.

Elligan, D. (2004). Rap therapy: a practical guide for communicating with youth and young

adults through rap music. New York, NY: Dafina Books.

Falicov, C. J. (2007). Working With Transnational Immigrants: Expanding Meanings of Family,

Community, and Culture. Family Process, 46(2), 157-171.

Fauntleroy, L. (Director). (2006). Alienated: Undocumented Immigrant Youth [Motion picture on

DVD]. United States of America: Educational Video Center.

Page 47: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 47

Fortuny, K., Hernandez, D.J., & Chaudry, A. (2010). Young children of immigrants: The leading

edge of America’s future. Brief 3.Washington, D.C.: The Urban Institute.

http://www.urban.org/publications/412203.html

Garrett, K. E. (Ed.). (2006). Living In America: Challenges Facing New Immigrants and

Refugees. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 3-32.

George, J., Greene, B. D., & Blackwell, M. (2005). Three Voices on Multiculturalism in the Art

Therapy Classroom. Journal of the American Art Therapy Association, 22, 132-138.

Giang, M. T., & Wittig, M. A. (2006). Implications of adolescents' acculturation strategies for

personal and collective self-esteem. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology,

12(4), 725-739.

IYJL. (Director). (2011, April 2). IYJL Out of the Shadows 2011 [Video]. Retrieved October 14,

2011, from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bATPoDrxkAA

McNiff, S., & Barlow, G. C. (2009). Cross-Cultural Psychotherapy and Art. Art Therapy, 26(3),

100-106.

National Immigration Forum. (2011, May 11). DREAM Act Reintroduced in Senate. National

Immigration Forum.

National Immigration Forum. (2011, July). Secure Communities. National Immigration Forum.

Okie, S. (2007). Immigrants and Health Care -- At the Intersection of Two Broken Systems. New

England Journal of Medicine, 357(6), 525-529. doi: 10.1056/NEJMp078113

Riley, S. (2001). Art therapy with Adolescents. West J Med, 175, 54-57.

Rousseau, C., Drapeau, A., Lacroix, L., Bagilishya, D., & Heusch, N. (2005). Evaluation of a

classroom program of creative expression workshops for refugee and immigrant children.

Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 46(2), 180-185.

Page 48: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 48

Rousseau, C., Lacroix, L., Singh, A., Gauthier, M., & Benoit, M. (2005). Creative Expression

Workshops in School: Prevention Programs for Immigrant and Refugee Children. The

Canadian Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Review, 14(3), 77-80.

Rousseau, C., Singh, A., Lacroix, L., & Measham, T. (2004). Creative Expression Workshops for

Immigrant and Refugee Children. Journal of the American Academy of Child &

Adolescent Psychiatry, 43(2), 235-238. doi: 10.1097/00004583-200402000-00021

Shields, M. K., & Behrman, R. E. (2004). Children of Immigrant Families: Analysis and

Recommendations. Children of Immigrant Families, 14(2), 4-15.

Slayton, S. C., D’Archer, J., & Kaplan, F. (2010). Outcome Studies on the Efficacy of Art

Therapy: A Review of Findings. Journal of the American Art Therapy Association, 27,

108-118.

Stein, C. H., & Mankowski, E. S. (2004). Asking, Witnessing, Interpreting, Knowing:

Conducting Qualitative Research in Community Psychology. American Journal of

Community Psychology, 33(1/2), 21-35.

Suárez-Orozco, C., Gaytán, F. X., Bang, H., Pakes, J., O'Connor, E., & Rhodes, J. (2010).

Academic trajectories of newcomer immigrant youth. Developmental Psychology, 46(3),

602-618.

Sue, D. W. & Capodilupo C. M. (2008). Racial, gender, and sexual orientation microaggressions:

Implications for counseling and psychotherapy. In D. W. Sue & D. Sue (Eds.),

Counseling the culturally diverse: Theory and practice (5th

ed., pp.105-130). Hoboken,

NJ: Wiley.

Tillie Allen, N. M. (2005). Exploring Hip Hop Therapy with High-Risk Youth. Praxis, 5, 30-36.

Page 49: Hip Hop Therapy: Culturally Responsive Therapy for Immigrant and Refugee Youth through Art Integration

Hip Hop Therapy 49

Tinajero, R. J. (2009). Hip Hop rhetoric relandscaping the rhetorical tradition (Unpublished

doctoral dissertation). University of Texas at El Paso.

Tyson, E., & Baffour, T. (2004). Arts-based strengths: a solution-focused intervention with

adolescents in an acute-care psychiatric setting. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 31(4), 213-

227.