Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    1/1357 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    In this special feature, regular contributor to Green

    Building magazine, Gavin Harper has assembled this

    special supplement for us looking at hydrogen fuel and

    fuel cells ...

    The recent flurry of activity by the scientific and engineering

    community has brought the fuel cell into the public eye, with

    the subject being mentioned on the Green Building forum,

    prompting a flurry of activity on the subject. We decided to

    cover the topic with a round-up of some current projects,

    interviews with people at the centre of the action, and an

    exposition of the technology, with the aim of attempting to

    answer some of the questions posed, and investigating

    the real capabilities of this technology.

    Many would believe that the fuel cell was a recent

    innovation, however, its roots can be traced back to as

    early as 1838. Sir William Robert Grove is widely heralded

    as the father of the fuel cell. He was born in 1811, in

    Swansea, Wales, a Welsh lawyer who later applied himself

    to the mastery of science. He discovered what is known

    as the Grove gas battery. In 1843 he published a diagram

    and made a primitive model. However, it was not really

    until much later (in 1959), that a fuel cell with a sizable

    power output (5kW) was developed by British engineer,

    Francis Thomas Bacon.

    Green Building magazine :

    www.greenbuildingmagazine.co.uk

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    2/1358 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    What is a fuel cell?A fuel cell is an electrochemical energy conversion device. Why

    electrochemical? Because it harnesses the energy made in

    chemical reactions to produce electrical energy. You might like

    to think of a fuel cell as being very similar to a battery, however,

    there are some key differences. A battery is a sealed unit, where

    in the case of disposable batteries, once all of the reactants are

    used up, their energy is depleted. Fuel cells differ in this respect,

    in that the reactants are continuously replenished allowing the

    cell to operate for much longer periods.

    There is also another key difference. In a battery, because of

    the chemical reactions that are occurring, the electrodes change

    over the life of the battery. In the case of rechargeable batteries,

    this change is reversible adding energy to the battery allows

    the electrodes to change back into their original state. Fuel cells

    differ significantly in this respect. A fuel cells electrodes are

    catalytic and do not change considerably over the life of the fuel

    cell. The fuel in a fuel cell is not burned, like in an engine, as such.

    Fuel cells are quiet, even silent in operation, and are free from

    polluting emissions. The key fuel in a fuel cell is hydrogen. Inmany fuel cells this is supplied as a gas, however, with some fuel

    cells, for example direct methanol fuel cells, another fuel is used

    which is a hydrogen carrier. This is to say, the methanol acts

    as a transport mechanism for getting hydrogen to the fuel cell.

    In Woking, natural gas is being used as a carrier for hydrogen,

    being reformed on-site before it enters the fuel cell.

    Why not just use hydrogen? Well, sometimes by using a

    hydrogen carrier we make the fuel easier to transport and store.

    These hydrogen carriers could have an important part to play

    in a transition to a hydrogen economy, as they would allow us

    to use existing infrastructure that is currently used to transport

    petrol and other liquid fuels. However, it must also be noted

    that there are carbon dioxide emissions as a result of using ahydrogen carrier.

    The idea was broached on the Green Building Forum, of

    a hydrogen infrastructure being a useless duplication of

    infrastructure that is already present for distributing energy

    namely our gas and electricity networks. However, if the idea

    of hydrogen flowing through pipes in the street seems an alien

    one, think back to before the discovery of North Sea gas, when

    town gas contained up to 50% hydrogen. Allan Jones remains

    confident that gas will continue to flow into the UK for many

    years yet, citing that LPG is easily transportable and can be

    imported easily. However, the UK has already changed from one

    piped gas to another variety with different characteristics its

    not inconceivable could happen again.

    How do fuel cells work?Lets take a look at what happens inside a fuel cell. In this

    example we are going to look at a proton exchange membrane

    or polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell. As we will see later,

    there are different types of fuel cells, all of which follow similar

    principles.

    There are two sides to the fuel cell (see Figure 1), the anode

    and the cathode. The anode is what we would call our positive

    terminal or +V and the cathode, we would call our negative

    terminal or -V. Our anode is perpetually exposed to hydrogen

    which is constantly replenished from a supply such as a tank. The

    cathode is perpetually exposed to oxygen, which is constantly

    replenished. The two are separated by a plastic membrane made

    from nafion, but more about that later.

    Looking at the anode, the hydrogen must first diffuse through

    a gas diffusion electrode (GDE). This is a material which allowsthe gas to pass through to the catalyst, whilst also conducting

    electricity. Carbon cloths and papers are commonly used as they

    have the property of being porous to the hydrogen, whilst also

    conducting electricity.

    Once it has passed through the GDE it comes into contact

    with the catalyst, which generally contains platinum. The catalyst

    facilitates the chemical reaction which comes next, allowing the

    hydrogen to break into protons and electrons. The nafion plastic

    membrane is porous to protons and allows them to pass through.

    However, the electrons cannot pass through the membrane.

    Instead, they take the next easiest route to reach the other side

    this is the electric circuit that allows us to extract useful power

    from the fuel cell. As the electrons travel round the circuit,

    they do some work; this could be powering a motor in a car or

    scooter, powering a portable electronic device or illuminating a

    lamp in your home. When they reach the other side, the oxygen

    (which can either be pure oxygen or the oxygen present in air)

    reacts with the electrons which have travelled through the circuit,

    and the protons which have travelled through the membrane, to

    form water.

    How much power does a fuel cell produce?Typically, each cell produces a potential difference of around 0.8

    volts. In a similar way to in a car battery where multiple cells

    Figure 1. Simplified diagram of how a fuel cell works.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    3/1359 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    are used to create 12v, or in many electrical appliances where

    we use a number of batteries to create a higher voltage, so

    fuel cells can be built up in stacks. A fuel cell stack produces a

    higher voltage than an individual fuel cell. The amount of current

    that a fuel cell produces is largely dependent upon the size of

    the active area where the chemical reaction is taking place.

    Fuel cell effi cienc yOne of the great advantages of fuel cells is that unlike

    conventional heat engines, such as the internal combustion

    engine (the sort you find in your car or generator), or external

    combustion engines (such as steam and Stirling engines), the

    fuel cell is not constrained by the Carnot cycle effi ciency (that

    is to say the rule of thermodynamics which govern the effi ciency

    of conventional engines) because the fuel cells do not operate

    using a thermal cycle. As a result, fuel cells are theoretically far

    more effi cient than heat engines which results in extracting

    more energy from our fuel. However, work is still in progress to

    reach those theoretically attainable effi ciencies. From practical

    experience effi ciencies of 30% are being attained which

    correlates with those figures obtained by Paul in Montreal fromWikipedia on the Green Building Forum. Indeed, further to Pauls

    comments about energy storage in batteries, projects like HARI

    (see page 64), show how both technologies can be successfully

    integrated providing effi cient short term storage, with the

    capacity for longer-term storage of energy in hydrogen and

    the ability to transport this energy easily or use it as a transport

    fuel.

    The hydrogen economyWith peak oil, and the possibility of peak coal, peak gas and peak

    uranium, people are looking for new solutions to meet our energy

    needs. The hydrogen economy is one proposed way of meeting

    our energy needs more sustainably.

    It is important to note, that hydrogen is not used as a

    fuel but as a carrier for energy that is produced using other

    means. Hydrogen is a near ideal energy carrier and permits a

    decentralised energy infrastructure supporting the argument

    for small scale, local energy production. It can also fit within

    the framework of our present large scale energy generation

    infrastructure and the ability to store it eliminates many of

    the intermittency problems that are often discussed about

    renewables.

    Hydrogen is the first element on the periodic table for a very

    special reason. It is the simplest of all chemicals, and also the

    lightest. We do not need to fear running out of hydrogen, as

    it is the most abundant element in the universe. Hydrogen is

    a fantastic energy carrier and to understand what makes it so

    good, you need to look at why carbon based energy carriers are

    so bad. When a carbon based fuel burns, it produces carbon

    dioxide, a greenhouse gas. In addition, when carbon is burned

    in an internal combustion engine, impurities in the fuel lead

    to sulphurous emissions that lead to acid rain, and the large

    nitrogen content of the air, coupled with the high temperatures

    reached inside the engine, promote the production of NOX.

    Furthermore, engines also emit large amounts of unburnt

    hydrocarbons, VOCs and masses of particulates. The damage

    caused by burning carbon based fuels can clearly be seen in

    places like Los Angeles, which is permanently shrouded in a

    photochemical smog.

    We have seen the evil of carbon based fuels, which are

    responsible for the UKs transition to fuels with a lower carbon

    content typified by the dash for gas, where coal was usurped

    by natural gas as the energy of choice. However, the hydrogen

    economy promises a future without carbon.

    Hydrogen is colourless, odourless and tasteless, non toxic, an

    produces water as its only by-product. However, it is dangerous

    if mixed with air or oxygen because of the fire and explosion

    risk. In principle, it can asphyxiate through denying the body

    access to oxygen. Contrast this to carbon based fuels which

    are also explosive, cause damage to the ecosystem, personal

    health problems, and potential future fuel insecurity. Our global

    prosperity in the past couple of centuries has been built on

    carbon. Unfortunately carbon fuels have been burnt with little

    consideration for future supply, and the damage done to the

    environment. After much development, our carbon based

    engines still only reach around 20% effi ciency. Furthermore,

    our energy is currently generated centrally, which, due to lossesin transmission and conversion, can be horribly ineffi cient. By

    transitioning to a hydrogen economy, the future is open for

    distributed generation.

    Types of fuel cellThere are a large number of fuel cell types in research and

    development by a large number of companies. At the moment,

    the state of fuel cell technology can be broken down into a

    distinct number of types, all with their own distinct characteris-

    tics, which make them ideal for certain applications.

    So how is hydrogen made?There are a number of ways that we can get our hydrogen. It is

    bit of a myth that hydrogen is a fuel. It isnt really, as there is nosuch thing as a hydrogen mine.

    ElectrolysisAt school, you might have used a Hoffman apparatus in science

    class. A Hoffman apparatus has a reservoir of water through

    which is passed an electric current. The electric current

    disassociates the hydrogen from the oxygen in the water. The

    gas bubbles off from the electrodes and is collected in separate

    storage containers. It is observed that twice as much hydrogen

    is produced as oxygen. Taking a little bit of time to think about

    this, we see that the chemical formula for water is H2O. This

    makes sense as we can see that there is twice as much hydroge

    in water as oxygen. The hydrogen produced by the electrolysis

    process is very pure. Some fuel cells require a very pure form o

    hydrogen so this is ideal.

    The one disadvantage of electrolysis is that significant

    amounts of electrical energy are needed for the process. Whilst

    this electricity can be generated using clean, green renewable

    energy, there are also many champions of a nuclear-hydrogen

    economy using supposedly cheap nuclear energy to produce

    hydrogen this would leave us with a toxic legacy of waste and

    would negate many of the benefits of a clean hydrogen econom

    Steam reformationBy combining high temperature steam, and methane, it is

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    4/1360 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    possible to extract hydrogen from this fossil fuel. The process

    is fairly cheap and inexpensive, and the heat produced can also

    be harnessed (known as co-generation which is covered later).

    Co-generation provides us with lots of low-level heat which could

    prove useful in local combined heat and power schemes. This

    method does show a lot of promise as it is currently an effi cient

    cheap technology that will work with existing gas-distribution

    infrastructure. However the carbon emissions are impossible to

    ignore.

    Biomass gasification and reformationBiomass has proven itself as a relatively clean, near carbon

    neutral source of energy. Agricultural waste, organic matter,

    wood and other sources of biomass can be heated in a controlled

    atmosphere without the presence of oxygen. This yields a gas

    synthesis gas, which is hydrogen rich as well as containing

    carbon monoxide and dioxide.

    The carbon emissions from this source of energy are

    effectively neutral as the carbon dioxide was taken out of the

    atmosphere in the first place by the growing plants. However,carbon emissions in the production and distribution of Biomass

    cannot be ignored. There is also the possibility of sequestering

    the carbon produced in the gasification process. This could

    effectively make biomass with hydrogen extraction a carbon

    negative fuel.

    PhotoelectrolysisPhotoelectrolysis is a relatively new unproven technology. It

    involves using solar energy to stimulate a silicon junction similar

    to a photovoltaic cell, with the distinction that instead of the

    energy being converted to electricity, the silicon junction acts

    directly on the water where electrolysis occurs. This technology

    shows promise, although much development must be done.

    Biologically produced hydrogenThere are a number of types of algae that use

    photosynthesis to convert solar energy into hydrogen.

    At the moment these processes have only been

    demonstrated on a small scale, but research in this area

    is intense. It is expected that great strides forward in

    this area could be made.

    Clean coal?There are vast tracts of coal throughout the world.

    However, coal is carbon rich burning it doesnt

    help global warming, and mining leaves scars on the

    landscape which can last for generations. There are,

    however, schemes afoot to look at gasifying coal,

    extracting the carbon, and sequestering it.

    Co, tri and quad generationWhilst fuel cells are some way off achieving their

    theoretical maximum effi ciency, the waste heat that

    is produced can be utilised in heating and cooling

    applications. Whilst some heat is still lost this is

    inevitable the model of producing electricity using

    decentralised fuel cells is far more attractive than the

    present model of centralised generation. Allan Jones

    explores how fuel cells have the potential to reduce

    the amount of energy wasted as dumped heat, and

    electrical losses designed into a centralised generation scheme

    (see page 66).

    Taking the example of fuel cell combined heat and power from

    natural gas, it is seen in Figure 2 what supporting equipment is

    necessary to interface the fundamental unit of the fuel cell to

    the rest of the building services. Heat generated from the fuel

    cell is sequestered in a thermal store until it is required. This

    helps to balance supply and demand. For backup purposes, and

    for when additional heat is required, a gas burner is provided to

    supplement the heat from the fuel cell.

    Because many solid-oxide fuel cells are sensitive to sulphur,

    the sulphur must first be scrubbed from the gas to avoid

    contaminating the fuel cell. There are plans afoot to develop

    fuel cells which tolerate of sulphur. Companies such as TMI in

    Cleveland, Ohio are developing fuel cells that may not require

    this intermediate step and can also run from gases with high

    sulphur content such as that produced by agricultural biogas

    digesters. The gas must then be humidified waste heat from

    the fuel cell is used to heat up water to provide humidification.This humidification helps with the next step, which is the steam-

    reformation of natural gas into hydrogen and carbon dioxide. The

    gas then passes through a heat exchanger where it is pre-heated

    before going to the fuel cell, along with air, which is also pre-

    heated. The hot exhaust from the fuel cell is used to provide heat

    for the heat exchanger which produces the hot water, preheats

    the gases being supplied to the fuel cell and heats the reformer.

    The output from the fuel cell is direct current (DC) which

    must then be rectified into alternating current (AC) and

    synchronised with the phase and frequency of the grid into which

    it is being fed. In Woking (see page 66) it can be seen how fuel

    cells have been selected with power electronics that can work

    in island mode and maintain the grid frequency in the event

    Figure 2. A tri-generation fuel cell.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    5/1361 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    of a main grid failure. This capability enables the private wire

    network to operate independently in the event that the grid fails.

    Additionally, controls will interface with the building management

    system, to match the fuel cells operation to the buildings need

    for heat and power.

    This is accomplished by using the heat for useful applications

    heating a building, or coupled with absorptive cooling to

    meet a buildings cooling loads in the summer. In Woking,quadgeneration is being employed, which builds upon co-

    generation and tri-generation, by providing electricity, steam, hot

    water, and chilled water for cooling, all from a single fuel source

    natural gas. A variable fraction of the heat-generated can be

    diverted into absorptive cooling, enabling the fuel cell quad-gen

    system to match closely the demand for heating and cooling.

    Additionally, because the electricity is generated close to source,

    electrical losses are reduced.

    Things are beginning to happen apace. For instance, the

    PURE Energy Centre has announced its collaboration with Fuel

    Cells Scotland (see page 62), to produce the first unplugged

    hydrogen houses. The technology is in place, so it is only a

    matter of time before the first commercially available domestic

    fuel cell systems are being sold for early adopters. At last years

    Grove Fuel Cell Symposium, the boiler manufacturer BAXI was

    exhibiting a combined heat and power unit, so its only a matter

    of time before smaller units become available.

    Gavin Harper

    Useful links:

    WWW.GROVEFUELCELL.COM

    WWW.LSHC.CO.UK

    HTTP:// EC.EUROPA.EU/NEWS/SCIENCE/071011 _ 1 _ EN.HTM

    Figure 3. Where the energy from tri-generation goes.

    HYDROGENFUELTECHNOLOGY

    For many years, hydrogen fuel cell technology has

    been just over the horizon, just a couple of years

    away, a little out of grasp. Its a technology that

    doesnt ever seem to be covered in much depth in

    the mainstream, as it is always seen as intangible

    - something which is more science-fiction than science

    fact, and something that we wont need to worry

    about for a good couple of years yet...

    The signs are this perception is rapidly changing.

    A number of announcements and events in the past

    couple of months have been the catalyst for hydrogen

    technologies gaining increased prominence in the

    media, and a number of announcements have shown

    that hydrogen is beginning to permeate the publics

    imagination. It is a technology which we can no longer

    afford to ignore, as the signs are it is coming of age.

    Whilst the buildings and installations that presently

    feature fuel cells are few and far between, there

    are signs in the air that the technology is gaining

    momentum, and likely to become an increasingly

    common sight in the next couple of years.

    The bi-annual Grove Fuel Cell Symposium was held

    in London recently, widely regarded as the worlds

    premier fuel cell event, occupying the Queen Elizabeth

    II conference centre for three days. The event acted

    as a magnet for hydrogen experts, companies and

    organisations to descend on London for a few

    days and with any major event like this, there is

    bound to be an intensification of press releases,announcements and interest in the field. BAXI, the

    mainstream boiler manufacturer, were exhibiting a

    fuel cell combined heat and power (CHP) system, that

    could eventually scale down for smaller buildings, even

    domestic use.

    Support for hydrogen has just been bolstered by

    the European Union, who believe that hydrogen is

    part of the package in a sustainable energy future,

    and so on the 11th of October 2007, they launched a

    joint technology initiative, with over 1 billion funding

    including 470m from the EU coffers. This is bound

    to stimulate new research, innovative early-adopter

    buildings which integrate fuel cell technology and

    further development of the field.

    All the signs point to exciting times ahead, and we

    are seeing the first batch of designers integrating

    hydrogen into their homes.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    6/1362 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    PURE hydrogenOn the northernmost inhabited island of the

    British Isles is an unlikely combination of cuttingedge energy technology, and an unrivalled pool of

    expertise in hydrogen and fuel cells. Gavin Harper

    visits the PURE Energy Centre and talks to Ross Gazey.

    The Shetlands is too distant to be part of the national

    grid, so the bulk of its power is produced by an ageing

    oil-fired power station on the island. There are moves to

    increase the amount of energy supplied to the island by

    wind turbines and with the best wind resource in Europe,

    there is certainly potential to meet the needs of its 20,000

    inhabitants.

    Unfortunately, the island is also one of contrasts.

    Despite being the location of the North Sea oil industrys

    massive transhipment terminal at Sullum Voe, the island

    has the highest fuel prices in the United Kingdom because

    the oil must be shipped back to the UK for refining, before

    being shipped back for resale. This means that over 50%

    of islanders spend over 20% of their income on fuel.

    The lack of opportunities for graduates on the island

    prompted the community development organisation

    The Unst Partnership to look at investing in fuel cell

    technology as a way of putting Unst on the energy map,

    retaining skills on the island and diversifying revenue

    streams. It is clear that in a small community such as onUnst, no man is an island and the close links between

    PURE, and the community in which it operates, have

    benefits for everyone.

    Gazey likens the problems facing qualified young

    people in Unst to the brain drain facing Britain in the

    past couple of decades, where highly qualified graduates

    left the shores of blighty to the US. However, resourceful

    Gazey was determined for the same fate not to befall his

    home island. Looking for opportunities to develop clean

    energy opportunities for the future, he was instrumental in

    the founding days of what is known as the PURE Energy

    Centre.

    In addition to creating six full-time equivalent jobs

    on the island, the centre has also created wealth for its

    community, as a result of the visitors to the centre, who

    stay, spend money on the island and use the services

    and accommodation. Forget Live Earth, Unst was the

    first place in the world to hold a rock concert fuelled on

    renewable hydrogen!

    In a technology marketplace which is changing rapidly,

    and the state of the art develops day-by-day, PURE has

    built itself a formidable reputation in the European fuel

    cell industry in a relatively short time. As well as the

    technology improving, PURE believes that the economics

    of the technology are starting to make sense predicting

    that fuel cells will decrease in price by up to 50% in the

    next three years bringing the technology to a much

    wider marketplace.

    Energy centreThe PURE system is based on the premise that hydrogen

    should be produced from renewable sources. Presently

    this comes courtesy of a pair of 6kW Proven wind

    turbines, with plans to upgrade to two 15kW turbines

    when some design issues are rectified.

    Being a remote island in the middle of the North

    Sea, Unst receives more than its fair share of wind, so

    the availability from the turbines is very good indeed

    -averaging around 45-50%. Power from the turbines is

    used to heat the building by modified electric heaters,

    designed to utilise the supply from the wind turbines more

    effi ciently, and spare excess power is diverted into the

    electrolyser unit to produce hydrogen.

    The electrolyser and associated elec-trickery are

    housed inside the Hy-Pod. PURE has designed the

    system to be modular, housing all of the technology inside

    an easily transportable unit (see inset right). This opensup many opportunities for shipping the device and rolling

    out this solution around the world. Policy makers are

    beginning to sit up and notice, with many from the great

    and the good of UK and EU parliaments visiting PURE

    since its establishment.

    The hydrogen produced by the electrolyser is then

    stored for later use in standard K type cylinders. This

    is a cost-effective solution, and avoids the problems of

    ineffi ciency and energy-loss associated with having to

    compress the gas. PURE is able to do this because of its

    novel electrolyser arrangement, which operates at system

    pressure. The organisation then has a number of options.

    It can use the hydrogen in a 5kW Plug Power fuel cellwhich provides electricity on-site, mounted next to the

    HyPod. It has also been developing hydrogen cooking

    appliances, the first iteration being the PURE hydrogen

    barbecue, which often comes out for course attendees

    if the weather is fine. In addition, PURE is developing an

    internal combustion engine which will run on hydrogen

    allowing cheap, legacy technology to reap the benefits of

    clean hydrogen gas. The HyPod has also been equipped

    to recharge the hydride cylinders inside the PURE

    hydrogen vehicle, which Dr Daniel Aklil HAlluin commutes

    to work in!

    Hydrogen vehicleGazey told me that this is the first road-legal type-

    approved hydrogen vehicle in the UK. There is a hint of

    irony in its location, Gazey intimates, as on Unst, vehicles

    do not require an MOT!

    Whilst on many of the cars on the island, the tell-tale

    signs of bubbling paint betray the secrets of the tin-

    worm beneath, the ravages of the Shetland weather, and

    high salt content of the atmosphere do not show on the

    bodywork of Gazeys car, which he tells me, is ABS plastic

    covered with a green film - proudly alluding to the cars

    eco-credentials.

    Gazey is clear to differentiate the PURE vehicle from

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    7/1363 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    the crowd -the PURE hydrogen car is refueled with 100%

    green hydrogen. Many hydrogen vehicles are fuelled from

    hydrogen produced from fossil fuel. His vehicle employs PEM

    (proton exchange membrane) fuel cell technology to convert

    hydrogen into electrical energy, which can power the cars

    4.6kW DC electric motor. In the PURE car the hydrogen acts

    in symphony with the lead-acid batteries originally fitted to

    the G-Wiz car on which the PURE car was based, providing a

    hydrogen hybrid solution and giving the car extra range and

    acceleration.

    I am told that one of the challenges with hydrogen vehicle

    technology is designing a method for refueling, Gazey notes

    that the PURE system works at a relatively low pressure.

    However, he is quick to add that it does take six hours to fill

    the cars metal hydride cylinder (a kind of can filled with a

    hydrogen sponge which soaks up the gas). This is because

    the vehicle is refueled at low-pressure, which helps to

    circumvent some of the safety legislation that the mainstream

    car manufacturers are having to grapple with. It is clear from

    Gazeys description of the vehicle and refueling station that

    he has a passion for flair and innovation.

    So why Unst as the location for this novel enterprise?

    In addition to creating a novel and innovative vehicle,very much in keeping with the current zeitgeist for green

    technology sweeping the motoring industry, PURE has also

    created the sustainable infrastructure to allow refuelling of

    the hydrogen vehicle. All of this is surprising from one of

    Britains remotest islands.

    Road testI took the hydrogen car out for a spin and driving it was a

    surreal experience. It became apparent that once inside,

    anyone expecting more than a modicum of knee-room, was

    likely to be severely distressed. As my large frame climbed

    into the drivers seat, and flicked the red-switch retro-fitted

    by PURE, the Ballard fuel cell whirred into action behind me.

    The quiet hum of the cooling fans was a far cry from the roarof an internal combustion engine, and more akin to an engine

    fan fitted to many cars.

    Gazey reminded me that as the vehicle is gearless, there

    are only two pedals, loud and soft, with no clutch to worry

    about. To the right hand side of the steering wheel is a

    chunky rotary knob. R, N, E and F denote reverse, neutral,

    economy and fast. Ever the daredevil, I was urged to

    plump for fast. Gingerly pushing on the accelerator, the car

    surges forward. In all frankness, this was unexpected. Initial

    acceleration is quite brisk. Turning out of the car park the

    vehicles limitations become apparent as we disconcertingly

    lurch to the left but Gazey reassured me that with several

    hundred kilo of lead acid batteries and steel frame beneath

    us were not going to roll over. On the straight the pedal

    touches the floor, and the vehicle begins to get up to speed...

    surprisingly nippy!

    I was left with the feeling that it is amazing how such a

    bold technical achievement has been accomplished by such a

    small organisation and doubtless with pressure from declining

    oil reserves, vehicles like the PURE are likely to become a

    common sight on our streets in years to come.

    Gavin Harper

    For further info: PURE Energy Centre, Hagdale Industrial Estate,Unst, Shetland, ZE2 9DS

    TECHSPECOFTHEPUREHYDROGENPROPELLEDCA

    Vehicle body: 2 Door

    Dimensions: L 2.6m, W 1.3m, H 1.6m

    Rolling weight: 665kg

    Turning circle: 3.5 metres

    Top speed: 45mph/72kph

    Tyres: 13 low rolling resistance

    Drive: Rear-wheel drive

    Power: 8x6v lead acid batteries and a

    Ballard Nexa 1.2kW fuel cell

    Motor: 4.6kW, 48V DC motor

    Torque 50 lb ft @ 2000rpm

    Fuel cell: Proton exchange membrane

    Hydrogen storage: Metal hydride tanks

    Braking: Hydraulic regenerative

    Insurance group: 1

    The PURE hydrogen car being refuelled and (inset) one of the hydrogen fuestations that are dotted across the island.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    8/1364 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    Gavin Harper talks to Rupert Gammon,

    system architect of the Hydrogen

    and Renewables Integration Project

    (HARI) at West Beacon Farm in

    Leicestershire, the home of Tony

    Marmont.

    Tony Marmont is a name that has become

    synonymous with renewable energy in

    the UK. His West Beacon Farm has

    become one of the great examples of

    how renewable energies can integratewith the rural home.The hydrogen and

    renewables integration project at his farm,

    takes Tony Marmonts existing renewable

    energy infrastructure and examines how

    renewables could potentially integrate with

    hydrogen infrastructure in the future.

    The existing system consisted of a

    mixed basket of renewables, including two

    25kW Carter wind turbines a total installed

    capacity of 13kWp of photovoltaics and

    two micro-hydroelectric turbines with a

    combined output in the region of 3kW.

    The houses central heating needs aremet by a 10kW thermal heat pump,

    circulating water from a coil at the bottom

    of an artificial lake and a 15kW electrical,

    38kW thermal Totem combined heat and

    power unit that currently runs on liquified

    petroleum gas, as well as an array of

    evacuated tube solar thermal collectors

    for hot water.

    However, there is still work to be done.

    Speaking to Dr Gammon of Bryte Energy

    who has been responsible for much of

    the design and implementation of the

    project, there are still un-resolved issues

    with the architecture of the systems

    power electronics and it is constantly

    evolving. For instance, the system has now

    transitioned from a high voltage (600V)

    bus concept shown in the system diagram

    (right), to a lower voltage of 120V for the

    main distribution system.

    Batteries are used to provide short-

    term energy storage. The team did

    some experimentation with advanced

    batteries, however, these have now been

    disconnected in favour of traditional

    lead-acid batteries which have proven to

    be a more robust solution and a simpler

    technology.

    The most recent refinement to the

    system takes the renewable electricity

    produced by the solar arrays, micro hydro

    turbines and wind turbines, and converts

    any overcapacity that the batteries

    cannot store into hydrogen. It does this

    by electrolysis feeding spare power

    into a 36kW electrolyser, which, in turn,

    produces hydrogen at 25 bar which is

    then compressed and stored in cylinders,

    providing a measure of long-term energy

    storage, which complements the shorter

    term storage capability of the lead acidbatteries.

    So now when additional power is

    required on dull and windless days, a Plug

    Power 5kW fuel cell takes the hydrogen

    and turns it into electricity to augment

    any power being produced from the

    renewables. Interestingly, the stored

    hydrogen can also be used to meet some

    of the on-site transport energy needs.

    More on that later.

    Much has been learnt about the

    practical implementation of hydrogentechnologies, and incremental

    improvements have been made during the

    life of the installation. Pipework has been

    insulated over time to reduce thermal

    losses, with plans to further insulate

    the electrolyser. Furthermore, a water-

    conservation strategy has been adopted,

    whereby water, generated as a waste

    product from the fuel cell, is recirculated

    back to the electrolyser for production of

    fresh hydrogen ensuring it is not wasted.

    There has also been extensive research

    and work needed to enable the integration

    of the 5kW Plug Power fuel cell with

    the other renewable power system.

    Regardless of the hurdles Gammon

    remains confident that the technology

    underpinning the fuel cell concept is

    fundamentally reliable and sound. Most

    of the problems have been more as

    a result of system integration. For

    example, after experiencing problems with

    controlling the fuel cell, it was decided to

    move the fuel cell closer to the control

    electronics, as the line was experiencing

    some attenuation. There have also been

    a few teething troubles and modifications

    needed to the software controlling thefuel cell. Dr Gammon is clear, that whilst

    the basic technology is sound, the jury is

    still out on the full capabilities of the fuel

    cell.

    A significant amount of energy is

    produced by the installation at Beacon

    Farm. According to Tony Marmont, the

    energy generated on-site since the mid-

    eighties averages 50MWh per annum.

    Before the HARI project, 30MWh, on

    average, was used on site each year and

    the surplus 20MWh was exported to the

    grid. Now the spare capacity is divertedinto hydrogen production, however,

    whenever energy is converted from one

    form to another, some is invariably lost

    as heat. Tony Marmont estimates that

    the round-trip effi ciency of converting

    Hydrogen integrationat West Beacon Farm

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    9/1365 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    electricity to hydrogen, then back toelectricity, is around 30% - with 70% being

    lost as a result of ineffi ciency.

    Since the system has been operational,

    3.6MWh equivalent of hydrogen has

    been generated and stored onsite, whilst

    around 6MWh was lost as leaks during the

    bedding in process, but this issue is now

    resolved. This resulted in West Beacon

    Farm temporarily being a net importer of

    green energy. However, in the future, the

    plan is for the farm to be able to operate

    independently, with no need to buy from

    or sell to the grid.

    From storage to transportOriginally, there were plans to develop a

    fuel cell range extender for an electric car.

    However, these plans have been shelved

    in favour of developing a dual-fuel (petrol

    and hydrogen) car.

    Whilst internal combustion engines are

    not the most effi cient technology, they

    are very well understood, and this feature

    has made them appealing for the first

    wave of hydrogen vehicle development.

    Indeed, BMW has decided to stick with

    internal combustion engine technology

    for its Hydrogen 7. The plans are to

    employ compressed hydrogen stored in

    a pressurised tank the simplest option

    for storing the hydrogen. There are other

    methods under exploration

    Plans are afoot at the farm to modify

    a Toyota Prius to work as a dual fuel

    vehicle. Asking why it was decided to keep

    the legacy option of petrol, Gammonreplies dual fuel never gets stranded

    anywhere. If anything, this highlights

    how the infrastructure needed to support

    hydrogen transportation will need to be

    developed significantly for the technology

    to become a practical option for the

    average motorist.

    Lessons learntThe work conducted to date is showing

    that whilst there is a need for continued

    investment and development, practical

    hydrogen-based solutions are not too far

    away. Asking about the lessons learnedfrom the project, Gammon replies: The

    project has certainly shown us lots of

    small problems, but the big picture is that

    it has helped us to understand how the

    concept of a hydrogen economy really

    will work and it strongly underlines the

    fact that it is not about electricity storage,

    there are other ways of doing that but

    its about hydrogen as a grid balancing

    mechanism which also produces transport

    fuel. Its not about storage, its about

    transferring surplus electricity to use as a

    transport fuel.

    Gavin HarperFurther Information:

    WWW.BEACONENERGY.CO.UK/PDFS/WESTBEACON-

    FARM _ 050208.PDF

    Gammon, R., Roy, A., Barton, J. & Little, M.,(2006) Hydrogen and Renewables Integration,CREST, Loughborough UniversityWWW.BRYTE-ENERGY.COM

    All images and table courtesy of Dr RupertGammon

    Table 1. Summary of all renewable energy systems at West Beacon Farm.

    System Manufacturer/Supplier/ Model Designation Rated Performance Cost (in )(indicative)

    Electrolyser Hydrogenics (formerly Vandenborre) 8 Nm 3/hour of H2, 34kW, 2.5 MPa (25 bar) rated 143,000

    Fuel cell (1) Intelligent Energy, CHP Unit 2 kW (el), 2kW (th), 24 VDC 25,000

    Fuel cell (2) Plug Power GenCore, supplied by SiGen Ltd 5 kW (el), 48 V DC 20,000

    H2 Compressor Hydro-Pac supplied by BOC 11 Nm3

    /hour, 3.75 kW, 8:1 compression ratio 59,000H

    2Storage Supplied by BOC 48 cylinders, each 0.475 m3, 13.7MPa (137 bar) max pressure,

    2856 Nm3 total H2

    capacity122,000

    Sub total cost o f fuel ce ll system 369,000

    Wind turbines Carter wind turbines 2 x 25kW two bladed stall-regulated, pitch over-speed 50,000

    Solar PV BP 13kW total, mixed polycrystalline and monocrystalline 60,000

    Hydro-electric Two systems installed by Dulas 850W cross-flow turbine with 2m head2.2kW Turgo turbine with 25m head

    67,000

    Integrationsystem

    Control techniques and bespoke convertersfrom Loughborough University

    Various 49,000

    All systems total cost 595,000

    West Beacon Farm hydrogen project:above: the house behind the hydrogen shedbelow left : the electrolyser that makes hydrogeexcess renewable energybelow right: the Plug Power fuel cell

    bottom: the hydrogen storage tanks.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    10/1366 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    an interview with Allan Jones

    Allan Jones, MBE was the mastermind behind the UKs first

    fuel cell CHP venture in Woking, and is now Chief Executive

    Offi cer of the London Climate Change Agency. Gavin Harper

    talked to Jones about fuel cells and private wire networks,

    and about their future role in our built environment...

    Ibegan by asking Jones why he had embarked on the idea of

    combining fuel cell technology with private wire (local supply)

    networks. Was it more for technical or regulatory reasons,

    and what advantages did such networks have over the national

    grid? The fuel cell CHP was embedded into an existing private

    wire network at Woking Park and the fuel cell CHP was used

    as a black start generator (as well as a CHP) to enable the

    decentralised energy system at Woking Park to operate in island

    generation mode in the event of a failure of the national grid.

    This enabled the three swimming pools and the leisure centre to

    continue in operation whilst everywhere else around them could

    be in darkness. Island generation is a key attribute of fuel cell

    CHP since they can switch from grid connect to island operation

    in 0.5 milli seconds. Although Woking has other island generation

    systems, this is very fast. For example, computers crash without

    power supply at 8 milli seconds so would not even see a power

    cut with a fuel cell driven island generation system. This is why

    big banks and credit card companies use fuel cells in the USA.

    The Woking Park system actually operated in island generation

    mode due to power cuts in the national grid several times whilst

    I was at Woking. The Woking Park decentralised energy system

    comprises other larger CHP trigeneration systems and solar

    photovoltaics. The heat from the fuel cell CHP was used for

    supplying into both the district heating and cooling (via heat fired

    absorption chillers) systems.

    Electricity, heat and cooling was required for the Woking

    Park site and supplying electricity on private wire networks atretail (though competitive) prices dramatically increased the

    economics of the project by 400% over supplying electricity into

    the national grid at very low wholesale prices. The decentralised

    energy system at Woking Park met all of the electricity, heat and

    cooling requirements of the site as well as being a net exporter

    of surplus power which was supplied to other Woking sites at

    competitive retail prices under the exempt licensing regime in

    the UK, paying only a distribution charge to the local public wires

    distribution network operator, ie., no grid transmission charges,

    losses or government levies.

    There were financial benefits because of the economics of

    operating private wire networks under the exempt licensing

    regime. I implemented 80 (yes eighty) decentralised energysystems on private wire networks at Woking, which not only

    supplied these individual sites but also traded their electricity

    together (imports/exports) between sites over the local public

    wires distribution network without the need to sell or buy

    electricity from the national grid.

    I then asked whether he was disappointed with the current

    regulatory framework for UK energy supplies, and what he

    would change? The current regulatory framework does not

    really inhibit supply on private wire networks to non domestic

    customers since up to 100MW can be generated, distributed

    and supplied on each private wire network. However, this is

    limited to only 1MW for domestic customers on each private wire

    What are ...?

    Private wire networks are a network of supply wires within anorganisations buildings for distributing electricity aroundthe organisation.

    Public wire networks are a network of wires linking differentbuildings and organisations. This includes the national grid.

    Working towards a hydrogen future

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    11/1367 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    network with the export over public wires limited to 2.5MW in

    aggregate. This is unfair on domestic customers, since cheaper

    electricity can be supplied to domestic customers on private wire

    networks than from the grid, and inhibits the ability to provide

    decentralised energy to mixed development, which in London is

    very large scale, whereas in Woking they never came up against

    this barrier. In its Energy White Paper the government promised

    to look into the regulatory barriers to decentralised energy.

    So based on that, how do you believe our energy markets

    might adapt to a future hydrogen economy and how might the

    current regulatory framework change or adapt? The current

    regulatory framework only really applies to electricity and gas.

    It does not concern itself with heat, heat to cool, renewable

    gases and liquid fuels (both rich in hydrogen) or hydrogen.

    However, if the regulatory barriers to decentralised energy are

    removed, this would have the effect of not only stimulating low

    and zero carbon technologies and infrastructure, it would also

    provide an accelerated pathway to renewable hydrogen. For

    example, renewable gases and liquid fuels derived from waste

    and biomass (largest renewable energy resource in London) can

    provide todays renewable energy for buildings (via CHP) and

    transport, and tomorrows renewable hydrogen for buildings (via

    CHP) and transport, since biogas (derived from organic waste

    and biomass, via anaerobic digestion) and syngas (town gas) and

    synthetic liquid fuels (derived from non organic or mixed waste

    via gasification or pyrolysis) are all hydrogen rich fuels.

    But to what extent do you believe that fuel cells can act as

    an enabling technology for decentralised energy? Fuel cells

    will not act as an enabling technology for decentralised energy

    but decentralised energy will act as enabling technology for

    fuel cells since the value of electricity would be increased which

    would significantly improve the economics of fuel cells and bring

    forward the utilisation of fuel cells.

    So what give you the most hope for the future? Londontaking the lead in tackling climate change on a world city-wide

    stage and the London Climate Change Agencys role in that.

    Which leads us on to the gargantuan challenge Jones current

    faces as Chief Executive Offi cer of the London Climate Change

    Agency (LCCA), a post which he has now held since 2004. The

    LCCA is the Mayors direct-delivery agency which has already se

    in motion projects, including carbon accounting, Better Buildings

    Partnership a project to enable and accelerate the uptake of

    energy effi ciency retrofits in Londons commercial offi ces under

    the Green Organisations Programme, study on the implications

    for CO2

    emissions of housing growth in London and prototyping

    a deep service model for domestic energy effi ciency and micro

    generation, which is now being rolled out under the Green HomeProgramme, renewable energy projects at the London Transpor

    Museum, Palestra and City Hall, fuel cell CHP trigeneration study

    at Palestra (which is currently being procured), renewable gases

    and liquid fuels from waste and biomass project currently under

    way with London Remade and the London ESCO a joint ventur

    Energy Services Company with EDF Energy established to desig

    finance, build and operate decentralised energy systems.

    This is no small task, with urban centres such as London

    possessing an extremely high energy density. London uses the

    same amount of energy in a year as Greece or Portugal, so how

    does Jones see us meeting this demand sustainably, and will

    hydrogen help us in meeting this aim? The answer to this is

    in the Mayors Climate Change Action Plan. 75% of Londons

    CO2

    emissions is due to centralised energy supply. This is not

    normally shown in this way since emissions are normally smeare

    across end use (ie., housing, commercial, industrial, etc). Howeve

    it is important to identify the real cause of climate change since

    this is how emissions can be reduced at large scale and quickly.

    The Action Plan sets a target of taking 25% of Londons energy

    supply of reliance on centralised energy by 2025 and by more

    than 50% by 2050. This, taken together with energy effi ciency

    and the greening up of the remnants of centralised energy

    The now famous Woking combined heat and power plant with (inset) the fuelcell building set alongside the public swimmimg baths.

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    12/1368 GreenBuildingmagazine - Spring08

    with large scale renewables will achieve a 60% reduction in CO2

    emissions, not by 2050, but by 2025. Hydrogen will play a role in

    this.

    During the dash for gas Britain transitioned a significant

    chunk of its centralised energy generating capacity to natural

    gas. The fuel cells being used in Woking and other projects,

    reform hydrogen from natural gas. Some people hold concerns

    that, in the future, this will make Britain dependent on other

    countries for its energy. Jones was quick to allay fears about

    natural gas supply. With the UKs natural gas supplies rapidly

    dwindling, how does Jones see us moving beyond reformation

    of natural gas for hydrogen, and if so how does he foresee us

    producing hydrogen on the scale required? The UKs natural gas

    supplies may be dwindling but the UK has taken action on this by

    connecting Norwegian gas to the UK by pipeline and establishing

    a liquefied natural gas (LNG) infrastructure in the UK. LNG has

    a very high energy density so very large amounts of gas can be

    transported in a very small space. The UK has established LNG

    terminals in the UK (I used LNG in Woking), enabling LNG to be

    transported by tanker from such places as Indonesia, Trinidad

    and elsewhere. The UK does not actually use any Siberian gasand probably has no need to. Therefore, natural gas will be

    around for some time yet and probably longer if it is used for

    CHP and notCCGT (combined cycle gas turbine)power stations.

    Therefore, hydrogen can continue to be reformed from natural

    gas for sometime yet but London is working on a renewable

    hydrogen energy infrastructure to replace the natural gas

    infrastructure.

    Jones clearly has a record of practical implementation of

    fuel cell projects and could well be the most qualified person

    in the UK to crystal ball gaze and see the road ahead for

    hydrogen in the UK. I asked him to put his neck on the line and

    give us some sort of timescale. Hydrogen is 75% of the known

    universe so is in pretty much everything, including us. Hydrogenwill be transported by natural gas (initially), biogas, syngas or

    synthetic liquid fuels (longer term). This will be supplemented

    by electrolysing renewable electricity locally but I do not see

    this as a major source. Other sources of hydrogen also have

    potential, such as growing hydrogen from microbes or a direct

    photosynthesis process. Therefore, hydrogen will be transported

    as part of a fuel by pipeline (gases) or by tanker (liquids).

    There is no need to transport pure hydrogen (which would be

    expensive, if not impractical) since hydrogen is only needed at

    the point of supply at the stationary or transport fuel cell where

    it can be reformed in situ at the fuel cell CHP or filling station for

    fuel cell transportation. This could be technically feasible by 2025

    and politically feasible by the same date, if the regulatory barriers

    to decentralised energy were removed.

    The incumbent government appears to have a resurgent

    interest in nuclear power after several decades and seems

    poised to guide us into a nuclear future, whilst other voices,

    such as Centre for Alternative Technologys ZeroCarbonBritain1

    report, dissent from this view and see the UK becoming a

    nuclear free nation. The hydrogen economy has voices on both

    sides of the fence. Some see a hydrogen future enabled by

    nuclear installations electrolysing water to produce hydrogen,

    whilst others believe that hydrogen is the key to enabling

    decentralised technologies. But how does Jones feel about the

    view put forward by some promoters of a nuclear/hydrogen

    future, and whether nuclear power has a role to play in his

    vision of the hydrogen economy. No. Nuclear power stations

    are very ineffi cient, quite apart from the very significant cost,

    environmental, disposal, long term storage and political issues.

    According to the Digest of UK Energy Statistics (DUKES)

    published by BERR (formerly the DTI), nuclear power stations

    are only 38% effi cient across the year as a whole. Two thirds of

    its energy is wasted into the atmosphere through cooling towers

    and losses in the grid and a further 9% of electricity is lost in the

    grid transmission and distribution systems (Ofgem figures). This

    wasted thermal and electrical energy has to be replaced by fossil

    fuel energy to heat buildings, steam for industry and losses in

    the grid. UK power stations use 50% of the UKs water resources

    and in a declining water resource world, with climate change, this

    is just not sustainable and not conducive to what we are looking

    for in a renewable hydrogen energy economy.

    Nuclear power stations and so called carbon capture and

    sequestered coal fired power stations are bear traps. Generating

    hydrogen from power stations using electrolysis is technically

    feasible but not sustainable for the reasons as above, quiteapart from consuming even more water, as well as the expense

    and impracticability of transporting hydrogen long distances

    from power stations. In other words hydrogen goes with low and

    zero carbon decentralised energy and not with unsustainable

    centralised energy.

    Ken Livingstone is quoted as saying, What Allan Jones has

    achieved in Woking is nothing short of revolutionary and I

    am delighted that he has agreed to take up the challenge of

    replicating what he achieved in one borough on Londons world-

    city sized stage.

    I asked Jones how he planned to make London the green

    capital of Europe and he commented that the plan, as set outin the Mayors Climate Change Action Plan, concerns tackling

    emissions in 7 sectors:

    l existing homes

    l existing commercial and municipal activity

    l new build and development

    l energy supply

    l ground transport

    l aviation

    l Mayoral Group showing by doing.

    Of these, energy supply is by far the largest emitter, causing

    emissions of 35 million tonnes pa, 75% of Londons emissions.

    This is set to increase by 15% by 2025 if no action is taken.

    In closing our interview, Jones says, The Mayors ambition is

    not just for London to become the green capital of Europe but

    for London to lead the fight against climate change on a world

    stage. That is why the C40, bringing together 40 of the worlds

    largest cities, and the partnership with the Clinton Foundation

    has been established. 75% of the worlds CO2

    emissions comes

    from cities. Cities are most at risk from climate change and cities

    are best placed to tackle climate change. Cities can do this and

    do not need permission from federal governments to do so.

    Gavin Harper

    1. WWW.ZEROCARBONBRITAIN.COM

  • 8/14/2019 Green Building Magazine - Hydrogen Supplement - Spring 08

    13/13

    THEATREISHYDROGENFUELCELLPOWERED

    The Arcola Theatre is a good example of why Londons culturalsector is so dynamic and successful. Arcola is leading the theatreindustry in developing this premiere sustainable production and Iknow that many other theatres are now keen to follow. The Living

    Unknown Soldier is unique in that it is the worlds first productionto be powered by a fuel cell, supplied and sponsored by the LondonHydrogen Partnership. Every individual, every business, every shop,and every theatre has a part to play in tackling climate changeand this lead by Arcola Theatre is just what we need said KenLivingstone, Mayor of London

    Londons Arcola Theatre, one of the UKs leading independentvenues, has installed a hydrogen fuel cell to power its caf/bar andselected main house shows. The fuel cell operates almost silently,producing nothing but electricity and clean water. The 5kW fuel cellsystem takes pride of place in the foyer of the theatre, accompaniedby displays describing the benefits and challenges posed by thistechnology. The prominent location of the fuel cell, and the challengeof relying entirely upon it, provides both a powerful educational tooland a source of motivation for reducing energy use.

    The first show to be powered by the fuel cell, The Living UnknownSoldier, produced by Strawberry Vale, may well be Londonspremier ecologically sustainable show. The environmental impactof all aspects of the production has been minimised, including setconstruction, marketing, company travel and show lighting. Theproductions environmental footprint will be evaluated by GlobalAction Plan and the lessons learned published for the benefit of otherpractitioners.

    The lighting for the show has a peak power consumption of 4.5kW,up to 60% less than comparable lighting installations. This is madepossible through extensive use of LED lighting and the careful use ofhigh effi ciency tungsten lamps.

    In addition Arcolas bar/caf has been upgraded to an eco-bar,serving organic and fair-trade refreshments, illuminated by a low

    energy LED lighting system. The lighting for the entire caf/bar nowconsumes under 500 watts, a saving of 60%, with the added benefitof providing near infinite flexibility in light level and colour forperfect daytime operation as well as for caf/bar performances.

    This project is part of Arcola Theatres extensive sustainability-relatedactivities - under the banner of Arcola Energy. It is spearheaded byDr Ben Todd, the theatres executive director, who also works as aconsultant in the fuel cell industry. He said: The arts have a crucialrole to play in elucidating and motivating the changes in lifestylenecessary to deliver an equitable future for all humankind. ThroughArcola Energy, Arcola Theatre is demonstrating that bold changes canbe made and that making them offers exciting opportunities for newcreative partnerships.

    Todd also noted that When we launched Arcola Energy in July 2007we planned to install renewable technologies within 12 months, thisis unlikely to be possible due to restrictions on what we can do asa leaseholder and the protracted business of securing the freeholdfor our premises a problem faced by many organisations. Theinstallation of the fuel cell and our present emphasis on greeningour operations are examples of what can be done now, whilstinfrastructure projects are under development.

    WWW.ARCOLAENERGY.COM

    HYDROGENHOMESFOR SCOTLAND

    Hjaltland Housing Association, along with the PURE Energy Centreand Fuel Cells Scotland, is to build the UKs first hydrogen homes,unplugged from the grid, and storing power generated onsite in theform of hydrogen, which can then be converted to heat and energy b

    a solid-oxide fuel cell, with combined electrical and thermal effi cienof 90%.

    The houses are going to be powered by micro CHP fuel cell systemsdeveloped by Fuel Cells Scotland. Gavin Harper caught up with FuelCells Scotland at the H207 conference earlier this year in Aberdeenwhere they were exhibiting their novel solid-oxide fuel cell. By thetime it reached the conference, the demonstration model had beenoperating for 1500 hours. It was a first in that the cell is a uniqueseal-less design. By eliminating the seals from the fuel cells, thephysical dimensions can be shrunk, making a higher energy-densitycell, suitable for small applications like domestic micro-CHP. The fuecell solution will also offer some advantages over the Stirling enginebased micro-CHP units currently being installed in some homes, inthat they have no moving parts.

    The fuel cells have been developed by Dr TG Lindsay of Fuel CellsScotland whose work on solid oxide fuel cell stacks is the culminatioof 12 years of research and development. The installation is beingsupported by the Scottish Executive Renewable Hydrogen and FuelCell Scheme, and the applications side will be managed by PUREEnergy Centre.

    Once the fuel cell has been installed, the second phase of the scheminvolves developing a renewable-sourced hydrogen production andstorage infrastructure around the houses. Initially, the hydrogen wilbe used to meet the homes heat and power needs, but the projecthopes to eventually develop to the point of producing hydrogen forfuelling a pair of hydrogen cars for the houses.

    These houses have the potential to be a blueprint for future zero-carbon housing, as with renewably-sourced hydrogen, the only outpfrom the fuel cells will be pure water. Whilst at the moment, thetechnology is expensive, and the project is made possible by grant-funding, as the technology develops its economic-competitiveness, icould provide a clean energy-lifeline for isolated communities.

    Dr Daniel Aklil DHalluin of the PURE Energy Centre said, 40% ofthe worldwide population live with no access to electricity and heatThe CHP scheme will provide these populations with such access. Itwill also provide communities around the world with access to cleanhydrogen fuel to power clean vehicles.

    Links:

    WWW.PURE.SHETLAND.CO.UK/HTML/INDEX.HTML

    WWW.HJALTLAND.ORG.UK

    WWW.FUELCELLS-SCOTLAND.COM