Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan

  • Published on

  • View

  • Download

Embed Size (px)


<ul><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 1/16</p><p>Causes of</p><p>Delay/Postponement in</p><p>Construction-Projects of</p><p>Pakistan</p><p>Farooq Rashid</p><p> Aisha</p><p>Naz</p><p>SZABIST Islamabad SZABIST Islamabad</p><p>Islamabad Pakistan Islamabad Pakistan</p><p>AbstractConstruction delays are common roblem in</p><p>ro!ects o" Pakistan# These roblems occur</p><p>"requently durin$ ro!ect li"e%time leadin$ to</p><p>disutes and liti$ation# There"ore&amp; it is essential</p><p>to study and analyze causes o" construction</p><p>delays# 'elay is one o" the most common&amp;</p><p>imortant and serious roblem (hich imacts</p><p>the time "actor (ith relation to cost o" ro!ects in</p><p>the Construction Industry# The three main causes</p><p>o" time%delays included chan$in$ orders&amp;</p><p>o(ners) "inancial constraints and o(ners) lack o"</p><p>e*erience in the construction business#</p><p>Re$ardin$ cost o+erruns&amp; the three main causes</p><p>(ere identi"ied as contractor%related roblems&amp;</p><p>material%related roblems and&amp; a$ain&amp; o(ners</p><p>,"inancial constraints# The minimization o" time</p><p>delays and cost o+erruns in ro!ects (ould</p><p>require- the a+ailability o" adequate "unds&amp;</p><p>allocation o" su""icient time and money at the</p><p>desi$n hase&amp; and selection o" a cometent</p><p>consultant and a reliable contractor to carry out</p><p>the (ork#</p><p>Key terms</p><p>Construction industry&amp; corrution&amp; schedule</p><p>delay&amp; "ianc. o+errun</p><p>Introduction-</p><p>This is e*cetionally un"ortunate that the</p><p>de+eloment business does not areciate</p><p>$reat notoriety re$ardless o" the certainty it</p><p>is one o" the bi$$est di+ision o" Pakistan# It</p><p>$i+es (ide oenin$s "or (ork in di""erent</p><p>nations and in Pakistan and additionally</p><p>holds si$ni"icant commitment to(ards</p><p>de+eloment o" /'P# 'e+eloment</p><p>delay0de"erral sa( as a standout amon$st the</p><p>most (idely reco$nized issues in the</p><p>de+eloment business# 'e"ers un"a+orably</p><p>in"luence on undertakin$ contractor&amp;</p><p>stakeholders includin$ o(ner&amp; construction</p><p>e*erts&amp; de+eloment e*erts&amp; clients and</p><p>others#</p><p>Numerous e*amination endea+ors ha+e been</p><p>made to study reason "or ostonement in</p><p>di+erse nations0countries 12arzouk and</p><p>Tarek I# 3l%Rasas&amp;4564 7 e#$# in the #united</p><p>States&amp; atmoshere&amp; (ork suly&amp; and sub%</p><p>builder (ere "ound to be the hu$e</p><p>e*lanation behind delay in de+eloment</p><p>ro!ects# Poor risk or$anization&amp; oor</p><p>suer+ision&amp; un"oreseen site conditions&amp;</p><p>moderate decision makin$ includin$</p><p>assortment&amp; and central mi*ture satis"iesdesires are the rule de"erral comonents in</p><p>8on$ 9on$#united 1Bordoli and Bald(in &amp;</p><p>6::;7# </p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 2/16</p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 3/16</p><p>Pakistan# Thus (e shall conduct a three</p><p>dimensional study (hich e+entually</p><p>considers all the ma!or layers o" this</p><p>$ame%% the contractors&amp; /o+ernment and</p><p>consultants#</p><p>Ad+ancements in the de+eloment business</p><p>are hu$e in size&amp; inno+ation intricacy&amp;</p><p>interdeendencies&amp; and +arieties in requests</p><p>"rom customers In de+eloment&amp;</p><p>ostonement could be characterized as the</p><p>schedule in+ade either ast "ruition date</p><p>detailed in an a$reement or ast the date that</p><p>the $atherin$s concurred uon "or</p><p>con+eyance o" an undertakin$# It is +ital that</p><p>acti+ities to be "inished inside the</p><p>determined undertakin$s schedule#</p><p>Schedule and "ianc. are +ery imortant "or a</p><p>ro!ect and tyically called the bein$ "or the</p><p>mana$ement and the contractor# For the</p><p>contractor&amp; delay means ro!ect schedule</p><p>eriod is lon$ so o+erhead "ianc.s is hi$h</p><p>because o" lon$er (ork eriod&amp; material</p><p>"ianc. is hi$h because o" in"lation this is</p><p>because (hen a ro!ect comlete late it can</p><p>disallo( emloyers the ro"its or bene"its</p><p>that $ather throu$h utilization o" the</p><p>+enture0ro!ects and may like(ise oen</p><p>them to $enuine bud$etary and "inancial</p><p>dan$ers&amp; "or e*amle&amp; hi$h remium rates</p><p>and mis"ortune o" business $ood "ortunes#</p><p>n the builders side&amp; ostone in "ruition</p><p>in+ol+es e*tra "ianace $atherin$ "rom</p><p>de+eloed site o""ice o+erheads&amp; (ork andequiment standby e*enses and other</p><p>immaterial "iance&amp; "or e*amle&amp; oen door</p><p>"ianace# there is numerous elements include</p><p>in this rocess so it is uncommon in</p><p>de+eloment undertakin$ "inish in its</p><p>arran$ed schedule it is a $reat si$n ho(e+er</p><p>in de+eloment +entures0ro!ects but it once</p><p>in a (hile haen# schedulely con+eyance o"</p><p>acti+ities inside e+aluated lan assessed</p><p>schedule and (ith strikin$ quality (hich</p><p>seci"ied by the customer is a "ile o" "ruit"ul</p><p>task con+eyance# Det (hen ne$lect to</p><p>accomlish indicated schedule&amp; lanned</p><p>e*ense and e*cetional quality it in"luences</p><p>ad+ersely on tasks# In this case normal</p><p>ractices ermit a rate o" the +enture "ianace</p><p>as a ossibility recomense in the a$reement</p><p>"ianc. and also contract $atherin$s</p><p>concurred u on the additional schedule and</p><p>e*ense connected (ith ostonement&amp; by</p><p>and lar$e there is issues bet(een the o(nerand contractor in the matter o" (hether the</p><p>builder (as quali"ied "or case the additional</p><p>"ianace because in Pakistan there is an issue</p><p>o" corrution# Such circumstances&amp; there is</p><p>ha+e to think about the reason "or</p><p>ostonement (hich con"ronts builder in</p><p>de"ined +enture# So e""ortlessly "i$ure out</p><p>the real urose "or the delay# 'esite these</p><p>imacts&amp; it is un"ortunately all e*cessi+ely</p><p>normal that most tasks are not "inishedinside the concurred contract eriod and at</p><p>the "ianace it (as tendered "or#</p><p>=iterature Re+ie(</p><p>/eneral-</p><p>Construction de"erral0delay is +ie(ed as astandout amon$st the most reeatin$ issues</p><p>in the construction business# 'elay has an</p><p>ad+erse e""ect on undertakin$ achie+ementre$ardin$ schedule&amp; e*ense&amp; and quality#</p><p>The imacts o" construction ostonements</p><p>are not limited to the construction business</p><p>!ust&amp; additionally imact the $eneraleconomy o" a country like Pakistan&amp; (here</p><p>construction assumes a real art in its</p><p>imro+ement and contributes# In Pakistan</p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 4/16</p><p>(hen (e searate our economy into the</p><p>areas (e see that our 6: is "ocused around</p><p>the construction (hich is a si$ni"icant someiece o" our country#</p><p>So&amp;it is "undamental to characterize the mosthu$e reason "or de"erral to e+ade or</p><p>minimize their e""ect on construction</p><p>ro!ects# Causes o" ostonement or delay</p><p>could be clari"ied as indicated by the 1 AN##9hhaomirzya&amp; ho(dy #e At raslh&amp;45667</p><p>'elay in Pro!ect 3*cusable de"er Non%</p><p>3*cusable Comensable Non%Comensable#one o" the basic issues con"ronted by the</p><p>Pakistan construction industry is the re$ular</p><p>and rotracted ostones in such ro!ects#'elay in construction undertakin$s is a</p><p>tyical certainty and an unreasonable</p><p>roblem# Construction delay issues inPakistan (ere discussed in numerous studies</p><p>and break do(n the causes that hel</p><p>construction delays# Consequences o" this</p><p>study sho(ed that the real reason "orde"erral in construction industry o" Pakistan</p><p>is- oor contract administration&amp; unlikely</p><p>lannin$&amp; absence o" holders"inancin$0installment "or "inished (ork&amp;</p><p>outline ad!ustments throu$hout construction&amp;</p><p>calendar de"ers and de"iciencies in materials&amp;</p><p>"or e*amle&amp; cement and steel# The most</p><p>critical reason "or de"erral includeddebasement&amp; corrution&amp; terrorism&amp; delays in</p><p>installments to builders and the ensuin$</p><p>money stream issues throu$houtconstruction&amp; con"i$uration ro$ressions&amp;</p><p>clashes in (ork schedule o" subcontractors&amp;</p><p>moderate choice makin$ and o""icialor$anization in the mana$ers associations&amp;</p><p>lan "ailures&amp; (ork lack and insu""icient</p><p>(ork skills# 'ue to the imact o"</p><p>multinational "irms&amp; the startin$accumulation o" ostonement reasons</p><p>rundo(n relied on uon uni+ersal studies</p><p>and "urther analyzed a$ainst the reasons</p><p>reco$nized in Pakistan# Some ro!ects are!ust a coule o" days behind the calendarE</p><p>some are ostoned o+er months# So it isaramount to think about the real Causes o"</p><p>ostonement to minimize and kee a(ay</p><p>"rom the delay in any construction ro!ect#No( in the ne( schedule ro!ects utilizes</p><p>ne( aroach called the "ast track aroach#</p><p>This has romted the need to inoint</p><p>recisely the si$ni"icant reason "or de"er thatmust be obser+ed throu$hout the (hole</p><p>eriods o" the ro!ect#</p><p>There is like(ise ro$rammin$ accessible(hich (ould ermit e*edient access to</p><p>e*tend delay data and mo+ement</p><p>contributions#"inancial o+errun</p><p>Cost o+errun is characterized as e*ansion</p><p>in $enuine "inance o+er lan# Financeo+errun is additionally here and there called</p><p>"inance escalation&amp;"inance build&amp; or</p><p>lan0bud$et o+errun# Fianacial o+errun ischaracterized as the alter in a$reement o"</p><p>sum di+ision by the basically builder honor</p><p>sum # comutation mi$ht chan$ed o+ercountry (ith country#"inancial o+errun G Final a$reement rice H</p><p>ri$inal a$reement rice actual a$reement</p><p>rice</p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 5/16</p><p>Choudhry 1455@7 clari"ied the cost0"inanceo+errun such as distinction (ith the ori$inal</p><p>"ianc. e+aluation o" +entures and real0actual</p><p>de+eloment "inance on "inish o" (orks# The$ood comletion o" de+eloment ro!ect</p><p>construction acti+ities and (ithin the bud$et</p><p>and a""irmed bud$et rely uon a methodthat# this is not areciable "or builders&amp;</p><p>e*erts on the other hand&amp; numerous tasks</p><p>e*erience (ide de"ers and alon$ these lines</p><p>surass schedule and "inance estimates# an other issue is ob+ious (ith</p><p>con+entional and traditional kind a$reement</p><p>this tye o" a$reement honored to the most</p><p>minimal %bidder% the $rantin$ technique bythe lar$er</p><p>art o" ublic +entures in risin$ nationsincludin$ Pakistan#</p><p>Imro+in$ construction roducti+ity by</p><p>method "or "inance e""ecti+eness and</p><p>scheduleliness (ould ositi+ely hel "inance</p><p>reser+es "or the o+erall# 3*ertions controlled</p><p>to "inance and schedule adequacy connected</p><p>throu$h o+erseein$ schedule and e*ense&amp;</p><p>this study "ocused on by means o" e*lorin$</p><p>schedule and "inance o+erruns o" </p><p>de+eloment +entures in our country</p><p>akistan#A money related comonent is a</p><p>standout amon$st the most basic</p><p>comonents are the reason "or ostones in</p><p>de+eloment +entures# 1%Ala$hbari% et al&amp;</p><p>455J</p><p>'r Tahir Na(as di+ide "inance o+errun into</p><p>"i+e domains#</p><p>6#Finance +erruns 'ue to /o+ernment</p><p>K =ack o" Funds</p><p>K =ack o" Control o+er rice</p><p>K </p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 6/16</p><p>K Frequent Chan$es durin$</p><p>3*ecution</p><p>K =ack o" In+ol+ement inPlannin$ sta$e</p><p>K /old lattin$ "rom</p><p>ContractorK Slo(ness in 'ecision</p><p>2akin$</p><p>K Chan$e o" 'esi$nK 'isrution in Cash%"lo(s</p><p>K Poor Communications</p><p>K Insu""icient Funds</p><p>M# Finance +errun due to ther Factors#</p><p>K 3*treme </p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 7/16</p><p>chan$es in ro!ect concetion&amp; ro!ects</p><p>commitments&amp; delay0de"er in decision</p><p>makin$&amp; $ettin$ mana$ers aro+al&amp;di""iculties in $ettin$ a (ork $rant&amp;</p><p>corresondence and coordicountry issues#</p><p>Chan and 9umaras (amy ha+e done are+ie( to assess the relati+e imortance o"</p><p>;? comonents o" otential ostones in</p><p>construction ro!ects in 8on$ 9on$# They(atched that M si$ni"icant reason "or due</p><p>date slia$e related to mismana$ement o"</p><p>dan$er&amp; terrible suer+ision&amp; state o" the site&amp;</p><p>ostone in takin$ choices&amp; "luctuatin$ clientneeds&amp; +ariety o" (orkin$ schedule#</p><p>Corrution-</p><p>arious meanin$s o" corrut ractice e*ist&amp;makin$ it troublesome to underin#</p><p>Basically&amp; (hat is corrut to one man may</p><p>be +ie(ed as normal ractice to an alternate#</p><p>Case in oint&amp; the 455&gt; CIB Corrution</p><p>study "ound that around 4M o" resondents</p><p>"elt that tolerant or dis$uisin$ "i*es (as</p><p>either not e*cetionally corrut or not</p><p>corrut (hatsoe+er# Transarency Inter</p><p>nationals Bribe Payers Inde* reort "rom</p><p>4566 demonstrates that the constructionbusiness is the most corrut se$ment as "ar</p><p>and (ide as ossible#</p><p>The intricate and di+ided nature o" the</p><p>business $i+es an en+ironment tode"ilement&amp; (ith +arious members in the</p><p>suly chain cometin$ "or hi$h esteem</p><p>contracts# 'e"ilement can take numerousshaes and structures inside the business&amp;</p><p>(ith instances o" ay o"" to acquire</p><p>arran$in$ authorization&amp; the e*a$$eratin$ o"lan&amp; the control o" installment requisitions&amp;</p><p>and lot to imart and artition the business#</p><p>2oreo+er&amp; issues in "ollo(in$ installmentsand "luctuatin$ la("ul re$ulations can</p><p>encoura$e corrut conduct $lobally# </p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan</p><p> 8/16</p><p>As indicated by Oadir 1455?7 in Pakistan a</p><p>ercenta$e o" the "undamental uroses</p><p>behind ost%"reedom de"ilement are-a7 /round A(ards- decision o" a lar$e</p><p>number o" (ithout a roo" o+er head</p><p>throu$h ortion the $rounds "allin$ backon debasement# Fake cases (ere</p><p>a""irmed (ith assi$n</p><p>b7 In another sector called as ri+ate in the6:J5 to 6:;5 and e+en in 6::5 an</p><p>e*tensi+e total eole in $eneral (as</p><p>abused (ith this oen cash near about</p><p>6? billon to 6@ billion ruees into therecords o" these or$anizations#</p><p>c7 Pakistan&amp; s dru$ money is a bi$ roblem</p><p>'ru$ 2oney- Pakistan sa( the assa$e</p><p>o" medication cash in the early ;5sactuatin$ debasement (ith "orti"yin$ the</p><p>antiestablishment economy# e7 Forei$nAid and In+estment-</p><p>$7 In"ormal structure o" National 3conomy-</p><p>A casual and undocumented economycouled (ith careless methodolo$y $a+e</p><p>imressi+e oen doors to the business $rou</p><p>"or un%reasonable ractices#</p><p>h7 Institutional 3rosion-The or$anizations authoritati+e&amp; o""icial</p><p>(ith le$al ne$lected create an arran$ementand equalizations# r$anizational</p><p>disaointment is one o" the rimary dri+er</p><p>o" debasement in our country# Pay o"" is a</p><p>real test indi""erent countries as (ell as in</p><p>India# International comanies in 4564</p><p>ranked this country :@ "rom the 6J&gt;</p><p>countries and 6: 1"rom the 4;7 indi+idually&amp;</p><p>demonstratin$ the si$ni"icance o" the</p><p>sub!ect#</p><p>Another roblem o" called Bribes in</p><p>$o+ernment authorities is still $enuine</p><p>dan$er Indias score has deteriorated in</p><p>last year)s# In a "e( schedules&amp; authorities</p><p>e*ected re(ards a"ter comletin$ their task</p><p>o""icials to dischar$e undertakin$ trusts&amp; "or</p><p>instance&amp; (here they hold stores o"</p><p>contributor or$s# 2oney related control to</p><p>$et "inancin$ ro"its romoters or</p><p>manu"acturers may control bud$etary</p><p>articulations and +aluations to acquire</p><p>"inancin$ on esecially +aluable oints# In</p><p>international sur+ey "or the "rauds&amp; India has</p><p>6&gt; resondents (ere ready to misquote</p><p>"inancial resentation&amp; essentially suerior</p><p>than normal# recent</p><p>"eeble records mana$e oorly records</p><p>administration de"ecti+ely created"rame(orks $i+e an oen door to the control</p><p>o" ossession documentation&amp; includin$ title</p><p>to land ri$hts# Constrained or questionabledata in ractice&amp; it is "requently troublesome</p><p>"or or$anizations to lead due deli$ence on</p><p>contractor&amp; subcontractors and e*ecutorsbecause o" oor data# The resentation o"</p><p>interestin$ identi"iers "or or$anizations and</p><p>the /o+ernment may enhance the</p><p>circumstance# Any(ay acquirin$ to "ul"illand correct recorded data is rone to remain</p><p>a challen$e#</p><p>Shah% Q% Schacter in 455@ Q =an$seth in</p><p>6::: communicated (ith debasement thatthe country articular and shi"ts "rom one</p><p>country toan other country and its causeslike(ise "luctuate startin$ (ith one country</p><p>then onto the ne*t&amp; ho(e+er this is</p><p>concei+able that distin$uish little o" its</p><p>enter oints "ocused around in%ro"unditynation studies in (hich Amon$ the rimary</p><p>helin$ elements arran$ements&amp; are</p><p>e*ercises that are mis$uided (ith o+ersa(&amp;</p><p>"allin$ "lat o" resonsibility andtransarency and# ublic ser+ants&amp; "ailin$ too""er an administration mindset# </p></li><li><p>8/9/2019 Causes of Delay in construction projects in Pakistan...</p></li></ul>