55
Commercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E. Chairman, BH/GLAAR Commercial Real Estate Committee Director, BH/GLAAR Board of Directors Director, California Association of REALTORS® California Association of REALTORS® Region 20 California Commercial Alliance (CCA) ©2014 BRUBAKER Group. All rights reserved.

Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Commercial Real Estate Financial Analysis:

Cash Flow Model

BRUBAKER Group

Commercial & Industrial Properties

Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E.

Chairman, BH/GLAAR Commercial Real Estate Committee

Director, BH/GLAAR Board of Directors

Director, California Association of REALTORS®

California Association of REALTORS® Region 20

California Commercial Alliance (CCA)

©2014 BRUBAKER Group. All rights reserved.

Page 2: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

In commercial real estate financial analysis, it’s

customary to prepare a “setup”

Page 3: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

The “setup” is usually provided within the

marketing package for a listed property

Page 4: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

The setup typically includes cash flow and other financial analysis

calculations and investment indices

Page 5: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Let’s take a look at a standard multifamily

residential income property setup…it’s the easiest for us to develop and understand a cash

flow model

Page 6: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 7: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Work with a setup model you like…your commercial mortgage brokers can help

you with this

Page 8: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

We’ll start with income…and then move to expenses…then calculate

cash flow

Page 9: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Actual or current numbers vs. “pro forma” or “market” numbers

Page 10: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 11: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Scheduled Gross Income (SGI) = Total Monthly Income

“Annualized”

Page 12: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 13: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Vacancy Rate Reserve = Vacancy Rate % X SGI

Page 14: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 15: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Gross Operating Income (GOI) = SGI - Vacancy Rate Reserve

Page 16: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 17: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Total Expenses = Property Taxes + Ordinary Expenses +

Capital Expense Reserves

Page 18: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 19: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

We know what Ordinary Expenses are, but what are

Capital Expenses?

Page 20: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 21: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

U.S. companies report financials according to GAAP

(Generally Accepted Accounting Principles), which

are established by FASB (Financial Standards Accounting Board)

Page 22: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Under GAAP, Ordinary Expenses are “expensed”

during the year the cost was incurred

Page 23: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Capital Expenditures add to the life of an asset and must be depreciated over a cost recovery period of years

(useful life), so we reserve for these anticipated costs

Page 24: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Common examples of capital expenses:

•Roof •Hot water boiler •Elevator

Page 25: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

The reserve is a financial analysis recognition of an

anticipated capital cost…the owner doesn’t actually put money into an account that gets transferred upon sale

Page 26: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Here’s an example… There’s ten years of life left in

the roof, and a new roof is $60,000, what should be

reserved each year for this anticipated cost?

Page 27: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

$60,000/10 years remaining = $6,000 per year to be

reserved

Page 28: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Net Operating Income (NOI) = GOI - Expenses

Page 29: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 30: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Pre-Tax Cash Flow = NOI – Loan Payments

Page 31: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 32: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

This is called “positive” cash flow, and it’s very important

Page 33: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Total Return Before Taxes = Pre-Tax Cash Flow + Principal Reduction

Page 34: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 35: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Total Rate of Return (ROR) = Total Return / Down payment

(This is also called the

“Cash-on-Cash” Return)

Page 36: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

The Cash-on-Cash Return is the ROR based upon the

total return and the investor’s actual cash

outlay (down payment)

Page 37: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 38: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Debt Service Coverage Ratio DSCR = NOI/Loan payments

(The Debt Service is the

total of the loan payments, principle + interest)

Page 39: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 40: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

In this example,

DSCR = $91,885/$69,089

DSCR = 1.33

Page 41: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Capitalization Rate (CAP Rate) = NOI/Price

Page 42: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 43: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

The CAP Rate is analogous to a ROR (Rate of Return),

which is commonly used to rate the performance of

many types of investments

Page 44: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

For example, if you invest $100,000 into a CD

(Certificate of Deposit) and your annual return

(interest) is $10,000…what is your ROR?

Page 45: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

If your client invests $1,000,000 into an

apartment building and the net operating income is

$70,000…what is the CAP Rate?

Page 46: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

A building is listed for $10M and the net operating

income is $500,000

What is the CAP Rate?

Page 47: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Get to know the average “CAP Rates” within the market areas you serve

Page 48: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM) = Price/SGI

Page 49: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E
Page 50: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Therefore, using algebra...

Price = GRM X SGI

Page 51: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Which means...the Price is expressed by the

GRM in “multiples” or “orders of magnitude” of

the annual income

Page 52: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

GRM is a function of:

•Price •Income

Page 53: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

CAP Rate is a function of:

•Price •Income •Expenses

Page 54: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Investor Success

Page 55: Commercial Real Estate Financial AnalysisCommercial Real Estate Financial Analysis: Cash Flow Model BRUBAKER Group Commercial & Industrial Properties Brian Brubaker | Broker, M.E

Questions?

BRUBAKER Group

Commercial & Industrial Properties