Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    1/27

    !"# %&'&%(

     !" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /"0$&1 '$2$&3 

    "##"$%& '()*& +%,','#(%- !" 

    #-.)$% . /%-'). & '()*

    #$ &'()()#$ *#+ , -+)( #* .'+()#+,+)

    (# (/' 0$)('1 2(,('2 .#0+( #* ,&&',32

     *#+ (/' *'1'+,3 .)+.0)(

    )*+,- -.* /0, 1!+/,2 3/4/,3 43 45+613 61*+4,

    0#(.$0 1*  2 %--'$$'& 3-* 245676849 :;

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    2/27

     71,3/+.! 8*,3,!/,2

    ,;< )=>?@AB;C .DC =E FGHI& FH 9*5*)* FJF ;8 ?;V"&>@=C&S FH 9*5*)*FJTUNV& AMDORWAMB LD=X>RC@=B@NXYKZ&S FH 9*5*)*FJF* ,;< .DC K>

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    3/27

     /4)9, .- 6.!/,!/3

    +NB<

    5CNC

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    4/27

    '2

    )NK

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    5/27

     

    " $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /"0$&1 '$2$&3

    (=* Fe\eFJ

    "##"$%& '()*& +%,','#(%- 

    !" 

    #-.)$% . /%-'). & '()*

    #$ &'()()#$ *#+ , -+)( #* .'+()#+,+)

    (# (/' 0$)('1 2(,('2 .#0+( #* ,&&',32

     *#+ (/' *'1'+,3 .)+.0)(

    )*+,- -.* /0, 1!+/,2 3/4/,3 43 45+613 61*+4,

    ,;AK ^@A@=[AW?@AB;C >@=C*S FH 9*5*)*

    FJTUNV* 6=@QK =E NRC;=@K;A> AMDORW

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    6/27

    T

    CA[AC?*S  *;6?8 &>X5Z

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    7/27

    c

    BA[ADgOAQ< D=P^=?K& ^NMQ @=^^

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    8/27

    e

    K?X^=OK AM N >N@CADRON@ L>@=B@NXXAMB ONMBRNB

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    9/27

    f

    DONKK

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    10/27

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    11/27

    H

    BNMAa

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    12/27

    d

     .K @

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    13/27

    G

    C;< WAK>RCN@CA@AMDA>NOO? WAKNB@

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    14/27

    FJ

    8AMNOO?& C;< D=R@C =E N>>

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    15/27

    FF

     .DD=@WAMBO?& C;AK )=R@CbK AMCG"H

    %(IJKL 2";C !"> -"=;DB"C; 6"@E=GM:> 8=">;D>G"H -"=*;C@"HF;H>NC 2;DBA=GHM 6"F;

     2N@A=RK )=>?@AB;C .DC >@=[AKA=MK XNQ< DO?@AB;C AM N LD=X>RC@=B@NX&S

     P;AD; AK W

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    16/27

    FT

    ^@N@?* 5* TT* .MW >

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    17/27

    Fc

    +

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    18/27

    Fe

    D=X>RC

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    19/27

    Ff

    1=C; N@< M

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    20/27

    FI

    FH\FG& 6>O?AMB 5

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    21/27

    FH

    >@=>

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    22/27

    Fd

    IJT\IJf UGC; )A@*V& D

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    23/27

    FG

    CA[< PNK C= XNQ< C;< .MW@=AW >ONCE=@X X=@< NCC@NDCA[<C= 3N[N\EORNCA\^O< PAC; C;< 3N[N  B5=8@49E* 5* FH& ?>B9=l FH9*5*)* FJHUFV UAWR@>=K< NMW D;N@NDC

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    24/27

    TJ

    D=X>RC@=B@NXX

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    25/27

    TF

    KA=M AM C;< CP= W

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    26/27

    TT

    ^* +

  • 8/9/2019 Goog v Oracle, Solicitor General Brief Copy

    27/27

    Tc

    WRC@=B@NX* -NC;