52
Connection Modelling in Fire Ian Burgess

Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

  • Upload
    vuthuan

  • View
    215

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Connection Modelling in Fire

Ian Burgess

Page 2: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Definition of joint and connection

Joint

Connections

Page 3: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

EC3-1.8 Stiffness classification of joints

M

φ

Semi-rigid

Pinned S >0,5EIb/Lb

Rigid

S >kbEIb/LbKb=8 (braced frames)Kb=25 (other frames)

Page 4: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Other classifications

Strength:

• “Full-strength”: Bending strength > Strength of member.

• “Partial-strength”

• “Pinned”: Bending strength < 0.25 Strength of member.

Ductility:

• “Ductile/Class 1”: Sufficient rotation capacity to develop plastic mechanism.

• “Semi-ductile”

• “Brittle/Class 3”: Can only be used in elastic design.

Page 5: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component Modelling at Ambient Temperature

Page 6: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Beam web

Principal component zones of end-plate

M

Column web

Beam flange, web

Column web

Compression

Beam web

Column web Column

flange End plate

Tension bolts

Tension

Page 7: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

EC3-1.8 extended end-plate joint model

M

Beam web tension

Column web tension

Column flange bending End plate

bending

Bolttension

Beam flangeColumn web

compressionColumn

web shear

Page 8: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Equivalent spring model

ce

M

z2

ke,2

ke,1

z1

,

, , , , ,

11 1 1 1 1et i

cwt i cfb i bt i epb i bwt i

k =

k k k k k+ + + +

Page 9: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Simplified spring model

ce

keq

zeq

M

Page 10: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Moment-rotation behaviour in fire

Page 11: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Semi-rigid behaviour of connections in fire: original work

Late 80s – early 90s

• Design opportunity? Interest particularly based on using connection residual stiffness and strength to enhance the fire resistance of “simple” steel beams.

• Analytical studies to assess the likely advantages/problems.

Page 12: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Semi-rigid behaviour of connections in fire: cruciform tests

Mid – 1990s

• Cruciform tests to create small database of M-φcurves. Semi-empirical models to rationalise results.

• 2 successive experimental projects at BRE Garston (Lennon) in “portable” furnace.

1. First series (Leston-Jones) tested a limited range of small non-composite flush-endplate connections.

2. Second series (Al-Jabri ) tested flush and extended endplate connections in composite and non-composite arrangements, including some Cardington connections.

Page 13: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Garston cruciform tests: test arrangement

Column head restrained in position

Load Load

Beam restrained horizontally

Specimen located within furnace

Test Furnace

Specimen

Page 14: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Garston cruciform tests: “portable” furnace

Page 15: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Garston cruciform tests: End-plate Type 2

50

50

150

1010 90

60

375

254x254x89UC(50)

356x171x51UB(50)

6mm FW all round

All holes 22mm dia. forM20 Grade 8.8 bolts

190

Page 16: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

High-temperature M-φ-θ characteristics of endplate joints

Rotation (mrad)

Flush End-plate

20 40 60 80 100

20°C 200°C 400°C

500°C

600°C

700°C

35 40 Moment (kNm)

25 20

15 10 5

0 0

20

40

60

80

100

20 40 60 80 100 Rotation (mrad)

Curves at 100°C intervals

Moment (kNm)

20°C/100°C

Flexible End-plate

30

Page 17: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Cardington beam-column joint after fire test

Buckling due to high axial force on heating

Page 18: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component zones in end-plate joint

Column web in tension

Column web in compression

Beam flange incompression

Beam web in tension and compression

Column flange andend plate in bending

Bolts in tension

Tension Compression Shear

M

Column web in shear

Beam web in shear

Page 19: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component zones in end-plate joint with axial thrust

Reduced tension

Highercompression in web

Beam flange in highercompression

Beam web mainly incompression

Reduced force on column flange

Lower tension

Tension Compression Shear

Column web in shear

M

F

Beam web in shear

Page 20: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component Behaviour at High Temperatures

Page 21: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Spyrou Component testing 1998-2001: Objectives

Compression Zone

• Examine experimentally the effect of elevated temperatures on column web buckling.

• Develop simplified/semi-empirical model of column web compression component behaviour for end-plate joints.

• Check both against finite element modelling.

Generally

• Check flush endplate moment-rotation predictions against previous cruciform furnace tests.

Tension Zone

• Do experiments on T-stubs at high temperatures.

• Develop simplified/semi-empirical model of tension component behaviour for end-plate joints.

• Check both against finite element modelling.

Page 22: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Spyrou furnace and control apparatus

Control panel

View portsfor cameras

Loading actuator

Page 23: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Failure modes for tension T-stubs

Failure Mode 2 Failure Mode 3Failure Mode 1

Page 24: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Spyrou compression zone test arrangement

ActuatorReaction Frame

Specimen

Furnace

Page 25: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Roberts’ model for ultimate strength of stocky webs

Uniform stress σyw

ββ c

Pu1 2 3 4

Simplified model of compression zone

Page 26: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

tfb

γ/10

β

γ

w

γe

β c

300

w1

γ/10

Leff=e+(γ/5)

1.Yield of column web

Principles of simple compression zone model

2 3

β

γ'

w

γ'e'

βc

650tfb

w1

Lt

Yielding

2. Yield of column flange (first plastic hinges)

β Δw′

Le=β+c/4

c/2Mpfc

1

3. Yield of column flange (final plastic hinges)

Page 27: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian shear panel tests

Page 28: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Restrained high-temperature joint testing

Page 29: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian & Tan restrained tests

Page 30: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian & Tan restrained specimen

UB305X102X25kg/m

14521652

700

1500

16521452100 100

800

ENDPL

UC254X254X107kg/m

ENDPL

100 100

D29D29

D29

D29

D29

D29

D29 D29

Page 31: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian & Tan restrained tests

Page 32: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian & Tan restrained tests

Page 33: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Qian & Tan restrained tests

Page 34: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

1. Modified Rotational Models

Component Modelling in Fire

Page 35: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Simoes da Silva (2001) component approach

• Find ambient-temperature force-displacement response at ambient temperature according to EC3-1-8 component method principles.

• Apply high-temperature material reduction factors for stiffness and strength to produce high-temperature equivalents.

Page 36: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Simoes da Silva modelling of Sheffield tests

Page 37: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Modified rotational models: Qian & Tan

?

VNb

Nc

Nc

cwt cfb epb bt

bwscws cwc bfc

F

?

FRd

K

F

?

FRd

Elastic-plastic component Rigid-plastic component

cwt cfb epb bt

cwt cfb epb bt

cwt cfb epb btMV

M

Page 38: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component Modelling in Fire

2. General Connection Elements

Page 39: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

The “Component” method with axial force

• In fire axial compression acts together with moment due to restraint to thermal expansion. Component model would deal with this automatically, though M-φcurves change due to thrust.

K1

K2

Kc

Page 40: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

The “Component” method with axial force

FcKc

F2

F1K1

K2

Ft

M

• In fire axial compression acts together with moment due to restraint to thermal expansion. Component model would deal with this automatically, though M-φcurves change due to thrust.

Page 41: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

The “Component” method with axial force

• In fire axial compression acts together with moment due to restraint to thermal expansion. Component model would deal with this automatically, though M-φcurves change due to thrust.

FcKc

F2

F1K1

K2

Ft

M

F

Page 42: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component-Based Connection Element (Block)

kC kTekTc

kS

u

w

φ

lT,1

lT,3

lT,2

lC,1

lC,2

21

kC kTekTc

kS

u

w

φ

lT,1

lT,3

lT,2

lC,1

lC,2

21 21Compression Spring- Column Web

Tension Spring –

T-Stub in End-Plate

Shear Spring- Bolts

Page 43: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Comparison of joint element with tests by Leston-Jones

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80Connection rotation [mrad]

Stee

l temp

eratu

re [°

C]

BFEP 5 - 5 kNmBFEP 15 -15 kNmBolt rows individuallyBolt rows as a group

Page 44: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Component-based connection element: beam shear panel

kC kTekTc

kS

u

lT,1

lT,3

lT,2

lC,1

lC,2

21

kC kTekTc

kS

u

lT,1

lT,3

lT,2

lC,1

lC,2

21 21

Page 45: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Implementation of joint element in software

I

J

K

L

Page 46: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

The end …

Page 47: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

… nearly …

Page 48: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Next emphasis

Floor beam Shear tab plate

Column tree

Robustness in tying (tension) of typical connection details in fire.

Example: WTC5 system

Page 49: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Failure of tab plates in WTC 5 column trees

Page 50: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Combined catenary tension and shear

Page 51: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

Current work on robustness

Page 52: Connection Modelling in Firefire.fsv.cvut.cz/COST_C26_Prague/07-03-30_31/1-03 Burgess.pdf · 254x254x89UC(50) 356x171x51 UB(50) 6mm FW all round All holes 22mm dia. for M20 Grade

… Thank you