Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    1/28

    FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ITS IMPACT ON EMPLOYMENT

    Literature

    Foreign direct investment (FDI) refers to long term participation by country A into

    country B. It usually involves participation in

    management, joint-venture, transfer of technology and expertise. There are two types of

    FDI: inward foreign direct investment

    and outward foreign direct investment, resulting in a net FDI History

    Foreign direct investment (FDI) is a measure of foreign ownership of productive assets,

    such as factories, mines and land.

    Increasing foreign investment can be used as one measure of growing economic

    globalization. Figure below shows net inflows

    of foreign direct investment. The largest flows of foreign investment occur between the

    industrialized countries (North America,

    Western Europe and Japan). But flows to non-industrialized countries are increasing

    sharply.

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    2/28

    US International Direct Investment Flows:[1]

    Period FDI Outflow FDI Inflows Net

    1960-69 $ 42.18 bn $ 5.13 bn + $ 37.04 bn

    1970-79 $ 122.72 bn $ 40.79 bn + $ 81.93 bn

    1980-89 $ 206.27 bn $ 329.23 bn - $ 122.96 bn

    1990-99 $ 950.47 bn $ 907.34 bn + $ 43.13 bn

    2000-07 $ 1,629.05 bn $ 1,421.31 bn + $ 207.74 bn

    Total $ 2,950.69 bn $ 2,703.81 bn + $ 246.88 bn

    A foreign direct investor may be classified in any sector of the economy and could be any

    one of the following:[citation

    needed

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    3/28

    an individual;

    a group of related individuals;

    an incorporated or unincorporated entity;

    a public company or private company;

    a group of related enterprises;

    a government body;

    an estate (law), trust or other societal organisation; or

    any combination of the above.

    The foreign direct investor may acquire 10% or more of the voting power of an enterprise

    in an economy through any of the

    following methods:

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    4/28

    by incorporating a wholly owned subsidiary or company

    by acquiring shares in an associated enterprise

    through a merger or an acquisition of an unrelated enterprise

    participating in an equity joint venture with another investor or enterprise

    Foreign direct investment incentives may take the following forms:citation

    needed

    low corporate tax and income tax rates

    tax holidays

    other types of tax concessions

    preferential tariffs

    special economic zones

    EPZ - Export Processing Zones

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    5/28

    Some countries have put restrictions on FDI in certain sectors. India, with its restriction

    on FDI in the retail sector is an

    example.In a country like India, the walmartization of the country could have

    significant negative effects on the overall

    economy by reducing the number of people employed in the retail sector (currently thesecond largest employment sector

    nationally) and depressing the income of people involved in the agriculture sector

    (currently the largest employment sector

    nationally).

    Foreign direct investment in the United States

    "Invest in America" is an initiative of the Commerce department and aimed to promote

    the arrival of foreigners investors to the

    country.

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    6/28

    The Invest in America policy is focused on:

    Facilitating investor queries.

    Carrying out maneuvers to aid foreign investors.

    Provide support both at local and state levels.

    Address concerns related to the business environment by helping as an ombudsman inWashington Dc for the international

    venture community.

    Offering policy guidelines and helping getting access to the legal system.

    The United States is the worlds largest recipient of FDI. More than $325.3 billion in FDI

    flowed into the United States in 2008,

    which is a 37 percent increase from 2007. The $2.1 trillion stock of FDI in the United

    States at the end of 2008 is the

    equivalent of approximately 16 percent of U.S. gross domestic product (GDP).55

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    7/28

    Benefits of FDI in America: In the last 6 years, over 4000 new projects and 630,000 new

    jobs have been created by foreign

    companies, resulting in close to $314 billion in investment.[citation needed] Unarguably,

    US affiliates of foreign companies

    have a history of paying higher wages than US corporations.[citation needed] Foreign

    companies have in the past supported

    an annual US payroll of $364 billion with an average annual compensation of $68,000

    per employee: citation needed

    Increased US exports through the use of multinational distribution networks. FDI has

    resulted in 30% of jobs for Americans in

    the manufacturing sector, which accounts for 12% of all manufacturing jobs in the US.[5]

    Affiliates of foreign corporations spent more than $34 billions on research and

    development in 2006 and continue to support

    many national projects. Inward FDI has led to higher productivity through increased

    capital, which in turn has led to high living

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    8/28

    standards.

    Foreign direct investment in China

    FDI in China has been one of the major successes of the past 3 decades. [citation needed]

    Starting from a baseline of less

    than $19 billion just 20 years ago, FDI in China has grown to over $300 billion in the

    first 10 years. China has continued its

    massive growth and is the leader among all developing nations in terms of FDI. [citation

    needed] Even though there was a

    slight dip in FDI in 2009 as a result of the global slowdown, 2010 has again seen

    investments increase. [citation needed] The

    Chinese continue to steam roll with expectations of an economic growth of a 10% this

    year.

    Types of Foreign Direct Investment: An Overview

    FDI or Foreign Direct Investment is any form of investment that earns interest in

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    9/28

    enterprises which function outside of the

    domestic territory of the investor.

    FDIs require a business relationship between a parent company and its foreign subsidiary.

    Foreign direct business

    relationships give rise to multinational corporations. For an investment to be regarded as

    an FDI, the parent firm needs to

    have at least 10% of the ordinary shares of its foreign affiliates. The investing firm may

    also qualify for an FDI if it owns

    voting power in a business enterprise operating in a foreign country.

    FDIs can be broadly classified into two types: outward FDIs and inward FDIs. This

    classification is based on the types

    of restrictions imposed, and the various prerequisites required for these investments.

    An outward-bound FDI is backed by the government against all types of associated risks.

    This form of FDI is subject to

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    10/28

    tax incentives as well as disincentives of various forms. Risk coverage provided to the

    domestic industries and subsidies

    granted to the local firms stand in the way of outward FDIs, which are also known as

    'direct investments abroad.'

    Different economic factors encourage inward FDIs. These include interest loans, tax

    breaks, grants, subsidies, and the

    removal of restrictions and limitations. Factors detrimental to the growth of FDIs include

    necessities of differential

    performance and limitations related with ownership patterns.

    Other categorizations of FDI exist as well. Vertical Foreign Direct Investment takes place

    when a multinational

    corporation owns some shares of a foreign enterprise, which supplies input for it or uses

    the output produced by the

    MNC.

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    11/28

    Horizontal foreign direct investments happen when a multinational company carries out a

    similar business operation in

    different nations.

    Foreign Direct Investment is guided by different motives. FDIs that are undertaken to

    strengthen the existing market

    structure or explore the opportunities of new markets can be called 'market-seeking FDIs.'

    'Resource-seeking FDIs' are

    aimed at factors of production which have more operational efficiency than those

    available in the home country of the

    investor.

    Some foreign direct investments involve the transfer of strategic assets. FDI activities

    may also be carried out to ensure

    optimization of available opportunities and economies of scale. In this case, the foreign

    direct investment is termed as

    'efficiency-seeking.'

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    12/28

    Introduction

    Declaration. In the FDI Council, she led the governance task force from 2003 to 2004 and

    became President-Elect in 2003 and President in 2005.

    Maurice Kugler is a Colombian economist born in 1967. He received his Ph.D. in

    Economics from UC Berkeley in 2000, as well as a M.Sc.(Econ) and a B.Sc. (Econ) both

    from the London School of Economics. He was named in 2007 to the inaugural CIGI

    Chair in International Public Policy by the Laurier School of Business and Economics. In2008, CIGI, the Centre for International Governance Innovation, is jointly with

    University of Waterloo and Wilfrid Laurier University launching the Balsillie School for

    International Affairs, under the sponsorship of the entrepreneur and philanthropist Jim

    Balsillie.In his work on spillovers from foreign direct investment (FDI), Kugler has

    shown that the presence of multinational corporation affiliates (MNC) can yield

    technological opportunities for host country producers in upstream sectors, especially

    when the MNC subsdiary is an exporter and the potential spillover recipient firm has

    absorptive capacity to adopt new technology. When subsidiaries and local firms are

    connected through the production chain, then FDI generates transmission of

    technological knowhow as input suppliers are the recipients of information from their

    clients.

    A study on the link between labor migration and FDI shows them to be complementary

    rather than substitutes as standard trade theory would suggest. In a neoclassical model,

    for the capital-labor ratios to equalize, in the presence of factor mobility, either jobs flow

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    13/28

    to workers in the form of capital inflows or workers flow to jobs in the form of migration,

    in countries with relatively low capital-labor ratios. In this context, migration and FDI

    would be substitutes. However, if migration leads to information flows about investment

    opportunities in the origin country of workers entering the labor force in their destination

    country, there can be a dynamic complementarity between migration and subsequent

    FDI.

    The shutdown of an FDI enterprise established for natural resources exploration

    The recommendation in paragraph 383 of BPM5 is that "expenditures of direct

    investment enterprises established for exploration of minerals and other natural resources

    in an economy are treated as capital expenditures (fixed capital formation)." In addition,

    the text stipulates that "if the exploration proves unsuccessful and results in a shutdown

    of the enterprise, no further balance of payments entries are recorded. Rather, a negative

    stock adjustment is made in the direct investment position of the direct investor in the

    host economy, and an equal reduction is made in the liability position of that economy tothat of the direct investor. (Both adjustments fall under the heading other adjustments in

    the international investment position.)" Paragraph 60 of the OECD Benchmark Definition

    of Foreign Direct Investment (Benchmark) uses similar language.

    However, some balance of payments compilers have argued that a stream of negative

    reinvested earnings flows should be recorded in the current account of the host economy

    over a number of years until the stock of fixed capital corresponding to the total

    exploration expenditures of the direct investment enterprise has been fully amortised as

    consumption of fixed capital, with corresponding entries recorded for the investing

    economy. Such treatment would be consistent with the System of National Accounts 1993

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    14/28

    recommends that the capitalized exploration costs should be amortized as consumption of

    fixed capital over the average service lives of such exploration assets. According to that

    argument, the direct investment enterprise continues to exist and the equity value remains

    until it is fully amortized. Each year, the direct investment enterprise will have negative

    reinvested earnings equivalent to the amortization of the exploration asset. If the

    amortization approach is not adopted, there is an asymmetric treatment of unsuccessful

    expenditures in natural resources exploration in the host economy's national balance

    sheets, as such expenditures of "national" enterprises would be amortized whereas those

    of direct investment enterprises would be written-off.

    It is important to note that this last recommendation overturns the practice described in

    the BOP Textbook , which excludes from the FDI data transactions between nonfinancial

    FDI enterprises and affiliated SPEs with the sole purpose of financial intermediation. The

    effect of the recommendation is that there will no longer be any difference in the

    treatment of SPEs that have the sole purpose of financial intermediation and SPEs that

    have the primary purpose of financial intermediationthe FDI data are to include both

    (i) transactions between nonfinancial FDI enterprises and affiliated SPEs with the sole

    purpose of financial intermediation, and (ii) transactions between nonfinancial FDI

    enterprises and affiliated SPEs with the primary purpose of financial intermediation.

    The Committee also agreed that, in light of concerns expressed by some members of the

    OECD and ECB groups, the decision about the inclusion in the FDI data of financial

    transactions between units that are not financial intermediaries and affiliated financial

    SPEs abroad would be re-examined in the context of the next revision of the Balance of

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    15/28

    Payments Manual. In the meantime, countries that exclude such transactions from the

    direct investment data are encouraged to explain their practices and if possible to publish

    memorandum items to facilitate international comparability.

    Payments associated with the acquisition of a right to undertake a direct investment

    In many developing or transition economies, the government requires the payment of a

    fixed amount of money by direct investors for the right to undertake a direct investment

    in the host economy. Often, but not always, these operating or concession rights are

    related to the extraction of natural resources. In transition economies, compilers refer to

    these payments as "bonuses". They are legal transactions and should not be associated

    with poor governance. The issue was to determine whether or not such bonuses constitute

    direct investment transactions and to recommend a common recording practice for such

    transactions.

    Data

    VisionPLUS is a transaction processing software application from First Data

    International (FDI). Originally developed by the Paysys Research and Development

    Group, this application is mainly used for credit card transaction processing by

    multinational banks and transaction processing companies. Banks use this application to

    store and process credit card accounts and process transactions (Visa, Mastercard,

    American Express, Europay, private label transactions). The rough estimate of number of

    cards processed on different versions of this application software around the world is 350

    million.

    Modules

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    16/28

    VisionPLUS is an account processing system. VisionPLUS consists of modules that work

    together to manage a companys credit processing environment. The main modules of

    Visionplus include:

    * Credit Management System (CMS) - account processing module

    * Collections Tracking Analysis (CTA) - delinquent collections module

    * Account Services Management (ASM) - customer services module

    * Financial Authorisation System (FAS) - financial authorisations module

    * Letters tracking System (LTS) - letter generation module* Security Sub System (SSC) - user access control module

    * Interchange Tracking System (ITS) - dispute tracking module

    * Transaction Management System (TRAMS) - front-end processor

    * Merchant BankCard System (MBS) - merchant acquiring system

    * VisionPLUS Messaging eXchange (VMx) - XML messaging gateway to

    VisionPLUS

    * Hierarchy company system (HCS) supports commercial card clients

    * Loyalty Management System (LMS) - Managing of loyalty points based on

    transactions done.

    * Direct Payment Utility (DPU) Tool for recurring and one-time payment,

    which provides different payment options and allows for processing and managing

    balance transfer.

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    17/28

    Litrature review

    DPU is now included as part of CMS-Latoo

    Visionplus offers banks the flexibility to have their own features and functionalities. Out

    of the above modules CMS plays an important part, as all account related activities are

    posted in the CMS module.

    Literature review

    The VisionPlus Software was introduced by Paysys International Inc. in 1996. In 2001,

    FDI acquired Paysys and since then VisionPlus is an FDI product.[edit]Versions

    1983 CardPac was released by CCS. Its main market was the bankcard industry (Visa and

    MasterCard transaction processing only).

    1988 Vision21 was released for the private label card market by CCSI

    1991 VisionPLUS for both private label and bankcard market by CCSI

    1998 VisionPLUS 2.5 was released by Paysys

    2000 VisionPLUS 8.0 was released by Paysys

    2006 VisionPLUS 8.01 was released by First Data

    2007 VisionPLUS 8.15 was released by First Data

    2008 VisionPLUS 8.17 was released by First Data

    The current version is 8.34.

    A 1997 review of countries' practices for compiling data on foreign direct investment

    (FDI) transactions indicated that the treatment of three types of FDI transactions cause

    confusion among compilers:

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    18/28

    Transactions with affiliated financial intermediaries

    Payments associated with the acquisition of a right to undertake a direct investment

    The shutdown of an FDI enterprise established for natural resources exploration

    Methodology

    Following consultations with the OECD and ECB groups, the Committee decided at its

    October 2001 meeting that the recommended treatment of payments for the right to

    undertake a direct investment is to be as follows:

    The contra-entry to the payment of a rent (bonus) by a non-resident investor to the

    government authorities should be recorded under direct investment when there is a

    clear intention to establish a direct investment enterprise (such as in the case of a

    contractual arrangement between the investor and the government).

    The contra-entry to the payment of a rent by a non-resident enterprise, when no

    direct investment enterprise is or will be established, should be recorded under

    "income; investment income; other investment" until a "rent" sub-component of

    income is included in the balance of payments manual. Rent would be paid by non-

    resident enterprises when they make payments to exploit movable natural resources

    such as in the case of tree cutting rights or fishing rights in a country's territorial

    waters.

    The New Economic Partnership for Africas Development (NEPAD) recorded that in the

    1990s, regulatory and other reforms have been introduced by a number of governments to

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    19/28

    make their economies more attractive to foreign investors. Today, these regulatory

    conditions are on a par with those in other developing countries. For example, many more

    countries now allow profits to be repatriated freely or offer tax incentives and similar

    inducements to foreign investors. Many African countries have investment promotion

    agencies (IPAs), to assist these investors. And yet, no FDI has come to Africa (in fact,

    capital has flown out of Africa see below). A former Minister of Finance of an African

    country said: We have removed our shirt and trousers to attract FDI; what more do they

    expect us to do?

    As for South Africa that has rapidly liberalised its trade and investment regimes since

    independence, capital has left the country rather than coming in. As the London

    Economist, in a special survey of South Africa in 2001, recorded:

    And by the standards of other countries, South Africa has lured relatively little

    foreign direct investment: $32 per head in 1994-99, compared with $106 for Brazil,

    $252 for Argentina, $333 for Chile. At the same time, money has been leaving

    South Africa: the $9.8 billion it invested abroad in 1994-99 exceeded the inward

    flow by about $1.6 billion. And its big companies, long confined by apartheid's

    isolation, are now anxious to seek stock-exchange listings abroad. So in the past

    few years, Anglo American (mining), Billiton (mining), Old Mutual (insurance),

    South African Breweries and Dimension Data (a hugely successful information-

    technology company) have all sought primary listings elsewhere.

    Results

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    20/28

    he panel presentation titled South-South FDI vs. North-South FDI: Southern

    Perspectives explored the hypothesis that South-South FDI differs from North-South

    FDI in two main respects: (i) because the investing firms are less risk-averse given their

    familiarity (in their home country) with similar operating environments to that of the

    receiving country; and (ii) because the efficiency, technology, skill, product quality, etc.

    'gaps' between investor and receiving country are smaller. IDRCproject participants in

    the panel included Stephen Gelb (Edge Institute, South Africa), Nguyen Thang (Vietnam

    Academy of Social Sciences), and Rajiv Kumar (Indian Council for Research on

    International Economic Relations).

    The session, chaired by David Kaplan of University of Cape Town, focused on two

    questions: are southern firms more willing to invest in other developing countries, and do

    they provide more potential for positive spillovers and benefits to host countries? Dr.

    Gelb noted that analysis of inward FDI inflows (investment coming into a country by

    foreign firms) in Kenya, Uganda and South Africa does not support an affirmative

    response to either question. Similarly, Dr. Thangs analysis of inward FDI inflows into

    Vietnam does not provide clear evidence on the technology spillover advantages,

    although familiarity with the region and with the culture seem to have played a vital role

    in shaping the FDI landscape in Vietnam.

    The session featured preliminary results of the following IDRC supported projects:

    1) Foreign Direct Investment Behaviour in Low and Middle Income Countries , and

    2) South-South Links: Third World Multinationals and Development in South Africa,

    http://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-97587-201-1-DO_TOPIC.htmlhttp://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-89664-201-1-DO_TOPIC.htmlhttp://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-89664-201-1-DO_TOPIC.htmlhttp://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-97587-201-1-DO_TOPIC.html
  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    21/28

    East Africa and India (for an overview on the work of these projects, click on the links

    above).

    The panel was held on June 10 in Cape Town as part of the Annual Bank Conference on

    Development Economics (ABCDE). The ABCDE conference as a whole was on the

    overarching theme of People, Politics & Globalization and combined plenary sessions

    with over 20 parallel sessions on a wide range of topics.

    Conclusion

    The reigning orthodoxy in neo-liberal economics

    The reigning orthodoxy in neo-liberal economics on FDI boils down to five canonical

    truths:

    FDI is necessary for the development of the Third World.

    Without FDI there will be no growth.

    FDI brings inter alia efficient management of resources, technology, a culture of competition, and access to global markets.

    Nobody is forcing the South to seek FDI; the governments themselves want it.

    The private sector is the engine of growth; hence countries in the South must deregulate

    their economies, and privatise state assets as fast as possible.

    More than 90% of literature, and third world government policies, are dominated by this

    view. In a brief paper, it is not necessary to repeat the arguments. The principal argument,

    simply stated, is the following: Aid and loans in the 1960s and 70s created aid

    dependency and the debt crisis in the 1980s and 90s. FDI is the best source of

    development finance, on the grounds, among other, that it is self-liquidating since foreign

    http://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-89664-201-1-DO_TOPIC.htmlhttp://www.idrc.ca/ggp/ev-89664-201-1-DO_TOPIC.html
  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    22/28

    investors have to show profits for the host country as well as for themselves; and it does

    not lead to debt overhang.

    b) FDI is neither good nor bad; it all depends on how you deal with it

    A more qualified proposition is made (e.g. in the Oxfam Briefing paper) that properly

    regulated FDI can bring growth, jobs, technology, skills, market a

    ccess and development; that its negative effects must be balanced with its good effects; or

    that FDI must be "sequenced", or be subject to some kind of Tobin Tax. FDI is neither

    good nor bad; it all depends on how you deal with it. This view is now becoming popular

    in many circles, including some reformed neo-liberal economists, especially after the

    East Asian and Argentina crises of 1997 2001.

    c) Aid Created Debt Crisis; FDI Will Create An Even Greater Crisis Of

    Development

    More recent empirical evidence suggests a completely different picture. Analysts like

    David Woodard argue that if aid created the debt crisis, FDI will create an even greater

    crisis of development, looming not in too distant future. This view challenges both the

    reigning neo-liberal orthodoxy, and the above stated more qualified perspective. The

    view is further explored below in the next section.

    d) FDI is Not a Development Tool at all; it is a Response to Systemic Crisis of the

    Developed Countries

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    23/28

    A more radical alternative view is presented in a separate SEATINI Fact Sheet (What is

    FDI? ). It argues that FDI, essentially, is a tool (one among many) in the economic

    arsenal of the developed industrialised countries in their overall strategy to control the

    resources and markets of the South. This control is necessary in order for Western

    corporations to counter against the downward pressure that is continually exerted by

    workers on Corporate profitability. FDI is a means to resolve the Wests own systemic

    contradictions. Contrary to its claim, it is not a means to assist the developing countries.

    However, FDI is well marketed by the West through development literature and

    through institutions such as the IMF, the World Bank, the WTO, and even the UNCTAD.

    2. Does FDI Bring Development ? The Experience of Mexico, East Asia and

    Argentina

    Mexico, Thailand, Indonesia, the Philippines, Malaysia and Argentina are among the

    countries often cited by the World Bank, the IMF and mainstream economists as model

    countries that opened their doors to free trade and free flow of capital on the assumption

    that these would bring development to them. What has been their experience?

    In 1995, Mexico faced a payments crisis, and there was a run on the banks. The economy

    took a downward spin, and the middle classes took the brunt of the crisis. As for the

    distressed American banks, they were baled out by the US Treasury. The tequilafactor reverberated disconcertingly for several months in the region. Since 1995, Mexico

    liberalised further its trade and investment regimes. It is now facing massive

    deindustrialisation and joblessness.

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    24/28

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    25/28

    debt crisis, arise because of capital inflows are insufficient to cover current account

    deficits. When this is reached, capital inflows fell sharply, compounding the problem....

    (However) vulnerability to financial crisis is primarily associated with large current

    account deficits, the associated accumulation of foreign exchange liabilities (which in

    turn add to the deficits), and a resulting acute dependence on foreign capital to finance

    the deficits.

    The truth about FDI is that, like drug addiction, it creates dependency the more FDI a

    developing country secures, the more it needs to service it and keep the system going.

    Woodward writes:

    Simplistically, FDI flows may be seen as equivalent to borrowing at an interest rate of

    16-18% p.a. for developing countries as a whole, and 24-30% in sub-Saharan Africa, so

    that net outward resource transfers can only be avoided by allowing inward FDI stocks to

    grow at this rate. This implies a rapid expansion relative to the ability to meet the foreign

    exchange costs.

    Drawing from the experience of Malaysia, Woodward reckons that when the FDI stocks

    (as opposed to flow) in a developing country reaches 48% of GDP (which in many

    African countries it has), then it is in the crisis zone. Indeed, the danger point for

    other developing countries may be significantly below 48%

    Woodward, at the time of his study, had not considered the case of Argentina, which it

    turns out, proves his point. Argentina has long been modelled by the IMF/WB experts as

    the paragon of the Washington Consensus, an exemplary country that had abolished trade

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    26/28

    barriers, had opened itself up to the free inflow and outflow of capital, had tied its

    currency to the US dollar (the Currency Board Automatic Adjustment Mechanism), had

    privatised practically everything, from banks to malls, to attract FDI. In December 2001

    the model collapsed like a pack of cards. The country simply disintegrated in a morass

    of economic, social and political chaos following the default on $155 billion of debt - the

    largest in history.

    If the developing countries do not take heed of the evidence before their very eyes, and

    their leaders continue to peddle the idea that somehow FDI will get their countries out of

    the poverty trap, then one of two conclusions follow. Either they are persuaded by the

    incessant misinformation by Bretton Woods institutions and neo-liberal economists

    among their own ranks, or they are too desperate, and cannot think of any alternative way

    out of their poverty trap.

    3. The Truth About FDI in Africa

    There is an argument that Africa has fallen behind other countries because it does not

    have conditions adequate to attract FDI.

    The truth is that Africa has done more to oblige overseas investors than almost any other

    continent, and yet investments have gone to other continents. In Africa, it has gone

    primarily to countries like Angola - because of its oil and in spite of over three decades of

    instability. Nothing has come to those countries, such as Zambia, that have almost fully

    liberalised their investment regimes far more than say China or India.

    References

  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    27/28

    ^ Sridhar, V., and Vijay Prashad. 2007. Wal-Mart with Indian Characteristics.

    CONNECTICUT LAW REVIEW 39 (4):1785-1803.

    ^ Sridhar, V., and Vijay Prashad. 2007. Wal-Mart with Indian Characteristics.

    CONNECTICUT LAW REVIEW 39 (4):1785-1803.

    ^ U.S. Reforms Promote Openness Retrieved on 2010-03-10

    ^ Foreign Direct Investment Facts and Myths Retrieved on 2010-03-10

    ^ Benefits of FDI The International Trade Administration. Retrieved on 2010-03-10

    ^ Foreign direct investment in China jumps 32% CBC Canada. Retrieved on 2010-

    03-10

    Aliber, R.Z:" A Theory of Direct Foreign Investment", in, Kindleberger C.P [ edit}

    the International Corporation, A Symposium , MIT press, 1970.

    Anand, J & Kogut, B: " Technological Capabilities of Countries, Firm Rivalry and

    Foreign Direct Investment", in, Journal of International Business Studies

    [ hereafter JIBS ], vol. 28, no. 3, 1997.

    Aristotelous, K. & Fountas, S: "An Empirical Analysis of Inward Foreign Direct

    Investment Flows in the EU with Emphasis on the Market Enlargement

    Hypothesis", in, Journal of Common Market Studies , [hereafter JCMS ], vol.

    34, no. 4, 1994.

    Balassa, Bela: " American Direct Investment in the Common Market", Banca

    Nazionale Del Lavoro, Quarterly Review, 1966.

    Barrel, R & Pain, N: "The Growth of Foreign Direct Investment in Europe", in,

    National Institute Economic Review, No. 160, April 1997.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-1%23cite_ref-1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-2%23cite_ref-2http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-3%23cite_ref-3http://www.siteselection.com/issues/2009/jan/Cover/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-4%23cite_ref-4http://www.directforeigninvestment.net/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-5%23cite_ref-5http://mi.o2.ie/www.investamerica.gov/home/iia_main_001154.asphttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-6%23cite_ref-6http://www.cbc.ca/money/story/2009/12/15/china-foreign-investment.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-1%23cite_ref-1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-2%23cite_ref-2http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-3%23cite_ref-3http://www.siteselection.com/issues/2009/jan/Cover/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-4%23cite_ref-4http://www.directforeigninvestment.net/http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-5%23cite_ref-5http://mi.o2.ie/www.investamerica.gov/home/iia_main_001154.asphttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investment#cite_ref-6%23cite_ref-6http://www.cbc.ca/money/story/2009/12/15/china-foreign-investment.html
  • 8/8/2019 Document 1... Mini Thesis Final 2

    28/28

    Benito, G.R.G. & Gripsrud, G: " The Expansion of Foreign Direct Investments:

    Discrete Rational Location Choices or a Cultural Learning Process?", in,

    JIBS , vol. 23, no. 3, 1992.

    Bouma, E: " Foreign Direct Investment", in, Jepma, C.J & Rhoen, A.P. [ edit]:

    International Trade: A Business Perspective , Longman, 1996.

    Brewer, T.L: " Government Policies, Market Imperfections, and Foreign Direct

    Investment", in, JIBS , vol. 24, no. 1, 1993.

    Appendix

    1. Litrature

    2. Introduction

    3. Literature Review

    4. Data

    5. Methodology

    6. Conclusion

    7. References