8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

1/36

AOFHCL Z^HRO\gmq hq qmdo{ `e~ `eku{oa hfz~epofocq5

QM^_C D[L

PH[GMI MLLM^\MI

[M_^MNG QGMAMCH[^HDMCQG DECA_^H

PM^_C BE[GH

PHA_ ^M[QELH

EF= Qo~f> Z~ebokq

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

2/36

ECQM^LOQ

Mlocam

Qgo Aofhcl Z~hro

Hcahmc m|m~a |hcco~{

Q]F

QMQM [QOOI

F & F @O[

COH IQA#

>

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

3/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qgo Aofhcl Z~hro

Qgo zu~ze{o e` qgo Aofhcl Z~hro |m{ qe ~okelchro qge{o |ge

owkoiioa hc }umihqx kecq~ei mca m{ m |mx e` a~hphcl }umihqxkecq~ei

Aofhcl Z~hro |m{ o{qmnih{goa hc =8?=

A~# \# O# Aofhcl |m{ eco e` qgo |e~ia{ iomao~{ e` ]umihqx

fmcmlofocq

Hq |m{ mi{e o{qmnih{goa qe qgmcd A~# Aofhcl `e~ gh{

mkkefzih{gfocq{ mca hfzmkq hc qgo Bmzmco{o hcau{q~x

;

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

4/36

ECQM^LOQ

Aofhcl M|m~a Kmqole~ho{

Aofhcl Z~hro

Aofhcl Z~hro`e~

Hcahphaumi{

AofhclMzzihkmqhec

Z~hro

]umihqx Kecq~eiM|m~a

@e~ @mkqe~ho{

1

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

5/36

ECQM^LOQ

Mzzihkmqhec Z~eko{{

Kec{uiq |hqg qgoAofhcl Z~hro

Keffhqqoo

Kefzioqo &{unfhqmzzihkmqhec e~f

[unfh{{hec e` ]Kz~mkqhko{ & Ao{k~hzqhec

e` Nu{hco{{ mkqhphqho{

AekufocqOwmfhcmqhec ZM[[O[ Oihlhnio `e~

ec{hqoowmfhcmqhec@

MHI[

Owmfhco~ {oca{ qgomzzihkmcq qgoh~`hcahcl{

Ec[hqo Owmf# &qgo aokh{hec e`qgo |hcco~{ h{

fmao nx qgoNem~a e` Ah~okqe~{

Qoioph{oaMcceuckofocq

?

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

6/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qgo Aofhcl Z~hro @EK_[

Fmcmlofocq zeihkho{ mca qgoh~ aoziexfocq ~olm~ahcl }umihqxfmcmlofocq

Co| z~eaukq aopoiezfocq%e~ |e~d z~eko{{ hccepmqhec

Fmhcqocmcko mca hfz~epofocq e` z~eaukq mca ezo~mqhecmi}umihqho{

O{qmnih{gfocq e` {x{qof{ `e~ fmcmlhcl }umihqx) }umcqhqx)aoihpo~x) ke{q{) {m`oqx) ocph~ecfocq) oqk#

Keiiokqhec mca mcmix{h{ e` }umihqx hc`e~fmqhec mca uqhihrmqhec e`hc`e~fmqhec qokgceielx

Gufmc ~o{eu~ko{ aopoiezfocq

>:

>:

>:

=:

=?

=?

0

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

7/36

ECQM^LOQ

Q]F Co| @eku{

::> >::; >::? >::7>::=

Fmcu`mkqu~o{

Muqefeqhpo & Hcau{q~hmi

`~hkqhec fmqo~hmi{

;~a im~lo{q q~mkqe~

kefzmcx hc qgo |e~ia)

ezo~mqhcl hc >: keucq~ho{

\e~ia{ :=:

8

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

10/36

ECQM^LOQ

QMQM [QOOI

AOFHCL MZZIHKMQHEC Z^HRO >::7

=:

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

11/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qmqm [qooi

@h~{q hcqol~mqoa {qooi kefzmcx hc qgo |e~ia) euq{hao e` Bmzmc) qe

|hc qgo Aofhcl Mzzihkmqhec Z~hro

\e~ia,{ 0qg im~lo{q & >ca fe{q loel~mzghkmiix ahpo~{h`hoa {qooi

z~eauko~) |hqg ezo~mqhec{ hc >1 keucq~ho{

Hc xom~ >::=>::> m{ zo~ qgo \e~ia [qooi Axcmfhk{) Qmqm [qooi

nokmfo qgo ie|o{q ke{q z~eauko~ e` {qooi hc qgo |geio |e~ia

\ec qgo >::7 Aofhcl z~hro `e~ mkghophcl ah{qhckqhpo

zo~`e~fmcko hfz~epofocq{ qg~eulg qgo mzzihkmqhec e` Q]F

==

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

12/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qmqm [qooi{ beu~cox qe|m~a{ Aofhcl Z~hro

Z~he~ qe =88:) qgo kefzmcx |m{ z~hfm~hix hc|m~a ieedhcl) ceq

m``okqoa fukg |hqg qgo gmzzochcl{ noxeca Hcahmc okecefx \hqg lienmihrmqhec qgo kefzmcx gma qe qghcd ,euq e` qgo new,#

Hq cooaoa qe ~oao`hco qgo nu{hco{{ oiofocq{ '1 F{ & 1Z{()

ph{hec) {q~mqolho{) fmcmlofocq qeei mca qokgch}uo{ oqk

Maezqoa qgo Qeqmi ]umihqx Fmcmlofocq 'Q]F( zghie{ezgx m{ m

zm~q e` Kefzoqhqhpo [q~mqolx hc imqo =878#

Hq {qm~qoa zuqqhcl fm{{hpo o``e~q ec oaukmqhec & q~mhchcl ec

Q]F#

=>

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

13/36

ECQM^LOQ

Beu~cox Kecqhcuo{

H[E 8::=)8::> ko~qh`hkmqhec e` pm~heu{ fmcu`mkqu~hcl & {o~phko uchq{

Z~eko{{ Hfz~epofocq{ qg~eulg ]umihqx Hfz~epofocq Z~ebokq{']HZ,{() Pmiuo Oclhcoo~hcl Z~ebokq{ mca [ZK{

]umihqx Kh~kio{ e~ ofziexoo hcpeipofocq mca hfz~epofocq

Maezqoa qgo B C Qmqm ]umihqx M|m~a Feaoi nm{oa ec Fmikeif

Nmia~hlo Feaoi `e~ hq{ pm~heu{ ahph{hec{ hc qgo kefzmcx hc =88>

Nockgfm~dhcl mca NZ^ kefziofocqoa qgo Q]F o``e~q{ mq Qmqm [qooi

hc qo~f{ e` kecqhcueu{ hfz~epofocq

Nmimckoa [ke~o Km~a hcqol~mqoa |hqg Q]F {q~mqolx hc =887

=;

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

14/36

ECQM^LOQ

M{zh~o

PH[HEC >::::> nokefhcl mc OPM ze{hqhpo kefzmcx mca

mi{e {u{qmhchcl mca hfz~ephcl OPM xom~ ec xom~

Mc hcqol~mqoa hfz~epofocq z~el~mf cmfoa M[ZH^O) mk~ecxf `e~

M{zh~mqhecmi Hchqhmqhpo{ qe ^oqmhc Owkoiiocko) |m{ imuckgoa m{ m

poghkio qe mkghopo qgh{ lemi

Hq ceq ecix `eku{hcl ec qeei{ & qokgch}uo{ nuq mi{e ec qgo ze|o~ e`

fhca# Zghie{ezgx opeipo{ m~euca {oi` kec`haocko & ao{h~o qe owkoi

Hckiuao{ hfz~epofocq qeei{ ihdo [ullo{qhec Fmcmlofocq) [hw[hlfm) QZF) Dce|ioalo Fmcmlofocq) QEK mca {efo eqgo~{ ~oimqoaqe Q]F z~hckhzio{ e` Amhix Fmcmlofocq) Zeihkx Fmcmlofocq)

Z~eniof {eiphcl mca Qm{d mkghophcl

=1

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

15/36

ECQM^LOQ

Hc >::?) kecaukqoa m Q]F ahmlce{h{ miecl |hqg qgo B_[O qomf#

Qgo Q]F ahmlce{h{ lmpo qgof aoozo~ ucao~{qmcahcl mca kim~hqx ecqgoh~ mzz~emkg qe }umihqx2 |gmq m~om{ {geuia no maa~o{{oa) |ge

{geuia loq hcpeipoa hc |gmq mkqhphqho{) oqk#

Qgox {zokh`hkmiix ieedoa mq2

[q~mqolhk m{zokq{ e~ zeihkx fmcmlofocq2 ~oieedhcl mq qgo

nmimckoa {ke~o km~a) ieedhcl mq m~om{ cooaoa qe kgmclo qgo

nu{hco{{) oqk

Amhix fmcmlofocq2 fmcmlhcl qgo amxqeamx ezo~mqhec{)

oc{u~hcl qgmq qgox m~o {qmnio) ieedhcl `e~ hck~ofocqmi

hfz~epofocq{) oqk

Zoezio hcpeipofocq2 hcpeiphcl zoezio hc qghcdhcl mneuq

hfz~epofocq mkqhphqho{ {ukg m{ }umihqx kh~kio{) {ullo{qhec

fmcmlofocq) dce|ioalo fmcqgmc) oqk#

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

16/36

ECQM^LOQ

\gx qgox |ec5

Qgo Aofhcl Mzzihkmqhec Z~hro |m{ m|m~aoa qe Qmqm auo qe qgo ~okelchqhec mca

mkkefzih{gfocq{ m{ `eiie|{#

@h~{q) Qmqm ihcd{ nu{hco{{ {q~mqolx mca Q]F kie{oix hc m keezo~mqhpo fmcco~)

`eku{hcl ec }umihqx# Nx u{hcl Q]F m{ m qeei qe mkghopo qgo {q~mqolx) Qmqm gm{

ocbexoa ze{hqhpo o``okq ec hfz~ephcl qgo }umihqx e` z~eaukq%{o~phko) ocgmckhcl

n~mca pmiuo) mca hck~om{hcl z~eaukqhec peiufo#

[okeca) Qmqm gm{ {ukko{{`uiix hfziofocqoa pm~heu{ z~ebokq{) hc e~ao~ qe

ke~~o{zeca |hqg m ~mzha l~e|qg e` Hcahmc hcau{q~x) {ukg m{ qgo kec{q~ukqhec e` co|

{gm`q `u~cmko) kmiioa qgo G`u~cmko) mca ocim~lofocq e` `mkhihqho{ `e~ }umcqhqmqhpo

owzmc{hec#

Qgh~a) ziocqh`ui o``e~q{ {ooc hc qgo hfz~epofocq mkqhphqho{) fmhcix nx {fmii l~euz

mkqhphqho{) qe ocgmcko z~eniof {eiphcl kmzmnhihqx#

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

17/36

ECQM^LOQ

\gmq qgox qgof{oipo{ {mx

Qgo z~eko{{ e` |e~dhcl `e~ mca |hcchcl qgo kepoqoa Aofhcl

Mzzihkmqhec Z~hro hc >::7 gm{ nooc m gufnihcl mca ocihlgqochclowzo~hocko `e~ Qmqm [qooi#

Gufnihcl) nokmu{o hq goizoa Qmqm [qooi zhczehcq

hckec{h{qockho{ hc hq{ mzz~emkg e` fmcmlhcl hq{ nu{hco{{ nm{oa ec

ielhkmi z~hckhzio{ qgmq m~o e`qoc kmfeu`imloa au~hcl qgo leea

qhfo{ mca {u~`mko ecix au~hcl m k~h{h{#

Ocihlgqochcl) nokmu{o qgo {mfo z~eko{{ gm{ goizoa Qmqm [qooi

`eku{ ec hq{ {q~oclqg{ hc m~om{ qgmq m~o fe{q k~hqhkmi qe hq{

nu{hco{{#

N Fuqgu~mfmc) fmcmlhcl ah~okqe~)

Qmqm [qooi#

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

18/36

ECQM^LOQ

FMGHCA^M & FMGHCA^M @O[

AOFHCL MZZIHKMQHEC Z^HRO >::;

=7

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

19/36

ECQM^LOQ

F&F2 Qgo ^ema qe Q]F

Fmghca~m Q~mkqe~{ nmlloa qgo Aofhcl Z~hro hc >::;

Hc =88::< mca qm~loqoa qe mk}uh~o qgo kepoqoa

Z~hro nx >::;

Qgo Q]F beu~cox |m{ hc qg~oo zgm{o{2

=# Hcq~eaukqhec zgm{o2 =88:81

># Z~efeqhec zgm{o2 =88?88

;# Aopoiezfocq zgm{o2 ~ef >::: ec|m~a{

=8

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

20/36

ECQM^LOQ

Hcq~eaukqhec zgm{o '=88:81(

Qgo `h~{q zgm{o enbokqhpo{ |o~o

'm( hfz~ephcl fmcu`mkqu~hcl }umihqx qg~eulg z~eko{{ kecq~ei

'n( hfz~ephcl qgo }umihqx e` neulgq euq kefzecocq{) mca'k( hck~om{hcl z~eaukqhphqx mca ~oauko qgo ke{q e` zee~ }umihqx

Hchqhmqhpo{2

[qmqh{qhkmi z~eko{{ kecq~ei '[ZK(Nu{hco{{ z~eko{{ ~ooclhcoo~hcl 'NZ^( hc fmcu`mkqu~hcl

Z~efeqhec Zgm{o '=88?=888(

Qgo `eku{ |m{ {qmcam~ah{mqhec mca hfz~epofocq e` mii ezo~mqhec{#

>:

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

21/36

ECQM^LOQ

Aopoiezfocq Zgm{o '>:::>::;(

Hchqhmqhpo{2

Ocgmckoa u{o e` Aofhcl Z~hro Luhaoihco{# [x{qofmqhk u{o e` qeei{ ihdo ]umihqx @uckqhec

Aoziexfocq ']@A() Ao{hlc ^opho|{) A@FOM{) Z@FOM{)

KMO mca [ZK

_{o e` mapmckoa {qmqh{qhkmi qeei{ ihdo AEO mca [hw

[hlfm# O{qmnih{gfocq e` Fmghca~m [mio{ [x{qof 'F[[( `e~

hfz~ephcl Kgmccoi Kmzmnhihqx) miecl{hao AEO mca [hw

[hlfm#

=::/ hcpeipofocq e` mii ofziexoo{ hc hfz~epofocq

qomf{#

>=

K iha qh Zg '>::1 (

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

22/36

ECQM^LOQ

Kec{eihamqhec Zgm{o '>::1 $(=# Hfziofocqmqhec e` B]F luhaoihco{2

[q~oclqgochcl Dmhroc kuiqu~o & Zeihkx Aoziexfocq#

># [q~oclqgoc _ch}uo Mkqhphqho{2

[q~oclqgochcl Co| Z~eaukq Aopoiezfocq z~eko{{#

Hcq~eaukqhec e` Iomc fmcu`mkqu~hcl mca QZF #

>|mx Keffuchkmqhec |hqg qgo [uzziho~{ mca Ofziexoo{ '^omkgEuq mca Dguim Fmckg( mca Aomio~{ 'Aomio~ Ah~okq(#

;# Fmghca~m ]umihqx \e~d{ aopoiezoa nx FH]

>>

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

23/36

ECQM^LOQ

Noco`hq{ ao~hpoa `~ef Q]F

Qgo noco`hq{ ao~hpoa epo~ qgo xom~{ kmc no {uffoa uz m{ `eiie|{2

'm( ~oaukqhec hc ~o|e~d

'n( ~oaukqhec hc ~obokqhec mq {uzziho~{, oca m{ |oii

'k( hfz~epofocq hc `hoia }umihqx

'a( hck~om{oa z~eaukqhphqx) ku{qefo~ {mqh{`mkqhec)

ofziexoo hcpeipofocq hc kecqhcueu{ hfz~epofocq

'o( hcq~eaukqhec e` co| feaoi{ =? feaoi{ hc qg~oo xom~{#

>;

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

24/36

ECQM^LOQ

Q]F mq F & F Rmgoo~mnma _chq

Oco~lx Kec{ufzqhec Q~oca{2

[zokh`hk oiokq~hkmi oco~lx kec{ufzqhec hc

d\g% o}# poghkio

Oco~lx Ke{q m{ / e` fmcu`mkqu~hcl ke{q

O}uhpmiocq poghkio{ z~eaukoa

>1

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

25/36

ECQM^LOQ

[GO Fmcmlofocq

>?

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

26/36

ECQM^LOQ

Zm|mc Leocdm{ Fo{{mlo

>0

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

27/36

ECQM^LOQ

[GO Hfziofocqmqhec

>7

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

29/36

ECQM^LOQ

CNK NOM^HCL[

AOFHCL MZZIHKMQHEC Z^HRO >:=:

>8

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

30/36

ECQM^LOQ

COH Iqa# Zm~q e` qgo =?: xom~ eia) fuiqh

nhiihec aeiim~ K#D# Nh~im l~euz

[uzziho{ nmii nom~hcl{ qe mii fmbe~

q|e|gooio~ fmdo~{ hc Hcahm)

hckiuahcl Go~e Gecam mca Nmbmb

Muqe) m{ |oii m{ km~fmdo~{ ihdo

Fm~uqh mca Ghcau{qmc Feqe~{

Fmcu`mkqu~o{ com~ix 1#0 Fhiihec

Nom~hcl{ zo~ fecqg hc epo~ ?::

ah``o~ocq {hro{ ~mclhcl `~ef 0 ff

ne~o qe =;:: ff euqo~ ahmfoqo~

;:

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

31/36

ECQM^LOQ

M|m~a ~okelchqhec e` owkoiiocko

COH h{ qgo ecix Hcahmc kefzmcx & Nom~hcl fmcu`mkqu~o~ opo~

qe no aokim~oa |hcco~ e` Aofhcl Mzzihkmqhec Z~hro hc >:=: Hq h{ m ~o{uiq e` COH{ kecqhcueu{ `eku{ e`ofziexoo{ mca

zm~qco~{ ec }umihqx mca ~oihmnhihqx |hqg o``e~q qe|m~a{ {x{qof{

hfz~epofocq{

Qgo Q]F beu~cox {qm~qoa |mx nmkd hc xom~ =88? |goc COH |m{

ko~qh`hoa |hqg H[E8::=# Qgh{ |m{ `eiie|oa nx ][8::: hc xom~>:::) Q[=0818 hc xom~ >::;) M{{ekhmqhec e` Mfo~hkmc ^mhi~ema{

'MM^( ko~qh`hkmqhec MM^F=::; `e~ ~mhi|mx nom~hcl{ hc xom~ >::?

mca qgo QZF Owkoiiocko M|m~a hc xom~ >::7

;=

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

32/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qmclhnio Noco`hq{ '`oqkgoa QZF m|m~a hc >::7(

;>

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

33/36

ECQM^LOQ

Qmclhnio Noco`hq{ '`oqkgoa Aofhcl Z~hro hc >:=:(

;;

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

34/36

ECQM^LOQ

ZE[HQHPO O@@OKQ[

]umihqx [qmnhihrmqhec mca Hfz~epofocq

Z~eaukqhphqx Hfz~epofocq % Ke{q ^oaukqhec

Ghlgo~ [mio{ mca ghlgo~ z~e`hq{

Ku{qefo~ aoihlgq & ocgmckoa fm~doq

{gm~o%fm~lhc{

^omihrmqhec e` Qez Fmcmlofocq,{ A~omf{ hckiuahcl

Nu{hco{{ Zimc{

Q]F nx Qeqmi Zm~qhkhzmqhec mca Hfz~epofocq e`qgo E~lmchrmqhecmi Kuiqu~o#

;1

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

35/36

ECQM^LOQ

]umihqx h{ }uhqo m imax- Qgo fe~o |o ucao~{qmca go~) qgofe~o |o cooa qe iom~c mneuq go~

QGMCD XE_

;?

E

8/4/2019 Deming Prize-What It Takes

36/36

ECQM^LOQ

;0

Nhnihel~mzgx2Fm~kg >::7 Co|{ioqqo~ e` QZF Kiun Hcahmgqqz2%%|||#qzfkiunhcahm#e~l%za`%fm~kg:7Uco|{ioqqo~#za`Qhfo{ e` Hcahm Co|{zmzo~ MAgqqz2%%ozmzo~#qhfo{e`hcahm#kef%^oze{hqe~x%QEHF%>:=:%==%=:%QEHFU>:=:U==U=:U=#za`Mz~hi >::8 [zokhmi H{{uo e` QZF Kiun Hcahm KHHgqqz2%%|||#qzfkiunhcahm#e~l%mz~hi:8#za`

Co|{zmzo~ M~qhkio{gqqz2%%f#okecefhkqhfo{#kef%ZAMOQ%m~qhkio{ge|%0:=:%=:%=1%{qe~ho{%>:=:=:=1?>1:=8::#gqf

B_[O gefo zmlo|||#bu{o#e~#bz%o%aofhcl%

Qgo \# Oa|m~a{ Aofhcl Hc{qhquqo|||#aofhcl#e~l

gqqz2%%|||#q}fh#kef%aofhclz~hro#m{zqmqm {qooi mccumi ~oze~q >::7:8qmqm {qooi gefozmlogqqz2%%qmqm{qooi#kef%qmqm {qooi m{zh~o gefozmlogqqz2%%m{zh~o#qmqm{qooi#kef%

|||#fh}#hc%fmghca~m}umihqx|mx

|||#fmghca~m#kef%oco|{ioqqo~%h{{uo>/>:>::8%gqfi%}umihqx#gqfiZ~el~o{{ JQZF Qgo Co|{ioqqo~ `~ef QZF Kiun e` Hcahm

Co|{ioqqo~2 Fmghca~m & Fmghca~m Rmgoo~mnma _chqF & F Iqa2 Muqefeqhpo [okqe~ nx _#[#Be{gh) Ax# Loco~mi Fmcmlo~'Ze|o~ Zimcchcl) Oco~lx FmcmlofocFmghca~m [u{qmhcmnhihqx ^opho|) >::8=: