44
Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous Languages: Specification & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite this version: Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry. Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous Languages: Specification & Code Generation. [Research Report] RR-3310, INRIA. 1997. <inria-00073379> HAL Id: inria-00073379 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073379 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    17

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous Languages:

Specification & Code Generation

Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry

To cite this version:

Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry. Compositionality in Dataflow SynchronousLanguages: Specification & Code Generation. [Research Report] RR-3310, INRIA. 1997.<inria-00073379>

HAL Id: inria-00073379

https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073379

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ap por t de r ech er ch e

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

����� ������� ������������� �� ������������ �����! #"%$&���'��()��*���)+,(���+�- �/.0���1-2 '�3, )��4*��� 5 ����-6+�-#�!-#$7�� ����

Albert Benveniste , Paul Le Guernic , Pascal Aubry

N ˚ 3310

November 1997

THEME 1

Page 3: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite
Page 4: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

����������� ���������������������������� �"!#�$�%�'&�(%)*� �+� ,"�-�.�/�"01,2�30%45�768���4�&' 9�&"����:� �<;&����/4=0/4�+4)>���?�� �

@8A�B�CED�F8GHCEI�J5CKI'LNMOFPCRQ�S�T?U'AWVXCZY[U2CED\I'LN]_^_Q2S�T?M�]`T�A @8U'B'D\a-b

cXdfe\g�hji�kml�n\oph\qEr`s8hOt�opu�ovtpe\g�h\owxvyKz{hOt%|}f~%t*x

lWqE}f}�y$xvtX��h�xph\�>dfh\x*�>d�h��3�E�fi\�8k�� y��Kh�g��?h\x�i\�E�$�1km�E�j}fq��Eh\o

�8�+�\�O���f�K�K� � y`��r��:qExv�:t�u��.o�qK�f�Ky��OqKtvh\��qKo�q opyK�.r�tp��y$��¡�y$xjtpd�h¢�fh\op���$�RyK¡��.qKxp�Kh£opu`optvh�gjoO¤/tpd�hgjqKtpd�h�g�qKtv�.�OqK��t*xpqE�fov�.q�tp��y$�¥y�¡Wt*d��.o��OyE�f�Oh\}�tH�:o�yK¡�tvh\�RtpdfqKtHyK¡H¦¨§�© ª�§�«¨¬®­�¬¯§�°5±�²�¬®­�³K´�cXd��.o�}�qK}?h\xH�:o�fhO�KyEtvh��µtpd�h¶�.opo*r�h\o7y�¡��OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�fq��:��t�u·q��.g��:�f�¸q�t[g�y��fr��.qKx¹�ºy���h¢�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�»¤%¡�y$x7��q�tpq�¼�y�½opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo��.qK�f�ErfqK�Kh\o\¾¿~Wo£�OqExvh\��h�opo7ovtpyExp�:�f�Ry�¡HyE�`z{h��ºt[�ºy���hZ¡�yEx7¡¯rfxptpd�h�x¹xph\r�ovhZ�:�Àovu�optvh\gjo�fh\op���$�R¡¯qK���.o�tpy ½�y$xpÁ�¤/½�h[Â?x*opt��ºyE���ºh\�$t*xpqKtvh[yE��½�dfqKt8qKxph[tpd�h¢qE�f���:tv�:yE�fqK�X¡�h\qKtprfxph\o8��hOh���h\��tvyqE�foptpx*qK�ºtj}fxpyK�$xpqEg�o�¡�yExjt*d�h_}frfx*}?yEoph7yK¡1�Oy`�fh¹�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�»Ã¹½/h[o*d�y�½�t*dfq�t�q¥�Oh\�$tpx*q��X��yEtv�:yE�¸�:ot*dfq�t y�¡%«O¦*Ä�ŨÆ�Ç�²�¬®°`ȹ«Nª�Ũ¦O¬ É�¦¨±�­�¬¯§�°¹qKoWxph\o*r��:tv�.����¡¯xpyEgÊq¢¦¨±�Ç`«O±�²�¬®­Ë³[±�°5±�²�³P«>¬.«WyK¡'t*d�h��E���Eh\�£}fxpyK�$xpqEg¹¾cXdfh\� ½/h7optprf�fu�ovh�}fqKx*q�tph8�ºy$g�}f���.q�tp��y$�¥¡�yEx�ovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo�}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjo\¤+qE�f� ½/h¹���.o*�Orfo*o�t*d�h7�.o*opr�hyK¡���.ovt*xv�.�fr�tph\�£�.gj}���h�g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE�_rfop�.���7qE�_qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoXg�h\���.rfgÊy�¡�OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$�1Ì�¡�y$x �?yKt*dtpyE}��.�Oo�½/hH}fxpy��`�:�fhHq¹�ºyEgj}��:hOtph�¡�y$xpgjqK�+optprf�fuK¾HÍ�yEx*xph\o*}�y$�f���.���8q��:�Ky$xv�:tpd�g�o�qKxphH�\rfx*xvh��Etp��u£rf����h\x�fhO�Kh\��y$}fg�h\�$t%�:�7tpdfh1¡¯xpqEgHh\½�y$xpÁjyK¡+t*d�h�Î�Ï/ÐѦ¨§�©�©j§�°HÒº§�Ó>©j±�­»¡�yExXopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo/�:qE���ErfqK�Kh�oO¾Ô[Õ$Ö5×*Ø�Ù ��Ú+�K� opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoW�.qK�f�ErfqK�Kh\o\¤»g�y`��r��:qExv�:t�uK¤��OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�fq��:��t�uE¤��ºy���hj�Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$�»¤»���.o{Ût*xv�.�fr�tph\�[�ºy���h1�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�»¤��OqErfo*q��:��t�u8qE�fq��:u�ov�.o\¤`oph\}�qKx*q�tvh1�ºy$gj}����.q�tp��y$�»¤f��h�ovu��f�>dfxpyE�f�:o*q�tp��y$�»¾

ܮݻÞpßNà\á%ÞXâ+ã:ßNäNåºæ

ç»èPéëêXì�í¨ì�î{ïXéëê�í¨ð8î�ñOò�î{ðPó�îvó7ôºîvï¯ê�éëõ>ð8õ¨ö�í�ìPï¯îv÷ëéëøXéëðPí¨ï¯ù�ï¯î{ì�õ>ï¯òWú3èPéëûNè8í¨ìPì�îví¨ïËî{ó¹ü�ðPóPî{ïXò�èPî�êNí¨øXî òËé òË÷ëî�éëðò�èPî�ý�ïËõOû{îvî{óPéëð�þ>ê1õ¨ö�ÿ�������� í¨÷ëîvðºòËî���õ>ï\êËèPõ>ì£õ>ð��5õ>øXì�õ>ê�é òËéëõ>ð�í¨÷ëé ò®ù� 3õ>ïËþºí¨ð�é��vî{ó��ºù���� ý��5óPî���õ\î�ôºî{ï1í¨ðPó�����`í¨ðPþ>ø�í>í¨û���\ò�è�îvêËî�ìPïËõOû{î{îvó�éëðPþ>ê+ú3éë÷ë÷���î2ìPü��P÷ëéëê�èPî{ó éëðWòËèPî��! "�$#% &#\ìPï¯éëðPþ>î{ï('?î{ïË÷�í¨þ)�ç�è�éëê�ú5õ>ï*Wéëê�õ>ï3èPí¨ê+��î{î{ð�ê�ü�ìPì�õ>ï¯òËî{ó éëð ì�í¨ï�ò+�Où�òËèPî2ö:õ>÷ë÷ëõvú"éëð�þ/ìPï¯õ-,¯îvû�òËê�.0/�üPï¯î�*í21#43" "�5���$6" 7 &/?êËìPï¯é ò��(8:9

1#<;+�5�+/0#>=?/?ê�ì�ïËé ò�ìPïËõ2,Ëî{û�ò5/?ý�@-A�B�����C� )/�ê�ìPï¯é òD�\ç$�$1#�3:�(E�=F/�ê�ìPï¯é ò5ìPï¯õ-,¯î{û{òD/�ýG@�@��-A�H�CI�KJ®ðXí¨óPó�é ò�éëõ>ð%òËõ'ò�è�î"÷ëéëê¯ò�î{óí¨ü�ò�è�õ>ïËê� 5ò�è�î ö�õ>÷ë÷ëõpú3éëðPþ ì�î{õ>ìP÷ëî�è�í{ôºî1éëðPóPéëï¯î{û�ò�÷ ù� D��ü�òXêËòËï¯õ>ðPþ>÷ ù� »û{õ>ðOòËïËé���ü�ò�î{ó8ò�õ�ò�è�éëê/ú»õ>ï�.�ò�èPîMLINOL�ö�õ>ïËø�í¨÷ëéëêËøè�í¨ê���î{î{ð�êËè�í¨øXî{÷ëî{ê�ê�÷ ùP��õ>ï¯ïËõvú»î{ó�ö�ï¯õ>øQ;+øXéëï3ý?ðOüPî{÷ëéR Kí¨ðPó1òËèPîS�Pí¨û�\þ>ï¯õ>üPðPó�õ>ð ÷�í-��î{÷ë÷ëîvó�ì�í¨ï¯òËé�í¨÷fõ>ïËó�îvï¯ê2éëê+øXõ>ê¯ò�÷ ùí¨û�>õpú3÷ëî{óPþ>î{ó�òËõ�ý�í¨ü�÷��»í¨ê�ìPéR�T ;�� U���í¨ðPó�ý�� ÷WVS�í¨ïËî�ú3é ò�èXJ®ï¯éëêNí�Y2J®ðPï¯é�í� Z�»í¨øXìPüPê�óPî�U5îví¨üP÷ëéëî{ü[ \H�]-A-^4@���î{ðPðPî{êjû{î{óPî�ñ� _EPïËí¨ðPû{î���î{ø�í¨éë÷-.

ð�í¨øXîa`+éëïËéëê�í�� ö:ïb J®ïËéëê�í�Y2J.ö:êËéëû� O��í¨øXì�üPê�óPî7U5îví¨üP÷ëéëî{ü[ &H�]-A-^4@>��î{ðPðPî{ê+û{î{óPî�ñ� &EPï�í¨ðPû{î���î{ø�í¨éë÷�.?ðPí¨øXî2`+é ö�ê�éëû�� ö�ï

Unite de recherche INRIA RennesIRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES Cedex (France)

Telephone : 02 99 84 71 00 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 00Telecopie : 02 99 84 71 71 - International : +33 2 99 84 71 71

Page 5: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�������� �5��?�� �����¯���� ���/�3�À��45�=�®�/�"0X�30/4»� �E�X�'&�(%)p���'45� � ���K���%4 �����%���345�86������&' 9�&"����:� ��45�¶0�������)º����������%4À&»���%4

��� ��� � � � q��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�fqK���:tvn£h�ovt8r���h¢�?yE�f��h¢tpx*qK�frf�Otv�:yE�µgjq�t*d�n\gjqKtv���$rfh¢�frµ�ºy$�f�ºh�}�t8��hg�y��fr��.qKxp�:tvnK¤��OyE�f�Oh\}�t��.g�}?yExptpqE�$t�}?yErfx��.q7�OyE�f�Oh\}�tp��y$�¢��h�opu�ovtpe\g�h\o�h\gH�fqKx��`r�n\o\¾ �Wy$rfo�nOt*rf���:yE�fo�.q£�ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�fqK���:tvn�}?yErfx���h�o �:qE���EqK�Kh�oW¼?yKtpo���h���yE����nOh�o�ovu��f�>d�xvy$��h\o\¤�qP�Kh����OyEgjg�h�yE�`z{h��ºtp� ¡%�:qo*}?n\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE��h\t��:q¥�En\��n�xpqKtv�:yE����h_�ºy���h_���.optpxp�:�frfnK¾=� yErfojhOsfd��:�?yE��o�rf��¡�yEx*gjq��:�:o*g�h£rf����¡�yEx*gHh}?yEr�x1tpx*q��:tvh\x �fh\o��`r�h�ovtp��y$�fo���h��\qKrfo*q��:��tpnK¤�y$xp�fyE�f�fqE�f�ºh�g�h\�$tO¤�h\t��ºy$g�gHrf���.�OqKtv�:yE�1à �.q¹�fyKtv�:yE�¥��h«Nª��¨¦º¬ É/¦*±�­Ë¬¯§�°-Æ�� §�Ó*ÆK§�°?°�±�°�¦¨Åº©�ÅO°�­%yEr��fh¶Æ��{ªfź°5ÆK±�°5¦¨Å\´��WyEr�o�qK}�}fr�uEqE�$tHo*rfx��OhOtvtph¹�fyKtv�:yE��¤'�fyErfo�OyE�f��r��:opyE��o2rf��hXnOt*rf��h%¡�y$xpg�hO�:�:h��ºyEgj}��:eOtph���hX�.q��OyEgj}��:�:qKtv�:yE�jopn\}fqExvn\h�h\t���h��.q��fn\opu`���>dfxvy$���.opqKtv�:yE�h��8��r�h ��h1�.q��Kn\�fn\x*q�tv�:yE�8��h �ºy���h ���.ovt*xv�.�fr�nE¾ � h\o%qK���EyExp��t*dfg�h\o%�ºy$xpxph\o*}�y$�f�fqE�Et*oopyE�$t%h\�¹�ºy$rfxpo%��h�fnO�Kh\��y$}f}?h\g�h\�$tXqKr�tpyErfxX��r8¡�y$xpgjqKt%�OyEgjg�r��������R��h�oX�.qK���$q��Kh�o�opu��f�>dfxpyE��h�oO¾��Ù ��� × ��� � � }fxpyK�Ex*qKgjgjq�tp��y$�[ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fhK¤5�fq�t*q�¼�y�½ ¤5op}?n\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�»¤5�Kn���n\x*q�tp��y$�£��h��Oy���hK¤5�Kn���nºÛx*q�tp��y$����h �Oy���h ���.optpxp�:�frfnK¤��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�fqK���:tvnE¤Eg�y��fr��.qKxp��tpnK¤`yEx*�fxph\o�}fqExvtp��h\�:o\¤`�OqKr�opqK���:tvnE¤$��h�ovu��f�>d�xvyKÛ�f�:o*q�tp��y$�»¾

Page 6: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �

������� ���

� �<٠�����f����� �� � �

���� Õ_Õ ��� Õ�� ���Ë���¯� Ù�� � � Õ � Ö�� � � � Ù��+Ù +� �+�f�P��Ú!�#"�� $

%'& � Õ �(��)+�E����� Ù�� � & Ö �¥� Ù �#�¯� � �P� � �*���*� Ù�� & Ö �\� Õ �¸�,+.-0/1-*2,354 � 76�8:9 ;

� < Ù �=� Ù �*����� Ù�� ���"� Õ ��� Ù�� � � " Ù�� �K��+�������¯� Ö � � Ú-�\� � Õ Ú ���� � "¶�0� Õ �>�?)'�K���*� Ù�� � 6�?¾�iA@-d�q�tX�.oXtpd�h }fxpyE�f��h�gCB ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ ��?¾ D E��>d�h\�frf���.����op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�fo¹¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ i��

$ �<Ù Ú ��¯����� � Ú-Ú��¯�\�O���¯��"� Õ Ú·� Ù Ú Õ " ÕF�+Õ ������� Ù�� � ;G ¾�i lWhO�.q�s��:�f�jopu��f�>dfxpyE�$u_¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ i*HG ¾ D I h���h\x*q�tp�:�f�jo*�>d�h��fr��:�:����¡�y$xXovh�}fqKx*q�tph�g�y��fr��:h\o ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ i*JG ¾ � cXdfh���yEtvtvy$g��:�:�fh�Ã2gHy��frf�:qExXqK�f�[���.ovt*xv�.�fr�tph\�[�ºy���h1�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE� ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾KDK�

;'< �� � � +��� �� �1�

� �,�!� Õ�� Ú!��L�� �NÙ � �����2�O� "Ú Ö¸Ù�� �E��"�����#��� Ö � � Úµ��� � Õ Ú� �#� � "¶��� Õ �(��)+�E����� Ù�� � ���~�¾�iKM�h\}?h\����h\�f�O��h�oѾ1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾KD>D~�¾ D Í��.x*�Or��:t{¡¯xphOh o*�>d�h\�frf���.���Eo¸¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾KDK�~�¾ �NM�h\xp�:�$�.������h�}�h��f��h\���º�:h\o�qEoX�OqKr�opqK���:t�u��ºy$�fovt*xpqK�:�$t*oX¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾KD G~�¾ � Í�y$xpxph\�Ot/}�xvyE�Ex*qKgjo�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾KD$�

O �,�!� Õ�� Ú!��L�� �NÙ � ����� �O� "Ú Ö Ù�� Ú Õ � Ö�� � � � Ù�� �#PK���*� Ù�� +v� Ùf× ��"� � Ù � Õ Ú Ø ��� � O�Õ��+Ù:Q �<H�:� � �¯� "ÚSR02 %�TU1¾:iVM�h\opu��f�>dfxpyE���5WO�.��� -0/�- Ã+¡¯xpyEg -X/�- tvyH�:��Â?���:tvh1}fqKxptv�.q���yEx*��h\x*o\¤EqK����tpd�h\�:x%qEovu��f�>dfxpy�Û

�fyErfoX�OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE� ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ �E�U1¾YD |��f��y��>dfxpyE�$u�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ �FDU1¾ �[Z�qK�f�f���.����h\����y��>dfxvy$�$u��.�[}fx*qK�ºtp�:�Oh�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ �>H

U1¾ �f¾:i Í/d�h\�>Á$�.���Hh��f��y��>dfxpyE�$u ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ �>HU1¾ �f¾YD |�`¡�yEx*�º�.���jh\����y��>dfxvy$�$u ¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾�¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾1¾ ¾ ¾�¾ ¾ �>J

\ JF�$J#<;:Y2JF +�(J?;� �ð�í¨øXîa`+éëï¯éëêNí�� ö�ï

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 7: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� � ����� ��X���,�

� y`��r��:qExv�:t�u[�:o qE���Ky��\q�tvh��_qKo�t*d�h�r���tp�:gjqKtvh�ovyE�:rftv�:yE�£¡�y$x�tpd�h���h�ov�:�E�¢y�¡�.qKxp�Kh�ovu�optvh\gjo\¤�qK�f�Ztpdf�:odfyK�.�foX�.�£}fqKxptv�.�Or��.qKx/¡�y$x�h�g��?h\�f��h��£ovu�optvh�g�o\¤�qE�f�[tpd�h\�:xWovyK¡�t�½/qExvh qK���£qKx*�>d���tph\�OtprfxphK¾ � y��fr��.qKxp��t�uqK���:y�½�o�t*d�h��fh\op���$��h\x"tvy�op�\q��:h��y�½�����h�ov�:�E��}fxvy$���:h\gjoO¤�qE�f�1¡¯qK�O���:�:tpq�tph�xph\rfophyK¡�}fxph\��hOÂ?��h\��gHy��frf��h�oO¾cXd�h�gjq�tpdfh\gjq�tp�:�\q��+tpx*qK�fop�:qKtv�:yE�[yK¡�tpd�h��ºyE���ºh\}ftWy�¡g�y��fr��.qKxp�:t�u¹�.o y�¡�tvh��£tpd�q�tWyK¡ ¦¨§�© ª�§�«¨¬®­�¬¯§��

°5±�²�¬®­�³K´'w2qPu`�:�f�1qKtvtph\�$tv�:yE��tvy�tpd�h��OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE��yK¡5o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo�� � w�FD����.o��Oh\�$tpx*q��ftpy�qK�$u�opu�ovtph\gg�y���h\���:�$�EyK�:�$�.���£�ºy$�f�Or�xpxph\�f�Ou£yEx }fqExpqK���:hO�:�.opg¹¾ � y$xvh�xph\�Oh\�$tv�:uK¤+ov�:�E����Â?�\qK�$t1h��5yExpt�dfqKo��?hOh��¥��hºÛ�EyKtph\�¹tvy�½%qKx*���.�$tpxpy`��rf�º�.�����ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�fqK���:t�u8�.�¹�Kh�xv��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�7½X��t*d£q��.g��:����qKtW��h�xv�:�`�:����}fxpy`y�¡¯oXyK¡�.qKxp�Kh1}fxpyK�$xpqEg�o¡¯xpyEg�}fqExvtp�:qK��}fxpy$yK¡¯o%�:�$�EyK�:�$�.�����ËqE�fovt*xpqE�ºtp��y$�fo/y�¡��/�OyEgj}�y$��h\�$t*o�� � w�� G �N¾

Í�y$g�}f���.q�tp��y$�¢qK���¢�ºy���h��Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$�£dfqKo1�?hOh��¢�E���Eh\�£�:h\o*o1q�tvtph\�$tv�:yE�_¡¯xvy$gÊtpd�hjo*qKg�h�}?yK�.�$t yK¡�`�:hO½ ¤�d�y�½/hO�Eh\x\¾�cXd��:o3�:o"rf�`¡�y$xvt*rf�fq�tphK¤�qKo3��t"�:o"�Oxp��tp�:�\q��K¡�yEx�t*d�h��h�ov�:�E�fh\x�tpyWo*�Oq��:h���y�½��1t*d�h���h�ov�:�E�1yK¡�.qKxp�KhXopu�ovtph\gjo��$u8i���ovtpyExp�:��� g�y��fr��:h\o���.Á�h����.qK�>ÁEÛ���yPs! p}fxpy��ºh\��rfxvh�o#"%yEx$ p}fxpy��ºh\o*oph\o%"�½X��t*d�g��:���.gjq���.�$tvh�x{¡¯qE�ºhH�fh\o*�Oxp�:}�tp��y$�»¤5qK�f� D&���Eh\��h�xpqKtv�.���8�ºy���h�yE�f��u£rfop�:�f�8tpdfh\ophH�.�$tvh\xv¡¯qK�Oh���h�op�\xv�.}�tv�:yE��oO¤5½�d��:��hoptv�:�:���ErfqExpqE�$tvhO�.���7tpdfqKt1Â?�fq��2h��f�OqE}fo*r��:qKtv�:yE�¢y�¡XqK�ºt*rfq����Oy���hj½X��t*d��:�¶t*d�h\oph����.qK�>ÁEÛN�?yPs�h\o tvyE�KhOt*d�h\x½X�:tpd¹t*d�hO�.xX�ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�»¤�½X�:���"g�qK�:�$t*q��.�7�OyEx*xvh��ºtp�fh\o*o�yK¡"t*d�h���h\op�:�E�7½ ¾ x\¾ t\¾�op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�»¾cXd��.o%}fqK}?h\x��.o/�fhO�KyEtvh���tpd�h��.opo*r�h\o�y�¡3�OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�fq��:��t�ujq��.g��:�f��qKt�g�y��fr��.qKx/�ºy���hW�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�»¤

¡�y$x��fqKtpq�¼?y�½ opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo1�:qE���Er�q��Kh�oO¾¹~WoH�fq�t*q�¼�y�½¿ovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo1�.o�x*q�t*d�h\x�q£}fqKx*qK���:�Eg g�yExpht*dfqK��q�¡�h\½-�ºy$�f�OxphOtphX�:qE���ErfqK�Kh�o'yEx2�`�.oprfqK��¡�yEx*gjq��:�:o*gjo'� U UX��i���¤$��t�½/qEo���h�ov�.xpqE���:hXtvy�qK��ovt*xpqE�ºt'¡¯xpyEgo*rf�>djqK����o*rf�>dj}fqExvtp�:�\r��:qEx2�.qK���$rfq��EhK¾3cXd`rfo½�h�dfqP�EhX�>d�yEoph\��tvy ½/yEx*Á ½X�:tpd�q�¡�y$xpgjq��:�.opg�}fxvy$}�y$ovh���$u_~ gH�.x�w�`r�hO�:��¤�tpdfqKt1y�¡ E$u�gH��yE���.�Hc+x*qK�fop��tp��y$� E$u�optvh�g�o(� -X/�- � w�`rf�$�)�*�¨¤3½�d��:�>d¢�:o qKt t*d�h�opqEg�htp�:g�h �Eh\xpu����:�Ed$t�½/hO�:�Ed$tO¤�qK���8¡¯rf���:u8�Eh\��h�xpqK��tpy��OqE}�tprfxph�tpd�h h�opoph\�f�Oh1y�¡2ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo/}fqKx*qK�f���$g7¾

+�ov�.����tpd��.o�¡�y$xpgjqK���.opg¹¤`½/h optprf��u��OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE��y�¡"o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo\¤`q��Kh�xvu�tpxp�:�$�.q���tvy$}��.�W�.�f��h\h\�»¾� yEoptHyK¡ yEr�xHh,��y$xvtj�.ojtpd�h��¸�fhO�KyEtvh���tvy¥�.opo*r�h�ojy�¡ �OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE��q��:��t�u t*dfq�t�qKxph[�Oxp��tp�:�\q��%tvy �ºy���h�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�»¾[~WoH�OqExvh\��h�opo�optvy$xv�.���[y�¡�y$�`z{h\�Ot��ºy���h�¡�y$x ¡¯rfxptpdfh\x�xph\r�ovh��.��opu`optvh�gjo���h\op�:�E�¶¡¯q��:�.o�tvy½/yEx*Á�¤`½�h Â?x*ovtX�ºy$�f�ºh��$tpx*q�tvh�yE�7½�dfqKt%qExvh�tpdfh�qK�f���:tv�:yE��q���¡�h\qKtprfxph\oX��h\h\��h��8tpy�qK�foptpx*qK�Ot/}fxpyK�$xpqEgjo¡�y$x�tpd�h£}frfx*}?yEoph7yK¡ �ºy���h¹�Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$�1Ã�½�h£o*d�y�½ tpd�q�t�qZ�Oh\�$tpx*q��X��yEtv�:yE�R�:o�tpd�q�tjy�¡1op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE�RqKo�xvh�opr��:tv�.���¢¡¯xvy$g qZ�OqErfopqK���:t�u qK�fqK��u�op�:o�y�¡Wt*d�h¹�K�:�Kh\� }�xvyE�Ex*qKg¹¾ @¶h¹}�qPu¥optpxpyE�f�qKtvtph\�$tv�:yE�¶tvy¢tpd��.o���yEtv�:yE�»¤2q[½�d�yE��h7qK}f}?h\�f�f� s¥�:oH��hO�EyKtph\�¶tvy_�:tpoHgjq�tpdfh\gjq�tp�:�\q��qE�fq��:u�ov�.oO¤+rfop�:���q8tvh��>df�����$rfh���yEt rf�f���.Á�h�tpd�h�yE�fh�¡�yEx tpdfh��\qKrfo*q��:��t�u[qK��q��:u`op�.o�y�¡�|ovtph\xphO��� U/h�xp� G ��¾1l�h\�:qKtvh��_�.opo*r�h\oyK¡ �ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�fqK���:t�u qKxph8�.�$�Kh\optv�:�EqKtvh��»¾ cXd�h\�R½�h[opdfy�½ tpdfqKt�t*d�h\xph¹�:ojopyEg�h7qE}f}fxpyE}fxp�:qKtvh��:hO�EhO�yK¡- v�:�$tph\x*gHh����.q�tvh£�Oy`�fh">¤½�d��.�>d¸qKtjtpd�h_o*qKg�h[tv�.g�h_q��:��y�½�ojrfojtpy¥o*�OqK��h£��y�½��¸�ºy���h£�Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE�¡�y$x��:qExv�EhHopu`optvh�gjoO¤�qE�f�¢optv�:����gjqK�:�$tpqK�:��o��OyEx*xvh��ºt*��h\o*oWqKt�t*d�h�ovu�optvh�gÊ�:�$tvh\�Ex*q�tp��y$�_}fdfqEovhE¾/.'�:�fqK���:u½/h����.op�\rfopo�t*d�h�ov�.��hj�.opo*r�hjy�¡%���:optpxp�.�fr�tvh��¶�:gj}��:h\g�h\�$t*q�tv�:yE�¶rfop�:�f�[qE�ZqEovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo g�h\���.rfg yK¡�OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$�»¤fqK�f�¹q��$q��.�»¤�qH¡¯r����+qK}f}?h\����� s7�:o��fhO�KyEtvh��8tpy��:tpoX¡�yEx*g�qK��ovt*rf��uE¾U%h\op�.��h\o t*d��.oO¤'�:hOt�rfoHg�h\�$tv�:yE�¶tpd�q�t�~ gH�.x�w��$rfhO�:�10Ê�ºy�½/yEx*Á�h�xpo(� w��$r��$�2�/dfqP�Kh��.�$tpxpy`��rf�ºh��¶q

g�y$xvh[hO�.qK�?yEx*q�tph\�¸�Kh�xpop��y$�RyK¡ yErfx -0/�- ¡�yEx*gjq��:�:o*g¹¤¡�y$x�tpdfh_}frfx*}�y$ovh£yK¡1�.�$�Kh�ovtp���$q�tv�.���¶�:o*o*r�h\o�yK¡�OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�fq��:��t�u��.�[}fxpy$yK¡¯o%�:�$�EyK�:�$�.�������:�Kh���h\o*o%}fxpyE}?h\xptv�:h\o\¾cXd��.o1½/yEx*Á[½/qEo �.���:tv�.q�tph\�Z½X��t*d��:�¶t*d�h��ºy$�Etphºs�t�y�¡�t*d�h436587�9;:$<¹opu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�oW�.qK���$rfq��EhH�$u_w'¾

� h I�r�h\x*���.�jqK�f�¶�:tpo�optprf�fh\�$tpo U1¾ � h I y=�'¤?>H¾ � q��5hO�.o@� � � I����=��¤+qK�f�¶w'¾"~ rf�fxpuA� ~Wrf�f�`�)�½�d�yÂ��fq��:��u8�:gj}��:h\g�h\�$tph\�¹tpd�h�ovh �.��h�qKo\¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 8: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« G

� ��� �V� �!� � � ������X� ��� � � �� �� � � ���,��� ����� � ���������

cXdfh\xph dfqEo/�?hOh��8ophO�Eh\x*q��5q�tvtph\gj}�t*o�tpy��>d�qKx*qK�ºtph\xp� W\h�tpdfh h�opoph\�$tv�.q��.o�y�¡3t*d�h�opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo}�qKx*qK���:�Eg� U UX�fi��'� Z�q��.�f�K����¾ @µ��t*d¢opyEg�h�hºsf}?h\xp��h��f�ºh�qK�f�£q�¡�tvh�x qKtvtvh�gj}�tpo tvy¹qK�f�fxph\o*o�t*d�h��.o*opr�hHy�¡g�y��`�:�f�¡¯xpyEg opu`���>dfxvy$�$u�tvy�qEovu��f�>d�xvy$�Eu��ËqK�����fqK�>Á �>¤K½/hX¡�hOh\��tpdfh�¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:���1¡�h�q�t*rfxvh�oqExvhX�.�f��h\h\��h�opoph\�$tv�.q��¡�y$xX�>dfqKx*qK�Otvh�xv�5WO�.����t*d��.o�}fqKx*qK�f���$g=ÃiK¾%wxpyK�Ex*qKgjo%}fxpyK�$xvh�opo��`�:qjqK�7�.�`Â?���:tvh�oph�`r�h��f�ºh1yK¡�ÓpŨ±K¦O­�¬¯§�°f«5Ã

�������½�d�h\xph��Ñ��h���yKtph\o%t*d�h1¡¯qKg��:��u�yK¡'}?yEo*op�:���:h xvh�qK�Otv�:yE�fo���¾

D�¾ @µ��t*d��.�_q�xph\qK�Otv�:yE�»¤?��h\�O�:op��y$�fo��\qK�[��h�tpqKÁKh\�¹yE�[t*d�h��fqEov�.oXyK¡'t*d�h7±&�>«OÅO°�¦¨Å�yK¡'opyEg�h�h\�Kh��Et*oO¤qKo2hOs�h\gj}��:� Â�h��j�Eu�tpd�h%¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f��t�u�}��.�OqK�fovt*q�tph\g�h\�$tpo\¤Kt*qKÁKh\��¡¯xvy$g � -0/"!$#"! <&%('*) -0/+#"! ¤EqK���36587�9;:$<jxph\o*}�h��ºtv�:�Kh\��u�Ã,$-/.102.43/5768.:9$02.�;�0<5$=25?>@BADCFE$-:-:.23/5HG@JIKAHEBL/.NM/=2E1925HO

cXd�h�Â�xpopt3optpq�tph\g�h\�$t��.o3ophO��¡�hºsf}��.qK��q�tvy$xvuE¾3cXd�h� CFE$-:-/.43/5 ""y$}�h�xpqKtvyEx»�fhO�:���Eh\x*o�tpdfhg�yEopt"xph\�ºh��$t��q��.r�hXy�¡ G q�t'tpdfh��º�:y`�>Á1yK¡�t*d�hX�ºy$�fov�.��h�xvh�����y���hE¤K�:t2tpd`rfo2dfqEo'tvy1tvh�ovt'¡�y$x+qE�foph\�f�Oh/yK¡ G �?hº¡�y$xvh}fxpy`��rf�º�.��� @ ¾�cXd�h L/.PM/=2E(925 "�y$}�h�xpqKtvyEx1��h\���:�Kh�xpo1�:tpo Â?xpopt qKxp�Erfg�h��Et1½�d�h��¶��t �.o�}fxph\oph\�$tO¤qK�f�¹yEtpd�h�xv½X�.ovh��:tpo�oph\�OyE�f�¹qKxp�Erfg�h��Et\¾

�f¾ @-d�h\�_��t �:o���hºÂ���h\�»¤5}fqExpqK���:hO�+�ºyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�[�:o q��:½/qPu�oX�E���Eh\�[�$u[tpqKÁ$�.����tpdfhH�ºy$�Pzvrf�f�Otv�:yE�£yK¡qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�¹xph\qK�Otv�:yE�fo3Ã

�RQPS��UTV� WX��QRY���TFZ �cu�}��.�OqK���:uK¤���¡�o*}?h\�º��¡�u`�:�f���.o+tpd�h%�.�$tvh\�$tp��y$�»¤�tpdfh\�Htpd�hXqK�?y��Kh¡�yEx*g�r��.q �:o'q�}�h�x{¡�h��ºt2��hºÂ�����tp��y$��yK¡}fqKx*q��:�:hO�?�OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�»¾U[{�8�ºyE�$t*xpqEovt\¤K��¡"}fxpyK�Ex*qKgjg��.���1½/qEo�tpdfh �.�$tvh\�$tp��y$�»¤Et*d�h\��tpd�h1��hOh���¡�yExtpd��.oX��hOÂ?���:tv�:yE�7tvy���h �OyEgj}fq�tp�:�f��h�½X��t*d7qE��y$}�h�xpqKtv�:yE�fqK��oph\gjqK�$tp�:�\o��Eh\xpu�g�rf�>d¹�ºy$g�}f���.�OqKtvh\otpd�h v½�d�h��7�:tX�.oX��hºÂ?�fh\� "�}fxph\xph�`r��.ov�:tvh]\�¾

>W¡��OyErfx*ovhE¤?o*rf�>d£q��>dfqExpqE�ºtph\xp� W�q�tv�:yE�7y�¡2½�dfqKt�tpdfhHopu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�oX}fqKx*qK���:�Eg �:o�gjqKÁKh\oXt*d�hH�O�:qEopoXyK¡ popu`���>dfxvy$�$u2^��ºy$g�}f���.qK�$t#"2¡�y$xpgjq��:�.opgjo'g�rf�>d��.qKxp�Kh�x3t*dfqK�jrfo*rfq��:�:u��ºy$�fov�.��h�xvh��»¾ UXr�t2�:tdfqEo2��h\h\��yErfxhOsf}�h�xv�:h\�f�Oh�tpd�q�tWt*d�h\oph�½/h\xph�t*d�hHÁKhOu¹¡�h\qKtprfxph\o�¡�yEx�t*d�h�tph\�>df�f� �`r�h�oW½/h�dfqP�Eh���hO�EhO�:yE}?h\�_opy�¡¯qEx�tvy½/yEx*Á�¾

Í��:h\qExv�:uK¤\tpd�h�ovhxph\gjqExpÁ`o5�OqK����¡�y$x�qX�ºy$gjgHy$� ¡�yEx*g�qKt»�:gj}��:h\g�h��Etp�:�f�Xtpd��.o3}fqExpqE���:�Eg¹¤Ot*d�h����6����� �¡�y$xpgjqKt � M�Í/�(H��5dfqEo�?hOh���}fxpyE}?yEoph\�j½X�:tpd�t*d��:o�yE��z{h\�ºtp���EhK¾'~��.ovy?¤Et*d��.o��\q��:�:o�¡�yExqHov�.gj}��:h\opt}�y$opop�.����h¡�y$xpgjqK���.opg ½X��t*d[tpd�h�qK�?y��Kh�¡�h\qKtprfxph\o\¤�y$�[½�d��.�>d¹¡¯rf�f�fqEgHh��$tpq����`r�h\optv�:yE�foWopd�y$r��.�£��h��.�$�Kh�ovtp���$q�tvh���Ëtpd�h }fr�xp}?yEoph yK¡"t*d��:o%�fqEov�.��ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo¡�yEx*gjq��:�:o*g¿½�y$r��.�8��yEt/�?h tvyjq��:��y�½-�?hOtptvh�xXop}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�y$x%}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjg��:�f��¤�d�y�½/hO�Kh�x��5Ã"t*d�h -X/�- ¡�y$xpgjq��:�.opg ½/h ��h\o*�Oxp�.��h ��hOs`t�d�qKo%tpdf�:oX�.�¹��t*oXyE��z{h\�ºtp���Eh\o\¾_ J®ð�ö:í¨û�òa ]`Ëï¯îví¨û�ò�éëõ>ðba�éëê"í%ê�÷ëéëþ>èºò�÷ ù ï¯îvê¯ò�ï¯éëû�ò�é ôºîò�î{ï¯øM Kí¨ê"ú»î�êËè�í¨÷ë÷�ê�î{î�éëð�òËèPî�êËîKc\üPî{÷�òËè�í*ò`Ëï¯îví¨û�ò�éëðPþXòËõXò�èPîî{ðOô\é 1

ïËõ>ðPøXî{ðºòXa'éëê�ðPõ¨ò�ò�èPî2õ>ð�÷ ù ì�õ>êËê�é��P÷ëî"OéëðPóWõ¨öféëðOòËî{ï�í¨û�òËéëõ>ð�í�ê¯ù�ðPû�èPïËõ>ð�õ>üPê'êËù\êËòËî{ø�ø�í{ùXè�ívôºî2ú3é òËè é òËê�îvðºô\éëïËõ>ðPøXî{ðºòa�d EPõ>ï'éëð�êËò�í¨ðPû{î� $øXõ>êËò"õ¨ö�òËèPî/îfeKõ>ï�ò�ïËî{÷�í*òËîvó�òËõWòËèPî/êËî{ø�í¨ðOòËéëû{ê'õ¨ög+L N4hbi4h]j%è�í¨ê"��î{î{ðHóPéëï¯î{û�ò�î{ó�ò�õvú�í¨ïËó�ê�õ>÷ ô\éëðPþò�èPéëê�éëêËê�üPî2ê�í*ò�éëê¯ö.í¨û�òËõ>ïËéë÷ ù�k U5î{ï ��]�l?�

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 9: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

H ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� � � � 1��� � ��X����� � � ��� ������ � � � � �$� ��X� � � � ��!� � ��� �������� � �������& Ö �¥� Ù ���Ë� � ��� � ���¯��� Ù�� & Ö �\� Õ ��� +.-0/1-*2�� @¶h�qKo*o*rfg�h%q��Ey`�\qK�frf�:qExvu��¥½�d��.�>d��:o2q1ophOt'y�¡5t�u�}�h����qExv�.qK���:h\o\¾�~W����t�u�}?h\o qExvhH�:gj}��:�:�O��tp��uZhºs�tvh��f��h��¢½X�:tpd¥q¹op}?h\�O�:qK�2hO�:h\g�h\�$t�� tvy£�?hj�:�$tvh�xp}�xvh\tvh\�¶qKo pqK��ovh��Et%"¨¾ E$yEg�h y�¡2t*d�h t�u�}�h�o�½/h��ºyE��ov�.��h\xXqExvh t*d�h�t�u�}?h y�¡'ª?Ç�ÓpÅ�«>¬ È�°5±�²ë«%½X�:tpd£��y$g�qK�:�! /#" ¤�qK����¨§�§�²�Ũ±�°f«½X�:tpd¹��yEgjqK�:�$ /&%(')" �Ëxph\�OqK���»�?yKt*d�t�u�}�h�oXqKxphWhOs`tph\�f�fh\�7½X��t*d8t*d�h��f�:optv�.���Erf�:o*d�h\�7hO�:h\g�h��Et���>¾@¶h ��hOÂ?��hWq�«¨­�±�­�Å+* tpy���h q t�u�}�hOÛN�OyE�fop�:optvh��$t��:�$tph\x*}fxvh\tpqKtv�:yE��y�¡,� ¤$qEopop���$���.���1tvy�h�qK�>d���qKxp�:qE���:h

-/. � q8��qK�:r�h0*21 -43 y��Kh�xW�:tpo �fyEgjq��.�»¾ @¶h���h\�fyKtvhj�$u!5µt*d�h�ovh\t1y�¡/qK���2optpqKtvh\o\¾ .?yEx1q¹oprf��ovh\t�yK¡��qExv�.qK���:h\o�6879�W¤�½/h ��hºÂ���h�q:61Û�ovt*q�tvh1tpyj�?h�qjt�u�}�hOÛN�OyE�fop�.ovtph\�$t��.�$tvh�xp}fxphOt*q�tp��y$�8yK¡;6�¾

.?yK�:��y�½X�.��� � w��$r��$�)�=<K¤f½/h ��hºÂ���h�q?>?³�© �*§�²�¬¯¦A@�Ó*±�°f«>¬®­�¬¯§�°B>?³P«>­NÅO© � -0/�- �%tvy���h�qjopu�ovtph\gC �EDF6 %HGI%KJ�L

�OyE�fop�.ovtp�:����y�¡'tpdfh1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���j�ºyEgj}?yE��h��$tpo�ÃM 6 �:oXq�Â�����tph�ovh\t%y�¡'t�u`}?h\� ��±�Ó>¬¯±&�º²�ź«��M G WN6 Z/�:oXqE�¹qEopoph\xptv�:yE�7�>dfqKx*qK�Otvh�xv�5WO�.���8¬®°?¬®­Ë¬¯±�²�«>­�±�­�Å>«>¾M J � J WN6PO % 6�ZX�:oXt*d�h�­�Óp±�°�«¨¬®­�¬¯§�°ZÓpÅO²�±�­�¬¯§�°8xphO�.q�tp�:�f��}fxvh\�`��y$rfoXqK�f�[�\rfxpxph\�$tXoptpq�tph\oQ*RO�qK���S*E¤�$u[xphº¡�h�xpxp�.����tvy[�?yKtpd¢}fqKoptUT�qK�f�¢�Orfx*xvh��$tW�Kh�xpop�:yE�foXyK¡��qKxp�:qE���:h\oV6PO�qK���B6�¾ .�y$x�hOs�qEgj}���htpd�hHqKo*ovh�xvtp��y$�?W �W O�XZY optpq�tph\oWtpdfqKt�tpd�h��PqK�:rfh y�¡[W_�.�$*��.o��$xvh�q�tvh�xX�$u Y tpd�qK�[�:tpo���qK�:r�h�:�A*RO¾R[N¡ J WF*RO\1 6 3 % *21 6 3 Z � / ¤f½�h o*qPu�tpdfqKt�ovt*q�tph�*]O¥�.o�q J �.ª�ÓpŨÆKŨ¦¨Å>«¨«O§�Ó/y�¡2ovt*q�tph�*E¾

~¿Ó>Ç�°:^`_a*cb % *<Q % *]T %cdeded �:oXqjoph�`r�h\���ºh1y�¡2ovt*q�tph\oXo*rf�>d8t*dfq�t*cbgf � G WN*cbFZih jlk�m/n % WN*po O Q % *po Z�f � J WN*po O Q % *po Z �vi��

cXdfh�¦¨§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�yK¡+t�½/y -X/�- C �C Q�q C T �:oX��hOÂ?��h��¹qEo/¡�yK�:��y�½�o3Ã6 � 6 Q�r 6 TG � G Q Y G TJ � J QRY J T %

t*d�h��ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�7�:o%t*d`rfoXtpdfh�}fq��.xv½X�.oph��OyE�Pzvrf���ºtv�:yE�¹yK¡"�.����tp�:qK�3qK���8t*xpqE�fov�:tv�:yE�¹xphO�.q�tv�:yE��oO¾s ç»èPî'ò�í¨÷ëî{ðOòËî{ó1ïËîví¨óPî{ï3ú"éë÷ë÷Eí¨÷ëê�õ/ðPõ¨ò�éëû{î2êËõ>øXî'û{÷ëõ>ê�î2ï¯îv÷�í*òËéëõ>ð�òËõ/òËèPîç(��;¢øXõOóPî{÷$õ¨öK�K�&�`í¨øXì�õ>ï�òa�tvu ê�ü�í¨÷ë÷ ù� �ô>í¨ï¯é�í-�P÷ëî{ê2í¨ðPó åxwzy á|{�} ô>í¨ï¯é�í-�P÷ëî{ê2í¨ï¯î�üPêËî{ó1ò�õ�ï¯î{ö�î{ï+òËõWû{üPï¯ï¯îvðºòí¨ðPó�~ {��ºã ê¯òNí*òËî{êa�'ç�è�éëê+éëê3î cOüPé ô¨í¨÷ëîvðºò

ò�õWõ>üPï'ìPï¯î{ê�î{ðºò�ðPõ¨òNí*òËéëõ>ð[�:��î/èPívôºî/ì�ïËî�ö�îvï¯ï¯îvó�ò�õ�û{õ>ðPêËéëóPî{ï+���£í¨ð�ó��� 4,Ëü�êËò"��î{ûví¨üPê�î�ò�èPîö:õ>ï¯ø/ü�÷��£ú5î�êËè�í¨÷ë÷�ú"ï¯é òËîøXõ>êËòË÷ ù%éëðºôºõ>÷ ôºî'û{üPïËï¯î{ðOò�ô¨í¨ïËé�í-�P÷ëî{ê� PïËí*ò�èPî{ï»òËè�í¨ð ìPí¨êËò�õ>ðPî{êa� u ê�éëðPþ�ò�è�î'êËò�í¨ðPó�í¨ï¯ó�ðPõ¨ò�í*òËéëõ>ðWú»õ>ü�÷ëó è�í{ôºî'ï¯îvêËüP÷ òËîvóWéëðí �PüPï¯óPî{ð1õ¨öfìPï¯éëøXî{óWô¨í¨ïËé�í-�P÷ëî{ê"éëðWòËèPî'ö�õ>ïËø�üP÷��"�

JF ��$J?;

Page 10: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �

�[Ù �\�f��� Ù�� � �NÙ � -0/1-� ½/h1o*dfqK����rfoph tpdfh1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.�����Kh\�fh\xp�:�1��yEtpq�tp��y$�fo/�:�¹t*d�h�ovh �`r�hO�EÃM�� %�� %���%ededcd ��h���yKtph -X/�- ��±�Ó>¬¯±&�º²�ź«>¾M ¡�yEx � q���qKxp�.qK���:hK¤��� . /&% � " ��h���yKtph\o%�:tpo�¦O²�§�¦�2Ã

1 � � �� � 3�� 1 ���� � 3M ¡�yEx � q���qKxp�.qK���:hK¤����H��h\�fyKtvh�oX�:tpoXqKo*opy`�O�:qKtvh��_«>­�±�­�Å���±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�Å��3��hºÂ���h\�[�$u Ã

��� ���������� ��� � ��� "!�� ��� �#� O� � D&�

½X��t*d£tpdfh��ºy$�E�Eh\�$tv�:yE�7tpd�q�tV*cb 1 � O� 3 �E�H¤���¾ hK¾:¤������.oWqK��ovh��Et��?hº¡�y$xvh�tpd�h�i�ovtXy��\�Orfx*xvh��f�ºh yK¡ � ¤qK�f�8�:oXqK��½%qPu�o}fxph\oph\�$t%q�¡�tph\x/tpd�h�i\opt/y`�\�Orfx*xph\�f�OhWy�¡ � ¾ E$t*q�tph���qExv�.qK���:h$��� �:oXqEopo*rfg�h\��tvy���h²�§�¦*±�² ���¾ hE¾�¤"�:o �fhO�Kh�x1opdfqExvh��ZqEg�yE���[��� ��h�xvh��Et -0/�- ¤+qK�f�Ztpd`rfo�ovt*q�tvhj��qKxp�.qK���:h\o1}��.qPu¢��y£xpyK�:h¡�yEx -0/�- �ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�»¾

% L���� ��� Õ � Ù�� � ��� � ���¯��� Ù�� ��Õ �Ë����� Ù�� � ÃM qjovh\��h��ºtvy$x�Ã

���'& ������� ( � - �� �!��)( � �Bd�WyEtvh tpd�q�tXtpdfh *�+ "!���"1}fqExvtX�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�f��o�tpyjtpd�h�}fxpyE}?h\xpt�u \1 & � ' 3-, 1 & � � 3 ">¾

M ��h\�\xvh�g�h\�$tv�.����qjxvh\�K�.ovtph\x��"� �./���0��� � �1� O.32 Y �� �!�� � � � %

½�d�h\xph4� . �.o%tpdfh�ovt*q�tph���qExv�.qK���:h qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�8½X��t*d5(�qKo%�.� � D&�>¤�qK�f�6� O. ��h���yKtph\o%�:tpo�}fxphO�`�:yErfo��q��.r�hK¾/cXd�h�g�yExph��.�$tpr��:tv�:�Kh �.�$tvh�xp}fxphOt*q�tp��y$�8yK¡+t*d��:o ovt*q�tph\g�h\�$tX�.o�à W �87 �9( 7 O Q 2 Y Z>¤�½�dfh\xph�:����hºs �:6"7��h���yKtph\o�tpdfh7�.�foptpqK�$t*o�qKt�½�d��.�>dR�?yKt*d � qE�f��(¶qKxph7}fxph\oph\�$t �¯tpdfhO�.x��O��y��>Á`o�qKxphop}?h\�O� Â?h\�¹tvy��?h h�`rfqK� �>¾'cXdfh�op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�8yK¡+q�xphO�K�.optvh\x/½/yEr��.�¹ov�.gj}���u7��h�Ã

��� � . ������� � �#� O. �� �!�� � �Z� d�WyEtvh tpd�q�t��?yKtpd[optpqKtvh\g�h��Et*o%�:gj}��:u8t*d�h h�`rfqK���:t�u�yK¡+�º�:y��>Á`o�Ã

�.'; � �gdM tvh�ovtp�:���j¡�y$xXqj}fxvy$}�h�xvt�u�Ã

��� ��<������� & � W �>= nPZ?�� �!�� & �Z� d�WyEtvh tpd�q�t�qj�ºy$�fovh �`r�h\�f�Oh yK¡+t*d��.o���hºÂ�����tp��y$�¹�:o\¤fq��$q��.�»¤

�.'; � �gd

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 11: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

J ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

M qjovu��f�>dfxpyE�f� W�q�tv�:yE�7�ºy$�fovt*xpqK�:�$t�ÃW & � / Z ; W"� � � / Z %

g�h\qK�f�:���jt*dfq�tXt*d�h��º�:y��>Á�y�¡ - �:o%t*d�h�ophOtXy�¡+�:��ovt*qK�$tpoXqKtX½�d��:�>d¹�?y$yE��h�qK�7��qKxp�:qE����h & �:o%t*xprfhK¾w�r�tvtp�:����t*d��.���EoXtpyK�EhOtpdfh\x/u`��h\�:�fo�tpd�h -0/�- Ã

u

u

u

-1

time

z�"� & ���0�+��(�� - �� �!�� ( � �q �"� � . ���0��� � � � O. 2 Y �� �!�� � �Z�q �"� �� ���0��� & ��W �-= nNZ �+ "!�� & ��

q �� ;1� . ;1���q W & � / Z ; W"� � � / Z

~ x*rf��y�¡"tpd��.o -X/�- ¡�yEx�tpd�h4(H�PqExv�.qK�f��h��.o%��h\}f�:�Otvh\�8yE��t*d�h Â��Erfxph qE��y��EhK¾+|qK�>d�tv�.gHh - �:o/xph\�ºh\���Eh\�»¤(¹�.o xvh�ovh\t qK�f�Z�Kh\tpo1tpdfh���qK�:r�hjyK¡ - ¾jcXdfh\� ([�:o ��h��Oxph\g�h\�$tph\�¶�Eu£y$��h�q�t1h\qE�>dZqE�ºtp����q�tp��y$�¢�Ou`�O��hyK¡2tpd�h -0/�- ¤5rf�$tv�:�+��tWxph\qE�>d�h\o�tpd�h���qK�:r�hInf¾ [{gjgHh����.q�tvh\��u£q�¡�tvh\x�tpd��.oW�.q�tptvh�x��.�fovt*qK�$tO¤�qj¡¯xph\o*d - �OqE��?h�xvh�qK�»¤�qE�f�¶ovy¹yE�»¾��WyEtvhjtpdfhjo*�>d$u�WOyE}�dfxvh����.���fqKtprfxphHyK¡�t*d�h/ {�.�f}fr�t*o#"jy�¡/tpd��.o -X/�- ¾�@-df���:h�tpd�h��qK�:r�hj�OqExpxp�:h\�_�$u - �:o1qK�¢�:��}fr�tO¤3tpd�hj�.�fovt*qK�$t1q�t�½�d��:�>d - �:o1xph\qK�_�:o ��yEt�ÃWxph\qE���:�f�8y�¡/tpd�h��.�f}fr�t�.o%yE�7��h\gjqE�f�`Û��fxv�:�Kh��8g�y���hK¾�cXdf�:o%�.oXxvhO¼�h\�Otvh��8�$u�tpdfh ¡¯qE�ºt%tpd�q�tX�.�f}fr�t*o%y�¡"t*d��.o -X/�- qKxph�tpd�h�}fqK�:x� qK�Otv�:�PqKtv�:yE�7�º�:y`�>Á ��¤f��qK�:r�h1yK¡ - ½�d�h��¹��tX�.oX}fxph\oph\�$t��$¾

+�ov�.���_t*d�h\oph7}fxp�.gH�:tv�:�Kh�oO¤'�fqKtpq�¼?y�½¿opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo1�.qK���$rfq��Eh\o o*rf�>d qKo '?) -0/"#"! � Z�q��.�f�K���/qK���3 587$9;:�<4� � I��fi�"qExvh�h\qEov�:�:u�h\�f�Oy���h\�»¾

� � Õ�� Õ�� ����� Ù�� � ÕF� ���Z� � Ú � Ù Ú���¯������� Ö � ~Wo�g�y��fr��.qKxp�:t�u��:oj½%qK�$tph\�»¤/��t��.o���h�ov�.xpqE���:h¹t*dfq�tt*d�h£}fqK�Oh7yK¡ qK� -X/�- �.o���y��OqK�%tvy¶��t�x*q�tpdfh\xHtpdfqE�R�E��y$�fq���¾ E$�.�f�ºh£qK�$u -0/1- �.ojopr��`z{h\�Ot�tpy¢¡¯r�xvt*d�h\x�OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�R�.�·ovy$gHh[uEhOt�rf�fÁ`��y�½��¸h\�$�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$tO¤�tpd��.o�gjqKÁKh\ojtpdfh_xvh �$rf�:xph\g�h\�$tjy�¡ dfqP�`�.���¶q�E��y$�fq���}fqK�Oh��`r���tph��.�f�ºy$�E�Eh\���:h\�$t\¾_cXd��:o��:o�½�d$u �Å�ª?Ó*§\Ä`¬*�O¬®­�­�ÄfÅ7Ç`«OÅ[§{Ò8¦O²�§�¦��«8­�Äf±�­�±�ÓpÅ[±�² �±�³P«ª�Ópź«ºÅO°�­�´2cXd��.od�qKo�ophO�Eh\x*q����OyE�foph�`r�h��f�ºh�oO¾�.+�.x*ovt\¤E�:t��.o��yEt}�y$opop�.����hWtvy��OyE�fop�:�fh\x2t*d�h1 p�ºyEgj}��:h\g�h��EtyK¡q8�O��y��>Á "�yEx�t*d�h� v��h\�EqKtv�:yE�[y�¡q7�º�:y��>Á="2ÃXtpdf�:o�½/yEr��.�_xph�`r��.xvh�xphº¡�h�xpxp�.����tvy¹tpd�h�q��:½/qPu�o }fxvh�ovh��$t�O��y��>Á�¾�cXd`rfoO¤+qKo1½X�:������h�xphO�Eh\q��:h\�¶�$u_yEr�x1hºsfqKgj}��:h\o\¤3�º�:y��>Á`o1½X���:�q��:½%qPu`o1�?h���qKxp�:qE����h�oO¤"qK�f�Z½�ho*dfqK���»�?h1qE���:h�tpy�xphO�.q�tph��O��y��>Á`o/yE���:u8rfop�.��� Y �¯�.�$tvh\x*oph\�ºtp��y$��yK¡"�.�fovt*qK�$tpo%yK¡"}fxph\oph\�f�Oh��>¤ , �Ër�����y$�8yK¡�.�foptpqE�Et*o%y�¡'}fxvh�ovh��f�ºh��¨¤�qE�f��@��ovh\t���� ��h�xvh��f�ºh1y�¡'�.�fovt*qK�$tpo%yK¡'}�xvh�ovh��f�ºh��¨¾

& �"�O� Õ � � � "&� [{��t*d�h¹o*qKg�h7�KhO�.�»¤��:tjopd�y$r��.�R�?h¹}?h\x*g���tptvh\��¤2¡�yExjqK� -X/�- ¤�tvy¥��yZ�fyKtpdf�:���¶½�d��:��ht*d�h�h��E�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$t%�:o }�y$opop�.����u7½�y$xpÁ$�.����¾�cXd��:o�¡�h\qKtprfxph�dfqKoW��h\h\�[uKh\t��.��h\�$tv��Â�h��[�:�¹tpdfh��:��tptvh\x*q�t*rfxphqE�f���.o%Á$�fy�½���qKoW«¨­�Ç�­�­NÅOÓ>¬®°$ÈW�:�$��qKxp�.qK�f�Oh�yEx/xvy$�frfoptp��h�opo!� � qKg JK�Eq`¤ � qKg JE�K�&��¾R[�t/�.o��Oh\�$tpx*q���tvy / <&:2¤½�dfh\xph��:t'�:o2rf����h\x*ovtpy`y`��tpdfqKt2q t*xpqE�fop��tp��y$��½X�:tpd���y h\�Kh��Et2qKt+qK���fqE�f����y �>dfqE���Kh�y�¡5ovt*q�tvh�o+�:o2qK��½%qPu�o�:hO�$q���¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 12: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �

.?yExXqK� -0/�- C ¤�ovt*r�tvtph\xp�:�f���.�$��qKxp�:qE�f�ºh1�.oX��hºÂ?�fh\�[qKo/¡�yE���:y�½�o�Ã+� ¡^`_a* bR% * Qx% * T]%cdeded

�.oXqjxpr��7yK¡[C ¤�opyj�:o^���_a* bR% � bR%cdedede% � b

� ��� �b����� ��������% * Q�% � Qx%edcded�% � Q�% * TR% � T]%cdedcd�% � TR%ededcd % �� �

½�dfh\xph1opu�g��?yK� � o2�fh\��yEtvh\oXq¹«>¬®²�ÅO°�­"ovt*q�tvh �.�¹½�d��.�>d¹qK����optpqKtvh ��qKxp�.qK���:h\oXÁKhOh\}7tpdfh �PqK�:rfh tpd�h\u7dfqE�qKt optpqKtvh�* o ¤5½�d����:h�yKtpdfh\x �PqExv�.qK�f��h�o�tpqEÁ�h�t*d�h��PqK�:rfhP�H¾ cXd�hH�`rfgH��h�xWyK¡�.�fovh�xvtph\�_op�:��h��Et�ovt*q�tph\o �:o� n7�fr�t�Â?���:tvhE¾HcXd��.o1gHy���h\�:o�t*dfq�t1tpdfh��OyE�fop�:�fh\xph\� -0/�- �OqK�Z��y[��yKt*d��:�f�8¡�y$x�qE�$u[qExp�f��t*xpqExvu[�fr�tÂ�����tph v��rfxpqKtv�:yE� ">¾E$t*r�tvtph\xp�:�f���.�$��qKxp�:qE�f�ºh��:oX�fyKt%dfqKx*��½X�.xvh����.�EtpyjyErfx -0/1- ¡�y$xpgjqK���.opg¹¤��fr�tXq �`r��.�>Áj�:�fo*}?h\�ºtp��y$�8yK¡

qK���5t*d�h�optpqKtvh�gHh��$tpo/½�h1dfqP�EhW�.�Et*xvy��fr��ºh\���:�7yErfx�hºsfqEg�}f��h1xvh\�Kh�q��.o�tpd�q�tXqK�$u��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE��yK¡3tpd�h�g�.o�ovt*r�tvtph\xp�:���7�:�$��qKxp�.qK�$tO¾ � yExph��Kh���h\x*q��:��uE¤�qE�$u -0/�- ��yEtW�.�$�KyK�:�`�:�f��tpd�h�q��:½/qPu�o�}�xvh�ovh��Et��º�:y��>Á ����h�:t����.xvh��ºtp��u�y$x%�:�����:xph\�Otv�:u����.o�optpr�tptvh�xv�.���j�:�$��qKxp�.qK�$tO¾

� ����� � ��$� ��X� � ��� � ���� � � �0� ����� ��� �$���,� (� � ��� �U � � � ���������� � � 1�H� � ��X� � �

����� ��� �"!$#&%'!(��)+*-,/.�021�)4365UXqEov�.�OqK���:uK¤ft*d�hH}�xvy$����h�g��.o�t�½/y�¡�yE�:�1à i��j�fx*r�tphº¡�yEx*�ºh�oph\}�qKx*q�tvh��OyEgj}��:�:qKtv�:yE�[�OqE�£�OqErfovh��fh\qK�f��y��>Á`oO¤qE�f� D&�1�Kh\�fh\x*q�tv�.�������.optpxp�:�frftvh\�8�ºy���h��.o�Eh\��h�xpqK���:uH�fyKt�OyEgj}fq�tp�:�f��h�½X�:tpd8g�qK�:�$t*q��.���:�f��ovt*xv�.�ºt/�ºy$g�Û}f���.qK�f�Oh�½X�:tpd¢tpd�hjovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfoWgHy���h\�'y�¡�ºy$gj}fr�tpqKtv�:yE�»¾ @¶hH�:���.rfoptpx*q�tphH�fxp��hO¼�u[tpd�h�ovh�t�½/y8�.opo*r�h\o�fhºs�tO¾

� � �?� Õ � Õ �+�f�P�f� Õ � Ù � ��� �¯���*� Ù�� �¸� Ö � Õ Ú"� � " Õ � Õ`Ù "�a� cXd��.o%�:o%�:���.rfoptpx*q�tph\���.�¹tpd�h�¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f�}f�:�Otprfxph�Ã

cXdfh�Â?x*ovt����.q��$xpqEg ��h�}��:�Otpo�tpd�h v��h�}�h��f��h��f�º�:h\o%"�qEopopy��º�.q�tph\�Z½X��t*d�ovy$g�h -X/�- o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE�1ÃHtpd�hi�ovt�yEr�t*}fr�t/��hOh��fo/tpd�hHi\opt�.�f}fr�t�¡�yEx���t*o��OyEgj}fr�t*q�tp��y$�»¤�qK�f��t*d�h DK�f��y$r�tp}�r�t���h\h\�fo�tpdfh DK�f���.�f}fr�t¡�y$x/��t*oX�ºyEgj}frftpq�tp��y$�»¾2cXd�h1ovh��ºyE���8���.q��$xpqEg o*d�y�½�o%q�}�y$opop�:�f��h1op�>dfh\�fr��:�.����¤f�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�f�f�:����tvyjtpd�hoptpqE�f�fqExp�Zop�>d�h��fr��:�:�f��Ãji��8xvh�qK�_�.�f}frftpo\¤�D&�7�OyEgj}fr�tphjxph\qE�ºtp��y$�»¤3� ��h\g��:t yEr�t*}fr�t*oO¾�cXd��.o1�K�:�Kh�o�q

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 13: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

i�� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

�OyEx*xvh��ºt�oph�`r�h��$tv�.q��/hºs�h\�\r�tv�:yE� yK¡Wtpdfh -0/�- ¾ [{�Rtpd�h¹tpd��.x*�R���.q��$xpqEg7¤2qE�RqK������tp��y$�fq��%��h�}�h��f��h\���ºu�.o�h\�`¡�y$xp�Oh\�_�$u_ophOtptv�.���7t*d�h��ºy$�fov�.��h�xvh�� -X/�- �.�ZopyEg�h�h��$�$�.xpyE�fg�h\�$t ½�d��:�>dZxvh�qK�Otpo ½X��t*dZ��y[��h\�:qPutpy7�:tpo1�.�f}frftpo�Ã1q¹��h\qE����y��>Á¹�.o��\xvh�q�tph\�»¾�[{�Ztpdfh��.qKopt1���:qK�Ex*qKg¹¤»d�y�½/hO�Kh�xO¤��:t��.o1xvh\�Kh�q��:h\�£t*dfq�t1tpdf�:oqE�f���:tv�:yE�fqK�3��h�}�h��f��h\���ºu7�\qKrfoph\�[�$u8t*d�h�h��E�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$t%�:����hOh��[½/qEoX�ºyEgj}fqKtv�.���:h ½X��t*d[tpd�h�y$xv�:�K�.�fqK�o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE��¤fqK�f�[��y���h�qK���:y��>Á�xph\o*r���tph\�8¡¯xvy$g qE}f}��:u$�.���j�:tO¾ Z h\xphK¤���h�qK���:y��>Á�½%qKoX�OqErfoph\�¹�Eu7tpd�hqE�ºt*rfq��»�.gj}���h�g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE�7y�¡'tpd�h�o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�»¤f�fyKt��$u�tpdfh�op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�8�:tpophO��¡{¾cXd�h%t*xpqE����tp��y$�fq���qE�fov½/h\x+tpy t*d��:o}fxvy$���:h\g<�$u�tpdfh%opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo+}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjg��:�f�Wop�>dfy$yE��dfqKo2�?hOh��

tpy£xvhO¡¯rfovh��OyE�fop�:�fh\xp�:���[oph\}fqExpqKtvhj�ºyEgj}��:�.q�tv�:yE�1Ã1g�y��fr��:h\o1¡�y$xW¡¯r�xvt*d�h\x�xph\r�ovhjopdfyEr��.�Z�?h�optvyExph\�¶qKoopyEr�xp�Oh��Oy`�fhK¤�qE�f�7�OyEgH���:�fh\�[qKoXo*rf�>d¹��hO¡�yExph1�Oy���h �Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$�»¾7@Zh�o*dfq��:��d�y�½/hO�Eh\x��:qKtvh\xXophOh t*dfq�tt*d��.o���y`h\oX��yEtX��hOh��7tpy���h1t*d�h��OqEovhE¤fd�y�½�h\�Kh�xO¾

�7Õ � Ö�� � � � Ù�� �Ë�\�f��� Ù�� � cXdf�:oX�.o%�:���.rfoptpx*q�tvh��8�.�¹tpd�h1¡�yE���:y�½X�.����}��:�Otprfxph�Ã

cXdf�:oWÂ��Er�xvh���h\}��.�ºt*o1q8�ºy$gjg�rf���.�OqKtv�:yE�£o*�ºh��fqKxp��yWÃ/t�½/y7}�xvy��ºh�opopyEx*o\¤�g�y`�fhO�:��h��¢qKo�oph�`r�h\�$tp�:qK�+gjq�Û�>df�:��h�oO¤3hºsf�>dfqK�f�KhHg�h�opo*q��Eh\o�rfov�.���£qK�¶qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoWg�h����:r�g ¡�yEx�t*d�hO�.x �ºy$g�gHrf���.�OqKtv�:yE�fo\¾HcXd�h��q�tpr�xpqK�5optpx*rf�Otprfxph yK¡3tv�.g�h1�:o%t*dfq�t%y�¡+q�ªf±�Ó>­�¬¯±�²'§�ÓpÆEźÓ��»qKo%��h�xv�:�Kh��j¡¯xvy$g tpdfh1�f�:xph\�Otvh\�8�Ex*qK}fd7�ºy$g�Û}?yEoph\�¹yK¡/i����:�.��h\qExXtv�.g�h yE�¹h\qE�>d¹}�xvy��ºh�opopyEx\¤�qK�f� D ���OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$�foO¾�cXd��:oWovt*xprf�Otprfxph1¡�yEx%tp�:g�h�fy$h�o���yEtWgjq�tp�>d¹t*d�h��:�:��h�qKxXtp�:g�h��ºyEx*xph\o*}�y$�f���.���Htpy�tpdfh��:��Â?���:tvh�oph�`r�h��f�ºh yK¡2xph\qE�ºtp��y$�fo%½�d��.�>d[�:ot*d�h �Kh�xvu���qKop�:o%yK¡+opu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o/}�qKx*qK���:�Eg¹¾

� � Õ �"Õ`Õ Ú �NÙ �H� Õ �f� Ù�� � � "£��� Ù "���K��+�������¯� Ö�� ��� � Õ Ú ���� � "�� � � � Ú�� Ù � � � �Ë�K���*� Ù�� �R� cXdf�:o�fhOh\�jh�g�h\xp�Kh\o+¡¯xpyEgÑtpd�h qK�?y��KhX���.op�\rfopop�:yE�»¾ [{�jtpd�h ��hºs�to*rf�foph\�Otv�:yE�»¤E½�h�o*dfq��:�f�.�$tpxpy`��rf�ºhWq r���� �`r�h¡¯x*qKg�h\½�y$xpÁ�tvy�d�qK�f���:h1tpd�h�ovh��f���Eh\x*ovh1qKo*}�h��ºt*o�Ã'tpd�h1¡�y$xpgjqK���.opg�y�¡/«º¦¨ÄfŨÆ�Ç�²�¬®°$È�«Nª�Ũ¦O¬ É�¦¨±�­�¬¯§�°�«º´

����� ��� ��)��-1&# ��� % * )��#���� �"!/#�.��-%4�� Õ`Ù �PÚ Õ ��� � � Ú �'���P���Ë��� Ù ��Ú Õ �P�1� Ù � Ù Ú Õ �5�K��+�������¯� Ö � Õ �Ë����� Ù�� � � ��� � Õ Ú� �#� � "?� � � � Ú � Ù � ×� � �¯�K�f��� Ù�� �R� Í/qErfo*q��:��t�u�xvh\�:qKtv�:yE�fo»dfqP�Eh���h\h\� �.�$�Kh�ovtp���$q�tvh�� ¡�yEx3ophO�Eh\x*q���uEh\qKx*o5�.� tpd�h�}fqKopt��.� tpd�hqExvh�q�y�¡g�y���h\�:o�y�¡�f�:optpxp�:��r�tvh��¢opu`optvh�gjo qE�f�¢�OyEgj}fr�t*q�tv�:yE��oO¾1cXd�hj�º�.qKo*ov�.�OqK�"qK}�}fxvy$qK�>d[�ºy$�fop�:��h�xpoqj�O�:qEopop�:�\q���qEr�tvy$g�qKtvy$�»¤��:�¹½�d��.�>d[�ºy$�f�Orfx*xph\�f�Ou��:o�g�y���h\���:h\�¹�`�:qjqE� v�.�f��h\}?h\����h\�f�Oh"1h�`r��:�PqK��h��f�ºhxphO�.q�tp��y$��qKg�y$����tpdfh/�.qK�?hO�.o"y�¡�t*d�h�t*xpqE�fop��tp��y$�foO¾SE$�.�f�ºh/�:����h\}?h\�f�fh\�f�Oh��.o+�Kh\�fh\x*q��:��u1��yKt'qWopu�gjgHh\tpxp�:�xphO�.q�tp��y$�4�ËqE�ºtv�:yE��o�y�¡"½�xv�:tv�.����qE�f��xph\qK�f�:���HqKxphW��yKt/ovu�gjg�hOt*xv�.�2�>¤$t*d�hWt*d�hOy$xvujyK¡�tpx*qK�ºh�o � ~�l J>J���dfqKo�?hOh�� hºs�tph\�f��h��1tvyWopy�Û��OqK���:h\�� povh�g�� Û��ºy$g�gHr�tpqKtv�:yE�fo%"'� Í � J$�)�N¤�qK�f�1t*d��:o"tvh��>df�����`r�hdfqEo3�?hOh\��xvh��ºh\�$tp��u

JF ��$J?;

Page 14: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« iEi

qE}f}��:��h���tpy�t*d�h1�:gj}��:h\g�h��Et*q�tp��y$��y�¡'xvh�qK�Otv�:�Kh qEr�tvy$gjq�tpqHyE�7���.ovt*xv�.�fr�tph\�¹qKx*�>d���tph\�Otprfxph\o�� ÍXÍ I��$�$�2��¾Í/qErfo*q��:��t�uR}�xvh\yEx*��h\x�xphO�.q�tp��y$�fo�dfqP�Eh[qK�:opy��?hOh\�µr�ovh��·�:�µq ��� �5h\xph\�$t�½%qPu��:� � UWÍ ZW�?I���� ��¤/¡¯xpyEg½�df�:�>d7½�h �?yEx*xvy�½µt*d�h h\o*oph\�$tv�.q��.o/y�¡"t*d�h }fxph\oph\�$t%tvh\�>d���� �`r�hE¾R[{�7qE�f���:tv�:yE�7tvy�g�y���hO�:���.�����OqErfo*q��:��t�uxphO�.q�tp��y$�fo\¤5}�xvh\yEx*��h\x*oW�\qK�_�?h�rfovh��_tpy¹o*}�h��º��¡�u¢o*�>d�h\�frf���.���7xph�`r��.xph\g�h\�$tpo\¤5tpd�h\u¢�OqE�_q��.opy7�?hjr�ovh��tpy�gHy���h\�3oph\�f� ��xvh��ºh\���Eh t�u�}?h�yK¡'�OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$�foO¾

@¶h_�ºy$�fov�.��h�x�q¶ophOtg6 yK¡���qKxp�.qK���:h\o\¾µ~ ª?ÓpŨ§�Ó*ÆKÅOÓHy$�¸t*d�h_ophOt06 �:o�q xphO�.q�tp��y$� �Ë�Kh\�fh\xp�:�\q��:��u�fh\��yEtvh\�¥�$u��!� ½�d��.�>d¶�:o�xvhO¼�hºs��:�Kh4� W�� W;�1qK���Zt*xpqE�fop��tp���Eh��NW����ZqE�f����� (£�.gj}��:uBW�� ( �¨¾c"y��¿½/h8qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvhjtpd�h7h�`r��:��q��:h\�f�Oh8xvh\�:qKtv�:yE���H¤2��hºÂ���h\� �$u W��Z� �9W����¶qE�f� ��� W"¾ [N¡h �`r�����qK��h��f�ºh �º�.qKo*oph\o/y�¡��<qExvh1ov�.���E��h\tvyE��oO¤�t*d�h\���=�.o�qHªf±�Ó>­�¬¯±�²+§�ÓpÆKÅOÓO´cXd�h_¦¨§�°��>Ç�°�¦O­Ë¬¯§�°7yK¡t�½/y¹}fxphOy$xp�fh\x*o��.o t*d�h�g��:���.gjq���}fxphOy$xp�fh\x�½�df�:�>d¢�:o1qK�¢hºs�tvh��fop��y$�_y�¡/tpd�h

t�½/y��ºy$�fov�.��h�xvh��8�ºy$�Pzvrf�f�Otpo\¾

-0/�- Ø ��� � ��� � Õ Ú ���� � "R�0� Õ �>�?)'�K���*� Ù�� �a� � y�½ ½�h��OyE�fop�.��h\x -0/�- CH� DN6 %vGI%KJ�L qEoW�?hº¡�yExphK¤��fr�t½X�:tpd¹t*d�h1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���jqK�f�f��tp��y$�fq��5¡�h�q�tpr�xvh�Ã�qEo%}fqKxpt%y�¡

M G WN6 Z ��xvh\�:qKtv�:yE�¹��hºÂ?�f�:���j�.���:tv�.q��3optpqKtvh\o�¨¤fqE�f�M J WF6PO % 6�Z��Ëtpx*qK�fop��tp��y$�7xphO�.q�tp��y$� �¨¤

½/h dfqP�Kh ª?Ó*Å*§�ÓpÆKÅOÓ¨«X��h\��yEtvh��7�$uW���� ¡�yEx W % � . 6 %

o*}?h\�º��Â�h��7�`�.q���ªf§P«¨«>¬*�O²�³7¦O³K¦º²�¬¯¦�� ���:xph\�Otvh��8�$xpqE}fdfo�ÃW���� ¡�y$xZW % � . 6 d

-0/�- �.�$�KyE���`�.����opr��>d�t�u�}�h y�¡3}fxphOy$xp��h�xxphO�.q�tp��y$��opdfqK������h1�OqK���:h\�j�.��t*d�h�oph�`r�h\� -0/�- �2¬®­®Ä8«O¦¨ÄfŨÆ�Ç�² ¬®°$È«NªfŨ¦º¬ É/¦*±�­Ë¬¯§�°f«O´'~Wo"}fxphOyEx*��h�xpo�qExvh5zvr�ovt"���.Á�hqE�$uWyKt*d�h\x"xvh\�:qKtv�:yE�»¤ -0/1- ½X��t*d�o*�>d�h\�frf���.���Wo*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�foqExvh�zvrfovt��:�:ÁKh¹qE�Eu¶yKt*d�h\x -0/1- ¤d�h��f�ºh¹tpdfhOu¥�:��d�h\xp��t�tpdfhO�.x�}�xvy$}�h�xvtp��h�oO¤'�.�R}fqExvtp�:�\r��:qEx�­�ÄfÅO³¥¦¨±�° �¨Å¦¨§�©Wªf§P«OŨÆK´

�[Ù �\�f��� Ù�� � �NÙ �8��� � Õ Ú ���� � "¥��� Õ �(��)+�E����� Ù�� � Ã'¡�yEx & q���qKxp�:qE����h1yK¡"t�u�}�h��¨§�§�² r x� " ¤�qK��� - %����qExv�.qK���:h\o/yK¡'qE�Eu�t�u�}?hK¤

�"��& ������� - � � ¤fxvh�op}»¾ ���<& �� �!�� - � �

�.oX��h���yKtph\�[�$u

- &� � xph\o*}»¾ - &

� �

� yKtph�t*d�h1¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:���WÃ

- �&

� �� ��� ������! #" $&%

�� - &� �

� � � ������! #" $&%(' ��� )*)+)

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 15: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

i D ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

[{�[qE}f}�h��f����s7~�¤���tX�.o�o*d�y�½���t*dfq�t�o*�>d�h\��r����.����o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�foXdfqP�Eh t*d�h1¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:����}fxpyE}?h\xptv�:h\o3Ã

W &� � h � � � ( � W & Y � � ( �¯� �

W &� �h W � � � � W & ,6� � � � G �

w�xvy$}�h�xvtp��h�o��¯�?¤ G �/�OqK�£�?h�rfoph\�¹tpy8�ºy$g�}�r�tvh��.�f}frft��Py$r�tp}�r�tWqK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE��o%y�¡�op�>dfh\�fr��:�.����op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�Ûtp��y$�fo�Ã

h l

kch

b l

(a (b c)) ka

b

h

c

l

k

[{�-tpd��.o7Â��ErfxphK¤Xt*d�h¥���:qK�Ex*qKg yE�µt*d�hZ�:hº¡�t[��h�}��:�Otpo¹qRo*�>d�h\��r����.���Ro*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE�-�:�$�KyE���`�.�����:y��Oq����qExv�.qK���:h\o\¾'cXd�h\oph�qKxph�df�:�f�fh\�¹�:�¹t*d�h����.q��Ex*qKg¿y$�8t*d�h�xp���$dEt\¤frfop�:����x*r��:h\o �¯�?¤ G �¨¾

�0�!�NÕ �P� � � " ��� � Õ Ú� �#� � " ��� Õ �(��)+�E����� Ù�� � � � Ù � �E��"�����#��� Ö � � ��� Ö ���Ë�R� cXd�h¹�.��h\q¶opr�}f}�y$xvtp�:�f��\qKrfo*q��:�:t�u¥qE�fq��:u�ov�.oHy�¡ qE� -0/�- o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE�R�:o��`r��:tvh[op�:gj}��:hK¾ >���tpdfh¹y$��h[dfqK�f��¤�qZtpx*qK�fop��tp��y$�xphO�.q�tp��y$�R�.�$�KyE���`�.��� yE���:uRt*d�h_t�u�}?h\o p}frfxph"£qK�f� p�?y$yE��h�qK� "£�OqE���?hZopyK�:�Kh��¸�$u·rf����Â?�OqKtv�:yE�·qK���t*d`rfoXgjqK��h1hºs�h��Or�t*qK���:hK¾1>��7tpd�h yEtpd�h�x%dfqK�f��¤�q�tpx*qK�fop��tp��y$�8xphO�.q�tp��y$�8�.�$�KyK�:�`�:�f��qExp���:tpx*qKxpujt�u�}�h�o%�:oqE�foptpx*qK�ºtph\�[qKo�tvh\x*g xvh\½�xv�:tv�.����¤�h\�f�Oy`�fh\�[�`�:q��f�:xph\�Otvh\�[�$xpqE}fdfo\¾ .?yEx��.�foptpqE�f�ºhE¤?xphO�.q�tv�:yE� � ��� - � T�Ë�:�$�EyK�:�$�.���?¤�o*qPuK¤5xvh�q��"t�u`}?h\o���:o�qK�foptpx*qK�Otvh��_qKo W - %�� Z � �5¤»ov�.�f�ºh �£�OqK�¢��hjopr��fovtp��t*r�tvh��¢�$uhOsf}fxvh�opop�:yE��� - � T ¾ >���tpd�h yKtpdfh\xd�qK�f�»¤$tpdfh xphO�.q�tv�:yE� �BX - � T � n@�Ëq��$q��.���:�$�KyE���`�.����xph\qK�ft�u�}�h�o��2�:oqE�foptpx*qK�ºtph\��qEo�tpdfh�¡¯r��:�»���:xph\�Otvh����Ex*qK}fd�½X�:tpd8�Kh\xptv�.�ºh�o W - %�� %�� Z>¤fqKo���y�tph\x*g¿xvh\½�xv�:tv�.��� �.o�}?yEo*ov�.���:hK¾~<�f�����Orf��t�u8qExv�.oph\o�¡¯xvy$g tpdfh�dEu��fxp�.�7�fqKtprfxph1y�¡+�Kh\�fh\x*q�� -X/�- ¤f�.�8½�d��.�>d[��y`yE��h�qK����qExv�.qK���:h\oX�\qK�¹��h�OyEgj}fr�tph\�j¡¯xpyEg t*d�h h\��q��.rfq�tp��y$�jy�¡3��y$�`ÛN�?y`yK�:h\qE�jhºsf}fxph\o*ov�:yE�fo �¯hE¾ �?¾�¤ & ��W W � nNZ �¨¤�qE�f��tpdfh\�8r�ovh��qEoXqj�ºyE�$t*xvyE����qExv�.qK���:hK¾@¶h¢��y�½ }fxvy��`�.��h[q¥tvh\�>d���� �`r�h[¡�y$xj�:��¡�h\x*xv�.��� op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���Eo�¡¯xpyEg �\qKrfo*q��:�:t�uRqK�fqK��u�op�:oH¡�y$x -X/�-

o*}?h\�º��Â�h��¶qEo��ºy$�Pzvrf�f�Otv�:yE�fo�y�¡%tpd�h8}�qKxptv�.�Or��.qKx ophOt yK¡%}fxp�.gH�:tv�:�Kh�optpqKtvh�gHh��$tpo ½/h�dfqP�Khj�.�$tpxpy`��rf�ºh��opy¹¡¯qKx\¾ [{�¢¡�y$xpgHr���� � H �¨¤"h\qE�>dZ}fxp�.gH�:tv�:�Kh�optpqKtvh\g�h��Et�d�qKo q[op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���£op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�ZqEopopy��º�.q�tvh��½X�:tpdR��t\¤��K�:�Kh��¥yE� t*d�h[�ºyEx*xph\o*}�y$�f���.���¢xp���$dEtHdfqK�f�¸ov�.��h7y�¡�tpdfh7t*qK���:hK¾=I �:�Kh\�RqK� -0/�- o*}?h\�º��Â�h��qEo%tpd�hH�ºyE��zvrf�f�ºtp��y$�¹y�¡�q�ovh\tXy�¡2opr��>d¹optpqKtvh�gHh��$tpo\¤�¡�yExXh�qK�>d[�ºy$�Pzvrf�f�OtX½�h�qE�f�¹tpd�hH�ºyEx*xph\o*}�y$�f���.���o*�>d�h��fr��:�:����op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�-tpy¸t*d�h¶�OyE�fop�.��h\xph\� -0/�- ¾ E`�:�f�OhK¤��:�=tprfx*�»¤�op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f��o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fot*d�h\gjophO�:�Kh�o�d�qP�KhHo*�>d�h��fr��:�:���£o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo1qEopopy��º�.q�tvh��£½X�:tpdZtpd�h�g7¤"tpd��.o g�h\�>dfqE���.opgÊyK¡�qK�f�f�:���o*�>d�h��fr��:�:����op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�fo[g�rfopt[��h¥qK}f}f���:h\�Àrf�$tv�:�1Âfsf}�yE�:�$t¹�:o[xph\qK�>dfh\�»¾¿�WyEtvh¶tpdfqKt£qK}f}��:u`�:�f�t*d�h\oph8x*r��:h\o�r��Etp����Âfsf}?yK�.�EtH�:oHxvh�qK�>d�h��¶tpqKÁKh\oHq�t�g�yEopt�t�½/y¢o*rf�O�Oh\o*ov�:�Kh�}fqEopoph\o\¾ [{�¥¡�yEx*g�rf�� �#H �¨¤�.qK�?hO�.oXyK¡'o*�>d�h\��r����.���$oXqKxph�hOsf}fxvh�opop�:yE�fo/�.�E�EyK�:�`�:���j��qKxp�.qK���:h\o%�.�¹tpd�h��fyEgjq��.�$ ]� %(')% /&" y$xp��h�xvh��8�$u ]�� ' /&" Ì�½X�:tpd�tpd��.o2�.�Hg��.�f�»¤Ehºsf}fxph\o*ov�:yE�fo+�.�$�KyK�:�`�:�f�Wtpdfh�ovu�g��?yK�.o <Y$"���g��:� �+qE�f� , "��Ëgjq�s��d�qP�Kh1q��O��h�qKxXg�h\qE���.����¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 16: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« i��

�¯lXÛ¨i�� j - � � �:-

�¯lXÛ�D&� ���'& ������� � � -�� "!�� � � � �

����������� ����������& ������� � ' ����� � ���� �

� ��� � � ���� � � ��� � � ���- � ����� � �� � ��� � � �

�¯lXÛ�� � - � � � � & � � ��¯l�Û�� � � ��� W - Qx%edcdede% -�� Z

��� � � ��� � dedcd �9� ����� � - o ��� � �

�#H �

lWrf��h�o/�¯l�Û*iE¤�¾\¾O¾O¤ lXÛN� �>¤fqKo%½/hO�:�3qKoXt*d�h�t*d�hOy$xvh�g tvyj¡�yE���:y�½ ¤�qKxph�¡�yEx*gjq��:��u zvr�ovtp� Â�h��[�:�£qE}f}?h\�f����s~�¾R[{�¹tpd��.o�qK}�}�h��f����s5¤fqj}fxph\�O�:oph ��hºÂ�����tp��y$�¹y�¡ �ÆKÅO­NÅOÓ>©H¬®°?¬.«>­Ë¬¯¦#"��.o�q��.opyH�E���Eh\�»¾� � Õ`Ù � Õ � � + Õ L Õ � 3������� Õ -0/�-�2! §�Ó#"�±�° -0/�- �$ ´�/ªEª?²�³#% Ç�²�Å>«(�&% � $ �Ë´\´�´�'%��&( �WÇ�°?­Ë¬®²*É*)Oª�§�¬®°�­�¬.«ÓpŨ±K¦¨ÄfŨÆ,+/­®Ä�¬.«�³�¬¯Åº²�Æ�«%±�° -0/�- �ÅX¦¨±�²®² ��� � Õ Ú + " 2 ´- ´�<o*r ���º�:h\�$tH¦¨§�°5Æ�¬®­�¬¯§�°jÒº§�Ó."¶­�§HÄf±=�PÅj±�Ç�°�¬0/OÇ�Å�ÆKÅO­�źÓ>©�¬®°�¬.«>­�¬¯¦�Ó>Ç�°£¬.«1+

�{± � ��� � Õ Ú + " 2 ¬.«'ª?Ó*§���± �O²�³�¦O¬®Óp¦OÇ�¬®­ Ò¨ÓpŨÅ�±�­'Å*±E¦*Ä�¬®°f«>­�±�°?­*��©�Ũ±�°�¬®°`È ­�Äf±�­?�:t'�:o2��h\�Kh�x"t*xprfh/t*dfq�tW+Q � � � W(T �32 � W"Q

� � ÚW & Q Y & T � / Z

Ç�°?²�ź«*«|W Q ��W T Äf§�²�ÆP«O´�%� � ��� � Õ Ú + " 2 Ä�±P«2ª�Óp§���± �O²�³�°�§ ©�Ç�²�­�¬ ª?²�Å1ÆEůɰ�¬®­�¬¯§�°¹§vÒ'��±�Ó>¬¯±&�º²�ź«�±�­'±�°�³�¬®°�«¨­�±�°?­*�"©jŨ±�°?¬®°$È

­�Äf±�­*� �"Ä�ź°5Å���ÅOÓ� � & Q�� � ÕF� W �547698 Q

Y � � & T�� � ÕF� W �547698 T

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 17: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

i\� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

Ä�§�²�Æ�«�¬®°�" ±�°5Æ�­�ÄfÅ 47698 Q ±�°�Æ 47698 T ±�ÓpÅ�Æ�¬ � ÅOÓpÅO°�­XÅ )Oª?Ó*Å>«¨«>¬¯§�°�« ��­�ÄfÅO°& Q Y & T � /

°5Å���ÅOÓ Äf§�²:ÆP«�¬®°�"�´@5Ä�ź°�"¢¬.«1«O±�¬¯Æ�­�§��¨Å�hºs�h\�\r�tpqE����hE¤+±�°�Æ ��� � Õ Ú + " 2 ª�Óp§���¬¯ÆKź« �{Æ�³�°�±�©H¬¯¦��j«O¦*Ä�Å*Æ�Ç�²�¬®°$È�«Nª�Ũ¦O¬ É�¦¨±�­�¬¯§�°�«Òº§�Ó ­®Ä�¬.« Ó>Ç�°�´

% L���� ��� Õ �R� @¶h o*d�y�½µd�h\xphWopyEg�h -0/�- optpq�tph\g�h\�$t*oqK����tpd�h\�:x�qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�jo*�>d�h\��r����.����qEo��h�xv�:�Kh��¡¯xpyEg �OqErfopqK���:t�u¢qE�fq��:u�ov�.oO¾ [{�¶tpd�h�¡�yE���:y�½X�.���[Â��Er�xvh�oO¤"�Kh\xptv�.�ºh�o1�:� �?yK�.�`¡¯qE�ºh���h���yKtph��:��}fr�t��O��y��>Á`oO¤�Eh\xptv�.�ºh�oW�.�¢�?yK�.�`ÛN��t*q��:�:����h\�fyKtvh��.�f}fr�t �fqKtpqf¤�qE�f�_�Eh\xptv�.�ºh�oW�.�Z�OyErfxp�:h\xW�fh\��yEtvhjyKt*d�h\x ��qKxp�:qE����h�oO¾�[�t�.o�yK¡/�.�$tvh�xvh�ovt�tpy¢o*}����:t��?hOt�½/hOh��¥tpd�h�ovh�t�½/y_��� ��h�xvh��$t�t�u�}�h�o y�¡X�.�f}fr�t*oO¤2qKo��:��}fr�t�xph\qE���:�f�[¡�yEx�qE�-0/�- �OqK��y`�\�Orfx�½X�:tpd8qE�$uj�OyEgH���:��q�tv�:yE�jyK¡"�fqKtpq�Û2qK������h\gjqE�f�`Û��fxv�:�Kh���g�y`�fhK¾2�WyEtvh tpdfqKtO¤`¡�yEx�h\qE�>d�Eh\xptvhOs¹yK¡�tpd�hH�Ex*qK}fd»¤�tpdfh��.qK�?hO�.o op��tptv�.���8y$�£tpdfh��.�f�ºy$gH�.���¹�fxpqE�f�>d�h�o�qKxph�hO��qK�:rfqKtvh��_}fxp��y$x�tvy7tpd�h�OyE�fop�.��h\xph\�¥�Eh\xptvhºs»¾¶cXd$r�oO¤2½�d�h���t*d��:o��Eh\xptvhºs¥�.o�tpy¶�?h8h\�PqK�:r�q�tvh��»¤2�:tH�.ojq��.xvh�qK��u¶Á$�fy�½�� ½�d��.�>dyEtpd�h�xX��qKxp�:qE���:h\oXqKxph ��hOh���h\�7¡�y$xX��t*o�h\�PqK�:r�q�tv�:yE��¾ E$hOh�tpd�h�qE}f}�h��f����s7¡�y$x�q�¡�yEx*gjq���o*rf}f}?yExptXy�¡2tpdf�:o�O�:qK�:g¹¾

� Ú+���\� × Ú"� ��� Õ�� �\�\��� Õ � Õ�� �'�

���<& ���0��� (�� - �+ "!�� (�� �zh

zhzh

hb

hu vh

vu

b

z

b b

bb

(input clock)(input data)(other)

[{�[t*d�h�qE��y��Eh�hOsfqKgj}��:hK¤��.�f}frftW�fq�t*q�qKxph�}fq��.xp½X�:oph qKo*ovy��º�.q�tph\�¹½X�:tpd£�ºy$xpxph\o*}?yE�f���.���j�.�f}fr�tW�O��y��>Á`o�Ãt*d��.o -0/1- xph\qK��o2��t*o��.�f}fr�t*oy$��q�}frfxphO�:uj�fq�t*q�Û��fxv�:�Kh��jgHy���hE¤E�.�f}frft�}fqKtvtvh�xp��o W - %�� % & Z2qKxph%¡¯xvh\h�tvy���h}�xvh�ovh��Et2y$xqE�fovh��$tO¤EqE�f�»¤$½�d�h\��tpd�h\u�qExvh�}fxph\oph\�$t\¤Et*d�hO�.x���q��.r�h��.o2¡¯xphOh q��.ovy?¾!@¶h �\q��:�f��t/q pxvh�qK�ºtp���Eh"-0/�- ¾

�7Õ ��� Õ � Õ�� �*� � "_�¢� Õ "��¯�\� Õ �%�

�"� � . ���0��� � �1� O. 2 Y �� �!�� � � �h

local

h tick

z

v

h

h ξz-

ξz

JF ��$J?;

Page 18: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« i G

� � Õ � �� � Õ L����=��� Õ �

u

u

u

-1

time

z�"� & ���0�+��(�� - �� �!�� ( � �q �"� � . ���0��� � � � O. 2 Y �� �!�� � �Z�q �"� �� ���0��� & ��W �-= nNZ �+ "!�� & ��

q �� ;1� . ;1���q W & � / Z ; W"� � � / Z

~ }f}��:u`�:���jt*d�h�xprf��h�o �¯lXÛ¨iK¤:¾O¾\¾O¤ lXÛ�� ��¡�yEx%�.�`¡�h\x*xv�.����o*�>d�h\�frf���.���Eo�¡¯xpyEg �OqKr�opqK���:t�uK¤`½/h��EhOt�Ã

u

hzz

h

h

h

local

ξ-

h

tick

h

b

hh

vbzb

hh

zξz

u

�"� & ���0�+��(�� - �� �!�� ( � �q �"� �. ���0��� � � � O. 2 Y �� �!�� � �Z�q �"� � � ���0��� & ��W �-= nNZ �+ "!�� & ��q � � ;1�. ;1� � ;�� % � �q W & � / Z ; W"� � � / Z

� yKtph¹t*d�h_�>dfqE���Kh¹�:�·�OyE�$tpxpyK�Eà � �.�f}fr�t��O��y��>Á�¤ �.�f}fr�t���q�tpq �[d�qK�?h_��h\h\�·�fx*qKoptv�.�Oq��:�:u�gHy�����Â�h��¡¯xpyEg�tpd�h � � & � � ÕF� ( � - Õ �¯� Õ6( � � "1optpqKtvh\g�h��EtXtpy�tpd�h��OyEgj}��:hOtph -0/�- Ã2�.�f}fr�t*oW��y�½ �ºy$�fov�.optyK¡+t*d�hH}�q��.x *� %�� � " ¤f½�dfh\xph � � xphº¡�h�xpoXtpy�tpd�h��PqK�:rfh��OqExpxp��h��7�$u - ½�d�h��£}fxvh�ovh��$tO¾/l�h\qE���:�f��y�¡2tpd�h- y��\�Orfx*o%yE�¹��h\gjqE�f�»¤�½�d�h��¹�OyE�f�f��tp��y$� & �.o%tpx*r�hK¾�cXd`rfo%½/h �Oq��:�3o*rf�>d¹qK� -X/�- p}fxpyEqK�Otv�:�Kh�"¨¾& �� �¸��� Ö � @-dfqKt%�fy�½�h1�Kh\tXq�tXtpdf�:o�optpqK�Kh�BiK¾ -X/�- �OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�8�.o+zvrfopt�tpd�h��OyE�Pzvr��f�ºtp��y$�8yK¡'�OyE�foptpx*q��.�$tpo\¾D�¾ E$�.�f�ºh�}fxphOy$xp�fh\x*o�qExvh/zvrfopt�xvh\�:qKtv�:yE�fo\¤fo*�>d�h\�frf���.����op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�fo%��y��ºy$gj}�y$ovh1qKo%½/hO�:�˾�f¾X~WoH�OqKr�opqK���:t�u¢qK��q��:u`op�.o1�:o���qKoph\�¶yE� qE�¶qE�foptpx*qK�ºtp��y$�»¤�t*d�h8x*r���h�o �¯l�Û*iE¤�¾:¾�¾:¤ lXÛ�� �W¡�yEx �.�`¡�h�xpxp�:�f�op�>dfh\�fr��:�.����¡¯xvy$g��OqErfopqK���:t�u8qExvh1��y$rf�f�¹tvy�t*d�hj«>³�°�­�± )1yK¡"t*d�h -X/�- �OyE�Pzvr��f�ºt*oO¾

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 19: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

i*H ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

��¾ ZWh��f�ºhE¤$�.��y$xp�fh\x�tpyHgjq�s��.g�� W\hWtpdfh��>dfqE�f�ºhWy�¡3h,��h��ºtv�:�Kh\��u�xph\�OyK�E�f� W\�:��� t*dfq�t%qK� -X/�- "��.o/hºs�hºÛ�Or�t*qK���:hK¤ "��.o2�Kh���h\x*q��:�:u�xvh\½�xv�:tvtph\�H�:��q1��� �5h\xph\�$t�fr�t�oph\gjqE�Etp�:�\q��:��u�h�`r��:�PqK��h��$t�ovu��$tpq�s��Ëx*rf�foxvh�gjq��.�£tpd�h�opqEg�h��%½�df���:hH�\qKrfo*q��:��t�u[qK��q��:u`op�.oX�:o�}?h\xv¡�yEx*gHh�����¾ UXr�tWt*d��:o��.q�tptvh\xWyE}?h\x*q�tp��y$�[�:o�K�:yE�fqK�?qE�f����yEt��ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�fqK�KÃ+d�h\xphW½/hWxph\qK�>djt*d�h����.g���t*oyK¡3�fxprftvhº¡�y$xp�OhW�ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�fqK���:t�uK¾

� � � � � ��� � � � � � �0�1 � ��� � !� � � � � �� � � � � ��X� �c%½/y�gjq�z{yEx/�.opo*r�h�oX��hOh��8tpy���h��OyE�fop�:�fh\xph\�1ÃiK¾.%WÅO²�± )E¬®°`ȹ«>³�°�¦¨Ä`Óp§�°�³��.o���hOh���h\�¢� ¡%���:optpxp�.�fr�tv�:yE�¢y��Kh�xW}?yEo*ov�.���:u[qEovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo g�h\���.q��.o1��hºÛov�.xph\� ½X�:tpd�y$r�tj}fqPu`�:���¢tpd�h[}fxp�:�Oh�¡�yEx�gjq��.�Et*q��.���.���¢t*d�h7optpxpyE���Zovu��f�>dfxpyE�$u¥d$u`}?yKt*d�h\op�.o��`�:q�ºy$ovtp��u8}�xvyEtvy��ºyE�:o\¾

D�¾�ÎHź«>¬ È�°?¬®°$È�©j§�Æ�Ç�²�ź«�Å /OÇ�¬ ªKªfÅ¨Æ �2¬®­�Ä ª?Óp§>ª�ÅOÓ%¬®°�­�źÓ�Òº±E¦¨Å>«»Òº§�Ó/«>Ç��>«OÅ /OÇ�ź°?­»ÓpźÇ`«OÅ��$qE�f���Eh\��h�xpqKtv�.���q��ºy$xpxph\�Ot�op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���RqK���-�ºy$g�gHrf���.�OqKtv�:yE�·}fxpyKtvy��OyK�X¡�y$x�tpdfh\ophZg�y��fr��:h\o\¤X�:o8tpd�h¶Á�hOu�tvyg�y`��r��:qExv�:t�uK¾

@¶h��ºy$�fop�:��h�x/tpd�h�ovh t�½/yj�:o*oprfh\o%��hºs�t\¾

� ��� � )41&��� # � � %�� � � � , .���cXdfh8gjq�z{yEx�}fxvy$���:h\g �.o�t*dfq�tHy�¡Xtvh�ovtp�:�f�£¡�yExHqK�foph\�f�Oh��:� qE� qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo1h\�$�`�:xpyE��gHh��$t�¹cXdf�:o�.o1�:���.rfoptpx*q�tvh��¢�.�¶tpd�hj¡�yE���:y�½X�.���£}��:�Otprfxphj�:�¶½�d��.�>dZtpd�h��.�`¡�yEx*gjq�tp��y$�¢yK¡ v½�d��.�>dZqExvh�tpd�h���qExv�.qK���:h\o}�xvh�ovh��Et �.�¥tpdfh8�ºy$�fov�.��h�xvh��¢�.�foptpqK�$t%"j�.o��:yEopt ½�d�h\� }�qKo*ov�.���¹¡¯xvy$g �:hº¡�t�tvy¢xp���$d$t1d�qK�f� op�:�fhK¤'ov�.�f�ºhhOsf}����.�º�:t���hOÂ?���:tv�:yE�7y�¡'tpd�h v�:��ovt*qK�$t#"1�:oX��yEt�qP��q��:�:qE����h1qK�$u8g�y$xvh�Ã

test forabsence

synchrony asynchrony

?

cXdfh �$rfh\optv�:yE�fgjqKx*ÁX�.�f���.�OqKtvh\o3tpdfqKt»��t3�:o3�Kh\�fh\x*q��:��uW�fyKt�}?yEo*ov�.���:hK¤��:� qE��qEovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo�h��E�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$tO¤tpy8��h��º�.��hHrf}?yE�¢}fxvh�ovh��f�ºh���qE�fovh��f�ºh1yK¡q�ov�:�E��q��"xphO�.q�tp���EhO�:u8tpy8qK��yEtpd�h�x�y$��hK¾�cXd�h�gjq�z{yEx }fxpyE���:h\g�.o/tpdfqKtXy�¡6 vtvh�ovtp�:�f�H¡�y$x%qK�foph\�f�Oh"�qEo%��h\�:����}fqExvt/y�¡+tpd�h �OyE�$tpxpyK��¾!@-df���:h1tpd��.oX�.o/}?h\xv¡�h\�Otv�:u8opyErf�f�7�.�qjopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo�}�qKx*qK���:�Eg¹¤�tpdf�:o%�.o�g�h\qE���:�f�K�:h\o*o��.�[qK�¹qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoy$��hK¾cXd�hjopyK�.r�tv�:yE�_�OyE�fop�.ovt*o��.�¢xph\optpxp�:�Otv�.����yEr�xpophO�:�Kh�oXtvy[ovyKÛN�\q��:��h�� Åº°5ÆK§�¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« -0/�- ¾�|�f��y��>dfxpy�Û

�fyErfo -0/1- qExvh¹tpd�y$ovh7¡�yEx�½�d��.�>d�t*d�h£�ºy$�Et*xvyE�/�fh\}?h\�f�fojy$���:u yE�-i��£t*d�h£}fxphO�`��y$rfo�ovt*q�tvhE¤�qE�f� D �t*d�h1��q��.r�h\o%}?yEo*ov�.���:��u��\qKx*xv�:h\���$u�h��E�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$t�op�:�E�fqK�:o\¤��fr�tX��yKt/yE�8tpd�h }fxph\oph\���ºh���qK�foph\���ºhWoptpqKtprfo

� ç»èPéëê�éëê�ì�í¨ï�ò+õ¨ö�òËèPî$,Ëõ��Wì�î{ï¯ö�õ>ïËøXî{ó_�Où�òËèPî� ��������Nj2û{õ>øXìPéë÷ëî{ï�� ê1`Ëû{÷ëõOû��ûví¨÷ëûvü�÷ëüPêXaI�

JF ��$J?;

Page 20: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« i��

yK¡�t*d�h\oph�ov�:�E��q��.oO¾�~W�¶h��f��y��>dfxpyE��y$rfo -X/�- �\qK�Z½�y$xpÁ£qEo q �Ëopu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o��Wg�y`��r���h�½/yEx*Á$�:�f�8�.�¶q�f�:optpxp�:��r�tvh��RhOs`h��Or�tp��y$�¸r�ov�.��� qK��qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoH�OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$�Rg�h\���.rfg¹¤X}fxpy��$�.��h���tpd�q�t�tpdf�:og�h����:r�g o*q�tv�.ovÂ�h\o%t*d�h1t�½�y�xph�`r��.xvh�gHh��$tpo/y�¡%i�����yKtX�:y`yEop�:�f��g�h\o*o*q��Kh�oO¤�qE�f� D �H��yKt��>dfqE���K�.����tpd�hy$xp�fh\x/y�¡'gHh�opo*q��Eh\o\¾~ �_hºsfqEg�}f��h�y�¡qE� -0/1- ½�d��.�>d£�.o� {hOs`y��>dfxpyE�fyErfo%" �Ë�˾ hK¾:¤���yEtWh\����y��>dfxvy$��yEr�o��/�.o�tpd�h� pxvh�qK�ºtp���Eh"

-0/�- �K�:�Kh��¹yE�¹tpd�h �:hº¡�t dfqK�f�£op�.��h y�¡'tpd�h�¡�yK�:��y�½X�.����}��.�ºtpr�xvhE¤�½�d�h�xvh�qKo%tpdfh v}fxpyEqE�ºtp���Eh" -0/�- o*d�y�½��y$�8t*d�h�xp���$dEtXdfqE�f�¹ov�.��h �.oXqK�¹h\�f�fy`�>d�xvy$��yErfo -0/1- Ã

zh

zhzh

hb

hu vh

vu

b

z

b b

bb

(input clock)(input data)(other)

u

hzz

h

h

h

local

ξ-

h

tick

h

b

hh

vbzb

hh

zξz

u

[{�·t*d�hZ�f�:qK�Ex*qKg y$�·tpd�hZ��hO¡�t¹d�qK�f�µop�:�fhK¤Xtpd�xvh\hZ��� ��h�xvh��$t8�º�:y��>Á$o7qKxph_ovy$rfx*�ºh_��y���h�o8yK¡1t*d�hZ�f� Ûxph\�Otvh��¸�$xpqE}fd»¾=cXdf�:o7gHh�qK�fojt*dfq�t8tpd�h¢}�xv�.gjqKxpuR��h\�O�:op�:yE���:�·hOs�h\�Orftv�.����q xvh�qK�Otv�:yE���ºyE��ov�.ovt*o��.��fh\�º�.���.����rf}?yE�[xvh\�:qKtv�:�Kh1}fxph\oph\�f�Oh���qE�foph\�f�Oh yK¡"tpdfh\oph��º�:y`�>Á`o\¾ [{�7�OyE�$tpx*qKoptO¤��.�8t*d�h����.q��$xpqEg¿yE�¹tpd�hxp�:�Ed$t�dfqE�f�8op�.��hK¤`yE�f��ujyE�fh��O��y��>Á�¤`tpd�h1qK�Otv�:�PqKtv�:yE���O��y��>Á �3¤��:o/qHopyEr�xp�Oh ��y���h�y�¡�t*d�h1�Ex*qK}fd»¾�ZWh��f�ºh�fy8tvh�ovt ¡�yEx�xphO�.q�tv�:�KhH}fxvh�ovh��f�ºh���qE�fovh��f�ºh �.o1��hOh���h\��¤5qE�f�£t*d�h��OyE�$tpxpyK�"yE���:u£��h\}?h\���fo�yE�£t*d�hH��qK�:r�hyK¡"t*d�h���y`yE��h�qK�7�PqExv�.qK�f��h & ¤�½�d��.�>d¹�:oX�OyEgj}fr�tph\�¹�.�Etph\x*�fq��:�:uK¾Z y�½ h��f��y��>dfxpyE�$u�q��:��y�½�ojrfo�tvy���h�ovu��f�>dfxpyE�f� W\h¹qE� -0/�- �:o����:�:r�ovt*xpqKtvh\���.�·qK�¸�:�$tprf��tp���Eh£½/qPu

y$�Rt*d�h[¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:��� ���.q��$xpqEg¹¤�½�d��.�>d��fh\}��.�ºt*o�tpd�h_o*�>d�h��fr��:�:��� o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE��qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�R½X��t*d·tpd�h�Ëh\�f�fy`�>d�xvy$��yErfo�}fovh�rf��yKÛNoptpqKtvh\g�h��Et

� � & � � Õ�������� - "2Ã

T TF F T TF F T TF F

u

b b

u

b

u

[{�¹t*d�h��:hº¡�tW���.q��$xpqEg¹¤fq�d��:optvy$xvu7y�¡'tpd��.oWoptpqKtvh�gHh��$tX�:o��fh\}��.�ºtph\�»¤�opd�y�½X�.����t*d�h�opr��O�ºh�opop�:�Kh1�:��ovt*qK�$tpo�ËyEx xvh�qK�ºtp��y$�fo�/ovh�}fqKx*q�tph\�[�$u7t*d��:�>Á¹�fqEopd�h��[���.��h�oO¾ [{�£t*d�hHg��.�f���:hK¤5qK�[�.�foptpqK�$tWd�qKoW�?hOh��£t�½X�.ovtph\�»¤qE�f���.��tpdfhW�.qKoptyE�fhK¤$tpd��.�>Áj�fqKo*d�h\�j�:�.��h\o/dfqP�Kh ��h\h\��xph\g�y��Kh��»¾�Í���h�qKxp��uE¤E��yH�:�`¡�y$xpgjqKtv�:yE��dfqEo��?hOh���:yEopt�Ã�½/h%Á$�fy�½�tpdfqKt - o*d�y$r��:�H��h%�EyKt+hºsfqK�Otv�:u ½�d�h\� & � / ¤KqK����tpd`rfo'�:t'�:o+y$����u��fhOh\�fh\�Htvy�½/qK��t"¡�yEx

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 21: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

i*J ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

& �.�7y$xp�fh\x%tvy�Á`��y�½À½�d�hOt*d�h\x - �.oXtpy���h ½%q��:tvh���¡�y$x�q��.ovy?¾2~ ¡�yEx*g�qK��ovt*rf��u7y�¡2��h\opu��f�>dfxpyE���5W\qKtv�:yE�qE�f�7h\�f��y��>dfxpyE�$u��.o�}fxph\oph\�$tvh����.�[~W}f}?h\�f�f� s U1¾� y��`�.���1¡¯xpyEg�hOs�y`�>d�xvy$��yErfo+tpy�h\�f�fy`�>d�xvy$��yErfo'�.o2h�qKop���:uH}?h\xv¡�yEx*g�h\�»¤E½�hXy$����ujo*d�y�½Ry$��hXt�u�}��:�\q��

��r�t�ov�.gj}��:h hºsfqKgj}��:h�Ã

hh

k k’k k’

h

b b’(other)(input data)(input clock)

cXdfhH�.��h\q7�.o tpy£qK�f�¢tvy¹tpd�h��ºy$�fop�:��h�xvh�� -0/1- q¹g�yE���:tvy$x ½�df�:�>dZ��hO�:���Eh\x*oWt*d�hj�:��¡�yEx*g�qKtv�:yE�£yK¡/}fxphºÛoph\���ºh���qK�foph\���ºhW�`�.q�t*d�h & % & � �?y`yK�:h\qE����qKxp�:qE���:h\o/½X��t*d8�.��h��Etp�:�\q��»�º�:y��>Á-��¤���¾ hK¾:¤l �� � /&" ; & � /&" ¤qE�f�£op�:g��:�:qExv�:u8¡�y$x�� � % & � ¾�cXd�hHxph\o*r��:tv�.��� -0/1- �.oWh��f��y��>dfxpyE��y$rfoO¤?ov�.�f�ºh���y`yE��h�qK�[��qKxp�:qE���:h\o & % & � qKxpho*�Ox*r�tp�:���5WOh��7qKtXtpd�h }fqE�ºh yK¡+qK�Otv�:��q�tv�:yE�¹�º�:y��>Á>�3¾1> tpd�h�xXop�>d�h�g�h\o%qKxph q��.ovy�}?yEo*ov�.���:hK¾

� ��� � )��) ,/�"!/# � � % � ��)��-1&# ������.�, % ) *�� ,/�"!() 3 .���-1�)4%lWhO�:hO��qK�$t�tpqKxp�Kh\t�qExp�>df��tph\�ºt*rfxph\o ¡�yEx�h\gH��h��f��h��ZqE}f}��:�:�\q�tv�:yE��o t�u�}��.�OqK���:u_qKxph¹i��8}frfxphO�:u¢ovh �`r�h\�$tv�.q���Oy���h���oprf�>dZqKo ÍÛN�Oy���h��>¤1D ���Oy`�fhHrfop�:�f�7q�t*dfxph\qK�f�:���7yEx tpqEopÁ$�.���7g�h\�>d�qK���.opgÊ}fxpy��`�:�fh\�£�$u_ovy$g�hÁ$�.�f�_yK¡q8xph\qK� ÛNtv�.g�h > E ��d�h\xphHt*d�h�tpdfxph\qE���:�f�8g�h\�>dfqE���:o*gÊy=�5h\x*oWopyEg�h���hO�$xvh\h�y�¡�OyE�f�\rfx*xvh��f�ºu��¨¤y$x%� � M E`w2Û�t�u�}?h�g�rf��tp�:}fxpy��ºh�opopyEx/qKx*�>d��:tvh\�Otprfxph\o/½X�:tpd[qKo*opy`�O�:qKtvh��7�OyEgjg�rf�f�:�\q�tv�:yE�7g�h\���.qf¾

>��Rtpd�h[yKt*d�h\x�dfqE�f�»¤�t*d�h£op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�Zo*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�foH½�h[��h�xv�:�Kh8¡¯xvy$g xpr��:h\o �¯l�Û*iE¤�¾:¾�¾:¤ lXÛ�� � yK¡�\qKrfo*q��:�:t�uRqK�fqK��u�op�:ojoptv�:��� hºsfd��.���:t�g�q�s��:gHrfg �OyE�f�\rfxpxph\���ºuK¾-~ �ºt*rfq����.gj}��:h\g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE�fo�½X���:�WdfqP�Ehtpy_�ºy$�`¡�yEx*g tvy£t*d�h\oph�o*�>d�h\�frf���.���_o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo\¾ [{�¶�Kh���h\x*q���¤�tpdfhOu¶½X���:��hºsfd��.���:t��:h\o*o �ËqK���Zh\�Kh��opyEg�h\tv�.gHh�o1��y �W�ºy$�f�Orfx*xph\�f�OuK¤»g�h\qK�f�:���¹tpd�q�t ¡¯rfxvt*d�h\x oph�`r�h��$tv�.q��:� W�q�tv�:yE�¢dfqKo���h\h\�¶}�h�x{¡�y$xpg�h��_tvy�Eh\��h�xpqKtvh1�ºy���hE¾

>W¡��ºy$rfx*ovhE¤/t*d��.o8qK������tp��y$�fq�� ovh �$rfh\�$tv�.q��:� W�q�tp��y$�¸�\qK�µ�?h_tpd�hZovy$rfxp�Oh£y�¡ }�yEtvh��Etp�:qK�ˤXyEtpd�h�xv½X�.ophr��Pzvrfoptv��Â�h\�»¤2��h�qK���:y��>Á_½�d�h��¥tpd�h7�ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\�¥g�y��fr��:h��.o�xvh�rfoph\�¶�:�¥t*d�h�¡�y$xpg y�¡XyE��z{h\�ºt��Oy���h��.�opyEg�h7h\�$�`�:xpyE�fg�h��Et\¤�tpdf�:o�½%qKoH���:�:r�ovt*xpqKtvh\�R�:��o*rf�foph\�ºtp��y$� ��¾:iK¾�cXdfh¹t*xpqE���:tv�:yE�fqK�/qE�fov½/h\xHtvy¶tpdf�:o}�xvy$����h�g �$u¶tpd�h7ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo�}�xvyE�Ex*qKgjg��:���£o*�>d�y`yK�d�qKo��?hOh��¥tvy¶xvhO¡¯rfovh7�ºyE��ov�.��h\xp�.���£ovh�}fqKx*q�tph�OyEgj}��:�:qKtv�:yE�1Ã�gHy��frf��h�o�¡�yEx ¡¯rfxptpd�h�x xvh�rfovhjo*d�yEr��.�¶��h�optvyExph\�ZqKo1opyErfx*�ºhj�ºy���hE¤�qK�f�¶�ºy$g����.��h\�¶qKoo*rf�>d¹��hO¡�yExph �ºy���h �Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$�»¾@¶h opdfqK����dfy�½�h\�Kh\x�ovh\h1tpdfqKt/t*d��.oX��y`h\o%��yKtX��h\h\�7tvy��?h�t*d�h �OqEovhE¤`dfy�½�h\�Kh\x\¾ [{��ovtph\qK��¤fq��\qKxphº¡¯r��

r�ovh�yK¡�tpd�h¹op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���¢o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo�y�¡WqK� -X/�- ½X�:�:�/qK���:y�½ rfo�tpy¢��h��ºyEgj}?yEoph��:t��.�EtpyZg�y��fr��:h\ot*dfq�t �\qK�¶��h�optvy$xvh��¢qKo1y$�`z{h\�Ot �ºy���h�¡�yEx�¡¯rfxptpdfh\x xph\rfophK¤�½�d�q�tvh\�Kh�x t*d�h�qK�OtprfqK�2h\�$�`�:xpyE�fg�h��Et1qK����.gj}��:h\g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE�¹qKx*�>d��:tvh\�Otprfxph1½X���:���?hK¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 22: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« i��

� � Õ �K�f� Õ8Ù�� �*� � "�� ÕE× ��� Ù ��� Õ Ú -X/�-]� @ZhWÂ?x*ovt�f�:o*�Orfo*o2t*d�h �\qKophXy�¡�ov�.���E��hOÛN�O��y��>Á�h�� -0/�- ¤`�.�j½�d��.�>dqK���3�PqExv�.qK�f��h�oXdfqP�Kh1tpdfh�opqEgHh��O��y��>Á�¾cXd�h �.o*opr�h �.oX�:���.rfoptpx*q�tph\�¹�:�¹t*d�h ¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:����}��.�ºt*rfxphK¤��.�¹½�d��.�>dt*d�hX���.xvh��ºtvh����$xpqE}fd��fhºÂ?���.����tpd�h��O�:x*�Orf��tv¡¯xvh\h/o*�>d�h\��r����.���1op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$��yK¡�opyEg�h%ov�.���K�:hºÛ��º�:y��>Á�h�� -X/�-�.oX��h�}��:�Otvh��1Ã

they all depend on the same inputs

otherinput datainput clock

[{�Rtpd�h£qE��y��Eh7}��.�ºt*rfxvhE¤�tpdfh¹�$xpqPu WOy$��h\oH�ExpyEr�}�q��:�%�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o�½�d��.�>dR�fh\}?h\�f�¸yE�Rtpd�h£o*qKg�h7o*rf�`ÛophOtHy�¡��.�f}fr�t*oO¤��h\t�rfo��OqK���/tpdfh\g $­�±P« P« ">¾Zc+qKo*Á`o�qKxph8��yEt�o*rf�`z{h��ºtHtvy¢t*d�h[xv�.opÁZy�¡��Oxph\q�tp�:�f�£¡¯qKÁKh�fh\qK�f��y��>Á`o�¡¯xpyEg��:gj}��:h\g�h\�$t*q�tv�:yE��¾ [{�8¡¯qK�OtO¤�qEo%q��:����qExv�.qK���:h\o%�?hO�:yE���E�:�f�Htpy�t*d�h opqEg�h t*qKo*Á���h\}?h\�f�y$�£tpdfh�o*qKg�h��:�f}�r�tpo\¤»h\qE�>d£tpqEopÁ[�OqE�_�?hHhOs`h��Or�tph\�ZqK�O�OyEx*���.����tvy¹tpdfh�¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f�8op�>dfh\g�h�Ã�i����ºyE� Û�:h\�Ot1�:�f}�r�tpo\¤!D&��hºs�h\�\r�tvhjt*qKo*Á?¾HcXd�h�qE�ºt*rfq��'½%qPu¹t*d�hjtpqEopÁ[�.o1hºs�h\�\r�tvh��_�.o qKx*���:tpx*qKxpuK¤5}fxvy��`�.��h\�¢��t�OyE�`¡�y$xpgjo/tpdfh�op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�jo*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE��¾[{�¹tpdfh���hºs�t�}��.�ºt*rfxvhE¤�½�h�o*d�y�½=dfy�½=tpdfh�qK�ºt*rfq��»�.gj}��:h\g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE�¹½X�:�����?h�}fxph\}fqExvh��1Ã

or RPC,or...

task activation

black-box tasks,they can be preempted!

sequential code,or procedure call,or...

cXdfh�tpd��.�>Á¶qKx*xvy�½�o1�.�fop�:��h8tpd�h7tpqKo*Á¶��h\}��.�ºtph\� y$�¥tpd�h7��yEtvtvy$g opd�y�½ yE�fh8}�y$opop�.����h�¡¯r����:u ovh �`r�h\�`Ûtp�:qK�2op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�8y�¡�tpd��.o1tpqEopÁ�¾�cXd�h��»¤»½�dfq�t1o*d�yEr��.�¢�?hjxvh�q��:��u£optvyExph\�¢qKo1ovy$rfx*�ºhH�Oy���h�¡�y$x�¡¯r�xvt*d�h\xxph\r�ovh��:o%y$���:u£­®Ä�Å�± �º«>­ËÓ*±K¦O­Ë¬¯§�°¶¦¨§�°�«¨¬.«>­�¬®°$È7§{Ò1­�ÄfÅ�­N±�«� �\¬¯Å0�ŨÆ8±�«/�O²�±E¦�=� �¨§ )`Å>«���­�§pÈ$ÅO­®Ä�ÅºÓ �2¬®­�Ĺ­�ÄfÅO¬®Ó±�«¨«º§�¦O¬¯±�­�Å*Æ8¬®°�­�ÅOÓ�Òº±K¦¨Å�«º¦¨ÄfŨÆ�Ç�²�¬®°$È�«Nª�Ũ¦O¬ É�¦¨±�­�¬¯§�°�«º´

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 23: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

DK� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

[{��}fqKxptv�.�Orf�:qExO¤���¡?t*d�hXoprf}�}�y$xvtp�:����hºs�h��Or�tp��y$�HqExp�>d��:tvh��ºt*rfxvh��:�$�EyK�:�Kh\o+q1xvh�q���Û�tp�:g�h�tpqKo*Á$�:�f��opu�ovtph\g�.gj}��:h\g�h\�$tv�.����opyEg�h�}�xvh\h\gj}�tv�:yE�¹g�h\�>dfqE���.opg¿�.�¹yEx*��h\x�tvy���u��fqEgH�.�OqK���:u�yE}ftv�.gH�5WOh o*�>d�h\��r����.���H¡�yEx�?h\opt%xvh�op}?yE�fophWtp�:g�hE¤$t*qKo*Á`o��\qK�8�?h ¡¯xvh\hO�:u�oprfo*}?h\�f��h�� ��xph\o*rfg�h\�8�Eujt*d�h�xph\qK� ÛNtv�.g�h ÁKh\x*��hO��¤`½X��t*d�yEr�t�.gj}fq��.xp�:�����OyE�`¡�y$xpg��:t�u�y�¡'tpd�h y$�`z{h\�Ot%�Oy���h1tvy��:tpoXo*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�»¾

� � Õ " ÕF�+Õ ������E�f� Õ£Ù�� � �¯������� ÕK× ��� Ù ��� Õ Ú -X/�-]� cXdfh��Eh\��h�xpqK���5W\qKtv�:yE�j�.o/���:�:r�ovt*xpqKtvh\�8�:�7tpdfhW¡�yE� Û�:y�½X�.����}f�:�Otprfxph�Ã

clock-dependent

or RPC,or...

task activation,

k

h

kk

cXdfh�y$���:u¢��hO½ }�yE�:�$t �.o1tpdfqKt�q��:�2��tph\gjo ���.op�\rfo*ovh��Z�?hº¡�y$xvh�qKxphj��y�½��O��y��>ÁEÛN�fh\}?h\�f��h��$tO¾�cXd`rfo1tpd�h�OyEgj}fr�t*q�tp��y$�fo�y�¡t*d�h/ {t*qKo*Á$o%">¤�t*d�hO�.x��:�$tph\x*�fq��2o*�>d�h\�frf���.����¤�qE�f�_t*d�hO�.x qK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE��¤5gHrfopt��?h�}�h�x{Û¡�y$xpg�h��µrfov�.���Ro*�>d�h��fr��:�:���¸op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�fo��.qK�?hO�:��h��-�$u��?y`yK�:h\qE�foO¾D[{�-tpd�h¶qK�?y��Kh£hºsfqEg�}f��hE¤�tpd�h�OyE�fop�.��h\xph\� -0/�- �:o/qK�Otv�:�PqKtvh��8�$u�ovy$g�h �º�:y��>Á ��¤`½�d��.�>d��.��t*rfxp��o/�fhºÂ?��h�o/tpd�h1qK�Otv�:�PqKtv�:yE���O��y��>Á ��yK¡t*d�h���h�}��:�Otvh��7t*qKo*Á�¾'cXdfh���yEtvtvy$g �:�:��h �.o�ÃiK¾ M � �5h\xph\�$tXtpqEopÁ`oX�OqE�7d�qP�Kh ��� ��h�xvh��EtXqE�ºtv�:��q�tp��y$�7�O��y��>Á`oO¾D�¾-.�y$xXh\qE�>d7t*qKo*Á�¤ftpd�h��:�$tvh�xp��q���o*�>d�h\�frf���.�����Kh���h\x*q��:�:u8��h\}?h\���fo�y$�¹opyEg�h1�.�Etph\x*�fq��"�º�:y`�>Á`o\¤f��¾ hE¾�¤yE�[opyEg�h }fxvh����.�Oq�tph\o%�.�$�KyK�:�`�:�f�H�.�$tvh\x*�fqK��ovt*q�tvh�o%y�¡'tpd�h t*qKo*Á�¾'cXd`rfo�tpd�h �.�$tvh\x*�fqK��op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f��:oW��u��fqKg��.��¤f�fr�t��\qK�¹��h�}�xvh��ºyEgj}frftvh\�[qKt%�OyEgj}��:��h tp�:g�hE¾

�f¾X~��.ovy?¤Et*d�hWt*qKo*Á�qE�fovt*xpqE�ºtp��y$��d�qKoq��º�:y`�>ÁEÛ���h\}?h\����h\�$to*�>d�h\��r����.����o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�»¾2cXd��.o��.oqE��y�Ûtpd�h�xXovy$rfx*�ºh�y�¡+�fu`��qKg��:�1o*�>d�h\��r����.���?¤`qK�:opyj�ºyEgj}frftvh\�¹q�tX�OyEgj}��:��h1tv�.g�h�Ã2�:tX�:o/�.g�}f��h�gHh��$tvh\��:�¹t*d�h�¡�yEx*g y�¡'q� povyK¡�t�½/qExvh�g�yE���:tvy$x#" ½�df�:�>d7yE}?h\�fo��¡�y$xp�f�:�fo/t*d�h }�y$opop�:�f���:��t�u8y�¡"hOs�h\�Orftv�.����q�K�:�Kh��8t*qKo*Á�q�tXqj�K�:�Kh����.�foptpqK�$t\¤���h\}?h\�����:�f��yE�7tpd�h��\rfxpxph\�$tXoptpq�t*rfo%y�¡+tpd�h -0/�- �º�:y��>Á`oO¾

��¾XcXd��.o opy�¡�t�½%qKxph gHy$���:tvyEx �OqE�£��h��OyEgH���:�fh\�[½X�:tpd£t*d�h��.�$tvh\x*x*rf}�tv�:yE�[g�h\�>d�qK���.opg y�¡�t*d�h�o*rf}`Û}�y$xvtp�:�f�jxph\qK� ÛNtv�.g�h�ÁKh\x*��hO�»�.�$tvh��f��h\�7tvyjy$}�tv�.g�� W\h�xvh�op}?yE�foph�tv�.gHh yK¡"t*d�h hºs�h\�\r�tv�:yE��¤�½X��t*d�yEr�t�:gj}fqK�:xp�.�����ºyE��¡�yEx*gH�:t�u�yK¡"tpdfh yE�`z{h��ºtX�ºy���h tpy��:tpoWop}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�»¾

� ��� � � ) 0 .�! !(. 3 1 # � )�� 3 .�� �1�� , � � � ��#&% !(, #&0 !()� � .�� ) ��)��) ,/�"!/#�.��

cXdfh�½�dfyK�:h�qK}f}fxpyEqE�>d��.o�opr�g�gjqExv�5WOh����.�7t*d�h1¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:�������.q��$xpqEg=Ã

JF ��$J?;

Page 24: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« Dfi

original module

all items are clock-dependent !!

monitor: exo2endo + scheduling

[{�¸tpdf�:o����.q��$xpqEg¹¤��Ex*qPu xvh��ºtpqE���K�:h\o���h���yKtph¹t*dfxphOh[gHy��frf��h�o��$Q % �/T % ���8yK¡ tpdfh_ovy$rfxp�Oh -0/�- op}?h\�O� ÛÂ��Oq�tp��y$�»¤»d�h\���ºh��E���Eh\�_�$u�� ���1Q?Y��/T Y�����¾ @ZhjqKo*opr�gHh�d�h\xph�t*dfq�t�tpdf�:o1}fqExvtp��tp��y$���:�f�7dfqEo �?hOh���E���Eh\�£�$u¹tpd�hj��h\op�:�E��h�xO¤��fqKoph\�[y$�[¡¯rf�f�Otv�:yE�fqK�+qE�f�_qKx*�>d��:tvh��ºtpr�xpqK�3�ºy$�fov�.��h�xpqKtv�:yE�fo\¾X�WyEtvh�t*dfq�t�tpd�h�.��h�g�}?yKtph\�f�Oh�yK¡ -0/�- �OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�@���+Y����� �3q��:��y�½�o+rfo+tvy �fr�}����.�OqKtvh%ovy$rfx*�ºh��Oy���h/qKt+�OyE�$�Kh����:h\�f�Oh½�df���:h }fqKxptv�:tv�:yE���.���jtpdfh�op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�»¾cXd�h��»¤/½�d���tph£�frf�f���:h\oj�.�fop�:�fh7t*d�h[�Ex*qPu¥xph\�OtpqE���K�:h\o���h\}f�:�Ot�tpd�h£optpx*rf�ºt*rfxpqKtv�:yE� �.�$tvy¥tpqEopÁ`ojqKo

�f�:o*�Orfo*oph\�¹��hO¡�yExphK¾.'�.�fq��:��u[t*d�h��f�:qE�>Á7dfqK� ¡®ÛNhO�:�:�:}foph\o ��h\�fyKtvhHtpd�hjg�yE���:tvy$xpo\¾ � y$���:tvyEx*oWqExvhH�:�¢�>dfqKxp�Kh yK¡�i���}�xvy��`��Û

�f�:���£t*d�h8qE�f���:tv�:yE�fqK��ºy$�Et*xvyE�2tvy_gjqKÁKh�tpd�h7�ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\�¶g�y��fr��:h�h\�f�fy`�>d�xvy$��yErfo1��¡�qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo�OyEgjg�r����:�\q�tp��y$��g�h����:q qExvhXtpy���h�rfoph\�»¤$qK�f� D �Wo*}?h\�º��¡�u`�:�f��tpd�h op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f� y�¡»tpd�h qK�foptpx*qK�Ot2tpqKo*Á`oO¾[{��}fxp�:�f�O�:}f��hE¤��ºyEgjgHrf���.�Oq�tp��y$��g�h\�f�:q�qK�f�Hxvh�q���Û�tp�:g�h%Á�h�xp��h\�:o+��y1��yKt'��h\h\�Htvy1��hXo*}�h��º��Â�h\�Hd�h\xphK¤

qEoWt*d�hOuZ�OqK�Z��h�rfoph\�_¡¯xvh\hO�:u_}fxpy��$�.��h��£tpd�h\u¢xph\o*}�h��ºt�tpd�h�oph\�f�`Û�xph\�ºh\���EhHqE�fovt*xpqE�ºt��ºyEgjgHrf���.�Oq�tp��y$�g�y���h\��qK�f�[�ºy$�`¡�yEx*g tpy�t*d�h�o*�>d�h\�frf���.�����ºy$�fovt*xpqK�:�$t*o/ophOt��$u�t*d�h�g�yE���:tvy$xpo\¾

��� � *� � �$�0� �

cXdfhjqE��y��Eh�qE}f}fxpyEqE�>d_�.o oprf}�}�y$xvtph\�¥�$u_tpd�h������ �ºyEgjg�yE�¢¡�yEx*gjq�t ¡�yEx opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo��:qE���ErfqK�Kh�o� M�Í/�(H��N¾"cXd�h � ���8¡�yEx*gjq�t»�.o»yE��h�}?yEo*op�:���:h��ºy$�f�OxphOtph2�:gj}��:h\g�h��Et*q�tp��y$� yK¡$y$rfx -0/�- g�y`�fhO��¤��.�f�O�:rf�f�:���o*�>d�h��fr��:�:���¶op}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�fo\¾ [�tjovh�xv�Eh\o�qKo�q¢�fqEov�.o�¡�yExHtpd�h[�ºy���h¹�Kh���h\x*q�tp��y$� opr��:tvh¹�.��tpdfh7|o*}fxp��t

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 25: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

D>D ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

36: � #"! - }fxpy�z{h��ºtO¾SE�¾ � qK�>dfqExp� qE�f��|W¾�l r�tvtph\��qExvh/�Orfx*xph\�$tv�:u ½/yEx*Á$�:�f��yE� �Eh\��h�xv�.���Oy`�fh��Eh\��h�xpqKtv�:yE���qKoph\�7yE�7tpd��.oX½/yEx*Á?¤`½X�:tpd[��� ��h�xvh��$t�xvh�q���Û�tp�:g�h/>H¾YE�¾?qK�f�¹qKx*�>d��:tvh\�Otprfxph\o%qEo%tpqKxp�Kh\tpo\¾

� ����9����@< !�� 7 ! ! 9 /�� @5ÄfÅ�±�Ç�­�Äf§�Ó¨«�±�ÓpÅ�¬®°�ÆEÅ)�O­NŨÆ8­N§ � ÅO°�§� ®­1Ï2±�¬®²®²�±�Ç�Æ1Òº§�Ó�¦¨±�ÓpÅËÒ¨Ç�²3ÓpŨ±EÆ�¬®°$È[§vÒ±�°�Æ�Ópź©�±�Ó �«�§�°¥±8Æ�Ó*±{Ò¨­ �PÅOÓ¨«>¬¯§�° §{Ò1­�ÄfÅ�©j±�°�Ç`«O¦ºÓ>¬ ª�­N´

� � � � � � ����� � ��� � � ��� �1 ��� � ��� ��� �$���,� (� � � � �U � � � ���������� � � �H� 1� ��X� � �

� �&� � )4* )����)����#&)4%[{�¹t*d��:oWqK}f}?h\�f�f� s»¤�qEoXqK�¹qK�foptpx*qK�Otv�:yE��yK¡'qExp�f��t*xpqExvu���y$gjq��.�foO¤�½/h �ºy$�fov�.��h�x%tpd�h1¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f����y$gjq��.�yK¡"��q��.r�h�o�� qE�f�¹��t*oXt�½/yHy$xp��h�xv�.���$o�� qK�f� ¥Ã

� ��

� � � � x� %2'4%./� ��� ��

" �N� �

� ' / �#J �

[{�Ztpdfh\ophH¡�y$xpgHr����1¤3ovu�gH��yE�:o � �Ëxph\o*}»¾ � ���.�f���.�OqKtvh prf�f��hOÂ?��h�� "���xvh�op}»¾� p��hºÂ?�fh\� " �¨¾/ + �f��hOÂ?��h�� "o*d�y$r��:�µ�fyKt8�?h¢�ºy$�`¡¯rfoph\�·½X�:tpd pqK��ovh��Et%" �z����à vqE�fovh��$t#"£�:o7q�}�h�x{¡�h��ºtp��u·��hºÂ���h\�-optpqKtprfo\¤X½�d��:��h prf�f�fhºÂ?��h�� "��.oW�.�$tvh\����h\�¢tvy7g�y���h\�+t*dfq�t1q���qExv�.qK���:h�dfqEo �fyKt �?hOh��¢}fxpy��frf�Oh\�£uEhOtW�.�_t*d�hj�Orfx*xvh��$txph\qE�ºtp��y$�»¾�.'�:�fqK���:uK¤��fyE�`Û���y`yE��h�qK�£t�u�}?h\o1qKxphHqE�fovt*xpqE�ºtph\�¢qEoWt*d�h�ov�.���E��hj���.ovtp�:���$r��.opd�h��_h\��h�gHh��$t��H¾cXd`rfo\¤P¡�yEx'�?y`yK�:h\qK��oO¤�t*d�hX}fq��.x\ ')% /&" �OqK�H��hXophOh��HqEo+q�xphºÂ?��h�g�h\�$t"yK¡?t*d�hXovu�g��?yK��H¤�t*d��:o'�.o2o*d�y�½���$u�t*d�h�rf�f�fh\x*�fxpqE�>Á�h\tpo\¾+~ �f�! x� % � " �.oXq�xphºÂ���h\g�h\�$tXyK¡ � ¤ft*d��:o��:oXo*d�y�½��¹�Eu8tpd�h y��Eh\x*�fxpqE�>Á�h\tpo\¾�7Õ ) � ���*� Ù���Ù�� Ú Õ � ÕF� Ú ÕF� �(� Õ ��� l�hO�.q�tp��y$� W � � �¥�.oj��hºÂ?�fh\� �.��t*qK���:hZiE¤2½�d�h\xph8�:t��:oo*}?h\�º��Â�h�� �:�¥t*d�h�¡�y$xpg y�¡Wq¢g�r��:tv�:��q��.r�h\�¥¡¯r��f�ºtp��y$�»¾ [�tpo�gjq��.�¶¡�h\qKtprfxph8�.o�t*dfq�tH��t�¡�yEx*���:��oO¤'½�d�h��& � / ¤�tpdfqKt(���Kh\tpoX��hOÂ?��h\�¹½�d��:�:h�W£�:oX��yEtO¾4�� Ù � Õ �P��� Õ � Ù�� Ú Õ � Õ�� Ú Õ�� �(� Õ �a� cXdfh1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���j}fxvy$}�h�xvtp��h�oXd�yK�.�1Ã

W &� � h � � � ( � W & Y � � ( �� �

W &� �h W � � � � W & ,6� � � �pi\� �

[{��tpd�h�ovh�h�`rfqKtv�:yE�fo\¤ & Y � qE�f� & , � qExvh xvh�op}?h\�Otv�:�KhO�:uj��hºÂ?�fh\�8qEot*d�hW�.�`Â?gHrfg �Ëxph\o*}»¾2o*rf}fxph\g�r�g �½ ¾ x\¾ t\¾ÀxphO�.q�tv�:yE� "£��hºÂ?�fh\�·�.� �#J �j½�d�h\�·�?yKtpd·��qK�:r�h�o��?hO�:yE��� tpy�tpd�hZoprf����y$g�qK�:� ]� % /&%('4" ¾> t*d�h\xp½X�.ovhE¤$t*d�hOu¹qKxph ��yEtpd¹h�`rfqK���Eu7��hºÂ?�f��tp��y$�7tpy � ¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 26: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« DK�

W � � �&� � � ��'/ �

c+qK�f��h¸iKøÎ�ůɰ�¬®­�¬¯§�°<§{ÒZ­®Ä�Å ÆKÅ{ª�ÅO°�ÆEź°5¦º³ W � � ��´������ ������ ����� �������������������� ����� ���!� �" �� �#� ��� $���&%'�(��)�*��#� �+)��,�-�.� �(� �+����/��0���21�34����)�)��������5)��6� �879�:� �(���)�;<���!� � " �&�)0�=������8�)0>���� $���?� ��*&*��!/0��&%@1BA � W6� �C�!�-�+ �&�)-;-������) �D� ���(�?���E���GFH)���%���I�)0>=�!�J�����K�L7M�N��� $����� ')%./#" 1

� � � O #&, � �#�! ��, ) ) % � ��)��-1&# ��� %@¶hjqKxphH�E���Eh\�_q¹ovh\tVW Qx%cdedcd�% W 7 y�¡��PqExv�.qK�f��h�oW½X�:tpd¶ovy$g�h�y�¡�tpd�h�g ��h\�:�f�¹�?y`yK�:h\qK��¾�cXd�h���y`yK�:h\qE���qExv�.qK���:h\o�½X���:��qK�:opy��?h ��h���yKtph\���$u & Q�% & T]%edcded ¤$qE�f�j½X�:���5��h�rfoph\��qKo�:qE��h\�:o�:�8��h\}?h\�f�fh\�f�O��h�oO¾2cXd�h��½/h�qKxphj�K�:�Kh��Ri��¹q£ovh\t y�¡X�ºyE��ovt*xpqK�:�$tpo1y$�¶tpd�h8�?y`yK�:h\qE�Z��qExv�.qK���:h\o1yK¡/t*d�h�¡�y$xpgQP W & Qx%ededcde% & � Z qKoxph\optpxp�.�ºtvh���tvy�t*d�h o*rf����yEgjq��.�� x� %./#%v'4" y�¡���hOÂ?��h\�j��qK�:r�h�oO¤`qK��� D&��q�ophOt�yK¡���h\}?h\�f�fh\�f�O��h�o���hOÂ?��h��y$�8t*d�h�ophOt�W Qx%edcdede% W 7 ¾S@¶h��OqK���»t*d�h ½�d�yK�:h�q7«O¦*Ä�Å*Æ�Ç�²�¬®°$È y�¡;W Q]%ededcd�% W 7 ¾|qE�>d8��h�}�h��f��h��f�ºu��.o�.�$tvh�xp}fxphOtph\��qEo�o*}?h\�º��Â�h����.�8c+qK���:h�iE¾'cXd`rfo\¤`tvyE�KhOt*d�h\x½X��t*d8t*d�h1��y`yK�:h\qE�

�OyE�foptpx*q��.�$tpo+y�¡5tpdfh%¡�yEx*gRP W & Q %edcdede% & � Z>¤$tpdfhOu�o*}�h��º��¡�uHq o*rf����yEgjq��.�Hy�¡5tpd�h�}fxpy��frf�Ot'�fyEgjq��.� � 7 yK¡qK���5}?yEo*ov�.���:h optpq�tph\o\¤���h\��yEtvh1�$uNS�tpd�h1ophOt/y�¡"optpqKtvh\o/o*q�tv�.ov¡�u$�.���Htpd�h�ovh��ºyE��ovt*xpqK�:�$tpo\¾ E$tpqKtvh\o/�.�TS·qKxph½�xp�:tvtvh�� * % � %edcded qK�f� �OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�f�f�:���[�.�$tvh\x*}fxphOt*q�tv�:yE��o�¡�yEx�t*d�h���qKxp�.qK���:h\o�W"Q %cdedcd�% W 7 qKxph���h\��yEtvh���$uB*<Q %cdedcde% * 7 ¡�y$x1opd�y$xvt �:��ovtph\qK�¢y�¡�*a1 W+Q 3 %cdedcde% *21 W 7 3 ¤3qK���¢op�:g��:�:qExv�:u¹¡�yEx �>¾�[{��SW¤3opyEg�h���q��.r�h�o *poqExvh�ophOtXtpy � ¤?qE�f�[tpdfh�yKt*d�h\xXy$��h\o qKxph�¡¯xvh\hK¤�y$x�q��:tvh�xp��q�tv�:�Kh\��u¹�ºy$�fovt*xpqK�:�fh\�¹�Eu[�?y$yE��h�qK�¹h�`rfqKtv�:yE�fo¡�y$xX��y`yE��h�qK�7�PqExv�.qK�f��h�oO¾UÕ � �¸� � ÎHÅ{ªfź°5ÆKÅO°�¦O³:W � � �R¬.«1ªf±�Ó>­�§vÒ�­®Ä�Å8¦¨§�°�«¨¬¯ÆEźÓ*Å*Æ_«O¦*Ä�ŨÆ�Ç�²�¬®°`È£¬ � �"Òº§�Ó �P±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�ź«W W % � % & Z�� °5§�°�Å£§vÒ8­�ÄfŹ­�Ó>¬ ª?²:Å>«£§{Ò �P±�²�Ç�Å>« W �)% � %./ Z % W d % � %�� Z4�¨ÅO²�§�°`È�«¹­N§�S'� �"ÄfÅOÓpÅWV ´ �ZÆKÅO°�§�­�ź«[±�°±�Ó,�º¬®­�Óp±�Ó>³@�P±�²�Ç�Å�Òº§�Ó�W+´4�� Ù�Ù�� � cXd�h� {y$����u£��¡#"�}fqKxpt�¡�yE���:y�½�o �$u£�.�fo*}�h��ºtv�:yE�Zy�¡�tpqK�f��h¹iK¾�~ o�¡�yEx tpd�h/ v� ¡#"�}fqKxptO¤5½/h��fyKtvht*dfq�t��?y`yK�:h\qE�Z�OyE�foptpx*q��.�$tpo�y�¡%tpd�hj¡�y$xpgXP W & Q %edcded�% & � Z ��y£��yEt �:�$�KyE���EhHt*d�h � �PqK�:rfhK¤"opy[tpdfqKt tpd�h�OyE�f�f��tp��y$��t*dfq�t'tpdfh��ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\��tpxp�:}f��h�o2��y ��yKt2�?hO�:yE����tvyCS��OqE��y$����uHxvh�opr��:t+¡¯xvy$g tpd�h��OyE�Pzvr��f�ºtp��y$�yK¡'�fh\}?h\�f��h��f�º�:h\o\¤?qE�f�¹½�h ophOh t*dfq�t W � � �7�:oX�.gj}��:��h��¹�$u7tpd��.oW�OyE�Pzvrf���ºtv�:yE��¤�qK�f�[�\qK�¹tpd`rfo�?h�qK����h\�7½X��t*d�yErft��>dfqK���E�:�f�=SW¾ Y

c%½/y7optpqKtvh\o y�¡ZS qKxph�o*q��.�£tvy[��h7°�ÅO¬ È�Ä��¨§�Ç�Ó¨«W��¡tpdfhOu£��� ��h�x hOsfqK�ºtp��u7¡�yEx yE�fh���qKxp�:qE���:h�½�h��OqK���t*d�hO�.x�Æ�¬.«O¦OÓ>¬®©H¬®°5±�­�¬®°$È��PqExv�.qK�f��hE¾!@¶h��OqK����q�ª�±�­®ÄH�.��SµqE�$ujÂ?���:tvh�oph�`r�h\���ºh�*PW Y Z % *NW �PZ %edcdedc% *NW:[ ZyK¡�fhO�:�Ed`��y$rfxp�:���joptpq�tph\o\¾

.?yEx *�qE�f� ��t�½/y���hO�:�Ed`�?yErfxp�:�f��optpqKtvh\o%yK¡\S ¤f½�h1½�xp��tph�*�� �!��xvh�op}»¾+* � � ����¡+t*d�hO�.x�xph\o*}�h��ºtp���Eh��qK�:r�h�o%¡�yEx%t*d�hO�.x����.o*�Oxp�:g��.�fq�tp�:������qExv�.qK���:h W o o*q�tp�:ov¡�u8t*d�h�xphO�.q�tp��y$��* o � � o ��xvh�op}»¾ * o � � o �%��hOÂ?��h��

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 27: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

D�� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

�.� ��� �¨¾2~À}fq�t*dg*NW Y Z % *NW �PZ %cdedede% *NW:[ Z�o*rf�>d�tpd�q�t *NW �$Z��9*NW � X Y Z��Ëxph\o*}»¾;*NW �$Z � *NW � X Y Z �'�.o�\q��:��h��¬®°5¦ºÓ*Å*±�«>¬®°$È ��xvh�op}»¾X°5§�°5ÆKŨ¦ºÓ*Å*±�«>¬®°$È��¨¾

~<o*�>d�h\��r����.���ESµ�:oW�Oq��:�:h\�¥¦º¬®Óp¦OÇ�¬®­ Ò¨ÓpŨÅ%� ¡%¬®­/¬.«1°5Å���ÅOÓ ­ËÓ>Ç�Å�¬®°�SÑ­�Äf±�­W o � � � � W o'2 � 2 � W)o�� dcded W o �

� � � W o �� � Ú �piKi��

W & Q Y dcded Y & � � / ZUÕ � �¸� � +v�>���������� � � Õ`Õ ��� � Õ Ú� �#� � "?��2 ¿«O¦*Ä�Å*Æ�Ç�²�¬®°$È7¬.«�¦O¬®Óp¦ºÇ�¬®­ Ò¨ÓpŨÅ�¬ � �?Òº§�Ó�Å,��źÓ>³�«>­�±�­�ÅV* . S«O±�­Ë¬.«�Ò¨³�¬®°$È jlk�_ * o �� � ��­�ÄfÅOÓpÅ�¬.«�±�°¢¬®°5¦ºÓpŨ±�«¨¬®°`È ªf±�­�Ä[² ¬®°��¬®°$È W �)%cdededc%�� Z�­N§I*$´4�� Ù�Ù�� � @Zh Â?x*ovt¿}fxpy��Kh�t*d�h {��¡#" }fqExvt\¾ ~ opo*rfg�h �viKi�� �.o �$�:yK�.q�tph\� ¡�y$x�opyEg�h �º�.xp�\r���tW o � � � � W o 2 � 2 � W o � dcded W o �

� � � W o � ¤���¾ hK¾:¤�W & Q Y dcded Y & � � / Z��.o�}�y$opop�.����h¡�y$x%tpd��.o��O�:x*�Or��:t%�:�?SW¾2lWh\optpxp�:�Ot�S·tpyjtpd�y$ovh�optpqKtvh\o/¡�y$x%½�d��.�>dW & Q Y dcded Y & � � / Zµy$x W & Q Y deded Y & � � � ZÀd�yE�:�fo\¤

�\q��:� S � � ������� � � � � / � t*d��.o�opr��fovh\tO¾cXdfh\�»¤�yE�CS � � ������� � � � � / � ¤P�ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� W o � � � � W o 2 � 2 � W o � deded W o �

� � � W o � �:gj}��:��h�o�ÃW o ��� W o 2 � dedcd � W o � � W o � %

qE�f�µt*d$r�o7t*d�h W)o�� o¹qKxphK¤WhO�:tpd�h�x7qK����� � ¤Wy$x8q��:tvh�xp��q�tv�:�Kh\��u·q��:� ��hºÂ���h\� �Ëh�`rfqK��tpyRy$��h¢yK¡�tpd�h��qK�:r�h�o � %./ %(' �¨¾ cXd`rfo�tpd�h�xvhH�:o1��y7�:���Oxph\qKop�.���8}fqKtpd_�:h\qE���.���8tpy¹qE�Eu£��hOÂ?��h��¢optpq�tphH�?hO�:yE���E�:�f�8tvyS � � ������� � � � � / � ¾�cXdf�:o�}�xvy��Eh\o�tpd�h v� ¡%" }fqExvt\¾@¶h ��y�½=}fxpy��Kh tpd�h' vyE���:u�� ¡%"1}fqExvt%�$u��ºyE�$t*xpqE���:�Otv�:yE�»¾2~ opo*rfg�h� 4* . S·o*q�tp�:ov¡�u`�:�f� jlk�_2*co �� � ¤o*rf�>dHtpdfqKt'tpd�h�xvh%�.o2��y1�:�f�\xvh�qKop�:�f� }fqKtpd����.�fÁ$�.��� W �)%edcdedc%�� Z"tvy *E¾!M�h\�fyKtvh��$u & Q %edcdede% & � tpdfh���y`yK�:h\qE���qExv�.qK���:h\oXo*rf�>d[t*dfq�t W & QRY dcded Y & � � / Z�d�yK�.�foWqKtWoptpq�tphI*E¾X~W�f�_�fh\��yEtvh��$u�5�t*d�hHgjq�s`�.gjq�� �¯¡�yExophOt/tpdfhOyExphOtp�:� rf���:yE� �>¤f�ºy$�f��h\�Otvh����Wo*rf�fophOt/y�¡2S ¤foprf�>d8tpdfqKt i�� W & Q Y dcded Y & � � / Z>¤ D&� hO�Eh\xpu � . 5o*q�tp�:ovÂ�h�o�Ã�j k % � o �� � qK��� tpd�h�xvh8�:oH��y¢�.�f�Oxph\qEov�.���_}fqKtpd¥�:�:��ÁE�.��� W �)%edcdedc%�� Z1tpy �>¤2qK�f� Â?�fq��:�:u¶� �5��$*E¾ U%u¹qKo*oprfgj}�tp��y$�»¤)5¸�.oW��yEtXh\gj}�t�uK¾ U%u7�ºy$�foptpx*rf�ºtp��y$�8yK¡�5X¤ftpd�h�xvh�qExvh opyEg�h ��qKxp�:qE���:h\o\¤fopqPuW�� � % W�� 2 %cdedcd�% W����K¤f½X��t*d���m Y ¤fo*rf�>d7tpdfqKt�Ã

yE��S � � ������� � � � � / � �|5 _iW�� � � W�� 2 � dcded � W���� � �$%yE�S5 _iW�� � � W�� 2 � dcded � W���� � � d �pi*D&�

+�ov�.���j�:h\gjgjq[i�½/h �ºy$�f�º�.rf��h1tpd�q�t

W�� � &� W�� 2 &

� W���� dcded W���� &� W�� � d�yK�.�fo\¤�½�d�h\xph

& ��W & Q Y dedcd Y & � Z�¤?qK�f� & � / �.o�}?yEo*ov�.���:h1�:�?SW¾ �pi\� �� ú3é òËè ï¯î{ê�ì�î{û{ò"ò�õ/õ>üPï"ð�õ¨ò�éëõ>ð õ¨ö?ð�îvéëþ>è4��õ>üPï¯éëðPþXêËò�í*ò�î{ê��

JF ��$J?;

Page 28: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« D G

E`�:�f�Oh �Im Y ¤�½/h�dfqP�Kh1qj�º�.xp�\r��:tO¤�qE�f�8t*d��.o%Â?���.opdfh\o%tpdfh�}fxvy`yK¡{¾ Y

cXd�h/�.�Et*r��:tv�:�Kh�.�$tvh�xp}fxphOt*q�tp��y$� y�¡ft*d��:o+�:h\gjgjq��.o3t*dfq�t\¤P¡�yEx+qK� -0/�- ½X��t*d�qW�O�:x*�Orf��tv¡¯xvh\h�o*�>d�h\�frf���.����¤�:t��.oW}?yEo*ov�.���:h�tvy7ovh �$rfh\�$tv�.q��:��u¹�ºy$g�}�r�tvh�qK���"��qKxp�:qE����h�o%¡¯xpyEg�t*d�h��.�f}frftpo�½X�:tpd¢��y8��h�qK���:y��>Á?¾/|qE�>d�.�f�\xvh�qKop�:���j}fqKtpd¹gHh��$tv�:yE��h��7�.� � h�g�gjq D��ºy$xpxph\o*}�y$�f�fo/tvyjy$��h }�y$opop�:�f��h�oph�`r�h��Etp�:qK�5hºs�h\�\r�tv�:yE�»¾

� � � � )4, # � # ��� � )4* )����)����#&)4% ��% � � -% � 1 # !�� � . ��% !(,/��# � !/%[{��tpd��.ojovh��ºtv�:yE��¤2½�h7�:�`¡�h�xj��h\}?h\�f�fh\�f�O��h�o�qEoH�\qKrfo*q��:�:t�u¶�OyE�foptpx*q��.�$tpo ¡¯xpyEg -0/�- optpqKtvh�gHh��$tpo\¾¶cXd�h}�xv�.�f�º�.}��:h\o%½/h�¡�yK�:��y�½=¡�yEx%yEr�xXqK�foptpx*qK�Otv�:yE�8g�h��>dfqK���.o*g�qKxph �E���Eh\�¹��hºs�t�Ã+ 4 × � 2 .�y$x WR��yEt�q£�?y$yE��h�qK�¶��qKxp�:qE���:hK¤+½�h�qE�fovt*xpqE�ºt �:tpoH��yEgjq��.� ���£qKo�tpd�h8op�.���K�:hOtpyE�/ � " ¤"qK���

tpd�h��¹hºs�tvh��f�¹��tXtpy�tpd�h�qE�f���:tv�:yE�fqK����qK�:r�h�o �4% � " ¾+ 4 × � 2 @µ��t*d��.�·h�`rfq�tp��y$�fojy�¡1tpdfh£¡�yEx*g �7� �pW�� "£yEx �"� & ���0��� �7� �cW�� Q �� "!�� �7� �pW�� T ½�h

opd�q��:�"¡¯r�xvt*d�h\x1qK��ovt*xpqE�ºt �_�$u_gjqK}�}��:�f�7t*d�h�ovh\t� ]� %('4% /&" tpy7t*d�h�ov�.���E��h���q��.r�h � �Ë��hOÂ?��h\�6�¨¾cXd��.o��.o/½�d�h\xph qEovu�gjg�hOt*xvuj��h\t�½�h\h\�8��hO¡�tf^�qK�f��xp�:�Ed$t�dfqE�f�8op�.��h yK¡�h�`rfqKtv�:yE�fo�y��O�Or�xpo��:�8yErfxqK�foptpx*qK�Otv�:yE�8tvh\�>d���� �`r�hE¾

+ 4 × % 2 E$�.�f�ºhj½/h�qExvh��:�$tph\xph\optvh\�¢�:�¶�OqErfo*q��:��t�u£�ºy$�foptpx*q��.�Et*oO¤»½/h�yE���:u_��hOh��¢tpy¹ÁKhOh�}¢t*xpqE�>Á7yK¡/�OyE�`ÂfÛ�Erfx*q�tp��y$�fo1¡�y$x ½�d��.�>d �Z�OqE�f��yEt���h7��hºÂ?�fh\�»¾ ZWh��f�ºhE¤'½�d�h\� � � � xph\o*r���t*o1¡¯xpyEg qK}f}��:u`�:�f�+ 4 × � 2 ¤$½/h�½/h\qEÁ�h\���:t�tvy �Hrf���ºyE��ovt*xpqK�:��h�� ">¤K½�d��.�>dj�:o/��h�}��:�Otvh��j�:��t*d�hWt*qK���:h\o��$u�qE�jh\gj}�t�u��yPs»¾

@¶h���y�½ }fxvy��OhOh\�7yE�¹��h�xv�:�`�:���jt*d�h op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�jqEopopy��º�.q�tph\�7tvyjh\qE�>d7}fxp�.gH�:tv�:�Kh optpqKtvh\g�h��Et\¾UÕ � �¸� % @5ÄfÅ/Òº§�²®²�§ �2¬®°$È�Ä�§�²�Æ�«*+

W &� � � & � ���

4�� Ù�Ù�� � �$u��:��op}?h\�Otv�:yE�¹y�¡'tpqE����hjiE¾UÕ � �¸�,� @5ÄfÅ/Òº§�²®²�§ �2¬®°$È�Ä�§�²�Æ�«*+

� � � W

4�� Ù�Ù�� � �$u8�.�fop}?h\�Otv�:yE�[yK¡'t*qK���:h�i�qK���[y�¡'tpd�h ¡�yE���:y�½X�.���jtpqK�f��h�o/�¯t*d�h Â?x*optXtpqK�f��h�hOsf}fxvh�opoph\o%t*dfq�t�:t��:o�}�y$opop�.����hE¤5¡�yEx�q���qKxp�.qK���:hK¤5tvy¹Á`��y�½<tpdfqKt �:t��:o1}fxph\oph\�$tW�.�_t*d�hj�ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\�£xph\qE�ºtp��y$�»¤5½X��t*d�yEr�tÁ`��y�½X�.������t*o�qK�OtprfqK�»��q��.r�h1uKhOt��Ã

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 29: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

D(H ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� � � � /W � � � � ¤

qK�foptpqE�ºtvh��7qEo �Ërfop�.��� 4 × � � à � � � � /W � � � �

¤

½/h\qKÁKh\��h��7qEo �Ërfop�.��� 4 × % � à � � � � /W �

½�df�:�>d7tprfx*�foXy$r�t%tvy��?h h�`r��:��q��:h\�$t%tvy-��� � W3¾UÕ � �¸� $ @5ÄfÅ/Òº§�²®²�§ �2¬®°$È�Ä�§�²�Æ�«*+

� � � W - %�� Z � W - %�� Z � �� �

4�� Ù�Ù�� � �$u¸�.�fo*}�h��ºtv�:yE�-y�¡�tpqE���:hRi¢qE�f�µy�¡ t*d�h¢¡�yE���:y�½X�.��� tpqE����h¢¡�yEx8tpd�h¶qK�foptpx*qK�Otvh\�µxphO�.q�tp��y$��fh\xp���Eh\�8¡¯xvy$g � � � W - %�� Z%rfov�.����}fxp�:���º�.}���h�o + 4 × � � 4 × � � 4 × % 2 � � ��h\��yEtvh�oXq�}�xvy$d��:�f��tph\�¹��q��.r�h���Ã

- � � ��� � � �� � � �

� � � �

¤f½/h\qKÁKh\��h��8qEo�Ã

- � � ��� � ��� �

¤

½�df�:�>d7�:o�h�`r��:�PqK��h��$t/tpyjtpd�h1¡�y$xpgHr���=y�¡'��h�gjg�q G ¾UÕ � �¸� ; @5ÄfÅ/Òº§�²®²�§ �2¬®°$È�Ä�§�²�Æ�«*+

1 � � & � � ��9W � -)3 Y 1 � � & � � �� � ��� � � 3 �

������ �����- � � � � � W& ���.� � � � ���

� �� ���� � � �

4�� Ù�Ù�� � �$uH�.�fo*}�h��ºtv�:yE�jyK¡»tpqK�f��h�i�qE�f�jy�¡»t*d�hX¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:��� t�½/y tpqE���:h\o�u`�:hO�.���.����xph\o*}�h��ºtv�:�Kh\��uIW8qK���� �H¡�yEx�1 � � & � � Õ��9W � -43 Y 1 � � & � � Õ��1����� � � 3 Ã

- � � �&� � � �� � � �/ � � �' � � �

� � � � /&� � � �� � � �/ � � �' � � �

¤

JF ��$J?;

Page 30: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« D$�

½�df�:�>d[�.o�h �$rf����q��:h\�$t�tpy�tpdfh ¡�yEx*g�r���� y�¡2�:h\gjgjq H�q�¡�tph\xW½�h�qKÁ�h����.�����Eu[xph\g�y��`�:���jt*d�hP� � oO¾%� yKtvht*d�h�qKopu�g�g�h\tpxpu_��h\t�½�h\h\�$W qE�f� - ¤»½�d��:��h�optpqKtvh\g�h��Et*o W � - qK��� - � W¥qExvhj�º�:h\qExv�:u[�:�fh\�$tv�.�OqK�˾cXdf�:oXqEovu�gjg�hOtpxpu��.oX�fr�h tpy�}fxv�.�f�O�:}��:h + 4 × � 2 ¡�y$x -X/�- qK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE��¾

� � � O . ,/,/)� ! *-,/. ��,/��3 %[{�¹t*d��:oXoph\�Otv�:yE�»¤�½�h }fxpy��Kh�tpd�h1¡�yE���:y�½X�.����xphºÂ���h\g�h\�$t%y�¡2cXd�h\yExph\g i�Ã� � Õ`Ù � Õ � � +p� Ù �P� Õ �K� �"� Ù "�������� 2 �+ÅO­1" �¨Å�±�° -X/�- «O±�­�¬.«®Ò¨³�¬®°`È7­®Ä�ÅÒº§�²®²�§��2¬®°`È£¦*§�°�Æ�¬®­Ë¬¯§�°f«1+$ ´���±K¦¨Ä�«>­�±�­�ź©�ÅO°�­�¬®° "µÄf±�«¹¬®­Ë«£±�«¨«º§�¦O¬¯±�­�Å*Æ «Oź­H§vÒ_ÆKÅOÓ>¬ �PŨƸÆKÅ{ª�ÅO°�ÆEź°5¦º¬¯Åº«¢±P«_ÆKÅOÓ>¬ �PŨÆ�Ò¨Ó*§�©

²�ÅO©H©�±P«��=�1( ��������±P«%ªf±�Ó>­X§{Ò#"�´- ´ %Wź«>Ç�²�­Ë¬®°`Èj«O¦¨ÄfŨÆ�Ç�²�¬®°`È7¬.«�¦O¬®Óp¦OÇ�¬®­ Ò¨Ó*Å*Å�´�E´�@5ÄfÅOÓpÅH¬.«/ª�Óp§���± �O²�³7°�§j©�Ç�²�­�¬ ª?²�ÅjÆKÅËÉ�°?¬®­Ë¬¯§�°¶§vÒ�± ��±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�Å��/©�Ũ±�°?¬®°$È8­®Ä�±�­ � �"ÄfÅO°�Å,�PÅOÓ

� � & Q�� � ��9W � 4 698 QY � � & T�� � ��9W � 4 698 TY dcdedY � � & � � � ��9W � 47698 �

¬.«%ª�±�Ó>­%§vÒ#"6��­®Ä�ź°& Q Y & T Y deded Y & � � /

Äf±�«�­N§ �*ÅXª?Óp§=�P±&�º² ³8¬®© ª�§�«*«>¬*�O²�Å�´@5Ä�ź° +$ ´��«�Òº±�Ó�±�«�¦*§�°�­�Óp§�²3¬.« ¦¨§�°5¦¨ÅºÓ>°5Å*Æ��­�ÄfÅ ¬®°Kª?Ç�­Ë«�§{Ò�" ±�ÓpÅ�­®Ä�Å «O§�Ç�Óp¦¨Å °�§�ÆKź«�§{Ò ­�ÄfÅHÆKÅ{ª�ÅO°�ÆEź°5¦º³

È�Ó*±¨ª�Ä�´- ´��>°Kª?Ç�­ ��±�² Ç�Å>«�±�Ó*Å�­�Äf§�«ºÅ ��±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�ź«�"Ä`¬¯¦¨Ä£°5Å���ÅOÓ�§\¦¨¦OÇ�Ó §�°_­�ÄfÅ�²�ůҨ­�Äf±�°�Æ�«¨¬¯ÆEÅj§{Ò�«>­N±�­NÅO©�ź°?­¯««>Ç�¦*Ä¢±P«�W �jÅ )ºª�Ópź«*«>¬¯§�°�´

�E´ §�ÓjŨ±E¦*Ä[ÈK¬ �PÅO° ¬®°�ª�Ç�­W¦¨§�°�­�Óp§�²»Ä�¬.«¨­�§�Ó>³_§vÒ "¸±�°�Æ£¦¨§�© ªf±�­�¬*�º²�Å�¬®°�ª�Ç�­��P±�²�Ç�Å�Ä`¬.«>­�§�Ó>³���­�ÄfÅOÓpÅ�¬.«Å )`±E¦º­�²�³8§�°5Å�Ó>Ç�°¶§{Ò#"6��¬¯´®Å�´ �1"¥¬.«�ÆEź­�ÅOÓ>©H¬®°?¬.«¨­�¬¯¦�´

��� / : � Í��:h\qKxp�:uK¤�t*d�hOy$xvh�g D¢}fxpy��`�:�fh\o�rfoj½X��t*d¸q¶o*r ���º�:h\�$t��ºyE������tp��y$�»¤t*d��.o��ºyE������tp��y$���.o���yKt�fh\�ºh�opo*qKxpuK¾ .?rfxptpd�h�xpg�y$xvhE¤ t*d�h�xprf��h�o8¡�y$x[�:��¡�h\x*xv�.���·��h\}?h\�f�fh\�f�O��h�o£qKo£�OqErfo*q��:��t�uµ�ºy$�foptpx*q��.�Et*o¹�:o�?yEr��f�¶tvy[tpd�h�opu��$tpq�s»¤3�fyKt tvy[t*d�h�ovh�gjqK�$tv�.�Oo1yK¡/t*d�h�}fxpyK�Ex*qKg¹¾ [{�¶}�qKxptv�.�Or��.qKx\¤»¡¯xpyEg optpqKtvh\g�h��Et � � & � � ÕF�9W � - "¨¤$½�h��>d�y`yEophXtvyH�:�`¡�h�x��fh\}?h\�f��h��f�ºu - � ��� � � W7��r�t/�fyKtt*d�h opu�gjgHh\tpxp�:�y$��h��:�8½�d��:�>dgW£qK�f� - qExvh hºsf�>dfqK�f�Kh\��¾+cXd��.oXg�h\qE�fot*dfq�t\¤�½�d��:��h "�gjqPuj�fyKtXopqKtv�.o{¡�ujt*d�h qKo*oprfgj}`Ûtp��y$�fo'y�¡�tpd�h\yExph\g DW¡�yEx'q��K�:�Kh���opu��f�ºt*qK�ºtp�:�¡�yEx*g<yK¡�"5¤���t2gjqPu�o*q�tv�.ov¡�u�tpd�h�g�q�¡�tph\x2}fxpyE}?h\x'xphO½�xp��tp�:�f��.�$tvy_q£opu��f�ºt*qK�ºtp�:�\q��:��u¶��� ��h�xvh��Et\¤+��r�t�oph\gjqK�$tv�.�OqK���:u_h �$rf����q��:h\�$t ¡�y$xpg¹¾ ZWh\xphK¤'oph\gjqK�$tv�.�OqK���:u_h �$rf� Û��qK��h��Et g�h\qE�fo�tpdfqKt tpd�hjt�½/y£}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjo �:�¶�ºy$�fov�.��h�xpqKtv�:yE�¢d�qP�Kh��:��h��$tv�.�Oq���x*rf�fo�½�d�h��¥op�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE��oXqKxph����.o*�OqKx*��h��»¾

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 31: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

D(J ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

4�� Ù�Ù�� � [�tX�:o%y$xv�$qK���5WOh����.�$tvy�ovh\�Kh�xpqK�5optvh�}fo\¾iK¾ @µ��t*d[tpd�h1¡�y$xpgHr��.q�W � � �8½/h1qEopopy��º�.q�tph t*d�h1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���jqKr�tpyEgjq�tpyE�1Ã

x,y

set x

set y

set y

set x

set xset b

set x

x,b,y

or Fb =

x y

x,y b,x

b=T

c"x*qK��ov�:tv�:yE�foHqKxph��.qK�?hO�:��h�� ½X��t*dRqE�ºtv�:yE��oO¾ � qK�?hO� x*�� � W "8�:�f�f�:�\q�tvh�o�t*dfq�t���qKxp�:qE���:h:W¸�.oHophOttvy¥qK�¸qKx*����t*xpqExvu¶��q��.r�h¹y�¡W�:tpo��¯hOs�tvh\����h\� �H��y$gjq��.� ��� r x� " ¾ E`tpq�tph\ojqKxph8�.qK�?hO�:�:h\��½X�:tpdtpd�y$ovh ��qKxp�:qE����h�o2tpd�q�t�qExvh � ¤$��¾ hK¾:¤$dfqP�EhW��yEt��h\h\�7ovh\tO¾'cXd��:o/qKrftvyEgjqKtvyE�j�.o�tpd�h�gHy$ovt�}�h�xpg��.o{Ûov�:�Kh1y$��h1½X��t*d7t*d�h1¡�yK�:�:y�½X�:����}fxpyE}?h\xptv�:h\o3Ã�Ëq �8optpqKtvh�oHqExvh7�PqK�:rfh\��½X�:tpd¸�ºy$�`Â��Er�xpqKtv�:yE�fo�y�¡Wt*d�h7t*xv�.}��:h W W % & % �$Z�t*dfq�t�qExvh8�OyEgj}fqKtv�.����h

½X�:tpd¹t*d�h�op�>dfh\�fr��:�.�����ºyE��ovt*xpqK�:�$t W � � �5¾�Ë�6����qExv�.qK�f��h�o/qExvh ophOtXoph�`r�h\�$tp�:qK���:uK¾�Ë���8~W���3�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o/qExvh1h\�Kh\�$t*rfq��:��u�ophOt\¾cXd`rfo�h�qK�>d�}fqKtpdjy�¡»t*d��:o/qKrftvyEgjqKtvyE�jo*}�h��º��Â�h\o�qK�jh\�PqK�:r�q�tv�:yE�jo*�>d�h\g�hX¡�y$x�t*d�hWt*xv�.}��:h�W W % & % �/Z½�d��.�>d��:o/�ºy$gj}fq�tp�:���:h�½X�:tpd�t*d�h1�ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\�jo*�>d�h\��r����.����op}?h\�O� Â?�\q�tp��y$�»¾2Í�y$�$�Kh\x*ophO�:uK¤KqE�Euj�ºy$x{Ûxvh��ºt+hO��q��.rfqKtv�:yE��o*�>d�h�gHh�¡�yEx+t*xv�.}��:h�W W % & % �$Z3�\qK�H��hXo*}�h��º��Â�h\�H�:��tpd��.o'½%qPuK¾ @¶h%�Oq��:�`tpd��.o2qKrftvy�Ûgjq�tvy$��t*d�hjÅ )`Ũ¦ºÇ�­�¬¯§�°¢±�Ç�­N§�©j±�­N§�°�qEopopy��º�.q�tvh��j½X��t*d8o*�>d�h\��r����.���jop}?h\�O� Â��Oq�tp��y$�:W � � �5¾

D�¾Xc3y¹h\qE�>d£}fxp�:g��:tv�:�Khjovt*q�tvh�g�h\�$tW½/h�qEopopy��º�.q�tph�tpd�hj�ºy$�Pzvrf�f�Otv�:yE�¢y�¡��:tpo1�OqErfopqK���:t�u[�ºyE��ovt*xpqK�:�$tpoqK�f�£}?yEo*op�:���:h��ºy$�foptpx*q��.�Et*o%�:�$�EyK�:�$�.�����º�:y��>Á`o�qK�f�£�?y`yK�:h\qE�7��qExv�.qK���:h\o\¤fqK���[½�h t*qKÁ�h t*d�h�}fxpy�Û�frf�OtXy�¡2qKo*ovy��º�.q�tph\�8hºs�h\�\r�tv�:yE�¹qKr�tpyEgjq�t*qf¾2cXd�h�}fqKtpdfo�y�¡"t*d�h�xph\o*r���tp�:�f�jqEr�tvy$gjq�tvy$�7o*}?h\�º��¡�uq��:�f�ºy$xpxph\�Ot"o*�>d�h\�frf���.���Eo+tpy�h\��q��.rfq�tph/t*d�h%�:�$�EyK�:�Kh\���PqExv�.qK�f��h�oO¾!@ZhX�OqK����t*d�hXxvh�oprf��tp�:���1}fxpy��frf�ºtqKr�tpyEgjq�tpyE�7tpd�h8Å )`Ũ¦ºÇ�­�¬¯§�°Z±�Ç�­N§�©j±�­N§�°�qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�8½X��t*d¹tpd�h��OyE�fop�:�fh\xph\�8}�xv�.g���tp���EhK¾

�f¾XcXd�h\�7½/h�t*qKÁKh t*d�h }fxvy��fr��ºt%y�¡+tpd�h1hºs�h��Or�tp��y$�7qEr�tvy$g�qKtpq�qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\��½X��t*d7h�qK�>d7ovt*q�tvh�g�h\�$tO¾U%u � h�gjg�q�D�½�h�Á`��y�½¸tpdfqKtO¤E¡�yEx2h�qK�>dHtprf}��:h�yK¡5��qExv�.qK���:h\o'½�df�:�>djo*q�tv�.ovÂ�h\o2t*d�h�o*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�»¤tpd�h�xvhj�.o�q[}fq�t*d¢yK¡/t*d�h�}fxpy`��rf�ºt�qEr�tvy$g�qKtvy$�_½�d��.�>d¢y$xv�:�K�.�fqKtvh\o ¡¯xpyEg �:tpo1�.���:tv�.q��optpqKtvh�qK���

JF ��$J?;

Page 32: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« DK�

tvh�xpg��.�fq�tph\oWqKtWt*d�h�Â?��q��"optpqKtvh��.�£½�d��.�>d£q��:�+�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o�qKxph�ovh\tO¤5g�h\qK�f�:���8tpdfqKt q��:�3��qExv�.qK���:h\oy�¡'tpd�h��OyE�fop�.��h\xph\�8tprf}��:h�qKxph ovh �`r�h\�$tv�.q��:�:u8ovh\tO¾

��¾-.'�:�fqK���:uK¤»½/hHxphºÂ���h�t*d�hHt*xpqE�fop��tp��y$�£�:qE��h\�:o�yK¡�tpd�hH¡�yEx*g x* ����W "HhOt*��¾:¤��Eu£qEopop���$���.����tvy�W¶hOtp�tpd�h8�PqK�:rfh�op}?h\�O� Â�h�� �$u¢tpdfh�}fxvyE�Ex*qKg¹¾�cXdfqE�fÁ`o tvy_�OyE�f���:tv�:yE�¥�[yK¡/t*d�hOy$xvh�g D�¤'qK�Otv�:yE�fo1yK¡tpd�hj¡�y$xpg x*�� �VW "�hOt*��¾:¤"qKxph�xvhOÂ?��h��¢�.�$tvy_op�:���E��hj½�xp��tp�:�f�Eo\¾jcXdf�:o1Â����:o*d�h�o tpd�h�}�xvy`y�¡/y�¡%tpd�htpd�h\yExph\g¹¾ Y

@¶h �:���.rfoptpx*q�tvh1t*d��:o�tvh\�>d���� �`r�h1y$�7t*d�h�¡�yK�:��y�½X�.����op�:gj}��:h -X/�- Ã� � � W - %�� Z q � � ;9�� ; � � ; � % � � d

cXdfh1�\qKrfo*q��:�:t�u8�ºy$�fovt*xpqK�:�$t%qK�f�¹qKo*opy`�O�:qKtvh��8hOs`h��Or�tp��y$�7qEr�tvy$gjq�tvy$�8qExvh�Ã

� � W - % �)% �/Zq W - %�� Z � � �

q � � ; �� ; ���4; � % � �

set vset u

set uset v

set y

h,u,v,y

y

u,yv,y

u,v,y

h=T

cXdfh�xvhOÂ?��h\�Zhºs�h��Or�tp��y$�ZqEr�tvy$g�qKtvy$�¢�.o yE�ftpq��.��h��Z�$uZxph\}f�:qE�º�.���S*���� - qK�f� *�� � � �$u�� ����� - qK���� ����� � ¤�qK�f�S*���� �8�$u �?_ � � W - %�� Z>¾

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 33: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�E� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� � � � � � � � � � ��� � � ��� �� � ��� ��� � � �� �� � � ������� � ��0� � �P ������� � � � � �� � � � � �,���0K� �/��� ����� � J �

cXd�xvy$r��Ed�y$r�tXtpdf�:o�qK}f}?h\����� s»¤�½�h�yE���:u¹�OyE�fop�.��h\xWhºs�h\�\r�tpqE����h -X/�- ��h\��yEtvh��£�EuBC � DN6 %vGI%KJ�L ¾ .�yExh�qK�>d �OyE�fop�:�fh\xph\� -0/�- ¤2½/h7qEopo*rfg�h8t*dfq�t���t�dfqKo��?hOh\�Rh�`r��.}f}?h\��½X�:tpd¸op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���Zo*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�foqEopopy��º�.q�tph\��½X�:tpd¹h�qK�>d7y�¡"�:tpoWovt*q�tvh�g�h\�$tpo\¤`¡�yK�:��y�½X�.����x*r���h�o �¯lXÛ¨iK¤YD�¤ �f¤ � �>¾

� �&� � ) %�� � � � , .���# # � ���� �� � ��,/. 3 �� �� !(. # � ����#�!() *�� ,(!/#&� 1 .�, ��) , %�� � ���!/� ) #�, ��% � ��� � ,/.���.��% � . 3 * . % #�!/#�.��

.�xvy$g t*d�hZ�fhºÂ?���:tv�:yE�-y�¡�op�>dfh\�fr��:�.���Ro*}�h��º��Â?�OqKtv�:yE�fo8�:�-oph\�Otv�:yE�·�?¾ Df¤X½�h¢Á`��y�½Êt*dfq�t J o*}�h��º��Â�h\o�.�¶}fqKxptv�.�Or��.qKx1q¹Â?�f��tphH¡¯qEg����:u¢yK¡/}fqExvtp�:qK�2yEx*��h\x*o�yE� 6�¤3�OyE�fop�:optv�.���[y�¡%q[�ºyK�:�:h\�ºtp��y$�¢yK¡/�O�:x*�Or��:t{¡¯xphOh�f�:xph\�Otvh\�H�Ex*qK}�dfoO¤P½X�:tpd�hO�:h\g�h��Et*o'y�¡ 6ÀqEo+�Kh\xptv�.�ºh�oO¤E}fqKx*qKg�hOtph\xp� W\h\���$u�t*d�hX}�y$opop�.����hX�OyE�`Â��$rfx*q�tv�:yE��oyK¡tpdfhjophOt1yK¡/�?y$yE��h�qK�¢�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o qE�f�Z�O��y��>Á`o y�¡�C ¾�M h���yKtph��Eu����¸tpdf�:o�Â?�f��tphH¡¯qEg����:u_y�¡%}fqKxptv�.q��y$xp�fh\x*oO¾3cXd`rfo�h\qK�>d�� . ���[�.o2q��O�:x*�Orf��tv¡¯xvh\h%�f�:xph\�Otvh\���$xpqE}fd�dfqP�`�.��� q1oprf��ovh\t+yK¡ 6 qEo+��t*o2�Kh�xvtp�:�Oh\o�Ì�$u��OyE�$�Kh��Etp��y$�»¤$h\qK�>d8��qKxp�:qE����h � ½�d��.�>d��.oX��yKt%q��Eh\xptvhOs�y�¡��Ñ�:o%qK����h\�8tvy��ÑqEo�q�ov�.���E��h\tvyE��¤$½X�:tpd�fyj��xpqE�f�>d8�:�.�fÁ�h��8tpy��:tO¾�cXd��:oX�OyE�$�Kh��$tv�:yE��½X�:�:�3d�yK�.�¹�:�7tpdfh�ovh �$rfhO��¾|qE�>d[xprf��^ _ *cb % *<Q % *]T %cdeded ���>¡{¾'�pi�� ��y�¡[C=��hOÂ?��h\o��:�¹}fqKxptv�.�Orf�:qExXq�oph�`r�h��f�ºh����b % ��� Q % ���T %edcded

yK¡/h\��h�g�h\�$tpo1yK¡�����¤"½�d�h\xph���� � �:o�tpd�h�}fqExvtp�:qK�2yEx*��h\x1}fqExvt1yK¡/t*xpqE�fov�:tv�:yE�¶xphO�.q�tv�:yE� J qKt1optpqKtvhg* � ¾� y�½ ¤�½�h1t*rfxp�¹t*d��:oWovh �$rfh\�f�Oh����b % ��� Q % ���T %cdeded �.�$tvy�qjop�:���E��h1�.�`Â?���:tvh��f�:xph\�Otvh\�7�Ex*qK}�d�D��� WN^Z?��� �b�� � � Q � � �T!� dedcd % �piO� �

½�dfh\xph� � "��.o�q£¦¨§�°5¦*±�­NÅO°�±�­Ë¬¯§�°�yE}?h\x*q�tp��y$��½�d��.�>d¹½�h ��hOÂ?��h���hOs`t3ÃiK¾-.�y$xh�qK�>d���qKxp�.qK���:h � . 6�¤`t*d�h y��\�Orfx*xvh��f�ºh�o�yK¡ � �:�"���b % ��� Q % ���T %cdedcd qExvhWtvyKt*q��:��ujy$xp��h�xvh���qKoqj�>dfq��.� �xb � �PQ � �4T � dcded ¾

D�¾WÍ�yE�fop�.��h\x%t*d�h����.o�z{yE�:�$tXrf���:yE�$# � ��� � yK¡"tpdfh �Ex*qK}fdfo%���b % ��� Q % ���T %cdeded ¾�cXd�h\�[�OyE�f�\q�tvh��fq�tp��y$����b � ��� Q � ���T � deded �.o ��hOÂ?��h��¢qKo tpdfhHg��:�f�:gjq��2}fqExvtp�:qK�3y$xp��h�x��$xvh�q�tvh�x�t*dfqK�_�?yKt*d&# � ��� �qK�f�¹t*d�h��>dfq��.�fo �xb � �PQ � �4T � dedcd ¡�yEx%h�qK�>d � . 6�¾� hºs�tO¤"½�hj�.qK�?hO��h�qK�>dZ�Kh�xvtphºs¢yK¡'� �b � � � Q � � �T � deded ½X��t*dZt*d�h�}fqK�:x � �PqExv�.qK�f��hE¤��OqKx*xp��h��¢��q��.r�h �qKtvt*qK�>d�h���½X��t*d�t*d��:o/�Eh\xptvhºs��.��t*d�h��OyE�fop�.��h\xph\��x*rf�»¾2cXd��.o/g�qEÁ�h�o�x*rf�0^ _a* bR% * Qx% * T]%cdedcd qE���.�`Â?���:tvh²:± �¨Åº²®²:Å*Æ�ªf±�Ó>­�¬¯±�²+§�ÓpÆKÅOÓ��»½�d��.�>d7½/h ��h\�fyKtvh �$u

^ � * b � * Q � * T � dcded.'�.�fq��:�:uK¤�½/h���hºÂ?�fh

^)( ��� % � ^+* -, $ %/.10�2 -354 -, " % $ % �pi G ��˽�d�h\xph�opu`gH��yE�) 76$"'��h���yKtph\o�df�:���.��� �5g�h\qK�f�:���Xt*dfq�ti��½�h�xph\g�y��EhK¤º�.� }fqKxptv�.q���y$xp�fh\x8� �b � � � Q � � �T � dcded ¤t*d�yEoph��Eh\xptv�.�ºh\oW�:qE��h\���:h\�_½X��t*d£��qKxp�:qE����h�oW�\qKx*xvu`�.���?��qKoWq8��q��.r�h��.�_x*rf�A^'¤»qK�f�£t*d�h\� D&��t*qKÁ�hHtpd�hxph\o*r��:tv�.���W�.qK�?hO�:�:h\��}fqKxptv�.q��$yEx*��h\x+qK�����OqK���$�:t;^ ( ¤�½�d�h\xph/o*rf}?h\x*op�\xv�.}�t d ( "/xphº¡�h�xpo"tvy� pqKopu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o#">¾9 JF�$J#<;:Y2JF +�(J?;� �ð�í¨øXîa`+éëï¯éëêNí�� ö�ï

JF ��$J?;

Page 34: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« ��i

[{�`¡�y$xpgjqK���:u¸o*}�h�qKÁ$�.����¤Xo*rf�O�Oh\o*ov�:�Kh_o*�>d�h\��r����.��� �$xpqE}fdfo�qExvh_�OyE�f�\q�tvh��fq�tph\��yE�µq¥��qExv�.qK���:hºÛ��$u$Û��qExv�.qK���:hW�fqEov�.o\¤Et*d�h\��qE�foph\�$t��qKxp�.qK���:h\o�qKxphW��hO�:hOtph\��½�df���:hWt*xpqE�fov�:tv�:�Kh �º�:yEo*rfxvhW�:o�tpqEÁ�h\��¤$qE�f�jÂ?�fqK���:u½/h�tpqKÁKhHt*xpqE�fop��tp���Eh�xph\�fr��ºtv�:yE�¢y�¡/tpd�h�opy¹y$��tpqK�:�fh\�¢}�qKxptv�.q��'yEx*��h\x tvy[�EhOt1��t*o qKo*ovy��O�:qKtvh\�¢���:xph\�Otvh���$xpqE}fd»¾�cXd��.o3}�xvy��ºh��frfxph'�:o»�:�:�:rfoptpx*q�tph\���.�1tpd�h�f�:qK�Ex*qKg·y�¡�t*d�h�}foph\rf��yKÛNoptpqKtvh�gHh��$t� � � & � � ÕF� ��� � - "�.�¢oph\�Otv�:yE� G ¾�iE¾ cXd�h�ÁKhOu_}?yK�.�$t �.oWt*dfq�t\¤»�:� ^ ( ¤�q��:�'�Kh�xvtp�:�Oh\oW�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE���£tvy¹}fxvh�ovh��$t y��O�\rfx*xvh��f�ºh�oyK¡2�PqExv�.qK�f��h�oO¾XcXd`rfoW�fy�tvh�ovtW¡�yExWqE�foph\�f�Oh��OqK�£�?hH}?h\xv¡�yEx*g�h\�»¾ [{�`Â�����tph��$xpqE}fdA^ ( �:oWyErfx g�y`�fhO�3yK¡qE�¶±�«>³�°�¦¨Ä`Óp§�°�§�Ç`« Ó>Ç�°jy�¡ -0/1- C ¾

.?yExQC � DF6 %HGI%KJ�L qE� -X/�- ¤f½�h ��hOÂ?��hC%( ��� % � DF6 %�� ( L % �pi�H �

½�dfh\xph � ( �:o[t*d�h¶¡¯qKg��:��uÀy�¡�qK��� ^ ( ¤�¡�y$xA^Ñx*qK���E�:����y��Kh�x8t*d�h�ophOt[y�¡jxprf��o[y�¡:C ¾ .?yEx$C o �DF64o %vG o %KJ o L % k � YR% ��¤�½/h1�fhºÂ?��h

C%( Q (h C%(T ��� % � DN6 %�� ( L % ½�dfh\xph�� 6 � 6 Q[r 6 T� ( � � ( Q Y ( � (T �piP� �

qE�f� Y ( ��h���yKtph\o��OyE�Pzvrf���ºtv�:yE�¸y�¡ ophOtpojyK¡�qEovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo�xpr��foO¤�½�d��.�>dR½/h£��hºÂ?�fh_��y�½ ¾ .�yEx^ (o . � (o % kR� YR% ��¤�½/h opqPu�t*dfq�t ^ (Q qK�f�S^ (T qKxph�¦*§�©Wªf±�­�¬*�O²�Å�»½�xp��tptvh��

^)(Q���� ( ^)(T % �pi�J ���¡'tpd�h1¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f���OyE�f���:tv�:yE��oXd�yK�.�1Ã< Q Ã\j � . 6 Q 6 T ¤��:qE��h\���:h\�7}fqKxptv�.q���yEx*��h�xpo ^ (Q qE�f�g^ (T dfqP�Kh �:��h��$tv�.�Oq���xph\optpxp�.�ºtv�:yE��otpyHt*d�h��>d�q��.�

�xb � �PQ � �4T � dcded ¤%g�h�qK���.���¥tpdfqKtO¤%¡�y$x � q o*dfqKxph\�¸��qKxp�:qE����hE¤�t*d�h_��q��.r�h�o��OqKx*xp��h��¸�$u� b % � Q % � T %cdeded qKxph��.��h\�$tv�.�OqK��¡�y$xQ^ (Q qE�f�A^ (T ¾ [N¡�t*d��:o��ºy$�f���:tv�:yE�_dfyK�.�foO¤�tpdfh\�»¤�¡�yEx � q8opdfqExvh����qKxp�:qE����hE¤f½/h��OqK�£r���� ¡�u[�>dfqK�:�fo � b � � Q�� � T � deded �:�[�.qK�?hO�:��h��£}fqKxptv�.q��3yEx*��h\x*o|^ (Q qK�f�S^ (T ¾@Zh�qEopo*rfg�h1tpd��.o�d�yE�:��o%�:�[���.op�\rfo*ov�.�����ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� < T1tpy�¡�yK�:��y�½ ¾

< T ÃXqKo*opr�gH�.�����ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� < Q d�yK�.�fo\¤�tpd�h��¹½�h�xph�`r��.xvh1�.�[qK�f���:tv�:yE�7tpd�q�tXtpdfh ��h�qKopt�rf}f}?h\x��?yErf���y�¡3�.qK�?hO�:�:h\�8}�qKxptv�.q���y$xp�fh\x*o+^ (Q qE�f�0^ (T hOs��:optpo\¾2cXd��:o%qEgHy$rf�$tpotvyjqKo*oprfg��.����t*dfq�t�tpd�h�xvh��.o���y}fq��.x�W W % �$Z%yK¡'o*dfqExvh��8�Eh\xptv�.�ºh\o%yK¡;^ (Q qE�f�?^ (T o*rf�>d¹tpdfqKt�W � Q �¹d�yK�.�fo%�.�A^ (Q ¤�½�d��:�:h � � T|Wd�yK�.�fo��:� ^ (T ¾ [{�$t*r���tp���EhO�:u¶o*}?h\qKÁ$�.����¤'��y_o*d�yExpt��O�:x*�Or��:t@�Ë�˾ hK¾:¤2��y p��h\qE����y��>Á " ���.o��\xvh�q�tph\�¥�.��ºy$g����.���.���jtpd�h t�½/y��ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\�7qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo�x*rf�fo\¾

[N¡��OyE�f���:tv�:yE��o�� < QP¤ < T��Xd�yK�.�»¤ft*d�h\�£½/h���hOÂ?��h�^ (Q Y ( ^ (T qEo��?hO�.����tpdfh�qK�?y��Kh rf}f}?h\x*�?yErf�f��¤?qK���� ( Q Y ( � (T qKo��?hO�.���Ztpd�h¹ovh\t�y�¡Q^ (Q Y ( ^ (T ¤2½�d�h\xph W ^ (Q % ^ (T Z�x*qK�f�Kh\o�y��Kh\x�tpd�h¹ovh\t�y�¡�}fqK�:x*o�yK¡�OyEgj}fqKtv�.����h1�.qK�?hO�:��h��[}fqKxptv�.q��5yEx*��h�xpo\¾2cXd��:o/¡�y$xpgjqK���:u8��hOÂ?��h\o �piP�&�¨¾

& Ö�� � � � Ù��5Ö ���a�1�7� Ö�� � � � Ù��5Ö � ~%tXtpdf�:oX}?yK�.�$t�q���q�tpr�xpqK� �`r�h�ovtp��y$�7qExv�.oph\o\¤`��qKg�hO�:uK¤��fy$h�o%tpd�h¡�yE���:y�½X�.����}�xvy$}�h�xvt�u8dfyK�.�1Ã

C%( Q (h C%(T � �xC Q h C T � ( % �pi\� �

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 35: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�FD ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

qK�:opy����:�:r�ovt*xpqKtvh\�¹�$u8t*d�h1¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���j�ºy$g�gHr�tpqKtv�:�Kh ���.q��$xpqEg=ÃW�C Qx% C T Z (2 � W�C ( Q % C (T Z

� �C Q q C T (2 � C ( Q q ( C (T

w�xvy$}�h�xvt�u �vi�� �%�.�$tpr��:tv�:�Kh\��u[hOs�}�xvh�opoph\oXt*dfq�t��ºy$g�gHrf���.�OqKtv�:yE�£�?h\dfqP�Eh\o�h �`r�����qK��h��Etp��u¹¡�y$xW�?yKtpdZovu��`Û�>d�xvy$��yErfo�qK�f�8qKopu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�»¾+l�yErf�Ed��:u�op}?h\qEÁE�.���?¤E��¡ �vi�� ��½/qEo�t*xpr�hE¤`tpd�h���½/h �ºy$r��.��.�$tvh�xp}fxphOt%y$rfx -X/�- g�y���hO�3h�`r��:�PqK��h��$tv�:u8qKoXopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo/yEx%qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoO¾

+��`¡�yExptprf��q�tvh\��uE¤?}fxpyE}?h\xpt�u �pi\� �/�fy$h�o���yEtWd�yK�.�¹�:�[�Eh\��h�xpqK�ˤf��r�h�tvy�t*d�h�}?yEo*ov�.���:���:t�u8tpy�hºs�h\x*�º�.oph�OyE�$tpxpyK���$u�tpd�h¢½/qPu¸y�¡�qK�foph\���ºh£�.�µovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo��OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE� q ¾V[{�·tpdfh£¡�yK�:��y�½X�.����oph\�Otv�:yE�»¤½/hjopd�y�½ÑtpdfqKt(�pi\� ���.�f��h\h\�¶d�yK�.�fo1rf�f�fh\x �ºh�xvt*q��.�¢o*r ���º�:h\�$t �ºy$�f���:tv�:yE�fo\¤»�:�¶½�d��.�>d_t*d�h���yEtv�:yE�_yK¡ÅO°�ÆE§\¦¨Ä`Ó*§�°�³ }��.qPu�o%q��Oh\�$tpx*q���xpyK�:hK¾

� � � � ����.�� � , .���[{�¹t*d��:oXoph\�Otv�:yE�»¤�½�h rfoph ��yKt*q�tv�:yE��o/¡¯xvy$g�ovh��ºtp��y$�7��¾ .�yEx%h�qK�>d -X/�- C � DF6 %HGI%KJ�L ¤�½/h���h\�fyKtvh �$u

C � � D�� �t*d�h -0/1- yE��t*q��.��h\�¹�$u8qK�foptpx*qK�Otv�.���j��qKxp�:qE����h�o/�:�$tvyjt*d�hO�.x��º�:y��>Á`oO¾2~��.opy�¤�¡�y$x�� 7�6�¤�½/h���h\�fyKtvh �$uC�� tpdfh�xvh�ovt*xv�.�ºtp��y$��y�¡ -0/1- C·tvy�� ¤fqE�f�[�$u�C � � t*d�h�qK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE�8y�¡+C�� �.�$tvyj�:tpo��O��y��>Á`oO¾

.?yEx�� � 7�� 7�6�½�h�o*qPu�tpd�q�t�� � �.oXq£¦º²�§�¦ �¬®°�ҺźÓ*ź°5¦*ÅXy�¡� ¤�½�xv�:tvtph\�� �� ��� % � D�i��

��¡Wt*d�h8¡�yE���:y�½X�.���Z���.q��$xpqEg �fhºÂ?��h�ojq¢o*rfx�z{h��ºtp���Eh�¡¯rf�f�Otv�:yE��qKo*ovy��O�:qKtv�.����¤+¡�yExHh\qE�>d�x*rf��yK¡ C �� ¤qr���� �`r�h�x*rf�7y�¡�C � � Ã

C � �3������ 2 � C �

��� ��������! #"%$��&�'"%( ��) � *

C � �cXdf�:oXg�h\qE�foXt*dfq�t�}fxph\oph\���ºh���qK�foph\���ºhWyK¡+��qExv�.qK���:h\o%�?hO�:yE���E�:�f��tpy�� ��� � �:�$C�� �OqE�7�?h �:��¡�h\x*xvh��¡¯xpyEg t*d�h/�PqK�:rfh\o+y�¡���qExv�.qK���:h\o"�.��C��� v¾U[N¡+� � �,� Q qE�f�-� � �.� T d�yE�:�»¤�t*d�h\��� � � W�� Q2r � T Z¡�yE���:y�½�o\¤»tpd`rfo1tpdfh\xphHhOs`�.optpo q7�Exph\q�tph\opt/� opr��>d_tpd�q�t0� � �1� dfyK�.�foO¾�ZWh��f�ºhj½/hj�\qK�Z�ºyE��ov�.��h\xt*d�h�rf�����`r�h1�:���Oxph\qKop�.�����>dfq��.�

2 �Z6�W nPZ3 � 6�W Y Z3 ��6 W �2Z3 � dedcd � D(D&�

yK¡foprf��ovh\tpo�yK¡46µopr��>d1tpdfqKtO¤�¡�yEx3h\qK�>d �5¤]6�W �$Z��:o3tpd�h��$xvh�q�tph\opt�ovh\t�y�¡f��qKxp�.qK���:h\o»o*rf�>d1tpd�q�t 6�W � 2 Y Z3 �6�W �$ZWd�yK�.�fo\¾W~Wo 2 �E6 WNnPZ>¤ 6 W Y ZW�ºyE��ov�.ovt*o�yK¡'t*d�hHo*rf�fophOt y�¡���qKxp�.qK���:h\oXt*dfq�t�qKxph�}fxph\oph\�$tWqEoWopy$y$�qEo/tpd�h��OyE�fop�:�fh\xph\� -0/�- �Kh\tpoXqE�ºtv�:��q�tph\�»¾ >W¡+�OyErfx*oph��>dfqK�:� � D>D&��g�r�ovt��?h\�OyEg�h ovt*q�tv�:yE��qKxpujqKt�ovy$g�hÂ�����tph �542Ã+6 W �64 X Y ZR�6 W �64 Zº¾ [{�7�Kh\�fh\x*q���¤�½�h1yE�f��u8Á`��y�½ÀtpdfqKt 6 W �64]Z 796�¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 36: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �E�

�7Õ ) � ���*� Ù�� � + Õ�� Ú Ù � � � Ù��5Ö 2 -X/�- C�¬.«j«O±�¬¯Æ_­N§ �¨Å h\����y��>dfxvy$��yEr�oj¬ Ò 6 W � 4 Z�� 6 �W¬¯´®Å�´ ��¬ Òj­�ÄfÅÒº§�²®²�§��2¬®°`È£¦¨§�°�Æ�¬®­Ë¬¯§�°Z¬.«1«O±�­�¬.«�É�Å¨Æ +

­�ÄfÅ�¦*Ä�±�¬®° 2 � 6�W nPZ3 ��6 W Y Z3 � 6 W �2Z3 � dedcd ¦¨§�°���źÓËÈ$ź«1­�§�67´ � D�� �Í�y$�f���:tv�:yE� � DK� ��hºsf}fxph\o*ovh�o"t*dfq�t2}fxph\oph\���ºh���qK�foph\���ºhyK¡�qK������qKxp�.qK���:h\o+�OqE�H�?h%�:�`¡�h�xpxph\�7¬®°�¦OÓpÅO©jÅO°�­�±�²®² ³¡¯xpyEg qK�:xph\qE��u¶Á`��y�½����PqK�:rfh\oj�OqExpxp��h�� �$u¥}�xvh�ovh��EtH��qKxp�:qE����h�oHqE�f��optpqKtvh¹�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o�y�¡ tpd�h -X/�- �.��OyE�fop�.��h\x*q�tp��y$�»¾�Z h\�f�OhZ��y¸tvh\opt7¡�yEx¹}fxvh�ovh��f�ºh���qE�fovh��f�ºh£y$�-t*d�h¢h��E�`�.xvy$�fg�h\�$t8�.o¹��hOh���h\�»¾ cXd�h¡�yE���:y�½X�.���Ht*d�hOy$xvh�g zvrfoptv��Â�h\o�yErfxXqE}f}fxpyEqK�>d1Ã� � Õ`Ù � Õ � % Ï�§�°�«>¬¯ÆKÅOÓ�±�° -X/�- C �`DN6 %vGI%UJ L ´�@5ÄfÅO° �%¦*§�°�Æ�¬®­Ë¬¯§�°��{± ��¬®© ª?²�¬¯Åº«H¦¨§�°5Æ�¬®­�¬¯§�° �#��� +��± � C�¬.«�ź°5ÆK§�¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`«O´�%��� §�ÓHŨ±K¦¨Ä?^ ( . � ( � �Åj¦¨±�°¶ÓpŨ¦¨§�°�«¨­�Ó>Ç�¦O­­�ÄfÅj¦¨§�Ó>Ópź«Nª�§�°�Æ�¬®°`ȹ«>³�°�¦¨Ä`Óp§�°�§�Ç`«�Ó>Ç�°?^_Òº§�Ó C ��¬®°

±�Ç�°?¬0/ºÇ�Å �±�³�ÇPª¶­N§�«¨¬®²:ź°?­ÓpŨ±K¦O­�¬¯§�°f«O´4�� Ù�Ù�� � ½�h�}�xvy��EhHt*d�h8xph\o*r���t��$uZ�:�f��rf�ºtp��y$�»¾8w��.�>Á¢qA^ ( . � ( ¤"qK���¶qEopo*rfg�hj¡�yEx1t*d�h8g�yEg�h��Ett*dfq�tX½/h1½�h�xvh1qK�f��h tpyj�fh\�ºy$gj}�y$ovh1�:tX�$�.qj�ºy$�f�OqKtvh\��q�tv�:yE�7qKo3Ã

*<Q � *]T � dcded � * 7� ��� �7 O 4 . 4 0 4 #" $&%���� %/.10 � ���

� ^ (7 � D�� �

�.�$tvy¶q_Â?�f��tph :5ÛN��h��$tv�EdR�ºyE���Oq�tph\�fqKtv�:yE� yK¡ ��y$�`ÛNop�:��h��Et�xvh�qK�Otv�:yE�foP* o ¤2¡�yE���:y�½�h����$u tpd�h¹tpqK���%yK¡Wtpd�h�.�`Â?�f��tph£�Ex*qK}fd/^ ( ¤�½�df�:�>d¸½�h_�fh\��yEtvh£�$u ^ (7 ¤%qK���R½/h£qKo*oprfg�h[tpd�q�t�o*rf�>d¸q¥��h��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�¸�:or���� �`r�hE¾�cXd�h\�¹½/h �º�.q��.g tpdfqKt

� D�� ���.oXq��.opy���qK���.�8½X�:tpd6:¥opr��fovtp��t*r�tvh��[�Eu>: X Y ¾ � D G �

c"yH}�xvy��Eh/� D G �¨¤$½/h���yEtvh tpdfqKtO¤`½�d�h\� -X/�- C¸�Kh\tpo/qK�Otv�:�PqKtvh��»¤`tpd�h���½/h Á`��y�½µtpd�q�t/�PqExv�.qK�f��h�o�?hO�:yE�`Û�E�:�f�7tpyS6�W Y Z ½X�:�����?h�}fxph\oph\�$t �.�Ztpd�h��ºy$�fop�:��h�xvh��_xph\qK�Otv�:yE�»¾ U/u_qEopo*rfgj}�tp��y$�»¤�tpdfh\xphH�.o q7r���� �`r�h* �7 � Q W Y Z/dfqP�`�:���P6 W Y Z/qKo/��qKxp�:qE���:h\o\¾+cXd`rfo\¤�}fxvh�ovh��$t��Eh\xptv�.�ºh\o%qE�f�8�fx*qK���>d�h\o�y�¡+�Ex*qK}fdg* 7 � Q<W Y Z/qKxphÁ`��y�½���¤���t�xph\gjq��.�fo/tvy��fhOtvh�xpg��.��h1tpd�h ��qK�:r�h�oX�OqExpxp��h��7�$u8}�xvh�ovh��Et%��qKxp�.qK���:h\o\¾

.?yEx � . 6+Q�¤�½�h�ov�.gj}��:u[}f�:�>Á7tpd�h���q��.r�h��\qKx*xv�:h\�£�$u¹tpd�hjg��:���.gjq��+hO�:h\g�h\�$t y�¡�>dfqK�:�£�fqEg�h\� ��.� ^ 7( ¾���q��.r�h�o��OqExpxp��h��¢�$u¢�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�f�f�:���[optpq�tph���qKxp�:qE����h�o1qKxphjr�}?�fqKtvh��¶qE�O�OyEx*���:�f�K�:uK¾�cXd`rfo1½�hÁ`��y�½Àq��:��y�¡[* 7 � Q<W Y Z>¾� hºs�tX½�h�g�y��Eh y$�¹�OyE�foptpx*rf�Otv�.���0* 7 � Q W �2Z>¾ .�xvy$g * 7 � Q W Y Z/½�h Á`��y�½ * �7 � Q W �PZ>¾cXd`rfo%½/h�Á`��y�½

dfy�½¶tpy o*}��:��t[6 T �.�Etpy }fxph\oph\�$t3qE�f��qE�fovh��$t3��qKxp�:qE���:h\o5¡�y$x3t*d�h/�OyE�fop�.��h\xph\� xph\qE�ºtv�:yE��¾�w��.�>Á t*d�h%}fxvh�ovh��$ty$��h\o\¤fqK���7xph\}?h\qKt/t*d�h�o*qKg�h qKxp�Erfg�h\�$tXqKoX�?hº¡�y$xvh1tpy��EhOtQ* 7 � Q W �PZ>¾l�h�}�h�q�t�tpd��.o�qKxp�Erfg�h\�$t�r��Etp��� 6 W �$Z � 6Ê¡�y$x�opyEg�h�Â?�f��tph � ���$u¶h��f��y��>dfxpyE�$uZqEopo*rfgj}�tp��y$� �¨¾

cXdf�:oX}fxpy��Kh�o%�º�.q��.g � D G �¨¾I �:�Kh���tpdfh �.���:tv�.q��5�ºyE������tp��y$�j¡�yEx ^ ( ¤`½/hW�Kh\t¡¯xpyEg � D G �>¤$�$u��.�f�frf�Otv�:yE�»¤`t*d�h��fh\op�:xph\��}�xvy`y�¡�t*dfq�t

�{± � � �%� �K´ Y

cXd�h��fhºs�t�xvh�oprf��tXqK���fxvh�opoph\o/t*d�h��`r�h\optv�:yE�7y�¡+½�d�h\�[}fxpyE}?h\xpt�u �vi�� ��d�yE�:�fo%t*xprfhK¾

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 37: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�K� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� � Õ`Ù � Õ � � Ï�§�°�«>¬¯ÆKÅOÓ�­ �§ -X/�- C o �`DN6 oK%HG o %KJ o�Ll% k � YR% ��´/ÎHÅO°�§�­NÅ �º³�6 � 6 Q 6 T ­®Ä�Å «OÅO­/§vÒ­�ÄfÅO¬®Ó�¦¨§�©H©�§�° �P±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�ź« �W±�°�Æ4�º³:C �EC Q q C T ­®Ä�ź¬®Ó�«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`«H¦¨§�© ªf§P«>¬®­Ë¬¯§�°�´¹Ï�§�°�«>¬¯ÆKÅOÓH­�ÄfÅÒº§�²®²�§��2¬®°`È£¦¨§�°�Æ�¬®­Ë¬¯§�°f«1++v� Q�2 C Q � C T ��±�°5ÆIC¿±�Ó*ÅHÅO°�ÆE§\¦¨Ä`Óp§�°�§�Ç`«º´+v� T 2 ÎHÅO°�§�­NÅ �º³�C �o

� �±�°5Æ�C � � ­�ÄfÅ1Ópź«>­ËÓ>¬¯¦O­�¬¯§�°Z§vÒ�C �o ±�°�ÆIC � ­N§�6 �2Ópź«�ªfŨ¦º­�¬ ��ź²�³K´:@5ÄfÅO°�C � Q

� ��

C �T� ��ZC � � Äf§�²:ÆP«O´

Ï�§�°�Æ�¬®­�¬¯§�° +p��T*2 Å )ºª�Ópź«*«Oź«�­®Ä�±�­+°�§�¦º²:§\¦ j¦¨§�°f«>­�Óp±�¬®°?­"Ó*Å>«>Ç�²�­Ë«5Ò¨Ó*§�©�¦¨§�© ª�§�«¨¬®°`È�­®Ä�Å ­#�§�¦¨§�°f«>¬¯ÆEźÓpŨÆ-0/�- ��¬¯´®Å�´ ��­�ÄfÅO¬®Ó�¦¨§�© ª�§�«>¬®­Ë¬¯§�°¥§�°�²�³�Ópź«>Ç�²�­Ë«�¬®°¥¦*§�°f«>­�Óp±�¬®°?­¯«1¬®°���§�² ��¬®°$È�}fxph\oph\�$t%��q��.r�h\o�§{Ò���±�Ó>¬¯±&�º²:Å>«O´�¯Ò�¦*§�°�Æ�¬®­Ë¬¯§�°f« +v� Q�2 ±�°�Æ +v� T*2 ±�ÓpÅ�«O±�­�¬.«®É/ŨÆ��­�ÄfÅO°�ª?Ó*§¨ªfźÓ>­�³�� $�� ��Ä�§�²�Æ�«�­ËÓ>Ç�Å�´

� � ! 9 /�- � @Zh£q��.xph\qK�fu¥�f�:o*�Orfo*oph\��t*d�h[�:gj}?yExptpqE�f�ºh¹y�¡��ErfqExpqE�EtphO�.���¢}fxpyE}?h\xpt�u �vi�� �>¾��Wy�½ ¤½�d$u¹�:oWtpd��.o�t*d�hOy$xvh�g �.�$tvh�xvh�ovtp�:��� B � q��.���:u7�?h\�OqErfoph���t�xvh�}��.qK�ºh�o��ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� �vi�� �>¤?½�d��.�>d[�.�E�EyK�:�Kh�o�.�`Â?�f��tph[x*rf�fo\¤�$u��ºy$�f���:tv�:yE�fo +v� Q�2 qK��� +v� T 2 ¤½�d��.�>d�y$���:u �:�$�KyE���Eh8q¶ov�.���K�:h[xvh�qK�ºtp��y$�»¾ @-d��:��h�OyE�f�f��tp��y$�fo +v� Q�2 qE�f� +v��T 2 qKxph%�Kh\�fh\x*q��:��u�r��f��h\�O�:��qK���:hK¤$ovy$gHhX��h��º�.�fqK�f��h�qE}f}fxpyPs`�.gjq�tp��y$��y�¡�tpd�h�g���$u�qK�foptpx*qK�Otv�.���1��yE�`�?y$yE��h�qK�H��yEgjq��.�fo�3�:o2qE�ºtpr�q��:��u��>d�h��>Á�h����.�Ht*d�h�36587�9;:$<1�ºy$gj}����:h\x\¤KophOh%ovh��ºtp��y$�U1¾ �f¾

4�� Ù�Ù�� � @Zh�}�xvy��ºh\h\�7�:�$tpyjophO�Eh\x*q��»optvh\}�oO¾iK¾ M h���yKtph��$u�C ( t*d�h���h�ovu��f�>dfxpyE�f�:o*q�tp��y$��y�¡+C ¤f��hºÂ���h\�[�$u �vi*H �>¤fqK�f�[��h���yKtph1�$ug^ ( qjx*rf�8yK¡C ( ¾/.�y$x�h\qK�>dB^ ( . � ( ¤»tpd�h�xvh��:o1qKt �:h\qEovt�yE��hj�ºy$xpxph\o*}?yE�f���.���8opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfoWx*rf�!^ ¡�yEx C ¾~W�$u[oprf�>dS^Z�:o �º�:h\qExv�:u�tpdfh�ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfoX�OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�7y�¡2t�½/y��ºyEgj}fqKtv�.���:h�xprf��o ^ Q qE�f�S^ T¡�yEx�C Q�qE�f�!C TE¤»xvh�op}?h\�Otv�:�KhO�:uK¾ ZWh��f�ºhjqKo*opy`�O�:qKtvh��£qKopu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o�xpr��foV^ (Q qK�f�$^ (T qKxph�q��.opy�ºy$g�}�q�tv�.���:hK¤�qE�f�¥tpd�h\�:x�qKopu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo �ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE� ^ (Q Y ( ^ (T �?hO�:yE���$o�tvy � ( Q Y ( � (T ¾cXd`rfoX½/h1d�qP�Kh�tpd�h �.�f�º�.rfop��y$�

C%( Q (h C%(T � �xC Q h C T � ( % � D H �

½�d��.�>d_}fxpy��Kh\o�tpd�h�Â?xpopt }�qKxpt�y�¡'�pi\� �>¾ E$y�¡¯qKx ½�h�d�qP�Kh�y$����u[rfoph\�£t*d�hH�fhºÂ?���:tv�:yE�¢y�¡��h�ovu��`Û�>dfxpyE���.opqKtv�:yE�¶qK�f�¥qEovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo��ºy$g�}?yEop�:tv�:yE�»¤+��yE��h�yK¡/t*d�h8�OyE�f���:tv�:yE��o +v� Q 2 ¤ +v� T 2 ½%qKoxvh �`r�h\optvh��»¾

D�¾Xc3y7}fxvy��Eh1tpd�h�y$}f}?yEop��tph��:���º�.rfov�:yE��¤f½�hH��hOh��[tvy8}fxpy��Kh1t*dfq�t\¤�½�d�h��£gHy��`�.���j¡¯xpyEg qEovu��f�>d�xvyKÛ��yEr�oW�ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�¹tvy7ovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo%y$��hK¤?tpd�h�qE�f���:tv�:yE�fqK�3��h\h\�¹¡�yEx q�xvh�qK�Otv�:yE�`Û�}�h�x{Û�xph\qK�Otv�:yE�gjq�tp�>df�:���[yK¡/�ºy$gj}fq�tp�:���:hjxprf��o1½X���:����yKt xph\o*r��:t��.�¶xvhvz{h\�ºtp�:�f�¹}fqK�:x*o�y�¡%xprf��o1tpdfqKt�yEtpd�h�xv½X�.oph½�y$r��.�7�?h �ºyEgj}fqKtv�.���:h��.�7tpd�h�qEovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo�ovh��fovhE¾2cXd��:o%�.o%½�d�h�xvh �ºy$�f���:tv�:yE�fo +p� Q 2 ¤ +v� T 2h\�$tvh�x%tpd�h �$qKg�hK¾� h\tB6 Q W �$Zº¤�6 T W �1Z>¤�qK��� 6�W �$Zº¤���h\��yEtvh t*d�h��>dfq��.�fo � D(D&�¹qEopopy��º�.q�tph\�-½X�:tpd C Q ¤IC T ¤�qK���C Q q C T ��C xph\o*}�h��ºtv�:�Kh\��uE¾ÑÍ�yE�fop�:�fh\x�t*d�hZophOt?6�W Y Z�y�¡ ��qKxp�.qK���:h\o�t*dfq�t¹qKxph_}fxph\oph\�$t8qKoovy`y$� qKoICÑ�Kh\tpoHqK�ºtp����qKtvh\��¾ M1r�h7tvy¢�OyE�f���:tv�:yE� +p��T 2 ¤'½�h7Á$�fy�½ t*dfq�t�h\qK�>d¥o*rf�>d¥��qKxp�:qE���:h

JF ��$J?;

Page 38: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« � G

g�rfopt1��h\��y$���8tpy¹qKtW�:h\qKoptWy$��h�yK¡tpdfh�ophOt*o 6 o W Y Z�¡�yExVk � YR% ��¾ ZWh\���ºh�y$��h�y�¡�tpdfh�¡�yE���:y�½X�:�f��OqEovh�oXg�rfopt%y`�\�Orfx3Ã

�\qKoph�i _ 6 W Y Z?� 6 Q W Y Z�\qKoph D _ 6 W Y Z?� 6 T W Y Z�\qKoph1� _ 6 W Y Z?� 6+Q4W Y Z r 6(TPW Y Z

Í���h�qKxp��uE¤K�OqEovh�o%i�qK�f� D1qExvh%h�`r��:��q��:h\�$t2rf}jtvy hOsf�>dfqK���E�:�f� t*d�hW�fqEgHh�o'y�¡5tpd�hWt�½�y �ºy$�fop�:��h�xvh��-X/�- ¾�cXd`rfoX½/h1qEopo*rfg�h1hO�:tpd�h�xX�OqEovhji1yExX�\qKoph���¾Í/qKoph¶�¸�.o7t*d�h¥h\qEov�:h\opt7y$��hK¾�[{�-tpdf�:o£�\qKophK¤ qK�EqK�:�-r�ov�.���µ�ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� +p� T 2 ¤�½�h¶�Kh\t¹t*dfq�t6 W �$Z���6+Q2W �$Z r 61TNW �$Z�d�yE�:��oO¾RcXd`rfo�¡�y��\rfo�yE���OqKoph¢iE¤�qE�f�R�OyE�fop�:�fh\xj��hºs�t06 W �2Zº¾¸c%½/yopr��?�\qKoph\o y`�\�Orfx3à i��g6 W �PZW�OyE�$tpqK�:��o�tpdfh�qE�ºtv�:��q�tp��y$�_�º�:y��>Á7yK¡|C T ¤�qE�f�£t*d�h\� 6 W �PZ � 6 T W Y ZqK�f� 6 W �1Z � 6 Q W �$Z r 6 T W � 2 Y Z%¡�yE���:y�½�o�Ì5y$xWq��:tvh�xp��q�tv�:�Kh\��u D&�g6 W �2Z��fy$h�o �fyKt1�ºyE�$t*q��.�£tpd�hqK�Otv�:�PqKtv�:yE�¹�º�:y��>Á�y�¡�C T ¤�qE�f�8t*d�h\�¹½/h �ºyE�$tp�:�`r�h�yErfxXqExv�$rfg�h\�$tO¾2~ xv�$r��:�f�H�.�¹tpd�h o*qKg�h1½/qPu¡�yEx 6�W��PZº¤fhOt*��¤f½/h1�Kh\t/t*dfq�t � Q � n�opr��>d8t*dfq�t�Ã

¡�yEx�n = � = � Q _ 6 Q W �$Z �Z6�W �$Z 6 QI%½�d�h\xph\qEo¡�y$x �?m � Q _ 6 W �$Z?�Z6 Q W �$Z r 6 T W � 2 � Q Z d � DE� �

[{�[}fqKxptv�.�Or��.qKx\¤`tpd�h�qE�ºtp����q�tp��y$�8yK¡�C T �.oX��h\tvh\x*g��:�fh\�[�$u�C Q ¾ZWh��f�ºhE¤$}��.�>Á�q }fq��.x W ^ (Q % ^ (T Z�o*rf�>d�tpd�q�t+^ (Q ��� ( ^ (T ���>¡{¾-�vi*J � ��Ã"t*d�hOuj�OqE�j��hW�OyEgH���:�fh\�j½�d��:��h}�h�x{¡�y$xpg��.����tpd�h�qEovu��f�>dfxpyE�fyErfo��ºyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$��C ( Q q ( C (T tvy�¡�yEx*g�opyEg�h ^ ( �Ë�º¡{¾'�vi�� � �¨¤�tpdf�:o�:oW��h\��yEtvh��7�$u?^ (Q Y ( ^ (T ��^ ( ¾�cXdfh\�1Ã�Ëq �8~ }f}��:u£op�>d�h�g�h��%� �1y�¡cXd�h\yExph\g ��tvy�^ (Q ¤?t*d��:o u`��h\�:��oWq�rf�f� �`r�h���h\�OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�[yK¡�^ (Q

�.�$tvy�qjovh �`r�h\�f�Oh1y�¡2xvh�qK�ºtp��y$�fo^)(Q �Z* Q

�Q � * Q

�T � deded � * Q

�7 � dcded

�Ë�6�@+�ov�.���/� DE�&�¨¤P½�h�Á$�fy�½Zt*d�h�o*rf�foph�`r�h��f�ºh : � yK¡fxvh�qK�ºtp��y$�fo»yK¡4C Q�q�t�½�df�:�>d�^+Q�7 � qK�ºtp����qKtvh\oC TK¾

�Ë���8~ }f}��:u£op�>d�h�g�h��%� �1y�¡cXd�h\yExph\g ��tvy�^ (T ¤?t*d��:o u`��h\�:��oWq�rf�f� �`r�h���h\�OyEgj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�[yK¡�^ (T�.�$tvy�qjovh �`r�h\�f�Oh1y�¡2xvh�qK�ºtp��y$�fo

^)(T � *]T�Q � *]T

�T � dedcd � *]T

�� � dedcd � D J �

�Ë�6��lWhO�.qK�?hO�'ovh �$rfh\�f�Oh YR% � %cdededH% � %edcded �:� � D J �XqEo$: Qx% : T]%cdedcd�% : � %cdedcd ����hºÂ?�fh\�¢qKt optvh�} D�� �qE�f�HÂ��:��tpdfh�d�yK�:h\o2�.�jovy�xphO�.qK�?hO�:�:h\�j��h\�OyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$��� D J �"½X�:tpd�op�:��h��Et�xph\qE�ºtp��y$�fo���¡�y$x\C T ¤�fh\��yEtvh\�[�$u 2 T ¤�½/h��EhOt�qE��yKt*d�h\x%��h��ºyEgj}?yEop��tp��y$�8yK¡;^ (T Ã

^)(T � 2 T � dedcd � 2 T � * T�7 � � 2 T � dedcd � 2 T � * T � 7 2 � dedcddcded � * T

�7 � � dcded

� � % � *]T�Q � *]T

�T � dedcd � *]T

�7 � deded

� ��ö��ö:õ>ï¯ø/üP÷�í>=FH�C�í¨ðPó ðPî{éëþ>è<��õ>üPï¯éëðPþXî�ñ�ì�÷�í¨ð�í*ò�éëõ>ð�ê"ö�õ>ï�òËèPî�óPî���ðPé òËéëõ>ð�õ¨ö�í�ê�éë÷ëî{ðOò3ï¯îví¨û{òËéëõ>ð[�

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 39: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�>H ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

�¯h��@+�ov�.���jq��$q��.���ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� +v��T 2 ¤�½/h��\qK�7qKo*ovh�xvt�tpdfqKtO¤�¡�y$xh�qK�>d-:2¤4* Q�7 ��� * T

�7 ¤�½�d�h�xvh ���

�fh\��yEtvh\o+�ºy$gj}fq�tp�:���:�:��t�u1y�¡��ºyE��ov�.��h\xph\� optpqKtvh�o"qEo"��h\h\��h��1¡�yEx+opu`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o3�ºy$gj}�y$ov�:tv�:yE�»¾.'�.�fq��:�:uK¤f½/h1�KhOt

^)(Q Y ( ^)(T � WN* Q�Q � * Q

�T � dedcd Z ( Y ( WN* T

�Q � * T

�T � dedcd Z (

� WN* Q � * T � deded Z (� ^)(

¡�y$x ovy$g�h�x*rf� ^RyK¡ -0/1- C ¤"½�d�h\xph:* 7 �.o1tpd�h�optpq�tphjyE��t*q��.��h\�¶�$u¢�ºy$g�}?yEop�.���7t*d�h�t�½/y�OyEgj}fqKtv�.����h1optpq�tph\o|*<Q

�7 qK�f��*bT

�7 ¾�cXd��.o/}�xvy��Eh\o�t*d�h1�:���º�.rfov�:yE�7ovu�gjg�hOt*xv�.��tpy � D H �qK���

t*d`rfo�}fxpy��Kh�o �pi\� �>¾cXdf�:o/Â?�f�:o*d�h\o�tpd�h�}fxpy`y�¡+y�¡"t*d�h tpdfhOyExph\g¹¾ Y

� � � � � ����1 # ��� )� � .�� ��,/.��� # � *-,/� � !/# � )@-df���:h£½�h_d�qP�Kh[�K�:�Kh���qZÂ?�f��t*qKxpu¸�Oxp�:tvh\xp�:yE�R¡�yEx�h��f��y��>dfxpyE�$uK¤�½�h_���.�·��yKt�}�xvy$}�y$ovh£q }fx*qK�Otv�.�Oq��qK���EyExp��t*dfg¿¡�y$xW�>d�h��>ÁE�.���jtpdf�:o �Oxp��tph\xp��y$�»¾ @¶h���y�t*d��.oW��y�½ ¾ [{�[tpd��.oWo*rf�foph\�Otv�:yE�»¤?½�hHopdfqK���3�:�f�f�:�\q�tvhi��_dfy�½ q �¯tp���$dEt��opr ���O��h��$tj�OyE�f�f��tp��y$�R¡�y$x�h\�f��y��>dfxpyE�$u��\qK����h_qE�ºtpr�q��:��u�tph\optvh��»¤/qE�f�CD&�Zd�y�½gjqEÁE�.����qE� -0/�- h��f��y��>dfxpyE��y$rfoX�OqE�£��h�}?h\xv¡�yEx*g�h\�»¾%~Wo ��yEtpd[t*d�h ��� � ¡�y$xpgjqKtWqK�f�¹t*d�h 36587�9;:$<�.qK�f�ErfqK�Kh��OqE� ��h[�ºy$�fop�:��h�xvh�� qKoH�ºyE���OxphOtvh8�:�foptpqE�f�ºh�o�yK¡�yErfx -X/�- gHy���h\�ˤ2½/h7o*dfqK���/xvh\��uZ¡�yExHyErfxhOsf}��:qE�fq�tp��y$��y$�7tpy`yK�.oXqK�f�¹q��:�Ky$xv�:tpdfgjo%q��.xph\qK�fu���hO�EhO�:yE}?h\�7�:�¹tpdfh\oph h\�$�`�:xpyE�fg�h��Et*oO¾

O � % � � < � Õ ����� � " Õ�� Ú Ù � � � Ù��5Ö~ o�yE��h�y�¡t*d�h�g�y`��r���h�o�y�¡t*d�hjhºs��:optv�.��� ��� �-yEx 36587$9 :$<¹�ºyEgj}��:�:h\x\¤»tpd�hH¡�yK�:��y�½X�.���¹ovt*xprf�Otprfxph��:o�OyEgj}fr�tph\�»¤f¡�yExXq��K�:�Kh��8}fxpyK�$xpqEg �¸Ã

JF ��$J?;

Page 40: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �`�

...

...

...

[c2]

c2

[c1]

c1

k0h0

b2

[b2]

...

...

...

b1

[b1]

[{��t*d��:o8}��:�OtprfxphK¤ & % � �fh\��yEtvh_�?y$yE��h�qK����qKxp�:qE���:h\o\¤V1 & 3 % 1 �H3 ��h\�fyKtvh_�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�����:�f�¶�O��y��>Á`o��ºy$g�}?y�Ûoph\�Zy�¡/tpd�h��.�foptpqE�Et*o q�t1½�d��.�>d & % � � / d�yK�.�fo\¤"xph\o*}�h��ºtp���EhO�:uK¾(.+�.�fqK���:uK¤�� % �ZqKxph�q��.ovy[�º�:y��>Á`o �Ë�˾ hK¾:¤��qExv�.qK���:h\o�y�¡Wt�u�}?h .PO$.23/5 �>¾¶cXdfh¹��y�½���ÛNqExpxpy�½�o �4b�� & QP¤Q1 & Q 3 � & T�¤Q1 & T 3 � & ��¤�h\tp��¤�:�f�f�:�\q�tvht*dfq�t ��y`yK�:h\qE�¹�PqExv�.qK�f��h & Q dfqKo�q��O��y��>Á8h�`rfq��3tvy �4b�qK���[yE���:u7��h\h\�foW��qKxp�:qE����h�o%½X��t*d£�º�:y��>Á6�4b1¡�yEx�:tpo�hO��q��.rfqKtv�:yE�»¤'qK�f� opy£yE��¾ [{� �fyK�.���_ovy?¤+q_tpxphOh��.o��frf���:t�rf�f�fh\x�h�qK�>d¶y�¡Xt*d�h7�O��y��>Á`o �4b % �Rb %cdedcd ¤t*d��.o1u$�:hO�.�fo t*d�h�ovyKÛN�\q��:��h��¸¦O²�§�¦�¹Ä`¬¯ÅOÓp±�Ó*¦*Ä�³��:�Ztpd�hj¡�y$xpg y�¡/q {¡�yExph\opt#">¤���¾ hE¾�¤3q[�OyK�:��h��ºtv�:yE�Zy�¡/tpxphOh�oO¾lWy$yEtpo y�¡t*d�h�tpxphOh\o�qKxph�xphO�.q�tph\�_�$u_opyEg�hH�O��y��>Á7h�`rfq�tp��y$�»¤5tpd��.o��:o1��h�}��.�ºtvh��¢qEoWt*d�h��f�:���.xph\�ºtp��y$�fq��qExpxpy�½RxphO�.q�tp�:��� � bR% � b2%edcded ¾2cXd��.o�optpx*rf�ºt*rfxphX�:o��fhOtpqK���:h\���.� � ~ U%� I��K����� ~ U%� I�� G �N¤K½�d�h�xvhX�:t��.o�o*d�y�½��tpy7�?h�q7�OqE��yE���.�OqK��¡�y$xpg ¡�yEx�xph\}fxph\oph\�$tv�.����t*d�hj�ºyEgH���.�fq�tp��y$�£y�¡�O��y��>Á¹h�`rfqKtv�:yE�fo qK�f�Zop�>d�h��fr��:�:�f�o*}?h\�º��Â?�\q�tv�:yE��o�yK¡ qZ}�xvyE�Ex*qKg¹¾Z� y�½ ¤�ºy$�fop�:��h�xv�.���Ztpd��.oj�º�:y`�>Á¥d��:h\x*qKx*�>d$uK¤2y$��h8h�qKop���:u }fxvy��Eh\oHtpd�h¡�yE���:y�½X�.����Ã� � Õ`Ù � Õ � $ �¯Ò/ª?Óp§*È�Ó*±�© � Äf±P«�±7¦º²�§�¦ HÄ�¬¯ÅºÓp±�Óp¦¨Ä`³¹¦¨§�°f«>¬.«>­Ë¬®°`È7§vÒ�±j«>¬®°$ÈK²�Å�­ËÓpŨÅ���­®Ä�ź°¢¬®­�¬.«�ź°5ÆK§=�¦¨Ä`Ó*§�°�§�Ç`«O´ W¦O­�Ç�±�²®²�³��»­�ÄfÅX¦¨Äf±�¬®° 2 �Z6 W nNZ3 � 6 W Y Z3 � 6�W �2Z3 � dcded ¦¨§�°�«>¬.«¨­Ë«�§{Ò�­�ÄfÅ«>Ç�¦*¦¨Åº«¨«¨¬ ��Å�«Oź­Ë«§vÒ �P±�Ó>¬¯± �O²�ź«�­®Ä�±�­2Äf±���Åj±P« ­�ÄfÅO¬®Ó�¦º²�§�¦ �­�ÄfÅ «>Ç��>«OÅO­¯«�§{Ò�¦O²�§�¦��«�É"ÈKÇ�Ó>¬®°$È7±�­/²�Å���ÅO²ë« = n %�=ZYa%�= � %edcded �Ó*Å>«NªfÅ*¦O­�¬ �PÅO²�³K´cXdfhOyExph\g G �.o�qE���.g�g�h����:qKtvh��ºyExpyK�:�.qKxpu�y�¡3cXdfhOyExph\g � yK¡3~W}f}?h\�f�f� s U1¾ [�t���y`h�o���yEt�optpqKtvhWt*dfq�t ��.o+h\�f�fy`�>d�xvy$��yErfo3� ¡5qK�f��yE���:u ��¡?�:tpo2�º�:y��>Á1d���h�xpqExp�>d$u��:o2q tpxphOhE¤��fr�t2��h�qKxp��u opy�¾ [{��¡¯qK�OtO¤�o*rf�>d�q�xph\o*r���t½/yErf�:�_�?h�tpx*r�h�¡�y$x -0/�- xph\optpxp�.�ºtvh��£tvy7t�u�}�h�o�� .PO$.23:5��������:9N.:=23 ¾ .�y$xW�Eh\��h�xpqK� -0/1- ¤�qK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE��o}?h\xv¡�yEx*g�h\�R½�d����:h£�ºy$g�}�r�tv�.���¥tpd�h£�O��y��>Á d��:h\x*qKx*�>d$u¥}�xvh\�Kh\�$t*o�¡¯xpyEg y$��tpqK�:�f�:���¥q¶��h\�Oh\o*opqExvu qK���o*r ���º�:h\�$t3�OyE�f�f��tp��y$��¡�yEx�h��f��y��>dfxpyE�$uXk qK�OtprfqK���:uK¤�}fxpyE}?h\xpt�u � D�� �5y�¡f��hºÂ�����tp��y$��i��.o3rf����h\�O�:�fqE���:h2¡�yEx�Eh\��h�xpqK�»}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjo\¾"cXd�h qK��ovt*xpqE�ºtv�:yE��o/}?h\xv¡�yEx*g�h\�7qKxph t�½/y�¡�yE�:�1Ã%i����.�`¡�h\x*xp�:���j��h�}�h��f��h\���º�:h\o/¡¯xpyEg�\qKrfo*q��:�:t�ujqE�fq��:u�ov�.o\¤`qE�f� D&��qK�foptpx*qK�Otv�.���H�?y`yK�:h\qK�7��qKxp�:qE���:h\o�½�d��:�>d¹xph\o*r���t/¡¯xpyEg¿t*d�h hO��q��.rfqKtv�:yE��yK¡qj}fxph\�f�:�\q�tvh1�.�$�KyK�:�`�:�f��qj��y$�`ÛN�?y`yK�:h\qE��hºsf}fxph\o*op��y$�»¾

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 41: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�>J ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

� hO�Kh�xvt*d�hO�:h\o*o\¤»�:�¶}fx*qK�ºtp�:�OhK¤»½/h�o*dfqK���2rfophHt*d�h��º�:y��>Á£d���h�xpqExp�>d$u£qKo�t*d�h�}fxpqE�ºtp�:�\q��'�Oxp��tph\xp��y$�[¡�yEx�>dfh\�>Á$�:�f�Hh��f��y��>dfxpyE�$uK¾

O � % � � % ���NÙ ���>� � " Õ�� Ú Ù � � � Ù��5Ö~ opo*rfg�h�½/h�dfqP�Eh�qK� -0/�- � ½�d��.�>d£�.oW��yEtWh\����y��>dfxvy$��yEr�oO¤�qE�f�[½/h,�±�°?­3�:tWtpy8��h�ovy?¾ @-dfqKtW�OqE�½/h���y B¢~Wo xvh\�Kh�q��:h\�¹�Eu7�:��op}?h\�Otv�.����tpdfh�}fxphO�`��y$rfoX}��.�ºt*rfxvhE¤���¡2½�h��\qK�£gjqKÁKh�t*d�h�xpy`yKtpo � b % �Rb %edcdedyK¡»tpd�hW�O��y��>Á�d��:h\x*qKx*�>dEuH��h\��y$���K�.��� tvyHovy$gHh�op�.���K�:hW�º�:y��>Á�t*xvh\hK¤$tpd�h��j½�hWqExvh��fyE��hE¾ [{�jyEtpd�h�x2½/yEx*�foO¤½/h��\qK�[�ºy$�f�ºh��Et*xpqKtvh y$�[tpd�h�xvy`yKt*oXy�¡2t*d�hH�O��y��>Á8df��h�xpqExp�>d$uK¾%cXd`rfo�t*d�h�op��t*rfq�tp��y$�¹¡�yEx ovt*rf��u¹�:o tpd�h¡�yE���:y�½X�.����¾@¶hHqExvh �E���Eh\�£q�ophOt � Q�%cdedcde% � � y�¡��O��y��>Á`oO¤?½�d��.�>d£qKxph�xvh\�:qKtvh\�£�$u[q�ophOt�yK¡2�O��y��>Á7h�`rfqKtv�:yE�foXyK¡

t*d�h1¡�yEx*gÀÃ� Q W"� Q�%cdedcde% � � Z �� '

dcded � D�� ����4W"� Q�%cdedcde% � � Z �� '

cXdf�:o2�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE�f��o3tpy1d�qP�$�.��� q1�ºyE���:h\�Otv�:yE� � Q�%cdededc% ����yK¡5}fxph\�f�:�\q�tvh�o+yE���º�:y`�>Á`o\¤�½�d��.�>d�qExvh%�?y$yE��h�qK�`Û��qK�:r�h��jhºsf}fxph\o*ov�:yE��o'tpdfqKtqKxphXhO�:tpd�h�x2tpx*r�h�y$x�qK��ovh��Et\¾"� yKtph�tpdfqKt�?hO�.����q��:½%qPu`o't*xprfh��:o�tpd�h��OqKoph/¡�yEx}�xvh����:�\q�tph\o��.���O�:qEopop�:�\q�����y`yK�:h\qE���:yK�K�.��¤E½�d��:��h��:��yErfx/�OqEovhE¤E�fr�h�tvyHtpd�h�xvh �`r��:xph\g�h��Et�¡�yEx/ovt*r�tvtph\xp�:���xpyE��rfovt*��h\o*o\¤f½�hHg�rfopt qE�O�ºh�}�t�t*d�h�}?yEo*ov�.���:���:t�u8¡�y$xWq p�º�:y��>Á8}fxph\�f�:�\q�tvh�"1tpy7�?h�qK��ovh��Et\¾ E$u�ovtph\gjo�yK¡h �`rfq�tp��y$�foyK¡3tpdfhW¡�y$xpg � DK� ��OqE����h1opyK�:�Kh\��¡�yEx/tpd�h\�:x���qKxp�:qE���:h\o �&Q %ededcde% � � ¤�g�h\qE���:�f�Ht*dfq�t/½�h��OqE�Â��f�[q�ophOt$� 4 Q %cdedcd�% � 4� y�¡'�º�:y`�>Á`o\¤fqK�f�¹qjovh\t � 4 Q %ededcd�% � 4� y�¡+�O��y��>Á�hOsf}fxvh�opop�:yE�fo\¤�oprf�>d7tpd�q�t

� Q � �4 Q W"� 4 Q %cdedcd�% � 4� Zdedcd ���K� �

� � � �4� W"� 4 Q %edcdedc% � 4� Z

d�qKojtpdfh¢opqEg�h[ophOt�yK¡1opyK�.r�tp��y$�fo�¡�yEx>� Q�%cdedcd�% � � qKojtpdfh_yExp���E�:��q��Xovu�optvh�g � DK� �>¤/qE�f�·��hO½Ê�º�:y��>Á$o� 4 Q %cdedcd�% � 4� qKxph/¡¯xvh\hK¤���¾ hE¾�¤$rf�f�OyE�foptpx*q��.��h\�H�$u�tpdfh�ovu�optvh\g�y�¡5h�`rfq�tp��y$�fo-�Ë�E� �>¾$.'�:��q��:��uE¤K½/h/�.�$tpxpy��frf�ºh�?y`yK�:h\qE�8��qKxp�.qK���:h\o & 4 Q %ededcd�% & 4� ¤�qE�f�7q� pgjqKoptvh\xX�O��y��>Á "4� 4 ¤fo*rf�>d¹tpdfqKt

� 4 Q �`1 & 4 Q 3 %edcdedc% � 4� �`1 & 4� 3� ��� � � dcded � � ���� � � ���fi��

cXdfh1�?yKtptvy$g��:�:��h �.o�ÃiK¾ E$u�ovtph\g yK¡"�º�:y��>Ájh�`rfqKtv�:yE�fo�� DK� ���:o/h �$rf����q��:h\�$t/tvy4�Ë�E�f¤ �fi��2q�¡�tph\x%d��.���.����qEr`s����:�.qKxpu���qExv�.qK���:h\o� % & 4 Q %cdedcde% & 4� ¾

D�¾ E$u�ovtph\g �Ë�K��¤ ��i����:o�h\�f��y��>dfxpyE�fyErfo\¾�f¾-.?rfxptpdfh\x��OyEg��f�:���.��� ���K�f¤ �fi��½X��t*d£qK��yEtpd�h�x -X/�- }�xvy��ºh�opoph\�7�.�7t*d�h�o*qKg�h ½%qPuK¤�½X�:���+xvh�opr��:tX�.�tpd�h�o*q�tp�:ov¡¯qK�Otv�:yE�7y�¡'qK�f���:tv�:yE��q����ºy$�f���:tv�:yE� ��T yK¡"t*d�hOy$xvh�g ��¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 42: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Ï�§�©Wªf§P«>¬®­�¬¯§�°�±�²�¬®­�³8¬®°¶ÆE±�­�±��X§��-«¨³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`« ²�±�°$ÈKÇ�±OÈ$Å>« �E�

� �¯����+����� Ù�� � UXqEov�.�OqK���:uK¤W��r����.���.��� �Ë�fiE¤ �E� �j¡¯xvy$g � D�� ���.�$tpr��:tv�:�Kh\��u-�OyEx*xvh�op}?yE���fo�tpy¸h �$rf�:}f}f�:���t*d�h�yExp�:�K�.�fq��R� }fxvyE�Ex*qKgʽX�:tpd¥q[oprf��t*qK���:h¢¦¨§�©�©HÇ�°?¬¯¦*±�­Ë¬¯§�°_ª�Óp§�­�§\¦¨§�²����.�¥oprf�>d¥q¹½%qPu_tpdfqKt tpd�h�OyEgj}?yErf�f�7}fxpyK�Ex*qKg � q �Ñ��h��ºy$gHh�o/h\�f��y��>dfxpyE�fyErfo\¾"cXd��.o%�.o/�fyKt%qHo*rfx*}fxv�.ophK¤E¡�yEx/��t%�.o%Á$�fy�½����.�t*d�h�qKxph\q�yK¡'���.optpxp�:�frftvh\�£opu�ovtph\gjo%tpd�q�tW�OyEgj}�y$��h\�$t*o%�:�£qj���.ovt*xv�.�fr�tph\�£opu�ovtph\g gHrfopt���h h �$rf�:}f}?h\�½X�:tpd[o*r��:tpqK�f��h }fxpyKtpy`�OyK�.o�¡�yEx%tpdfhO�.x��ºy$g�gHrf���.�OqKtv�:yE�fo\¾~W�:opy�¤Ptpdfh½%qPu ½/hg�y��Kh���¡¯xvy$g � D�� �5tvy ���K� �5xvh\�Kh�q��.o»yE��h�rf�f}��:h\qEopqE�Et�¡�h\q�t*rfxph�y�¡ft*d��:o"tvh��>df�����`r�hK¤

��qKg�hO�:u ÃWtpd��.o }fqKxpt�y�¡t*d�h�}�xvy��ºh�opo �.o��fyKt rf�����`r�hK¤�qE�f�_t*d$r�o t*d�h\xphjqKxphHqK�OtprfqK���:u_gjqK�$u£}�y$opop�.����h�f� �5h\xph\�$t"}�xvyEtvy��ºyE�:o»t*dfq�t"½�y$r��.� ½�y$xpÁ�¾ .?yEx"ov�.gj}���h/�OqEovh�o �¯hE¾ �?¾�¤�xpy`yKt3�O��y��>Á`o��+Q %cdededc% � � qKxphqE�ºtpr�q��:��ut*d�h\gjophO�:�Kh�o�¡¯xphOh��¨¤ opyEg�hZyE�$�`��y$rfo7�>dfyK�.�ºhZ}�xvh\�PqK���.o\¤WqK�f�À�ºy$xpxph\o*}�y$�f���.����opyK�.r�tv�:yE�fo[qExvh¢r�ovh��-tvy�Eh\��h�xpqKtvh �¯h��f��y��>dfxpyE��y$rfo�/�ºy���h��$u7t*d�h �����·�ºyEgj}��:�:h\x\¾1.?yExX�Eh\��h�xpqK���OqKoph\o\¤�t*d�h\xph �.oW��y�y$�E�`�:yErfo�>dfyK�.�ºh1qK�f�¹�:tX�:o%hOs�}?h\�Otvh��7t*dfq�tXyEtpd�h�x%�ºyE��ov�.��h\x*q�tp��y$�fo/½�y$r��.�8h��Etph\x%t*d�h �EqEgHh R�� ¤ftpd`rfo��fyj�Oy���h1�:o�\rfx*xvh��Etp��u��Eh\��h�xpqKtvh���¡�y$xX�ºyEx*xph\o*}�y$�f���.���H�\qKoph\oX�$u�tpdfh � �����ºy$g�}f���:h\x\¾

� � ��� � � �� � �

� ~�l J(J�������� � :�� ! < - � !1# 7*% :$9 �� ������� ! 9�� !$# 72¤ @5Ä�Å*§�Ó>³Z§{Ò�­�Óp±K¦¨Åº«��2cXdfhOyExphOtp�:�\q���Í�yEgj}fr�tph\xE��º�:h\�f�OhK¤ HE�f¤»i ^ J>Df¤?i��(J(J�¾

� ~ U%�?I���� ��������� � :;7�� ! 7$9 �$9 %+'���� ! - 9;: # � :$9 � ���(' !� ) !$# 9 5 � %� v~ xp�?yExph\o*�ºh��$t'�\qK��y$���.�Oq��¡�y$xpg y�¡'��y`yK�:h\qE�8hOsf}fxvh�opop�:yE�fo%"¨¤:[{�fxp�.q�l�h�ovh�qKx*�>d�l�h�}�y$xvt�� 4 D(DK�K��¤ �$rf��hji��K���?¾

� ~ U%�?I�� G ��������� � :;7�� ! 7$9 �$9 %&'���� ! - 9;: # � :$9 � ���(' !� ) !$# 9 5 � %� [{gj}���h�g�h\�$tpqKtv�:yE��y�¡5tpd�h��q�tpq�¼�y�½ �.qK���$rfq��Eh 36587�9;:$<�"¨¤2�.�! %Ó*§pÈKÓp±�©�©�¬®°$È �+±�°`È�Ç�±\ÈEź«jÎ�Å>«>¬ ÈK°-±�°�Æ �º©Wª�²�ÅO©jÅO°�­�±�­�¬¯§�°��~WÍ � ¤�i�HE�F^�i�����¤�i\�E� G ¾

� ~Wr��f�$������� � )�� ##" ¤ � �:oph\oXh��%$�r���xvhH���:optpxp�.�fr�nOh�o���h�}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjg�h\o%opu`���>dfxvy$��h\o%">¤fwd M¿cXd�h\op�.oO¤+����:��¾�l�h\�f�fh\o [>¤�i��K�`�`¾

� U UX�fi�� � �&� ! 9(' ! 9$5 -X/"! % �)� !$#"#*" % {l�h�q���ÛNc%�.g�h�opu`optvh�gjo��fh\op���$�_qK�f�¢}fxvyE�Ex*qKgjg��:�f��">¤ °�§=�­�ÄfÅOÓ�²�§�§�¶±�­ ÓpŨ±�² ��­�¬®©�Å ª�Óp§pÈKÓp±�©H©�¬®°$ÈK¤+o*}?h\�º�.q���oph\�Otv�:yE�¶y�¡+ %Óp§�¦\´W§{Òj­�ÄfÅ � � � �-�'�EyK��¾��[� 4 �f¤E`h\}�tph\g��?h\x�i\�K��iK¤5i*D$���<^�i*D(J>Df¾

� U%� I��$�fi,� � ��� ! 9,' ! 9 5 -0/"! %���� ' !- ) !$# 9$5 �U%�:$9 � � ���:���.U) ! � / � E`u`���>dfxvy$��yEr�o�}fxpyK�$xpqEgHÛg��.����½X�:tpd¹hO�Eh\�$tpoXqE�f�7xphO�.q�tp��y$�fo\Ã+t*d�h�EN[ I ��~ � �.qK���$rfq��Eh\o/qK�f�¹�:tpo�oph\gjqE�Etp�:�\oO¾ >»¦º¬¯´/Ï�§�© ª5´ XÓp§pÈ$´:¤3i*HfÃ:i\�E�F^�i\�E��¤fi\�E�fiK¾

� UWÍ ZW�?I���� � � �,� ! 9(' ! 9 5 -X/"! %���� � : -0/ 5f% �1��2 :$<3����:���4 - % :�9 � ���"' !5 ) !$# 9$5 �U%�M1q�t*q�Û�¼�y�½opu��f�>dfxpyE��y$rfo2�.qK���$rfq��Eh\o\¾+[{�� ÎHŨ¦¨±KÆEÅ�§{ÒHÏ�§�°5¦ºÇ�Ó>ÓpÅO°�¦O³��2ÓpÅ#�%Å )E¬¯§�°�«�±�°5Æ ª�ÅOÓ¨«Nª�Ũ¦O­Ë¬ ��Å>«��1% �&6>»¦*Ä�§\§�² 74>�³�©Wªf§P«>¬®Ç�©�¤�}�q��Kh�o�i ^$� G ¤ � � Í E �2yK��¾:JK�K��¤�E`}fxp�:�f�Kh\x �2h�xv�.q��?¤»i\�K�K��¾

� U%h\x*� G � 981# : # � � !$#"#*" % @�Ä�Å Ï�§�°�«>­ËÓ>Ç�¦O­Ë¬ ��Å >»Åº©�±�°?­Ë¬¯¦º« §{Ò �/«>­�źÓ*ź² ��M�x*q�¡�t ��y`yEÁ�¤: 5:5N, I<;=;#>=>=>@?BA]3$-�A<=�?fM:-=;DC&.EA#FN.G;2.10<5:.N-:./9 ¤�M�h\�Oh\g��?h\x�i\�K� G ¾

\IH êËüPûNè1í¨ê!.fú3è�í*ò3éëê»ò�è�îû{õ>øXø�üPðPéëûví*ò�éëõ>ð�÷�í{ùºîvï3éëð�ò�èPî�êËüPìPì�õ>ï¯òËéëðPþXóPéëê¯ò�ï¯é��Pü�òËî{ó�ò�í¨ïËþ>î�ò2í¨ï¯ûNèPé òËî{û�ò�üPï¯î�J

�+� ð H�H�ÿ�A

Page 43: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

�$� ��ÅO°���ź°?¬.«¨­�Å����"Å��%Ç�źÓ>°?¬¯¦�� Ç��OÓ>³

�ëÍXÍ I��$�$�2��� � � :$5 <&<&:") � % ��� � : - / 5f% � � 5 # :") � %-:�9 � � �@�: # � ¤; M �.ovt*xv�.�fr�tp�:�f�_qKr�tpyEgjq�t*q¡�y$x7qEovu��f�>d�xvy$��yErfo��fhOt�½/yEx*Á$o�y�¡�}fxpy��ºh\o*opyEx*o#">¤ �%Ç�Óp§¨ªfŨ±�°���§�Ç�Ó>°�±�²�§�° Ç�­�§�©�±�­�Å¨Æ >?³P«>­�ź©H«��� � > ��¤ ZWh�xpg�h\o\¤f�fi&�Ë� �¨¤ G �E�F^ G D��?¤ � qPu¢i\�K�`�`¾

�ëÍ � J`�2��� � � < !$# � � ) / % :$9 � � �?' : / /"! )���¤&>»Åº©�¬ �v¦¨§�©�©HÇ�­�±�­�¬¯§�°�«�� [{�`¡�yEx*gjq�tp��y$�_qK�f�¶Í�yEgj}fr`Ût*q�tp��y$�»¤�����¤ G �<^f�P�?¤?i��(J`�`¾

� M�Í/�(H�� 3 :�� #"! - ����9 - � #>/ 5 ) %3cXd�h M�h\�O�:qExpqKtv�:�Kh�Í�y���h�M Í�H¤ �2h�xpop��y$� iK¾YD�¤ � qPu¥i\�E�(H�Ì?|o*}fxp��t}�xvyKz{h\�ºt%|�w DK�(JE�$�`ÃSE`qK�\xvh�oO¾

� Z qK�:���K��� �1� 2 :�< ���: ��4 - %4>?³�°5¦*Ä�Óp§�°5§�Ç`«+ª?Óp§*È�Ó*±�©�©H¬®°`È�§{Ò%Ó*Å*±E¦º­�¬ ��ÅX«>³P«>­NÅO©H« ��¾� �.r$½�h�x"~ �OqK�fh\g��:�w�rf�»¾:¤3i\�E�K��¾

� w�>H�� �%��� ! -0/"! 9 :$9 � � �@� 9 ) ! < 5f%£~W��� -X/�- ÛN��qKoph\�¶�ºyEgjg�yE�¥oph\gjqK�$tp�:�\o�¡�yEx - 587$9 :$<£qK���-0/ : /"! ��4;: #>/ oO¤ � qKx*�>d¢i��K�(H�¾SE�qK�Oxph\o � qE�`rfop�\xv�.}�t\¾

� � qEg JK�Kq=� '���' : �/ � #(/ %E`}?h\�O� ¡�u`�.���¸�OyE�f�\rfxpxph\�$t8}�xvyE�Ex*qKg g�y��fr��:h\o\¤�HÏ�� @fÓp±�°�«O´�§�° %Óp§*È$´�+±�°`ÈE´±�°�Æ:>?³P«O´ � G � D �¨Ã:i\�E��Û�D(D(Df¤�i��(JK��¾

� � qEg JK�K� ��'��U' : / � #>/ %�@-dfqKtX�Ky`y��¹�:oXtph\gj}?yEx*q��»�:yK�K�.�!B [{�� %Ó*§\¦�´ � � � ­�Ä��j§�Ó>²�Æ¢Ï�§�°`È�Ópź«¨«��l�¾ |�¾ ~�¾ � qKopyE� �¯|��»¾ �>¤�� yExptpd ZWyK�:�.qK�f�»¤:H G �PÛ H>H(Jf¤�i\�>JK��¾

� � I���i������ ' !� ) !$# 9 5 � % ��� :+) / 5 !1# %�� � ' ! ��� # 7�9 ! % � � ' ! � :�5 #"! ¤� vwxpyK�Ex*qKgjg��.���xph\qK� ÛNtv�.g�h¹qE}f}��:�:�\q�tp��y$�fo�½X��t*d 36587�9;:$<�">¤ °�§�­®Ä�źӹ²�§�§��±�­�ÓpŨ±�² ��­Ë¬®©�Å�ª?Ó*§pÈKÓp±�©�©�¬®°$ÈK¤/o*}�h��º�.q��oph\�Otv�:yE�¹y�¡) %Óp§�¦\´§{Ò1­�ÄfÅ � � � �-�5�EyK��¾f�j� 4 �f¤�E$h�}�tvh�g��?h\x i��K��iK¤�i\�>Dfi ^5i\�K�>Hf¾

� � � I����=��� ��� : ' ':! 5 - :�9 � ���/' !1 ) !$# 9 5 �3¤, �M��.ovt*xv�.�fr�tph\�H�:gj}��:h\g�h\�$t*q�tv�:yE��y�¡ 3 587$9;:�<XÃ3o*�>d�hºÛ��r����.����qK�f�µ�$xpqE}fd·�º�.rfoptvh\xp�.����">¤ ¬®° + �KÓpÆ �>°�­�ÅOÓ>°�±�­�¬¯§�°5±�²V>5¦¨Äf§�§�²1±�°�Æ >�³�©Wªf§P«>¬®Ç�© §�° §�Ó�©�±�²�@�Ũ¦¨Ä`°?¬0/ºÇ�ź« ¬®°%WŨ±�² �c@3¬®©jÅ�±�°5Æ ±�Ç�²�­ �c@?§�²�ÅOÓp±�°?­�>�³P«¨­�ÅO©�«�� � h\�Otprfxph1�WyEtvh\o%�.�_Í�yEgj}fr�tph\xE��º�:h\�f�OhJ(HK��¤ E`}fxp�:���Eh\x �2h�xv�.q��?¤�i\�E�<^�i�HE�f¤ E$h\}�t\¾�i\�E���?¾

� � w�FD����@��� :$9 9;: :$9 � � ���!9) ! < 5f% @5ÄfÅ@�ÅO©Wªf§�Ó*±�²'�"§*ÈK¬¯¦�§{Ò %WŨ±K¦O­�¬ �PÅ ±�°�ÆÀÏ�§�°�¦OÇ�Ó>ÓpÅO°�­>�³P«>­NÅO©�« +Q>KªfŨ¦º¬ É/¦¨±�­�¬¯§�°�¾ E�}fxv�.���Eh\xvÛ �2h�xv�.q��?¤E� hO½���yEx*Á?¤»i��K�FD�¾

� � w� G ���@��� :$9 9;: :$9 � � ���!9) ! < 5f% @5ÄfÅ@�ÅO©Wªf§�Ó*±�²'�"§*ÈK¬¯¦�§{Ò %WŨ±K¦O­�¬ �PÅ ±�°�ÆÀÏ�§�°�¦OÇ�Ó>ÓpÅO°�­>�³P«>­NÅO©�« +Q>5±vҺź­�³�¾ E`}fxp�.���Kh�x{Û �2h\xp�:qK��¤$�Wh\½���y$xpÁ�¤»i\�E� G ¾

� w�`rf�`�2� � ��� 9) ! <&5f%�}?h\x*ovy$�fq��»�OyEgjg�rf�f�:�\q�tv�:yE��¾

JF ��$J?;

Page 44: Compositionality in Dataflow Synchronous …Compositionality in Data ow Synchronous Languages: Speci cation & Code Generation Albert Benveniste, Paul Le Guernic, Pascal Aubry To cite

Unit e de recherche INRIA Lorraine, Technopole de Nancy-Brabois, Campus scientifique,615 rue du Jardin Botanique, BP 101, 54600 VILLERS LES NANCY

Unit e de recherche INRIA Rennes, Irisa, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 RENNES CedexUnit e de recherche INRIA Rhone-Alpes, 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 MONTBONNOT ST MARTIN

Unit e de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY CedexUnit e de recherche INRIA Sophia-Antipolis, 2004 route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 SOPHIA-ANTIPOLIS Cedex

EditeurINRIA, Domaine de Voluceau, Rocquencourt, BP 105, 78153 LE CHESNAY Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399