3
Monday, December 1st, 2014 Via Email Brian Klein, Partner Baker Marquart LLP [email protected] Re: Cease and Desist Mr. Klein, I write in response to your letter dated November 26, 2014 regarding the article “Gaw Miners lying about partnerships” on the Coin Fire website at http://CoinFire.cf/ . I can certainly understand your client’s desire to have our reporting silenced with false claims of libel, and how Mr. Garza and GAW Miners may wish to simply silence our reporting rather than face it headon in a public view; however, letters sent to silence and intimidate Coin Fire from reporting simply will not be enough. In your letter, you demand that Coin Fire immediately cease and desist all claims made in the article published by our staff contributor Leo Harzig immediately. This letter is to inform you that Coin Fire will not comply with your request and has no legal obligation to do so. Your legal threats are not supported by the law and plainly seek to interfere with Coin Fire’s freedom of press and protected speech. In your letter you assert, “No one at GAW was contacted to discuss the story before it was published. If GAW had been contacted and given a chance to set the record straight, the article would be dramatically different: it would be accurate.” Coin Fire can and will produce material evidence that supports our claims that GAW was contacted multiple times via multiple, documentable, and subpoenable methods that shows your assertion to be false. Coin Fire made numerous, welldocumented, and wellsupported attempts to reach out to GAW Miners prior to the publication of this piece. While we are not legally obligated to confer with GAW Miners prior to publishing, we did so in an act of good faith. Evidence of multiple attempts of contact can be produced in the event of legal proceedings against Coin Fire, Mr. Johnson, or Mr. Harzig.

Coin Fire Response to GAW Miners C&D

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Official response from Coin Fire regarding the GAW Miners cease and desist letter.

Citation preview

  • Monday,December1st,2014

    ViaEmail

    BrianKlein,PartnerBakerMarquartLLP

    [email protected]

    Re:CeaseandDesist

    Mr.Klein,

    IwriteinresponsetoyourletterdatedNovember26,2014regardingthearticleGawMinerslyingaboutpartnershipsontheCoinFirewebsiteathttp://CoinFire.cf/.

    Icancertainlyunderstandyourclientsdesiretohaveourreportingsilencedwithfalse

    claimsoflibel,andhowMr.GarzaandGAWMinersmaywishtosimplysilenceourreporting

    ratherthanfaceitheadoninapublicviewhowever,letterssenttosilenceandintimidate

    CoinFirefromreportingsimplywillnotbeenough.

    Inyourletter,youdemandthatCoinFireimmediatelyceaseanddesistallclaims

    madeinthearticlepublishedbyourstaffcontributorLeoHarzigimmediately.Thisletteristo

    informyouthatCoinFirewillnotcomplywithyourrequestandhasnolegalobligationtodo

    so.YourlegalthreatsarenotsupportedbythelawandplainlyseektointerferewithCoin

    Firesfreedomofpressandprotectedspeech.

    Inyourletteryouassert,NooneatGAWwascontactedtodiscussthestorybeforeitwaspublished.IfGAWhadbeencontactedandgivenachancetosettherecordstraight,thearticlewouldbedramaticallydifferent:itwouldbeaccurate.CoinFirecanandwillproducematerialevidencethatsupportsourclaimsthatGAWwascontactedmultipletimesvia

    multiple,documentable,andsubpoenablemethodsthatshowsyourassertiontobefalse.

    CoinFiremadenumerous,welldocumented,andwellsupportedattemptstoreachout

    toGAWMinerspriortothepublicationofthispiece.Whilewearenotlegallyobligatedto

    conferwithGAWMinerspriortopublishing,wedidsoinanactofgoodfaith.Evidenceof

    multipleattemptsofcontactcanbeproducedintheeventoflegalproceedingsagainstCoin

    Fire,Mr.Johnson,orMr.Harzig.

  • CoinFiremadeeveryreasonableattempttoinformandgivebothMr.GarzaandGAW

    Minersampletimetoreviewandrespondtothefeaturethatwaspublished.Asevidencedin

    ExhibitA,theclaimstomakecontactthroughmultipleattemptsaredocumentedviaseveral

    methods.Thisisbutonepieceofevidencewehaveavailabletosupportourclaim.

    Pleaseprovidetomyselfandourteam,inwriting,anaccurateaccountingoftheexact

    informationandstatementsyourclientfoundintheoriginalpiecetobelibeloussothatour

    teammaybeginreviewingyourclaimsmoreindepthly.

    Mr.MichaelJohnson

    ExecutiveEditor,CoinFire

  • ExhibitA