9
Collecting in Brazil The payment behavior of domestic companies is acceptable, though standard payment terms are very varied and DSO remains high. Given the length and cost of legal action in Brazil, chances of obtaining enforceable judgments in a timely manner are low and it is preferable to consider amicable arrangements and specialist debt collection methods as a means to avoid domestic courts. When it comes to insolvent debtors, use of the company rescue mechanisms is increasing; in practice, however, the chances of recovering debt remain extremely low. Collection complexity Complexity relating to Notable High Very High Severe Payments Court proceedings Insolvency proceedings Notable Severe Euler Hermes Collection Profile Brazil MarkSchwettmann/Shutterstock.com

Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

  • Upload
    ngocong

  • View
    227

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Collecting in Brazil

• Thepaymentbehaviorofdomesticcompaniesisacceptable,thoughstandardpaymenttermsareveryvariedandDSOremainshigh.

• GiventhelengthandcostoflegalactioninBrazil,chancesofobtainingenforceablejudgmentsinatimelymannerarelowanditispreferabletoconsideramicablearrangementsandspecialistdebtcollectionmethodsasameanstoavoiddomesticcourts.

• Whenitcomestoinsolventdebtors,useofthecompanyrescuemechanismsisincreasing;inpractice,however,thechancesofrecoveringdebtremainextremelylow.

Collection complexity

Complexity relating to

Notable High Very High Severe

Payments

Court proceedings

Insolvency proceedings

Notable Severe

Euler Hermes

CollectionProfileBrazil

Mar

kSch

wet

tman

n/Sh

utte

rsto

ck.co

m

Page 2: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

ContentsGeneral Information........................................................................................................................................3

Availabilityoffinancialinformation................................................................................................................3Maincorporatestructures...............................................................................................................................3Regulatoryenvironment..................................................................................................................................3

Getting Paid........................................................................................................................................................4

DaysSalesOutstanding(DSO).......................................................................................................................4Latepaymentinterest.......................................................................................................................................4Debtcollectioncosts.........................................................................................................................................4Ownershipprotection......................................................................................................................................4Payments.............................................................................................................................................................4

Collecting Overdues........................................................................................................................................5

Amicableaction................................................................................................................................................. 5Legalaction......................................................................................................................................................... 5Alternativestolegalaction..............................................................................................................................6

Handling Insolvent Debtors..........................................................................................................................8

Insolvencyproceedings...................................................................................................................................8

Mar

ioJo

seBa

stos

Silva

/Shu

tters

tock

.com

Page 3: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Days Sales Outstanding (DSO): TheaverageDSOisaround61days for 2016.

General information

Availability of financial informationRelevantfinancialinformationondomestictradersisnotreliable.Indeed,althoughstockexchangelistedgroupstendtocommunicatereliableinformation,non-listedcompanies(whicharethemostcommontypeofbusinessinBrazil)failtodosoortendtoreleaseinformationonaninformalbasis.Asaresult,effortstoavoiddoubtfulpracticesareincreasinglyputintoplace,especiallyinrelationtoanti-corruptionefforts.Relyingonlocalandsettledbanksisthereforeadvisable,andfinancialinformationshouldbeobtainedthroughspecializedproviders.EulerHermesinBrazilhasaccesstothemostup-to-datefinancialinformationandobtainsthemostrelevantcontactsforfutureassessment.EulerHermesallocateseachcompanyagradereflectingitsfinancialhealthandhowitconductsbusiness.Gradesrepresentacoreofourknowledgeandanalyses,andhelpclientsidentifyandavoidrisk.Dataiscontinuouslymonitoredtoofferthemostup-to-dateinformationtosupportmanagementdecisions.

Main corporate structuresLiabilityforbusinessdebtsisdeterminedbylegalstructures,whicharedescribedasfollows:Corporations(SociedadeAnônima,SA)andLimitedCompanies(Limitadas,LTDA)arefrequentlyusedintheestablishmentofsubsidiariesandjointventures.Bothmaybefullyownedbylocal/foreignindividualsandundertakingsalike,andwhiletherearenominimumcapitalrequirements,certainlimitationsmayapplyinprotectedsectors.Limitadasrequireatleasttwoshareholders(otherwise,IndividualLLCsmaybesetup).Inaddition,Mixed-CapitalCompaniesallowprivateinvestorstoconductbusinessincollaborationwithpublicentities(whichtakecontrol).

Regulatory environmentBrazilisdividedinto26statesandhasapeculiarlegalenvironmentoperatingatbothfederalandstatelevels.Atthefederallevel,thecourts(TribunaisRegionaisFederais)usuallydealwithinternationalclaimsinvolvingthepublicauthoritiesandhaveageographicjurisdiction(Brasilia,RiodeJaneiro,SaoPaulo,PortoAlegreandRecife).Atthestatelevel(eachstatehasitsownlawsandjudicialsystem),thecourtsratherdealwithallthemattersexcludedfromfederaljurisdiction.CasesinfirstinstancearedealtwithbytheJusticesofthePeace,butcommercialdisputesarerathersolvedthroughtheMagistrates’Courtsbyspecializedjudges.FederalCourts(TribunaisdeJustiça)dealwithappeals.Inadditiontodifficultiesinsolvingjurisdictionalissues,thecourtsmustalsoworkwithCivilandCommonLaw,whicharebothusedinBrazil:inCivillegalsystemsjudgesmustfollowcodifiedrules(butcodificationisnotsystematicinpractice)but,bycontrastwithCommonlawsystems,theyarenotboundbyprecedents.Asaresult,thelegalenvironmentisrathercomplexandlitigationmayproveextremelylengthyanddifficult,whichdoesnothelptoanswerthevariouscriticismsregardingthelackofindependenceandtrustworthinessofthejudiciary.

3

Page 4: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Getting Paid

Days Sales Outstanding (DSO)Thepaymentbehaviorofdomesticcompaniesremainsacceptablebutisunderpressureduetothemacroeconomicdifficultiessince2014.AlthoughtheregulatorinBrazilhastriedtoregulatepaymentdelays,latepaymentsarestilllikelytooccurunlesstransactionsaresecured:theaverageDSOisaround61days,whilethepayments normally occur in around 30daysintheretailanddistributionsectors, and210daysintheagriculturesector.ItmaybenotedthattheSERASAdatabaseisavailabletoallcompaniesandprovidesrecordsoflatepayersandpaymentfailures,thusmakingitdifficultforbadpayerstoaccessnewlinesofcredit.

Late payment interestLatepaymentinterestmaybeclaimedfromthedayfollowingtheduedatebutthelawisfairlyhelplessonthisissue.TheCivilCodeprovidesthatamonthlyrateof1%ofthedebtmaybechargedbydefault,buttheruleinpracticeisthatinterestratesmustalwaysbeagreeduponasacontractualmatter.Localtradersareusedtopayinginterest,howeverthisisoftenconsideredasanegotiationtooltoobtainpaymentmorerapidly.

Debt collection costsCollectioncostsmayalsobefullychargedtothedebtor,althoughthelawdoesnotprovideauniformruleastowhetheradefaultsummaybechargedtothedebtor,thereforenegotiatingthisasacontractualissueisimportant.Courtsusuallyconsiderthatcostsoughttorepresentupto20%oftheoutstandingdebt(especiallyinthelegalactionphase),butamountsmaybeusedasanegotiationtool.

Ownership protectionRetentionofTitle(RoT,orReservadeDomíniounderArticles521to528oftheCivilCode)provisionsareavailable inBraziltoretainownershipovertradedgoodsaslongasthedebtisnotfullypaid. However,only‘simple’RoTisdeemedvalid,whichimpliesthatprotectionisrestrictedtogoodsthatareavailable(i.e.stillinthedebtor’spremises)andidentifiable.Aslongasthisrequirementismet,itiscommontouseRoTagreementsasabargainingtoolduringthepre-legalactionphasesoastotakethegoodsbackwhenpaymentdoesnotoccur.Oncetheinsolvencyprocessbegins,creditorsareabletolodgeaclaimagainstthedebtor’sassetsandreclaimanygoodsthatweredeliveredtothedebtorbutwerenotpaidforunderRoT.RoTprovisionisveryformal:thecontractmustcarefullydescribethegoodsatstakeand,inordertobevalidandopposabletothirdparties,itmustbetranslatedintoPortugueseandregisteredwiththeRegistroPúblicodeTítuloseDocumentos.In practice, RoT is not commonly used as chattel mortgage is preferred. Seekinglegaladviceisnecessary.

PaymentsThemostcommonpaymentmethodsareasfollows:Banktransfersareamongthemostpopularpaymentmethodsas

theyarefast,secured,andsupportedbyanincreasinglydevelopedbankingnetworkinternationallyanddomestically.ExporttransactionsmaybeguaranteedthroughanExportCreditInsurancepolicy,whichhelpsminimizetheriskofsuddenorunexpectedcustomerinsolvency.EulerHermes’worldwidenetworkofriskofficesmonitorsthefinancialwell-beingofcustomersandgrantsthemaspecificcreditlimituptowhichclientsmaytradeandclaimshouldsomethinggowrong.Alternatively,StandbyLettersofCredit(abankguaranteesthedebtor’screditqualityandrepaymentabilities)constitutereliableguaranteeswhichcanbeinterpretedasasignofgoodfaithsincetheycanbetriggeredasa‘paymentoflastresort’iftheclientfailstofulfilacontractualcommitment.Also,irrevocableandconfirmedDocumentaryLettersofCredit(adebtorguaranteesthatacertainamountofmoneyismadeavailabletoabeneficiarythroughabankoncecertaintermsspecificallyagreedbythepartieshavebeenmet)maybeconsideredastheycanbeobtainedeasilyfromlocalbanks.BillsofExchange(letradecambio)andPromissoryNotes(notapromissoria)areessentiallyusedfordomestictransactionsandconstitutemeansofpressureinsofarastheyconstituteeasilyexecutableenforcementordersexemptingcreditorsfromhavingtogotocourtifthedebtremainsunpaid.Infact,duetotheadvancedtechnologyusedinthebankingsystem,aformofbillalsoknownas‘duplicata’whichusedtoberelieduponinbusiness-to-businesstransactionshasprogressivelybeenreplacedbybankbills(boletobancario).Generallyspeaking,bankguaranteescanbeobtainedbutmayremainexpensivedependingontheissuinginstitution.Advancepaymentsofupto100%oftheinvoiceareauthorizedbylaw.

Late payment interest: Inpractice,theruleisthatinterestratesmustalwaysbeagreeduponasacontractualmatter.

4

Page 5: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Collecting overdues

Amicable actionNegotiatingGiventhelengthandcostoflegalactioninBrazil,chancesofobtainingenforceablejudgmentsinatimelymannerarelowanditispreferabletoconsideramicablearrangements(suchaspaymentinstalments)asasolution.Asamatteroflaw,negotiationthroughconciliationormediationisnotmandatorybuttheCivilProcedureCodestronglyencouragescourtstogivethepartiesadditionalopportunitiestoreachasettlementthroughAlternativeDisputeResolutionmethodsbeforetheevidencephaseandbeforethejudgment(seebelow).Asaresult,commencingcollectionwithstrongnegotiationeffortsisneveralossoftime.Beforestartinglegalproceedingsagainstadebtor,assessmentofassetsisfurthermoreextremelyimportantasitallowsverificationastowhetherthecompanyisstillactiveandwhetherrecoverychancesareatbest.Inaddition,itisessentialtobeawareofthedebtor’ssolvencystatus:ifinsolvencyproceedingshavebeeninitiated,itindeedbecomesimpossibletoenforceadebt.

Legal action

Ordinary proceedingsItshouldfirstbenotedthatdistancesmaybetroublesome.Ononehand,jurisdictiondependsonthedebtor’sgeographiclocationandthesizeofthecountrycanmakeproceedingscomplicated(howeverifthecontractprovidesforanotherjurisdictionclausethentheproblemmaybeavoided).Ontheotherhandandforthesamereason,findingthedebtormayprovedifficultandwouldslowtheproceedingsdowninsofarastrialmayonlystartafterthedebtor’snotificationbyaserviceprocess.Legaldunning(protesto)mustotherwisestartwitharegisteredDemandLetterrecallingthedebtor’sobligationtopaytheprincipaltogetherwithlatepaymentinterest(ascontractuallyagreedortakingalegalrateasareference).Fasttrackproceedings(açaomonitoria)maybeinitiatedwhenthecreditorhaswrittenproof,signedbytwowitnessesandregisteredbyapublicnotary(documentsmustbetranslatedintoPortuguesebyasworntranslatorandlegalizedbeforetheBrazilianConsulate),thattheclaimislegitimate:ifthedebtor’sobligationisdeemedcertain,liquidandexigible(certo,liquidoeexigivel),theMunicipalCourts(JusticesofthePeaceorMagistrates)usuallyrenderPaymentOrderswithin15days.Ifthedebtorfailstocomplywithinthreedays,theOrderthenbecomesenforceable.Ifanappealislodged,however,thecreditorhasnochoicebuttocommenceformalordinarylegalaction.Ordinarylegalactionwouldotherwiseusuallycommencewhenamicablecollectionhasfailed.TheclaimantmustservetherespondentwitharegisteredWritofSummons,towhichthedebtormustanswerwithin15daysofreceipt.Thisstepisessentialas

Collection @ Euler HermesItisalwaysadvisedtoattemptcollectionpriortoanylegalactioninordertomaximizechancesofsuccessfulrecoveryandavoidlegalcostsanddelays.Ourkeyprincipleistocollectincloseproximitytothedebtor,usingaseriesofletters,emailsandphonecallsinthelocaldebtorlanguage.OurWorldCollectionNetworkofEulerHermesofficesandexternalprovidersareexpertsinprofessionaltradedebtcollectionandnegotiation,ensuringpositiveoutcomeswhileretainingimportantclientrelationships.EulerHermescanhandlethecompletecollectionsprocessfromamicable,pre-legalactionthroughtojudgmentandenforcement.

Braziliancourtsareverystrictastothewaydefendantsshouldbesummonedincourtproceedings.Theproceedingsareinquisitiveinnatureandencompassaninvestigationphaseconductedbythecourt,anexaminationphaseandahearingphase.However,thetribunalmayrenderadefaultjudgment(revelia)ifadulyservedwritisleftunansweredfor.Inthiscase,theallegedclaimwouldbeconsideredlegitimateandthedecisionwouldreflectaccordingly.

Necessary documents• Commercialinvoices• Documentarybills• Proofoftransportanddeliveryofproducts• Promissorynotes• Powerofattorney• Articlesofassociationorconstitutionactsofthelegalentity• Documentevidencingthelegitimacyofwhoexecutesthepower

ofattorneyonbehalfofthelegalentity

Time limitationsLimitationperiods(prescrição)varyfromonetotenyearsaccordingtothesubjectmatteroftheclaim,startingfromthedaythecauseofactionarose.Commercialdisputesmustbefiledwithinthreeyears,butcheck-relatedmattersfallunderasix-monthlimitation.Beyondthesetimelimitations,legalactionwillnotbegranted.

Provisional measuresProvisionalmeasuresmayhelppreservethecreditor’sinterestspendingafinalandenforceablejudgment.Indeed,thecourtsmayorderprotectiveinjunctionsexparte(withoutthepresenceofbothparties),beforeorduringtheproceedings,toavoidirreparabledamage(preservationofthestatusquo,protectionofrights).Causeforemergencymustbedemonstrated(significantburdenofproof)andtheclaimantwouldoftenberequiredtoprovidesecurityonthecosts(upto20%oftheclaim)topreservethedebtorfromirresponsiblelawsuits.Whereevidenceislikelytodisappear,thecourtswouldalsoorderprecautionarymeasuresaimingatpreservingorobtainingsuchevidence.

5

Page 6: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Lodging an appealAsageneralrule,decisionsrenderedinfirstinstancebystatecourtscanbeappealed(apelação)tothefederalcourts(TribunaisdeJustiça).DecisionsrenderedinappealmayalsobedisputedbeforetheSupremeCourtofJustice(SuperiorTribunaldeJustiça)inBrasilia.

Enforcing court decisionsAjudgmentbecomesenforceableassoonasithasbecomefinal(i.e.whenallappealvenueshavebeenexhausted)andfinaljudgmentsoughttobeautomaticallyenforcedbyBraziliancourts.Sincereformsin2005and2006aimingatreducingenforcementperiods,attachmentofthedebtor’sassetsisnowpossibleifthelatterfailstoobeyafinalOrderwithinthreedays.The‘Penhoraon-line’instrument,also,allowsanyamountavailableonthedebtor’saccounttobeblockedinordertoenforceajudgment.Inpractice,executioncanprovetobedifficultsincethereareonlylimitedmeanswithwhichtotraceassetsinBrazil.

How long could legal action take?Obtainingadefaultjudgmentcantakebetweeneightand18monthswhileafulljudicialprocedurecanlastfortwotofouryears,dependingonthecomplexityofthecaseandtheavailabilityofthecourts.Aspreviouslymentioned,enforcementmayalsobealengthyprocedure.Casesinvolvingforeignpartieswouldnormallynottakelongerthancasesinvolvingdomesticpartiesonly,howeversomedelaysmaybeexpectedifdocumenttranslationsarenecessary.

How much could this cost?Asageneralrule,proceduralcosts(whichmayrepresentupto5%oftheclaim)andlegalcostsarechargedtothedefeatedparty,whichmaythereforeberequiredtopayupto20%oftheclaimincompensationtothesuccessfulparty.However,sinceBrazilianLawpreventscourtsfromrenderingdecisionsonsubjectmattersnotincludedintheparties’claims,itisessentialtoincludecost-relateddemandsintheWritwhenservingthedebtor.Courtfeesreaching1%oftheclaim(dependingonthestate)mustbepaidpriortocommencinglegalproceedings.Ifthelawsuitisdecidedonbehalfofthecreditor,thisamountshouldbereimbursedbythedebtor.Contingencyfees,wherebythelegalprofessionalsareentitledtoreceivingapercentageonthefinalaward,arelawfulthoughuncommon.

Alternatives to legal action

Alternative Dispute Resolution methods (ADR)AlternativeDisputeResolutionmethodsareincreasinglycommoninBrazilforbusiness-relateddisputes.Inparticular,arbitration(regulatedundertheArbitrationAct,LawNo.9307/96)isoftenviewedasbeingmoreefficientthanordinarylawsuitssinceitoffersexpeditiousandconfidentialproceedingstogetherwithabindingawardonthemerits.Arbitralawardsmaythenbeenforceddirectly.ThereishowevernoregulationformediationinBrazil.

Litigation @ Euler HermesShouldlegalactionbenecessary,EulerHermescanprovidesupportthroughoutthelegalprocessfromjudgmenttoenforcementviaourWorldCollectionNetworkofEulerHermesofficesandexternalproviders.Legalactioncanoftenbecomplicatedandexpensive,soyouwillbeinformedofallcostspriortoanyactionandadvisedonwhichrouteisbesttotake.

6

Page 7: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Foreign forumsForeigntradersmayalternativelyagreetosolvetheirbusinessdisputesinaforeignforum(i.e.underaforeignlaworbeforeaforeigncourt)providedthattheagreementischaracterizedbyaninternationalconnection(forexample,onepartyhaselecteddomicileinanothercountry,ortheplaceofexecutionislocatedabroad),andthatajurisdictionclauseisspecificallydraftedforthispurpose.Inpractice,Braziliancourtstendtoretainexclusivejurisdictiontodecideonvarioussubjectmatters(suchasrealestateissuesandinternationalcontractsenteredintobyBrazilianfederal,stateandmunicipalgovernmententities).Inaddition,itisworthaddingthatsomeBraziliancourtshaveinsistedonarightofnationalstobenefitfromdueprocessoflaw(i.e.arighttoappearbeforeBraziliancourts)notwithstandingtheexistenceofaforeignjurisdictionclausewhichmightthusbesimplyignored.

Enforcing foreign awardsAspreviouslyexplained,Braziliancourtsnormallyretainexclusivejurisdictionovervarioussubjectmattersandwouldthustendtodenyrecognitionofcertainforeignjudgmentsaimingatescapingdomesticcourts.Nonetheless,foreignjudgmentsmaybeenforcedinBrazilwithinthreemonthsonaverage,providedthatcertainconditionsareobserved.Essentially,foreigndecisionsmustbeconfirmedbytheSuperiorCourtofJusticetobecomeenforceableinBrazil.Thisimpliesthatthedecisionmustbefinalandenforceableintheissuingjurisdiction.ThedecisionmustalsobetranslatedinPortugueseandcertifiedbytheBrazilianconsulateresidinginthesaidcountry.Itmusthavebeendulyserved,andmustbecompatiblewithBrazilianpublicpolicy,sovereigntyandgoodmoralprinciples.Onceconfirmed,theforeignjudgmentbecomesfinalandacertifiedcopy(CartadeSentença)oftheBraziliandecisionisprovidedinordertocommenceenforcementbeforethefederalcourts.BrazilisasignatorytotheNewYorkConventionontheRecognitionandEnforcementofForeignArbitralAwardsof1958.Therefore,domesticcourtsalsooughttorecognizeandenforcedecisionsrenderedthroughinternationalarbitrationproceedings.Havingsaidthis,itmaybeemphasizedthatreferencetotheNewYorkConventionisrare,asthecourtsrathertendstosupportenforcementdecisionstowardsforeignarbitralawardsundertheArbitrationActof1996,whichstipulatesthatsuchdecisionsmustberecognizedandenforcedbytheSuperiorCourtofJustice.Thisprocedure,indeed,seemsmoreconstrainingthantheNewYorkConventionproceedingsinsofarasitaimsatverifyingtheexistenceofavalid(andtranslated)arbitrationagreementaswellasvariousformalities(examinationneverimpliesverificationsonthemerits)aspreviouslylisted.Enforcementsarethendealtwiththroughastandardizedone-stop-shopprocedurehandledbyspecializedjudges.

7

Page 8: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Handling insolvent debtors

Since2005,theinsolvencylegislationinspiredbytheU.S.Chapter11(Lawno.111.101/05)hasfacilitatedrescueproceedings.Greaterpriorityhasbeengiventocreditors,thusincreasinglytheavailabilityoffreshrestructuringcashforcompaniesfacingtemporaryfinancialdifficulties.Inpractice,however,thechancesofrecoveringdebtwhenthedebtorhasbecomeinsolventareextremelylow.

Insolvency proceedingsOut-of-Court proceedingsThelawalternativelyallowsout-of-courtrestructuringproceedings(Extra-JudicialRecuperation/RecuperaçãoExtrajudicial).Thedebtoristhusgivenachancetonegotiatearestructuringplaninformallyandconfidentiallywithitscreditors,withouthavingcourts.Theplanmustbeagreeduponbycreditorsrepresentingaminimumof60%ofthebusiness’debtsanditmustbeapprovedbythecourt.

Restructuring the debtJudicialRecuperation(RecuperaçãoJudicial)aimsfirstatpreservingthedebtor’sbusiness.Followingthecourt’sacceptanceofthereorganizationpetitionfiledbythedebtor,anautomatic180daysstayshieldingthedebtorfromexternalclaimscommences.Thecompany’sdirectorsusuallyremaininpossessionoftheirmanagingpowersandhavethesoleresponsibilitytosubmit,within60days,areorganizationplantotheCreditors’Committee,underthesupervisionofacourt-appointedtrustee(administradorjudicial).Eachclassofcreditor(labor-related,securedandunsecured)mustthenaccepttheplanforittobevalidatedbythecourt.Failingtodoso,thepartiesmayshifttoabankruptcyprocedure.Inpractice,bankruptcyprocedureshavedecreasedsincethelawof2005hascomeintoforce.

Winding up proceedingsBankruptcy(Falência)isthejudicialliquidationprocedureforaninsolventmerchant.Unlessthedebtorfilesvoluntarilyforliquidation,creditorsowning(singleorjoint)claimsequaltoatleast40minimumwagesmayfiletheirclaimswiththecourt.Ifpetitionforliquidationisgranted,othercreditorsmustthenfiletheirrespectiveclaimswithin15daysfollowingthepublicnotificationoftheproceedings.Anadministratorthenformulatesalistofadmissibleclaimsandcommencesthedebtor’sassetsliquidationpriortodistributingtheproceedsamongthecreditors.

Priority rulesPriorityrulesnormallyapplywhiledistributingtheproceedstothecreditors.Inliquidationproceedings,judicialadministrationcostsarenormallygivenabsolutepriorityoversecuredcreditors(suchasfinancialinstitutionsandfreshmoneyproviders),whichwouldhowevertypicallyreceivetheproceedsofthedebtor’sauctionedassetsbeforetheemployees(laborclaimsupto150timestheprevailingminimumwageforeachcreditor,andclaimsderivingfrom

accidentsatwork),securedcreditorsuptothevalueoftherelevantcollateral,federaltaxdebt,creditorsholdingspecialandgeneralprivileges,unsecuredcreditors,etc.Inreorganizationproceedings,employmentclaimsmustbepaidwithinoneyearoftheplan’sapproval.

Cancellation of suspect transactions (clawback)Inaddition,theliquidatormaycancelvarioustypesoftransactionsconcludedwithin90dayspriortotheinsolvencyproceedings(Section129oftheLaw).Typically,fraudulentdeals,improperpayments,disproportionatesales,transactionsaimingatfavoringonecreditorovertheothers,unfairloansetc.wouldbedeclaredvoid.

How long could insolvency proceedings take?Insolvencyproceedingstakearoundfiveyearsonaveragebutmayextendtotenyearsdependingonthecomplexityofthecase.

Necessary documentsAlloriginalsalessupportdocuments,theamountofthecredit,thederivationaswell.

Insolvency @ Euler HermesEulerHermesworkscloselywithdebtors,creditorsandlawyerstoprovidesupportduringinsolvencyandrestructuringprocesses.Withmanyoptionsavailablewhenitcomestoinsolvencyaction,wecanofferadviceonwhichoptionismostsuitable.

8

Mig

el/S

hutte

rsto

ck.co

m

Page 9: Collection Profile - eulerhermes.com · Bills of Exchange (letra de cambio) and Promissory Notes (nota promissoria) are essentially used for domestic transactions and constitute means

Coun

tryP

rofil

e:B

razil

ThisCollectionProfileispublishedbyEulerHermes,acompanyofAllianz,forinformationpurposesonly.Theinformationprovidedthereinshallnotberegardedasprovidinganylegaladviceoradviceofanykind.Readersshouldmaketheirown independentevaluationof this informationandundernocircumstancesshallanyactionbeundertakensolelyrelyingonit,whilelegaladviceshouldbesoughtwithlegalpractitionersatalltimes.Whilethisinformationhasbeencollectedanddraftedbyrecognizedexperts intheirfieldand it isbelievedtobecorrectandreliable,EulerHermesmakesnowarranty(expressofimplied)ofanykind,inregardstotheaccuracyorcompletenessofthisinformation,nordoes itacceptanyresponsibilityor liability forany lossordamagearising inanyway fromanyusemadeof,orreliance placed on, this information. This material should not be reproduced or disclosed without our consent. It isnotintendedfordistributioninanyjurisdictioninwhichthiswouldbeprohibitedandCollectionProfilesaresubjecttochangewithoutnotice.

©Copyright2017EulerHermes.Allrightsreserved.

EulerHermes,acompanyofAllianz,leaderincreditinsurancesolutionshelpingcompaniesgrowtheirbusinesssafelyathomeandabroad,providesglobalcommercialdebtcollectionserviceswithtrueend-to-endcapability.EulerHermesoffersbothdomesticand international tradedebtcollectionservicesworldwide.Throughournetwork,weuseourexperience and knowledge of local markets to ensure a professional service for our clients from pre-legal actionthroughtolegalproceedings.

VisitEulerHermesatwww.eulerhermes.com