Upload
louis-e-grivetti
View
217
Download
4
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, A Guide for Planning Food Service in Child Care Centers, FNS #64, Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1971.
U.S. Dept. of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Child Development, Child Development-Day Care; 2. Serving In-
fants; 5. Staff Training; 6. Health Services, Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1971.
Wright, C. M., Lally, J. R. and Dibble, M. V., Prenatal-postnatal Intervention: A Description and Discussion of Preliminary Findings of a Home Visit Program
Supplying Cognitive, Nutritional and Health Information to Disadvantaged Homes. Paper presented to the American Psychological Association Meeting, Miami Beach, 1970 (mimeo, Syracuse University Family Research Center, 100 Walnut Place, Syracuse, NY 13210).
FOOD HABIT RESEARCH: A REVIEW OF APPROACHES AND METHODS
Louis E. Grivetti and Rose Marie Pangborn
Seven major approaches have been used in food habit reseach. The advantages and limitations of each are outlined and evaluated.
As emphasized by Pyke (1), people are primarily concerned with eating food, not with ingesting nutrients. Despite the influence of culture on dietary habits, conventional training in the nutritional ~ciences has usually centered on biochemistry and physiology. Therefore, most nutrition educators are dependent on literature sources on cultural studies in order to apply their clinical and labo-' ratory studies in the field. Nutritionists who desire current and comprehensive information on food habits find that field investigators have used many different approaches, methods, and interpretations. Although recent publications have attempted to systematize the vast literature on food habits (2-4), the different approaches used to collect these data rarely have been considered. Accordingly, the following review outlines and evaluates the basic approaches used by food habit researchers in the biological, behavorial, medical, and social sciences.
Environmentalism. The environmentalist approach seeks causal relationships between culture, health, and the environment. Those supporting this view claim that dietary patterns are determined by environmental factors. The roots of this approach may be traced to Hippocrates of Cos (5th century B.C.) who argued that climate imposed limits on health and dietary patterns (5). Environmentalism 'continues to flourish in the 20th century as exemplified by Huntington (6, 7) and Semple (8, 9) who described contemporary food habits and dietary patterns in antiquity.
Cnltural Ecology. Cultural ecologists recognize that man and the environment
THE AUTHORS are, respectively, Doctoral Candidate, Department of Geography, and Professor, Department of Food Science and Technology, University of California, Davis, CA 95616.
204 I Journal of NUTRITION EDUCATION
exert pressures on each other and seek to identify the balanced relationships between man and his environment. For example, Thompson (10) effectively demonstrated that the dietary patterns of Fiji Islanders, based on complex intraisland trade networks, developed from a cultural response to a limited food supply. On the other hand, Steward (11) argued that food availability and technology predicate the evolution of social structure as re\'ealed in his studies on Shoshone an Indians. More recently, Lee (12, 13) studied the food resources of !Kung Bushmen of the Kalahari Desert and concluded that these preliterate hunters do not live under conditions of feast-orfamine as believed previously. Working in the highlands of New Guinea, Vayda et al. (14) and Rappaport (15, 16) developed the thesis that physiological stress, caused by cultural and environmental factors, lead some societies to develop elaborate rituals to obtain highprotein foods.
Regionalism. In contrast to the environmental and ecological themes that focus on societies in limited areas, some researchers have taken a regional approach to culture and food. Many have outlined world·wide trends in crop and food production and dietary sele,ction (17-22). Others take a more limited regional view of diet as seen in May's studies on malnutrition in selected nations of Asia and the Middle East (23), Europe (24, 25), Africa (26, 27, 28), and Mexico and Central America (29).
Culture-History. When more complete information on food habits is desired, the culture-history approach has been used, intercomparing data from archaeology, linguistics, history, and oral tradition (30). Many social scientists have considered the influence of religion on dietary practices (31-34), while
others-especially Simoons (35)-use historical and archaeological data in their analyses of dietary prohibitions.
The culture-history approach has been particularly effective in tracing the origin and distribution of dietary traits. Recent work by Jeffreys (36, 37) and Sauer (38) suggests that maize (Zea mays L.) was introduced into Africa and Europe long before the Spanish conquest of the Americas. Their hypothesis contrasts sharply with the traditional view that maize was introduced to the Old World early in the 16th century-an event that triggered its rapid acceptance in Spain, Italy, Turkey, and Egypt with the subsequent emergence of pellagra along the Mediterranean.
Sometimes culture-history and cultural ecology approaches are combined. Working in West Africa, Vermeer (39,40) investigated the links between culture, environment, and health in his studies on geophagia (earth-eating). Miracle (41) considered the development of indigenous agriculture, imported foods, and dietary patterns in the Congo Basin. Other examples include those by Bennett (42) and Nietschmann (43) on food habits of isolated Indian societies in Central America.
Functionalism. Functionalism attempts to explain food habits as satisfying social needs. In the functional view, food is symbolic of human relationships, and the daily production, processing, and exchange of consumables reinforces and stabilizes society. Richards (44, 45), an early functionalist, observed that the food quest was bound intimately to several non-nutritive cultural and economic food uses-a finding that frequently has been ignored.
In recent years, many programs of dietary improvement have failed to achieve expected results because the nonnutritivc,
VOL. 5, NO.3, JULY-SEPT., 1973
functional roles served by food have not been considered (46-53). Concern with food accepta!bility has led to an increase in studies using the functional approach. Jerome (54) and Wilson (55), nutritionists with training in anthropology, studied the food habits and nutritional status of U.S. black and Malay fishing societies, respectively. Sanjur and coworkers (56, 57) have combined their nutritional expertise with sociological techniques in studies on infant nutrition in Mexico and New York City.
The functional approach may reveal the logic behind dietary traditions which outsiders may view as wasteful. For example, Lea (58) observed the intriguing anomaly of severe undernutrition in a region of surplus harvests in New Guinea. Nearly half of the food produced was stored in anticipation of hostile exchanges, where enemies presented ever-increasing gifts of food to each other until one was incapable of exceeding the last gift and the argument was settled. Paradoxically, the winner and his family are left with no food reserves and suffer the nutritional consequences.
Functionalism and culture~history
sometimes are combined, as in the identification of famine foods and analysis of cultural behavior during dietary stress (59-63). These and related efforts offer a complementary perspective to the researoh by Keys et al. (64) on the physiological components of hunger and starvation.
Quantitative Approaches. Critical of descriptive methodologies used by some field researchers, others have stressed the importance of quantitative methods. For example, Gould (65) used the analytical framework of Game Theory to study traditional methods of crop production and marketing practices in West Africa. In their article on nutritional problems in Mexico, Chasey et al. (66) urged the more effective use of cross-cultural scaling techniques.
The current trend towards quantification may be viewed as a logical extension of research on cultural behavior and food haJbits conducted by Maslow (67) and Lewin (68). A further impetus was provided by the Committee on Food Habits, created in the United States during World War II (69), particularly in the area of psychomedical food acceptance behavior (70-75).
More recently, Sohutz et al. (76) and Ortega (77) have used the technique of multidimensional scaling to evaluate food selection under varying social situations. Further studies compared consumer at-
VOL. 5, NO.3, JULY-SEPT., 1973
titudes towards food in four regions of the United States (78). It is anticipated that multidimensional scaling may provide a better understanding of food selection in industrialized societies; when minor problems of matrix design and interview structure have been resolved, this technique may also be useful in cross-cultural food habit studies.
Sophisticated methods of computer simulation and systems analysis also are used by food habit investigators. Devanney (79) outlined an approach that predicts maximum dietary aoceptance with highest nutritional value. As an outgrowth of his research, Devanney argues that unconventional methods of protein production, e.g., fish protein concentrate, are not likely to be important in dietary improvement because the initial expenses associated with implementation cannot be absorbed by the lesser developed nations.
Clinical Approaches. Some medical and nutritional scientists have recognized the importance ofcuIture and the close relationsh1ps between food availability, familiarity with indigenous products, and nutritional quality. In a classic study of the Otomi Indians of Mexico, Anderson et al. (80) demonstrated that the diet of poor people is not necessarly poor in nutritional quality. In conclusion, Anderson argued against nutrition programs designed to "help" the Otomi because of the delicate cultural, ecological, and nutritional -balances that had developed over time. For example, calcium was obtained using lime-soaked maize ground on stone metates, and the essential amino acids were provided by maize and legumes. Other nutrients were satisfied through pulque, a fermented beverage made from cactus, and the selected use of chilies, mallows, squash, and wild fruits.
Echoing the cautious approaoh to dietary change, some clinicians and nutritionists have sought a better understanding of the total culture and dietary needs of individuals before outlining specific programs (81-88). Sometimes, such efforts include multidisciplinary collaboration with anthropologists, cultural geographers, or sociologists (89-92) . Examples of successful multidisciplinary efforts include those by Darby et al. (93) among the Navajo Indians, combined research by Patwardhan and Dal'by (94) in the Arab states of the Middle East, programs by Jelliffe (95-97) in the developing nations of Africa and Asia, and the exciting work by Scrimshaw (98, 99) at INCAP in Guatemala. The international character of applied nutrition research is reflected further by the Swed-
ish program on infant feeding in Ethiopia ( 1 00), where their general concern for increased nutritional quality led to a better understanding of the cultural, economic, and religious factors affecting diet and food habits in northeastern Africa (101).
Evaluation and Summary Each of the approaches used in food
habit research has served particular needs. No single approach, however, provides all the information necessary to the nutritionist because advantages and limitations are attached to each. For example, a regional overview may be useful during the initial stages of a study where general patterns emerge that permit broad hypotheses to be formulated. But when specific data are needed at the village, household, or individual level, the regional approach is incomplete.
Although environmentalism has attracted many physicians and nutritionists in recent years, it ignores the importance of man; almost all anthropologists and geographers have rejected the environmental approach since the early 1900s. The presence of a potential food in a favorable environment does not imply that it will be eaten, and the development of a quality diet has little to do with environmental determinants. Instead, diets develop in accord with cultural perception. Individuals and societies exploit those food resources perceived as offering satisfaction of social needs. Until recently, nutritional needs were not considered. For these and related reasons, most mbanites would starve in the Arctic or mountain highlands and not recognize the abundant food resources available to them. Likewise, citizens of other cultures can starve in the midst of plenty, even when foods widely consumed by visiting nutritionists are available.
Cultural ecologists, on the other hand, recognize the interactions between man and nature. Accordingly, cultural ecology is less deterministic than environmentalism and presents a more realistic, balanced approaoh. However, most cultural ecologists have focused on food hll1bits in limited areas and tend to ignore the historical factors that contribute to dietary traditions. Furthermore, cultural ecologists rarely consider the range of available consumables in a region or ask why specific products-some with high nutritional potential- have not been utilized.
The approach of culture-history offers a different spectrum of data and is used to best advantage when documents or artifacts associated w1th food production, are availaible for study. Such data
Journal of NUTRITION EDUCATION I 205
permit the reconstruction of dietary patterns at different periods of history and provide clues to the origins of contemporary food habits. In many instances, however, culture historians must rely on oral tradition, mythology, and linguistic evidence. As a result , some research hy culture historians is speculative, and sweeping conclusions have been drawn when more limited hypotheses were warranted.
With the functional approach, it is possible to understand the nuances of food uses within the cultural setting. Yet, functionalism tends to ignore valuable data from cultural ecology and culturehistory and focuses on contemporary patterns. A major drawback to the functional approach stems from the field method. The resident participant or observer usually spends six months to two years in the society and only 'with the greatest effort is able to divorce his own ethnocentric biases and correctly interpret the functions attached to food and describe the associated cultural behavior.
Interest in predictive models, one part of the recent trend toward quantification, reflects an advance in food habits studies.
Despite these developments, large differencesexist between the models thus far proposed and a,ctual situations involving diet and food habits. The rejection of high quality cereals by farmers in Mexico or India seems illogical; however, despite their elevated nutritional quality, high-yield cereals often succumb to local pests. When these disease problems have been conquered, ,the new crops still may be rejected because they do not taste right or do not have the proper texture, color, or keeping quality of more familiar, low-yield strains. Scientists interested in mathematical or economic models have yet to consider the vast array of social, environmental, and technological interactions tha,t influence food acceptance; predicting acceptable dietary combinations still is a future goal.
In conclusion, no single approach is satisfactory. However, several in combination offer exciting new dimensions for food habit researoh. When investigating the food habits of a particular ethnic group, the nutrition educator is encouraged to consider literature representative of several approaches and then select one appropriate to the needs of the community or ethnic group that provides the best sources of data for the particular problem in question. Multidisciplinary efforts linking the clinical and social sciences should be encoura'ged and expanded. The insights and perspectives generated through complementary efforts
206 I Journal of NUTRITION EDUCATION
permit a more complete understanding of the food customs of a given population. REFERENCES
1. Pyke, M., Food and Society, John Murray, London, 1968.
2. Freedman, R. L., The state of food habits research in the United States of America, Bolet/n Bibliografico de Antropologia Americana, 33-34: 167-193, 1970-71.
3. Wilson, C. S., Food habits: a selected annotated bibliography, J. Nutr. Educ., 5: 37, 1973 .
4. Human Relations Area Files (HRAF), Food Habit Survey, 3 vols., H.R.A.F., New Haven, Conn., 1964.
5. Hippocrates of Cos, Airs, waters, places, in Hippocrates, Vol. 1, Translated by Jones, W. H. S., William Heinemann, London, 1957, pp. 66-137 .
6. Huntington, E. , The geography of human productivity, Annals, Association of American Geographers, 33: 13, 1943.
7. Huntington, E., Mainsprings of Civilization, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1945, pp. 424-458.
8. Semple, E. c., Geogr.aphic factors in the ancient Mediterranean grain trade, Annals, Association of American Geographers, 11 :47, 1921.
9. Semple, E. C., The influence of geographic conditions upon ancient Mediterranean stock-raising, Annals, Association of American Geographers, 12:3, 1922.
10. Thompson, L., The relations of men, animals, and plants in an island community (Fiji), Amer. Anthropol., 51: 253, 1949.
11. Steward, J. H., Theory of Culture Change. The Methodology of Multilinear Evolution, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, 1955, pp. 101-121.
12. Lee, R. B., What hunters do for a living, or, how to make out on scarce resources, in Man the Hunter, Lee, R. B., and DeVore, I., Eds., Aldine Publishing Co., Chicago, 1968, pp. 30-48.
13. Lee, R. B., !Kung Bushman subsistence: an input-output analysis, in Environment and Cultural Behavior. Ecological Studies in Cultural Anthropology, Vayda, A. P., Ed., The Natural History Press, Garden City, N.Y., 1969, pp. 47-79.
14. Vayda, A. P., Leeds, A., and Smith, D. B., The place of pigs in Melanesian subsistence, in Proceedings of the 1961 Annual Spring Meeting of the American Ethnological Society, Garfield, V. E., Ed., University of Washington Press, Seattle, 1961, pp. 69-77.
15. Rappaport, R. A., Pigs for the Ancestors: Ritual in the Ecology of a New Guinea People, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn., 1968.
16. Rappaport, R. A., Ritual regulation of environmental relations among a New Guinea people, in Environment and Cultural Behavior. Ecological Studies in Cultural Anthropology, Vayda, A. P., Ed., The Natural History Press, Garden City, N.Y., 1969, pp. 181-201.
17. Bennett, M. K., International contrasts in food consumption, Geog. Rev., 31: 365, 1941.
18. Bennett, M. K., The World's Food. A Study of the Interrelations of World
Populatiolls, National Diets, and Food Potentials, Harper and Row, New York, 1954.
19. Kariel, H. G., A proposed classification of diet, Annals, Association of A merican Geographers, 56: 68, 1966.
20. Sorre, M., L es fondemellts biologiques. Essai d'ulle £cologie de fHomme. Vol. 1, of Les fondements de la geographie humaine, Armand Colin, Pari s. 1951; pp. 247-290.
21. Sorre, M., The geography of diet. in Readings in Cultural Geography, Wagner, P. L., and Mikesell, M. W., Eds., University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1962, pp. 445-456.
22. Whittlesey, D., Major agricultural regions of the earth, Allllals, A ssociation of American Geographers, 26: 199,1936.
23. May, J. M., The Ecology of Malnutrition in the Far and Near East . Food Resources, Habits, and Deficiencies, Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1961.
24. May, J. M., Th e Ecology of Malnutrition in Five Countries of Eastern and Central Europe. East Germany, Poland, Yugoslavia, A lbania, Greece, Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1963 .
25. May, J. M ., The Ecology of Malnutrition in Central and Southeastern Europe. Austria, Hungary, Rumania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1966.
26. May, J. M., The Ecology of Malnutritioll ill Middle Africa. Ghana, Nigeria, Republic of the Congo, Ry,·anda, Burundi, and the Former French Equatorial Africa, Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1965.
27. May, J. M., Th e Ecology of Malnutrition in Northern Africa. Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, Spanish Sahara and Ifni, Mauritania. Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1967.
28. May, J. M., Th e Ecology of Malnutrition in the French Speaking Countries of West Africa and Madagascar. Senegal, Guinea, Ivory Coast, Togo, Dahomey, Cameroun, Niger, Mali, Upper Volta and Madagascar. Hafner Publishing Co., New York, 1968.
29. May, J. M., The Ecology of Malnutrition in Mexico and Central America . Hafner Press, New York, 1972.
30. Wagner, P. L. and Mikesell, M. W., Eds., Readings on Cultural Geography, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1962, pp. 13-19.
31. Deffontaines, P., Geographie et Religions, Gallimard, Paris, 1948, pp. 367-394.
32. de Planhol, x., The World of Islam (Le Monde Islamique: Essai de Geographie Religieuse), Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1955, pp. 50-60.
33. Isaac, E., Influence of religion on the spread of citrus, Science, 129 : 179, 1959.
34. Sopher, D. E., Geography of Religions, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J .. 1967, pp. 35-38.
35. Simoons, F. J., Eat Not This Flesh. Food Avoidances in the Old World, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, 1961.
36. Jeffreys, M. D. W., The history of maize in Africa, South African J. Sci ., 50: 197. 1954.
37. Jeffreys, M. D. W., Pre-Columbian maize in Southern Africa, Nature, 215:
VOL. 5, NO. 3, JULY-SEPT., 1973
695, 1967. 38. Sauer, C. 0., Maize into Europe, in
Agricultural Origins and Dispersals. Th e Domestication of Animals and Foodstuffs, 2nd ed., Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, Cambridge, Mass ., 1969, pp. 147-167.
39. Vermeer, D. E., Agricultural and Dietary Practices Among the Tiv, lbo, and Birom Tribes, Nigeria, Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Berkeley, 1964.
40. Vermeer, D. E., Geophagy among the Ewe of Ghana, Ethnology, 10:56, 1971.
41. Miracle, M. P., Agriculture in the Congo. Tradition and Change in African Rural Economies, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, 1967.
42. Bennett, C. F ., Jr., Bayano Cuna Indians, Panama: an ecological study of livelihood and diet, Annals, Association of American Geographers, 52 :32, 1962.
43. Nietschmann, B. Q., Between Land and Water: The Subsistence Ecology of the Miskito Indians, Eastern Nicaragua, Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison, 1970.
44. Richards, A. I., Hunger and Work in a Savage Tribe. A Functional Study of Nutrition Among the Southern Bantu, G. Routledge and Sons, Ltd ., London, 1932.
45. Richards, A. I., Land, Labour and Diet in Northern Rhodesia. An Economic Study of the Bemba Tribe, International Institute of African Languages and Cultures, London, 1939.
46. Apodaca, A., Corn and custom: the introduction of hybrid corn to Spanish American farmers in New Mexico, in Human Problems in Technological Change. A Casebook, Spicer, E. H., Ed., John Wiley and Sons, Inc. New York, 1952, pp. 35-39.
47. Foster, G. M., Traditional Cultures: and the Impact of Technological Change, Harper and Row, New York, 1962.
48. Foster, G. M., Applied Anthropology, Little, Brown and Co., Boston, 1969.
49. Goodenough, W. H., Cooperation in Change. An Anthropological Approach to Community Development, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1966.
50. Paul, B. D., Ed., Health, Culture, and Community. Case Studies of Public Reactions to Health Programs, Russell Sage Foundation, New York, 1955.
51. Paul, B. D., The Role of Beliefs and Customs in Sanitation Programs, Amer. J. Publ. Health, 48:1502,1958.
52. Spicer, E. H., Ed., Human Problems in Technological Change. A Casebook, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, 1952.
53. Wellin, E., Water boiling in a Peruvian town, in Health, Culture, and Community. Case Studies of Public Reactions to Health Programs, Paul, B. D., Ed., Russell Sage Foundation, N.Y., 1955, pp. 71-103.
54. Jerome, N . W., Changing meal patterns among Southern-born Negroes in a Midwestern city, Nutr . News, 31 :9, 1968.
55. Wilson, C. S., Food beliefs affect nutritional status of Malay fisherfolk, J . Nutr. Educ., 2:96, 1971.
56. Sanjur, D., Cravioto, J., and Van Veen, A. G., Infant nutrition and sociocultural
VOL 5, NO.3, JULY-SEPT., 1973
influences in a village in Central Mexico, Trop. Geog. Med., 22:443, 1970.
57. Sanjur, D., Romero, E., and Kira, M., Milk consumption patterns of Puerto Rican preschool children in rural New York, Amer. J. Clin. Nutr ., 24: 1320, 1971.
58. Lea, D., Some non-nutritive functions of food in New Guinea, in Settlement and Encounter. Geographical Studies Presented to Sir Grenfell Price, Gale, F., and Lawton, G. H., Eds., Oxford University Press, New York, 1969, pp. 173-184.
59. Brooke, C., Types of food shortages in Tanzania, Geog. Rev., 57:333, 1967.
60. Irvine, F. R., Supplementary and emergency food plants of West Africa, Econ. Botany, 6: 23, 1952.
61. Pankhurst, R., The great Ethiopian famine of 1888-1892. A new assessment, J. Hist. Med., 21 :99, 271,1966.
62. Hvarfner, H., Hunger at fixed times. An ethnic accumulation with biological consequences?, Ethnologia Scandinavica, 1971, pp. 61-64.
63. Miracle, M. P., Seasonal hunger: A vague concept and an unexplored problem, Bulletinlnstitut Franfais d'Afrique Noire, S6rie B, 23 :273, 1961.
64. Keys, A. B., et aI., The Biology of Human Starvation, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, 2 vols., 1950.
65. Gould, P. R., Man against his environment: a game theoretic framework, Anndls, Association of American Geographers, 53: 290, 1963.
66. Chasey, J. P., van Veen, A. G., and Young, F. W., The Application of Social Science Research Methods to the Study of Food Habits and Food Consumption in an Industrializing Area, Amer. J. CUn. Nutr. , 20:56, 1967.
67. Maslow, A. H., The influence of familiarization on preference, J. Exp. Psych., 21: 162, 1937.
68. Lewin, K., Forces behind food habits and methods of change, in The Problem of Changing Food Habits, Bulletin No. 108, National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C., 1943, pp. 35-65.
69. Guthe, C. E., History of the Committee on Food Habits, in The Problem of Changing Food Habits, Bulletin No. 108, National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C., 1943, pp. 9-19.
70. Altus, W. D., Adjustments and food aversions among Army illiterates, J. of Consult. Psych., 13 :429, 1949.
71. Kamen, J. M., Reasons for non-consumption of food in the Army, J. Amer. Dietet. Assn., 41 :437, 1962.
72. Peryam, D. R., et aI., Food Preferences of M en in the U.S. Armed Forces, Quartermaster Food and Container Institute for the Armed Forces, Quartermaster Research and Engineering Command, U.S. Army, Chicago, 1960.
73. Pilgrim, F. J., The components of food acceptance and their measurement, Amer. J. Clin. Nutr., 5: 171, 1957.
74. Vawter, H. J. and Konishi, F., Food acceptance by soldiers under an ad libitum regimen, J. Amer. Dietet. Assn., 34: 36, 1958.
75. Wallen, R., Food aversions in behavioral
disorders, J. Consulting /,sYCh., L::: j IV, 1948.
76. Schutz, H. G., Rucker, M. H., and Hunt, J. D., Hospital patients' and employees' reactions to food-use combinations, J. Amer. Dietet. Assn., 60:207, 1972.
77. Ortega, J. J., Consumer Attitudes Towards Wine, Unpublished M.S. thesis, University of California, Davis, 1972.
78. Schutz, H. G. and Rucker, M. H., Regional Attitudes Towards Food Use in the United States (in preparation).
79. Devanney, J. W., III, The economics of F .P.C., in Proceedings, Western Hemisphere Nutrition Congress Ill, August 30-September 2, 1971, Miami Beach, Florida, Futura Publishing Co., Mount Kisco, N.Y., 1972, pp. 45-52.
80. Anderson, R. K., Calvo, J., Serrano, G., and Payne, G. C., A study of the nutritional status and food habits of Otomi Indians in the Mezquital Valley of Mexico, Amer.J.Publ.Health, 36 :883, 1946.
81. Burgess, H. J. L., Protein-calorie malnutrition in Uganda. Ankole District, East African Med. J., 39:391, 1962.
82. Burgess, A. P. and Dean, R. F . A. , Eds., Malnutrition alld Food Habits. Report of an International and Interprofessional Conference, Tavistock, London, 1962.
83 . de Garine, I ., Socio-Cultural Aspects of Food Behaviour. Essay on Classification of Food Prohibitions, F.A.O./ O.A.U. Scientific, Technical, and Research Commission, Report No.7, Food and Agricultural Organization, Rome, 1969, pp. 3-20.
84. Graubard, M., Man's Food. Its Rhyme or Reason, Macmillan, New York, 1943.
85. Le Gros Clark, F., Food habits and how to change them, Lallcet, 247:53, 1944.
86. Pyke, M., The development of food myths, Symposia of the Swedish Nutrition Foundation, 8:22-29, 1971.
87. Schaefer, A. E. and Johnson, O. C., Are we well fed? The search for the answer, Nutr. Today, 4:2, 1969.
88. Yudkin, J. and McKenzie, J. C., Eds., Changing Food Habits, MacGibbon and Kee, London, 1964.
89. Carter, J. P., et aI., Growth and sexual development of adolescent Egyptian village boys, Amer. J. CUn. Nutr., 22:59, 1969.
90. Darby, W. J., This hungry world. A responsrbility of preventive medicine, Amer. 1. Clin. Nutr., 16:509, 1965.
91. Darby, W. J., Nutrition in the 1970's, Nutr. Rev., 30:27, 1972.
92. Patwardhan, V. N., Pulses and beans in human nutrition, Amer. J. CUn. Nutr., 11: 12, 1962.
93 . Darby, W. J., et aI. , A study of the dietary background and nutriture of the Navajo Indian. Part II. Dietary pattern, J . Nutr., Supplement to Vol. 60, 1956, pp. 19-33.
94. P'atwardhan, V. N. and Darby, W. J., The State of Nutrition in the Arab Middle East, Vanderbilt University Press, Nashville, Tenn., 1972.
95. Jelliffe, D . B., Social culture and nutrition. Cultural blocks and protein malnutrition in early childhood in rural West Bengal, Pediatrics, 20: 128, 1957.
96. Jelliffe, D . B., Culture, social change and infant feeding. Current trends in tropical regions, Amer. J. Clin. Nutr.,
Journal of NUTRITION EDUCATION / 207
10: 19, 1962. 97. Jelliffe, D. B., Parallel food classifica
tions in developing and industrialized countries, Amer. I. Clin. Nutr., 20:279, 1967.
98. Scrimshaw, N. S., Nutrition functions of maternal and child health programs
in technically underdeveloped areas, Nutr. Rev., 20:33, 1962.
99. Scrimshaw, N. S., Ecological factors in nutritional disease, Amer. I. Clin. Nutr., 14: 112, 1964.
100. Hofvander, Y. and Eksmyr, R., An applied nutrition program in an Ethiopian
Program Ideas PTA and Nutritio,n Council Cooperate in Study Course
A Parent-Teacher Association Nutrition Study Course, sponsored jointly by the Tennessee PTA and the Tennessee Nutrition Council is an example of a new approach to nutrition education at the grass-roots level-a joint endeavor for a common goal.
The Tennessee PTA had the vision to see the importance of nutrition information for their members and were determined to do something about it. The Tennessee PTA stresses that an effective local PTA unit is one that has one or more study courses during the year; this coming year they are urging every local . PTA to study nutrition (a study course to the PTA means at least one 2-hour session of study) .
The Tennessee Nutrition Council has been seeking ways and means by which they can help to improve the nutriture of all Tennesseans, implement 'current programs, and initiate some new endeavors. A committee of three was appointed by the Nutrition Council to plan a study program in nutrition for the PTA and prepare a suitable guide or outline for this. The committee met with members of the Tennessee PTA executive board and discussed possible plans, topics, procedures, etc. The committee then went to work; many meetings, preliminary drafts, discussions, and rewrites resulted in a handbook for a PTA nutrition study course.!
Objectives The main objectives of the handbook
are:
1. To place the responsibility for planning and development of nutrition study groups in the hands of the local PTA units;
2. To ensure that instructors for the study groups are those qualified to present the facts of nutrition;
3. To emphasize to the instructors: a)
1. Nutrition Study Course for PTA members, A Handbook and Guide for Instructors and Leaders of Nutrition Study Groups, from The Tennessee Congress of Parents and Teachers, Inc., 1905 Acklen Ave., Nashville, TN 37212, 16 p., 50 cents per copy.
208 I Journal of NUTRITION EDUCATION
that the study group should not be given a lecture but that it should be a discussion with total involvement of all study group members; b) that the emphasis be on food and pmctical problems encountered by each group; and c) that discussion of foods and food choices be based on nutritive value; and
4. To remind local instructors of some of the current books that may be used as nutrition background, of current trends, and of reliable sources of information and resource materials.
Implementation The committee of the Tennessee Nu
trition Council does not feel that its jO!b is done now that the handbook is completed. The members are now pIanning how they can continue cooperative efforts with the PTA at all levels. Letters are being sent to all Council members, county and local nutrition committees, university and college faculty, extension agents, school service personnel, home economists, and nutritionists throughout the state enclosing a copy of the handbook and inviting them to get in touch with their local PT As and offer their services as instructors. Time will tell how successful an these efforts are.
A description of the Tennessee program and the handbook have been sent to the N ational PTA Board. It is hoped that the National PTA will encourage other states to conduct similar programs and use the handbook or prepare one suitable for their own needs.
E. Neige Todhunter, Ph.D., Visiting Professor of Nutrition, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN 37232.
'Food and Culture' Workshops for Virgin Islands Teachers
A series of workshops on "Relating Local Foods to the Culture" was given in 1971 and 1972 for elementary teachers in the Virgin Islands. Teachers were informed about the workshop through the Coordinator of Project Introspection, V. I. Department of Health. Project Introspection periodically conducts workshops for educators.
rural community, Amer. I. Clin. Nutl'., 24:578, 1971.
101. Knutsson, K. E. and Selinus, R., Fasting in Ethiopia. An anthropological and nutritional study, ArneI'. I. Clill. Nutr., 23:956, 1970.
The goals of the workshops were: 1) to exchange information that would help Virgin Islands children develop appreciation and awareness of their cultural food heritage; 2) to promote nutrition education through meaningful activities; and 3) to enhance the teacher-nutritionist-home economist relationship.
Materials and methods used in the workshop series included: exhibits of fresh local foods (e.g., cassava bread, sweet go, tania, papaya, and soursop); printed literature on fishing, agriculture, extension services, health and voluntary agencies; a West Indian doll depicted as the "Market Woman" (a traditional figure who carries a basket of produce on her head at the open market square); tasting 10lcal dishes; singing a local folksong; and eXiploring descriptive terms in a glossary of native foods.
Teachers' knowledge of an adequate diet and awareness of nutritional problems among school children were also checked, and suitable classroom and lunchroom activities were suggested. One feature of the workshops was a questionnaire to assess the extent of use of local foods and culture in teaching activities, use of resource people, and teachers' awareness of poor nutritional habits among their own students and what they do about them.
The workshops served as a beneficial beginning for exchange of ideas on the role of food in the local culture. A great deal O!f interest was generated. In fact, only one session had originally been schedu'led, and four others were added due to the enthusiasm of participants.
Some follow-up from the workshops was evident when several requests were made by participants for additional materials for use with their students.
Marva S. Browne, (formerly) Chief Project Nutritionist, Children and Youth Projects, Virgin Islands; P. O. Box 2953, St. Thomas, Virgin Islands 00801.
Food Science Course Turns o,n Non-science College Students
Faculty of the Department of Food Science and Technology, University of Massil'chusetts, Amherst, designed an in-
VOL. 5, NO.3, JULY-SEPT., 1973