February 8-9, 2011

SB Session Hall, Tinambac Municipal Complex

*

RESULT DAY 2

*

1. SB Chairman for Environment- Hon. Ramon Ilano

2. SB Chairman for Fisheries- Hon. Franco Alvarez

3. MAO- Engr. Reynaldo Rivera

4. Municipal AT- Jogie Sagales

5. MPDO- Engr. Diego Bayonito

6. Municipal Budget Officer- Joseph Banes

7. Barangay Captain (NTZ1)- Levi Terrobias

8. Barangay captain (NTZ 2)- Decoroso Rodriguez

9. PNP Tinambac- SPO4 Teresito Porteza

10. Philippine Army- Lt. Keenan Arguelles, Sgt. Ruben V. Luzana

11. BFARMC - Eli Tatel (NTZ1); Jun Dianela (NTZ2); Allan Sarmiento (Brgy. San Antonio)

12. PO Representative- Pio Perez

13. BFAR- Joel Balasta; Santigao Noblefranca

14. DENR-CENRO- Rosalie Samson; Alona Mendoza

15. Bantay-Dagat- Roberto Refugio, Dante Solo, Roberto Teope, Ernesto Brillantes

16. Women Representative- Liezel Icaro

17. NSLC- Cathy Demesa, Ferning Gervacio, Randy Banal

18. Samdhana Institute- Ding Cabreira

19. Rare- Pablo Roxas, Cristina Canlas, Ronet Santos

Mangalap ng impormasyon at mag-analisa

Pagpapatunay ng impormasyon

Pagconsonsolida ng impormasyon/datos

Pagplano

Pag-subaybay

Details Number

Number of fishermen (full time)

Fisherfolk member or no? Kung no, bakit? what PO)

Registered ba o hindi?

Number of fishermen (part time-farmers)

Number of fishers (women)

Number of fishers (children)

Number of gleaners (part time, recreational, panud-an)

Number of boats motorized

Number of non-motorized boats

Ave. number of individuals in a motorized boat/trip

Ave. number of individuals in a non-motorized boat/trip

Other forms of livelihood /month

Lean months for fishing/why

Peak months for fishing/why

1. Data gathering: Fishery Demographics

c/o LGU-Office of the municipal Agriculture

Date: TBD

*Illustrates seasonality of fish composition and gears in the locality

*Provides pattern or cycle of gear and catch in a year

*Helps in legislation (regulation of gears and catch)

*FGD (2 hrs, 10-15 participants)

2. Data gathering: Calendar Diagram

c/o LGU-Office of the municipal Agriculture

Date: TBD

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

Jun

Jul

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Kilogra

m

No.

of

gears

(sp

ecif

ic t

ype)

Month

Gear1

*A graphical representation of the catch effort over the years

*May help project what will be the catch in the future depending on current management

*FGD (10-15 participants-mostly fishermen aged 50-70 years old)

c/o LGU-Office of SB – Mr. Franco ALvarez

Date: TBD

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2005 2010

Catc

h (

kg./

pers

on/d

ay)

Year

Introduction

of cyanide

and

dynamite

fishing

Use of fine

mesh nets

?

3. Data gathering: Trend Diagram

* A simple documentation showing history of enforcement, enforcement practices and some details regarding infractions, gears and perpetrators.

* Can help us understand who, where, what (MPA intrusions)

* Can help in legislation and planning

* FGD (2 hrs, 10-15 participants-enforcers, some PNP mebers can assist)

4. Data gathering: MPA Enforcement

Year Number

of

infringem

ent

Types/for

ms of

infringeme

nt/gears

used

Intruders

(from where,

who, age

group)

Course/s of action

taken (apprehension,

affidavit writing,

litigation,

imprisonment)

Forms of

incentive

s/disince

ntives

Re

mar

ks

Year 1 (After

MPA

establishment)

Year 2

Year 3

Year 4

Year 5

Year 6

c/o Tinambac PNP and Philippine Army

Date: March 15, 2011

*5. Data gathering:

Fish and Gear inventory

List of all gears in the

village

Regulated or

no? What is the

type of

regulation?

Total number

in the

barangay

Number of

users in the

barangay

Soaking

time

Number of

users in one

gear per trip

Frequency

of use in a

day

List of fish

caught

Hook and line (multiple-

offshore or single)

Fish trap (bubo)

Gill nets (bottom set gill

net)

Beach seine

Spear

• An inventory of all gears and type of catch in the locality

• Helps describe what gear catches what fish

• Can help in decision making for regulations and legislations

• FGD (2 hrs, 10-15 participants-mostly fishers)

• Add specific type of gears if necessary by inserting a column, if necessary

c/o BFARMC and PO

Date: TBD

*5b. Data gathering:

Fish Catch Mangrove Seagrass Corals Deep sea

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

c/o BFARMC and PO

Date: TBD

6. Data gathering:

Invertebrate

s

Mangrove Seagrass Corals Deep sea

1. Banagan

2. Hipon

3. Kasag

4. Pusit

5. Kogita

6. Balat

7. Sea urchin

8. Sea horse

9. Shells

10. Lato

c/o BFARMC and PO

Date: TBD

7. Data gathering: *A historical account of the use, users and resources and folklores

(practices) of the MPA

*Could date back to time that can be recalled by participants

*Provides a comparison of the use, users, and resource (what changed overtime)

*FGD (2 hrs-10-15 participants-fishers residing close to or knowledgeable of MPA history)

Year Uses and activities of Core

Zone

Uses and activitiesBuffer

Zone

Before establishment

1 year after establishment

2 years after establishment

3 years after establishment

(up to 2010)

c/o BFARMC and PO

Date: TBD

8. Data gathering:

*A visual representation of an area highlighting relationships between elements

*Can provide us quick reference as to areas of uses, issues, areas of conflict, fishing grounds and etc.

*Useful tool for the community planning

*FGD (3 hrs, 10-15 or more participants); Resource MAP for gleaners (mostly females and kids)

c/o DENR-CENRO

Date: TBD

9. Data gathering:

*Major habitats

*Fish composition

*Issues

*Uses

Resource use and

issues coding

Use Code Issue Code

Human settlement Poisonous

substances

Power station Commercial

fishing

Chapel Mangrove

harvesting

Schools Reclamation

Agricultural land Garbage disposal

Hook and line fishing Inadequate IEC

Spear fishing Habitat

destruction

Bottom set gill nets Lack of law

enforcement

Fish landing area Poaching

Docking area Sedimentation

Navigational route River discharges

Multipurpose hall

Gleaning inside MPA

Gleaning Fishing inside

MPA

Resorts

Fish corral

Fish traps

Fish ponds

Guardhouse

c/o DENR-CENRO

Date: TBD

* 10. Data gathering:

*A quantitative assessment on fish, corals and

invertebrate communities by the local

communities

*Provides us data (inventory of fish, corals, and

invertebrates in our MPA) to support other tools

(i.e. FGDs)

*Training of 8 individuals (mostly fishers able to

snorkel)

*Actual data collection (4 hrs.)

c/o BFAR

Date: TBD

* 11. Data gathering:

Gear type

Operational expenses

per trip (hook, nylon,

net, bait, gasolina)

Number of

kilos caught

per trip

Number of

kilos sold

Price per

kilo Market Net income

Types of

expense

from sales

Number

of kilos

to take

home

Hook and line (single) (treat

each variation with a single

row)

Hook and line (multiple)

(classify according to number

of hooks and treat each with a

single row)

Fish trap (bubo) (treat each

variation with a single row)

Gill nets

Cast net (treat each variation

with a single row)

Beach seine

Fish corral

Spear

• A simple profile of fishing activities focusing on day to day income and

expenses

• Provide us a baseline (economics, gears, catch composition)

• FGD (2 hrs, 10-15 participants)

c/o NSLC and LGU

Date: TBD

* 12. Data gathering:

*A detailed census on social marketing venues, capacity, knowledge, attitude and practices

*One on one interviews

*About 30%-40% of the barangay residents will be interviewed

*Need to train enumerators

c/o NSLC and LGU

Date: TBD

*Activities

*Determine the number of target audience

*Training of enumerators

*Production of questionnaires

*Actual interviewing (one on one)

*Encoding

*Analysis

* 13. Data gathering:

2.5 m

2.5 m

* Scientific sampling on fish, coral, and invertebrate communities

* Provides a detailed description of our resources

* By Marine Environment and Resource Foundation

* Need to provide logistical support to visiting scientists (boat, guide)-4 to 5 days

* Communications needed for the Municipal Mayor and Barangay LGU

c/o LGU, NSLC and Rare

Date: TBD

*MPA effectiveness rating system is a harmonized report checklist

*This reporting document contains categories and elements that are used to gauge and highlight important threshold indicators and processes that help promote and achieve MPA management effectiveness outputs and outcomes.

14. Data gathering: MPA Effectiveness

Rating (for the Management Committee)

c/o LGU, NSLC and Rare

Date: TBD

• A tool to measure performance • A system intended to assist local governments and communities to

improve MPA management • Minimum set of criteria/activities for every level needs to be satisfied

first to be assigned that particular level • Based on the principles of functionality, participatori-ness,

transparency, accountability and participatory decision-making • With this system – you can always add things at the different levels,

but cant remove things – we may want to add later on based on our experience vis a vis SM at the end of the campaigns

Kamay na may hawak sa

likas yaman

at kumakalinga sa

magandang buhay.

-maunlad

-masagana

Banka na papunta

sa maunlad at masagana

at maunlad na buhay.

Banka simbolo ng mancom

Elisi 1: Malinaw sa Mancom

ang batayang kalagayan.

-Kanya-kanya/walang pagkakaisa

-ovefished. Marami ang

gumagamit pero wala o

kokonti lang ang nangangalaga

Sapangisdaan

-kulang ang kaalaman lalo

Na ng mangignisda tungkol sa

Sistema ng tamang paggamit ng

Likas na yaman

-Pagkawasak ng pangisdaan nagbunga ng kahirapan

Elisi 2:

Malinaw sa Mancom ang pangangailangan ng pagkilos-

Sama-samang pagkilos ay ngayon na. Ano meron na:

-pag-organisa

Supportive ng LGU

May Pos

May bantay-dagat

May bantay bakhawan

May AGCA Sanctuary

May networking

Patuloy na regular meeting

May BFRAMC

May TWG

May Mancom

May Org Assessment

May VMG

May pag-aaral sa governance at operation

Tiningnan ang kaluyahan at kakusugan sa finance

Gumawa ng action plan

Plan ng KAP survey

PCRA planning

Elise 3: PANINIWALA. Naniniwala

na nag tao ay magbabago. Bigyan lang

lng pagkakataon ang tao.

Kung naniniwala..hali na kayo sakay

tayo sa banka.

Bahagi ng paniniwala na ito ang

pananagutan sa:

Sarili

Lipunan

Kalikasan

Panginoon

- Sa pagmamahal sa lipunan, sa

kapwa, at sa kalikasan- eto ang buhay

na paniniwala.

SYNTHESIS

Katig: mga kaibigan

Na handang gumabay sa atin.

Mga Kabalikat natin sa

Paglalakbay.

Araw ay simbolo ng

pag-asa..

Tatakbo ang banka na

dala-dala natin

Sa ating puso ang

pagmamahal at pag-asa.

TASK SUMMARY