23
CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright © 2013 Glenn Rogers

CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

CRITICAL THINKING Understanding

The Principles And ProcessesOf Thinking Well

Chapter 5Thinking Critically About Language

ByGlenn Rogers, Ph.D.

Copyright©

2013Glenn Rogers

Page 2: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

This is a course on critical thinking. So why are we going to talk about language? Because without language you cannot be rational. Neither can you communicate. Just as critical thinking is about logic, critical thinking is about language.

One of the ways we understand the world we live in is by categorizing things. Language provides you with categories for rational analysis. This thing, a chair, is like that thing, a sofa, so the two things go into a category of similar things, things you sit on, or a broader category of similar things called furniture.

These categories we have are associated with the language we learn as children. The vocabulary of our language allows us identify specific things and concepts, and think in the concrete and the abstract about those things.

Page 3: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Rationality occurs in relation to language. Indeed, it is only possible where language exists. Where there is no language, there is no rationality. Critical thinking cannot occur without the use of language. The more we understand about language, and the better we use language, the better our critical thinking will be.

Understanding What Language is and How it Works

Language is a system of symbols used for thinking and communicating.

If I think the thought, I am hungry, I have utilized language at the thought level. I cannot have the thought, formulate or articulate the thought, I am hungry, without the use of language.

If I say or write, I am hungry, I have utilized language at the communication level.

Page 4: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Understanding What Language is and How it Works

What does it mean to say that language is a system of symbols used for thinking and communicating?

Words are symbols that represent real things and the ideas and concepts that are part of our reality. For instance, when I say the word, dog, you get the image of a dog in your head.

The word, dog, is made up of the letters (symbols) d/o/g, which create another symbol, the word dog. The image in your head is also a symbol.

The word, dog, is a signifier, that represents the real thing, a real animal that we happen to refer to as a dog. The image in your head is also a signifier. It is not a real dog.

We think in images, in symbols, in signifiers, and we speak using those same symbols and signifiers.

Page 5: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Linguistic Symbols

When humans think, when we utilize our rational faculties, we make use of symbols. When we speak, we utilize symbols. We utilize symbols in nearly every aspect of our lives. We might even say that because of the way and the extent to which we use symbols, we are a symbolic species.

The thing about using symbols, about thinking and speaking in symbols, is that symbols have to be interpreted.

The Location of Meaning

It is essential, especially from the point of view of the one trying to communicate with others, that we understand where meaning is, where it is located. The short answer is that meanings are in the receiver. What does that mean?

Page 6: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

The Location of Meaning

In communication theory, the person who is speaking or writing is referred to as the sender. The person listening or reading is the receiver.

The sender has an idea in her head that she wants to communicate to another person.

To get the idea that is in her head into the head of the other person, she must encode the idea (the message she wants to send) in linguistic symbols and send those symbols (via speaking or writing) to the other person.

That person, the receiver, must receive the message and then decode it (figure out what it means).

Page 7: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

The Location of Meaning

The decoding part of the communication process is where meaning is attached, by the receiver, to the symbols that were sent by the sender.

If the receiver attaches meanings to the incoming symbols that are close to the meanings attached by the sender (in her encoding process) then communication occurs.

If the meanings attached by the receiver are not close or are different than those attached by the sender, then a miscommunication occurs.

Thus, a major concern for communicators is how their message will be received or interpreted by those who hear or read it.

Page 8: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

The Location of Meaning

But aren’t words defined in dictionaries? Aren’t we supposed to look words up so that we know what they mean? Yes. But not everyone does. Why not? Sometimes people are too lazy to look up the meaning of a word.

Sometimes they think they already know what a word means. And sometimes, a word used in one context can mean one thing, which someone might understand, and at other times the same word can mean something different, which the person might not understand.

But more problematic is the fact that we have, because of our socialization, built-in meanings for words and concepts that transcend dictionary definitions. And sometimes the meanings people attach to words are associated with how words are spoken and the context in which they are spoken.

Page 9: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

The Location of Meaning

Good critical thinkers will keep this in mind when communicating with others. The basic question to be asked when preparing to communicate with others is, how will he or she or they understand what I am about to say? Do I have to be concerned about vocabulary, about education, about experience? Yes.

Choosing the Right Words

Choosing the right words to communicate the idea you want to get across is crucial.

Page 10: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Choosing the Right Words

The right word facilitates communication; the wrong word disrupts communication. You must consider the audience to whom you are speaking, whether one person or one hundred.

You must consider their educational level, their familiarity with the subject, their knowledge of the vocabulary associated with the topic under consideration, and so forth.

You need to use words that will clarify rather than confuse. However, you don’t want to simplify (dumb down) your presentation so that it begins to feel inconsequential.

Page 11: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Choosing the Right Words

Sometimes there is only one word that will do. Sometimes, in order to do justice to a given topic, a specific or specialized vocabulary is necessary. In that case, you need to define the words you are using so that your audience will understand what you are saying.

A dictionary and Thesaurus are indispensable tools when looking for just the right word to use.

Good critical thinkers will be careful about the words they use. It is not just that you want to avoid using the wrong word; you want to choose the right word, the best word, to say exactly what you want to say, a word the audience will understand.

Page 12: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Audience

Your audience is whomever you are speaking to, whether it is your best friend or five hundred strangers. Or it is whoever will be reading the paper you are writing. Your audience may be your professor. Or it may be other students who have to read each other’s papers. Or it may be the readers of a technical journal or a popular magazine.

You need to know something about your audience. What is their general educational level? How much are they likely to know about subject you are speaking or writing about? How interested are they in the subject?

How are they going to use the information you are going to give them? Are they going to use it to make up their minds about a political issue? Will they use it to make a decision about some social or economic concern? Will the information you give them impact what kind of a car they will buy, or how they do their grocery shopping?

Page 13: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Audience

Who is your audience? Will it be mostly men or mostly women? This matters because men and women, to a degree, may focus on different concerns and utilize different criteria in the decision-making process. Will your audience be most people in their twenties or people over fifty?

Will your audience be mostly people with masters and doctors degrees or mostly people who have not completed advanced degrees? Will your audience be people with considerable wealth, or people of average income?

These kinds of considerations matter when you are preparing to speak to an audience (of one or of many) because these kinds of considerations impact how people hear (interpret) what you say. Good critical thinkers will take their audience into consideration whether preparing a presentation or simply having a conversation.

Page 14: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Purpose

What is it you are trying to accomplish in your presentation? Are you trying to inform by presenting information? Or are you trying to persuade people to take action? Perhaps you are trying to motivate them to act based on the information you are sharing with them. Perhaps your purpose is to convince a professor that you know how to write a research paper, or that you have grasped the concepts of a given subject.

What you are trying to do has a lot to do with how you go about doing it.

A good critical thinker will figure out exactly what she needs to do, what her purpose is, and then write her article, or design her presentation to do just that. Convincing and motivating people is a different process from informing them. Motivating someone requires a call to action. Informing them does not.

Page 15: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Defining Important Terms

Defining important terms is crucial to good thinking and good communication.

Suppose, for instance, that you are writing a paper on the concerns related to genetically modified organisms (GMOs) as it relates to vegetables and health concerns.

You may understand the issues related to a tomato that has been genetically modified to be bigger, or to grow faster, or to require less water or to be resistant to a certain kind of insect, or whatever the genetic modification was intended to accomplish.

But the average person you are trying to educate about the concerns of genetically modified vegetables will probably not be comfortable with the technical language.

So define and explain terms and concepts.

Page 16: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Defining Important Terms

And your definition must be helpful…

Consider the following definitions:

genetically, that is, having to do with genetics; modified, that is, having to do with changes; organisms, that is having to do with simple or complex living, growing things.

Technically, I have defined each part of the term genetically modified organism. But how helpful are my definitions for someone who is not familiar with scientific language? Not very helpful at all.

A good definition is expansive and offers insight. It clarifies and explains.

Page 17: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Univocal and Equivocal Words

Some words have only one meaning; some words have more than one meaning.

A univocal word is one that has only one meaning. A typical illustration of a univocal term is the word entomology, which refers to the study of insects. The word has no other meanings.

An equivocal term is one that has more than one meaning. The word bank is an example of an equivocal term. The word bank can refer to an economic institution where money is kept for use, saved and loaned. The word can also refer to the strip of land that runs alongside a river—as in the riverbank. The word bank can also refer to a plane turning—to turn, the plane banks.

Page 18: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Univocal and Equivocal Words

Since we can’t think without language, and since we can only think well if we can use language proficiently, good critical thinkers will be careful to avoid using equivocal terms. It is always better to use univocal terms if possible. If one must use equivocal terms, be sure the terms is defined clearly and precisely so your audience understands in what sense you are using the word.

Good critical thinkers will always be aware of the words they are using.

Emotionally Supercharged Terminology

Human beings are rational-emotive beings. We are rational and we are emotional. We cannot be all of one and none of the other. When we think we are not only utilizing our rationality, we are also utilizing our emotionality.

Page 19: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Emotionally Supercharged Terminology

What has this got to do with critical thinking? Critical thinking cannot be devoid of emotion anymore than any other aspect of our lives can be devoid of emotion. But emotions must be subject to the scrutiny of rationality.

Some people want so much to convince others that their view is correct and that it ought to be adopted that they resort to the use of emotion rather than rationality to persuade. You will often here blatant appeals to emotion in debates about various subjects.

Consider the debate regarding euthanasia. Jim is terminally ill and wants to die with dignity. He asks the doctor for something that will result in his death. The doctor gives Jim a drink that will stop his bodily functions, resulting in Jim’s death. This is active euthanasia. Critics will say that the doctor “murdered” Jim. Did the doctor “murder” Jim?

Page 20: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Emotionally Supercharged Terminology

In this example, the word “murder” is an emotionally supercharged word. At best, it’s use in this context is questionable.

A good critical thinker is always fair and will not use emotionally charged language in an attempt to sway an audience.

Linguistic Misdirection

Linguistic misdirection is using a word that means something different than what is being considered, or terminology or phraseology that focuses attention on something other than the subject under consideration.

Page 21: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Linguistic Misdirection

An example: Fred asks his boss for a raise. His boss says, “Sorry Fred, I can’t do that.” But Fred has seen the quarterly earnings report and knows the company is doing quite well. His boss could, if he would, give Fred a raise. When he says, “I can’t” what he really means is, “I won’t.”

Misdirecting a discussion is unethical. Good critical thinkers will not engage is such deceitful behavior.

Summary

We cannot think without using language so we cannot think well without using language proficiently.

Page 22: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Summary

Language is a system of spoken, written, or gestured symbols that represent or signify an idea or concept. To get an idea from my mind to yours, I have to encode the idea in words and send them to you by means of speaking, writing, or gesturing.

You, then, when you receive the encoded message, must decode it, attaching meaning to the symbols you receive. If the meanings you attach to the symbols I sent you are the same or close to the same as the meanings I have for those symbols, we communicate.

If the meanings you attach to the symbols I sent you are different, we miscommunicate.

Page 23: CRITICAL THINKING Understanding The Principles And Processes Of Thinking Well Chapter 5 Thinking Critically About Language By Glenn Rogers, Ph.D. Copyright

Thinking Critically About Language

Summary

Good critical thinks need to understand how the process works and learn to use it well, paying attention to the audience to whom they are speaking, and the purpose they are trying to accomplish. They need to define important terms, and be care about equivocal terminology.

Good critical thinks will avoid using technical jargon when they can, will not use emotionally supercharged language, and will not engage in linguistic misdirection.