4
Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy Abstract—The occurrence of an aura is often considered evidence of a partial rather than an idiopathic generalized epilepsy syndrome. The authors exam- ined this hypothesis by prospectively recording reports of auras by patients being admitted for video-EEG monitoring. Auras were equally common (70%) among patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy as they were among those with localization-related epilepsy. Presence of an aura is not a reliable indica- tor of localization-related epilepsy. NEUROLOGY 2006;67:343–345 L.S. Boylan, MD; D.L. Labovitz, MD, MS; S.C. Jackson, RN, MA; K. Starner, RN, MS; and O. Devinsky, MD Epileptic auras are subjective symptoms that herald frank seizures in people with epilepsy. They are clas- sically considered a sign of a partial seizure with characteristic phenomenology determined by the site of onset or early spread in the brain. For example, de ´ja ` vu and a rising epigastric aura are associated with temporal lobe epilepsy, focal motor seizures re- flect ictal activity in the motor cortex, and elemen- tary visual symptoms are associated with occipital lobe epilepsy. The presence of an aura is considered evidence that epilepsy is of focal origin and that any subsequent generalized event is secondarily general- ized. The distinction between a partial and general- ized onset seizure affects diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis. The authors systematically evaluated au- ras in a series of patients admitted to an inpatient video-EEG monitoring unit for evaluation. Methods. Data were prospectively collected from adults admit- ted to the New York University Comprehensive Epilepsy Center inpatient video-EEG monitoring unit from April 16, 2001 to Sep- tember 16, 2002. This study was approved by the New York Uni- versity Institutional Review Board, and all subjects gave informed consent. Inclusion criteria were age older than 17 years, estab- lished epilepsy for 1 year as diagnosed by the admitting neurol- ogist, ability to speak and read English, and capacity to consent. Demographic and clinical information including age at epilepsy onset, seizure frequency, seizure subtypes, medication history, and psychiatric history were recorded by the admitting resident on the day of admission using a standardized admission template. On enrollment, subjects completed a questionnaire on symptoms before and after seizures. The questionnaire on symptoms sur- rounding seizures included the text “Sometimes people have a warning that they are going to have a seizure. The warning may come right before a seizure (this is often called an ‘aura’) or it might come hours or days before a seizure.” Patients who an- swered in the affirmative to the question “Can you tell that you are going to have a seizure seconds or minutes before it happens?” were considered to have an aura. Subjects responding yes were asked to provided a brief description of their symptoms (a blank of inch of space was provided). Diagnoses of epilepsy type were based on the final video-EEG report. p Values ( .05) were calculated with the Mantel-Haenszel 2 statistic or Fisher exact test (for cell sizes 5) for categorical data or two-tailed t tests for continuous data. Results. Complete data were available for 154 subjects (table 1). Twenty subjects had idiopathic generalized epi- lepsy (IGE). One patient with IGE also had nonepileptic seizures and reported pleomorphic auras. We excluded this patient from further analysis. There were two patients whose final video-EEG report noted features of both localization-related epilepsy and IGE. The first patient de- scribed her events as generalized tonic-clonic (GTC) sei- zures with an aura of “hiccups.” Two typical events were recorded. Both consisted of initial surface negative facial and diaphragmatic myoclonus followed by a GTC seizure with generalized EEG onset. During sleep she had occa- sional temporal sharp waves. She was classified as having IGE with an aura. The other patient with electrographic features of both IGE and localization-related epilepsy had typical events consisting of GTC seizures with an aura of “feeling terrible.” No clinical events were recorded during monitoring; however, the interictal EEG showed daily frontotemporal left hemisphere spike and wave activity as well as frequent generalized bursts of spikes. This patient was categorized, along with those with multifocal or extra- temporal epilepsy, as having “other focal epilepsy” (table 1). Characteristics of patients with IGE with and without auras are shown in table 2. Patients with IGE were just as likely to report aura symptoms as those with localization-related epilepsy. Pres- ence of an aura did not distinguish between patient groups based on any clinical variable except that those whose epilepsy type remained undiagnosed at the end of video- EEG monitoring were less likely to have an aura than those with better characterized epilepsy syndromes (p 0.02). Described auras among subjects with IGE were vari- able and included a range of subjective sensations “I get a feeling in my body that I just know,” “I get a pain in the head or feel light-headed,” “I get a warm sensation in my body,” “like a rising feeling,” “nausea, slow processing, sweating,” “strong head rush,” “light-headed, off balance, panicky,” “pulsating feeling in left hand,” “finger or head numbness,” “shaky feeling all over, spacey feeling in my head,” “feeling coursing through my body, my blood compo- sition changes, I’m very alert.” One patient described a visual aura “colors flow around people’s bodies (not ob- jects).” Two subjects reported motor phenomenon of “hic- cups” and “jumps or jerks.” Auras reported repeatedly by patients with video-EEG– confirmed temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) but not by those From the New York University School of Medicine (L.S.B., S.C.J., K.S., O.D.), Bellevue Hospital Center (L.S.B.), New York University Comprehen- sive Epilepsy Center (S.C.J., K.S., O.D.), St. Luke’s-Roosevelt Hospital Cen- ter (D.L.L.), New York, NY. Disclosure: The authors report no conflicts of interest. Received September 27, 2005. Accepted in final form March 20, 2006. Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Laura S. Boylan, De- partment of Neurology, New York University School of Medicine, 462 First Avenue, New York, NY 10016; [email protected] Copyright © 2006 by AAN Enterprises, Inc. 343

Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

  • Upload
    o

  • View
    215

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

Auras are frequent inidiopathic generalized

epilepsy

AbstractmdashThe occurrence of an aura is often considered evidence of a partialrather than an idiopathic generalized epilepsy syndrome The authors exam-ined this hypothesis by prospectively recording reports of auras by patientsbeing admitted for video-EEG monitoring Auras were equally common (70)among patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy as they were among thosewith localization-related epilepsy Presence of an aura is not a reliable indica-tor of localization-related epilepsy

NEUROLOGY 200667343ndash345

LS Boylan MD DL Labovitz MD MS SC Jackson RN MA K Starner RN MS and O Devinsky MD

Epileptic auras are subjective symptoms that heraldfrank seizures in people with epilepsy They are clas-sically considered a sign of a partial seizure withcharacteristic phenomenology determined by the siteof onset or early spread in the brain For exampledeja vu and a rising epigastric aura are associatedwith temporal lobe epilepsy focal motor seizures re-flect ictal activity in the motor cortex and elemen-tary visual symptoms are associated with occipitallobe epilepsy The presence of an aura is consideredevidence that epilepsy is of focal origin and that anysubsequent generalized event is secondarily general-ized The distinction between a partial and general-ized onset seizure affects diagnosis treatment andprognosis The authors systematically evaluated au-ras in a series of patients admitted to an inpatientvideo-EEG monitoring unit for evaluation

Methods Data were prospectively collected from adults admit-ted to the New York University Comprehensive Epilepsy Centerinpatient video-EEG monitoring unit from April 16 2001 to Sep-tember 16 2002 This study was approved by the New York Uni-versity Institutional Review Board and all subjects gave informedconsent Inclusion criteria were age older than 17 years estab-lished epilepsy for 1 year as diagnosed by the admitting neurol-ogist ability to speak and read English and capacity to consent

Demographic and clinical information including age at epilepsyonset seizure frequency seizure subtypes medication historyand psychiatric history were recorded by the admitting residenton the day of admission using a standardized admission templateOn enrollment subjects completed a questionnaire on symptomsbefore and after seizures The questionnaire on symptoms sur-rounding seizures included the text ldquoSometimes people have awarning that they are going to have a seizure The warning maycome right before a seizure (this is often called an lsquoaurarsquo) or itmight come hours or days before a seizurerdquo Patients who an-swered in the affirmative to the question ldquoCan you tell that youare going to have a seizure seconds or minutes before it happensrdquowere considered to have an aura Subjects responding yes wereasked to provided a brief description of their symptoms (a blank ofinch of space was provided) Diagnoses of epilepsy type were basedon the final video-EEG report

p Values ( 05) were calculated with the Mantel-Haenszel2 statistic or Fisher exact test (for cell sizes 5) for categoricaldata or two-tailed t tests for continuous data

Results Complete data were available for 154 subjects(table 1) Twenty subjects had idiopathic generalized epi-lepsy (IGE) One patient with IGE also had nonepilepticseizures and reported pleomorphic auras We excluded thispatient from further analysis There were two patientswhose final video-EEG report noted features of bothlocalization-related epilepsy and IGE The first patient de-scribed her events as generalized tonic-clonic (GTC) sei-zures with an aura of ldquohiccupsrdquo Two typical events wererecorded Both consisted of initial surface negative facialand diaphragmatic myoclonus followed by a GTC seizurewith generalized EEG onset During sleep she had occa-sional temporal sharp waves She was classified as havingIGE with an aura The other patient with electrographicfeatures of both IGE and localization-related epilepsy hadtypical events consisting of GTC seizures with an aura ofldquofeeling terriblerdquo No clinical events were recorded duringmonitoring however the interictal EEG showed dailyfrontotemporal left hemisphere spike and wave activity aswell as frequent generalized bursts of spikes This patientwas categorized along with those with multifocal or extra-temporal epilepsy as having ldquoother focal epilepsyrdquo (table1) Characteristics of patients with IGE with and withoutauras are shown in table 2

Patients with IGE were just as likely to report aurasymptoms as those with localization-related epilepsy Pres-ence of an aura did not distinguish between patient groupsbased on any clinical variable except that those whoseepilepsy type remained undiagnosed at the end of video-EEG monitoring were less likely to have an aura thanthose with better characterized epilepsy syndromes (p 002) Described auras among subjects with IGE were vari-able and included a range of subjective sensations ldquoI get afeeling in my body that I just knowrdquo ldquoI get a pain in thehead or feel light-headedrdquo ldquoI get a warm sensation in mybodyrdquo ldquolike a rising feelingrdquo ldquonausea slow processingsweatingrdquo ldquostrong head rushrdquo ldquolight-headed off balancepanickyrdquo ldquopulsating feeling in left handrdquo ldquofinger or headnumbnessrdquo ldquoshaky feeling all over spacey feeling in myheadrdquo ldquofeeling coursing through my body my blood compo-sition changes Irsquom very alertrdquo One patient described avisual aura ldquocolors flow around peoplersquos bodies (not ob-jects)rdquo Two subjects reported motor phenomenon of ldquohic-cupsrdquo and ldquojumps or jerksrdquo

Auras reported repeatedly by patients with video-EEGndashconfirmed temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) but not by those

From the New York University School of Medicine (LSB SCJ KSOD) Bellevue Hospital Center (LSB) New York University Comprehen-sive Epilepsy Center (SCJ KS OD) St Lukersquos-Roosevelt Hospital Cen-ter (DLL) New York NY

Disclosure The authors report no conflicts of interest

Received September 27 2005 Accepted in final form March 20 2006

Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Laura S Boylan De-partment of Neurology New York University School of Medicine 462 FirstAvenue New York NY 10016 lauraboylanmednyuedu

Copyright copy 2006 by AAN Enterprises Inc 343

with IGE included hearing complex and elementary audi-tory hallucinations (983 patients with TLE) deja vu phe-nomena (683) and olfactory or gustatory auras (683) Arange of auras that could be described as ldquorising epigastricsensationsrdquo were described by patients with TLE (1583)although some of the descriptions of aura in IGE might beconsidered to fall in this category as well (214) The pres-ence or absence of an aura was not consistently included invideo-EEG reports so we cannot comment categorically onEEG correlates of auras However when auras were spe-cifically noted as present they were generally surface neg-ative Of the 14 patients with auras and IGE seven had apremonitoring diagnosis of complex partial seizures

Discussion We found a high prevalence of aurasin IGE (70) However an array of other data high-lights other focal characteristics of IGE Animal andhuman data suggest that so-called generalized sei-zures involve selective thalamocortical networks

while sparing others1 Dense-array EEG recordingtechniques in patients with absence seizures re-vealed that onset was typically focal to the dorsolat-eral or orbital frontal cortex2 In another study mostpatients with IGE (56) had some electrographic ev-idence of focality3 Detailed video reviews of general-ized seizures revealed focal features of ictalsemiology in seven of 10 subjects in one study4 andthree of three patients with IGE found in a series of300 monitored epilepsy patients in another despitean initially generalized EEG5 The most common fo-cal feature in both reports was head version Anearlier study that systematically queried patientswith juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME) for the pres-ence or absence of visual aura or conscious headversion found that these were not rare6 Among sub-jects from families with both JME and idiopathicphotosensitive occipital lobe epilepsy 10 of 12 had

Table 1 Clinical characteristics of epilepsy patients with and without auras (N 154)

All subjects Subjects with an aura Subjects without an aura p Value

Age y mean (range) 385 (19ndash75) 378 (19ndash74) 396 (19ndash75) 04184

Sex no ()

Male 62 (40) 35 (56) 27 (44) 01295

Female 92 (60) 63 (68) 29 (32)

Age at epilepsy onset y mean (range) 215 (0ndash73) 196 (2ndash66) 246 (0ndash73) 00668

Duration of seizure disorder y mean (range) 170 (0ndash55) 181 (0ndash53) 151 (0ndash53) 01614

Education y mean (range) 142 (8ndash20) 141 (8ndash20) 145 (10ndash20) 04353

Current medications mean (range) 18 (0-6) 19 (0-4) 17 (0-6) 03022

Epilepsy type no ()

Idiopathic generalized 20 (13) 14 (70) 6 (30) Ref

All focal epilepsy 104 (68) 73 (70) 31 (30) 09863

Temporal 83 (54) 63 (76) 20 (24) 05862

Other focal 21 (14) 10 (48) 11 (52) 01501

Undetermined 30 (19) 11 (37) 19 (63) 00241

Laterality no ()

Left 54 (52) 38 (70) 16 (30) Ref

Right 27 (26) 21 (78) 6 (22) 04816

Bilateral 23 (22) 14 (61) 9 (39) 04165

n 94 60 patients with missing data Subjects with missing data did not differ on other measures from subjects for whom data were available

dagger For patients with focal epilepsy only

Table 2 Characteristics of patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy with and without auras (n 19)

All subjects Subjects with an aura Subjects without an aura p Value

Age y mean (range) 301 (21ndash50) 268 (21ndash35) 370 (21ndash50) 00731

Sex no ()

Male 7 (37) 6 (86) 1 (14) 03331

Female 12 (63) 7 (58) 5 (42)

Age at epilepsy onset y mean (range) 122 (4ndash20) 130 (6ndash20) 103 (4ndash15) 02862

Duration of seizure disorder y mean (range) 179 (2ndash46) 138 (2ndash23) 267 (12ndash46) 00062

Seizure type no ()

GTC only 5 (26) 3 (60) 2 (40) Ref

GTC and absence 6 (32) 6 (100) 0 (0) 01818

GTC and myoclonic 3 (16) 2 (67) 1 (33) 05357

GTC absence and myoclonic 5 (26) 2 (40) 3 (60) 03968

All subjects had generalized tonic-clonic seizures

GTC generalized tonic clonic

344 NEUROLOGY 67 July (2 of 2) 2006

visual auras and six of 12 had conscious head ver-sion Even among patients with sporadic JME threeof 40 reported visual auras and two of 40 had con-scious head version

In our sample auras were found just as oftenamong those with IGE as among those withlocalization-related epilepsy Auditory olfactory andgustatory as well as deja vu auras were reportedcommonly by patients with TLE but not at all bythose with IGE In contrast symptoms that could becategorized under the rubric of a ldquorising epigastricsensationrdquo were seen in both IGE and TLE

Patients not reporting an aura were less likely tobe given an epilepsy characterization at the end ofmonitoring perhaps reflecting greater hesitancy ofdiagnosticians in these circumstances (table 1)Among patients with IGE those with an aura had asignificantly shorter duration of seizure disorderthan those without an aura (table 2) possibly reflect-ing earlier referral for monitoring among patientswith aura as patients with partial epilepsy may becandidates for surgical intervention Indeed half ofthe patients with auras and IGE were thought at thetime of admission to be having complex partial sei-zures The rates of aura are higher among men thanamong women and among those with both GTC andabsence seizures (table 2) but these differences did

not reach significance and further investigation isneeded

Even accounting for referral bias it is reasonableto conclude that the presence of auras is not rare inIGE and should not be relied on for diagnosis of typeof epilepsy The presence of auras in IGE suggests arole for focal hyperexcitability in the genesis of sei-zures characterized by generalized onset as mea-sured by conventional surface EEG Elucidation ofunderlying mechanisms of this focal activity maycontribute to the development of seizure predictionalgorithms and novel therapeutic approaches in IGE

References1 Blumenfeld H From molecules to networks corticalsubcortical interac-

tions in the pathophysiology of idiopathic generalized epilepsy Epilepsia200344(suppl 2)7ndash15

2 Holmes MD Brown M Tucker DM Are ldquogeneralizedrdquo seizures trulygeneralized Evidence of localized mesial frontal and frontopolar dis-charges in absence Epilepsia 2004451568ndash1579

3 Lombroso CT Consistent EEG focalities detected in subjects with pri-mary generalized epilepsies monitored for two decades Epilepsia 199738797ndash812

4 Niaz FE Abou-Khalil B Fakhoury T The generalized tonic-clonic sei-zure in partial versus generalized epilepsy semiologic differences Epi-lepsia 1999401664ndash1666

5 Casaubon L Pohlmann-Eden B Khosravani H Carlen PL Wennberg RVideo-EEG evidence of lateralized clinical features in primary general-ized epilepsy with tonic-clonic seizures Epileptic Disord 20035149ndash156

6 Taylor I Marini C Johnson MR Turner S Berkovic SF Scheffer IEJuvenile myoclonic epilepsy and idiopathic photosensitive occipital lobeepilepsy is there overlap Brain 20041271878ndash1886

ACCESS wwwneurologyorg NOWFOR FULL-TEXT ARTICLES

Neurology online is now available to all subscribers Our online version features extensive search capability by title keywords article key words and author names Subscribers can search full-text article Neurology archives to 1999 andcan access link references with PubMed The one-time activation requires only your subscriber number whichappears on your mailing label If this label is not available to you call 1-800-638-3030 (United States) or 1-301-714-2300 (outside United States) to obtain this number

July (2 of 2) 2006 NEUROLOGY 67 345

DOI 10121201wnl00002251853708197200667343-345 Neurology

L S Boylan D L Labovitz S C Jackson et al Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

This information is current as of July 24 2006

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlref-list-1

This article cites 5 articles 1 of which you can access for free at

Citations httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlotherarticles

This article has been cited by 1 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionclinical_neurology_historyClinical neurology history

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionantiepileptic_drugsAntiepileptic drugs

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionall_epilepsy_seizuresAll EpilepsySeizuresfollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaboutxhtmlpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaddirxhtmlreprintsusInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright All rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 2: Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

with IGE included hearing complex and elementary audi-tory hallucinations (983 patients with TLE) deja vu phe-nomena (683) and olfactory or gustatory auras (683) Arange of auras that could be described as ldquorising epigastricsensationsrdquo were described by patients with TLE (1583)although some of the descriptions of aura in IGE might beconsidered to fall in this category as well (214) The pres-ence or absence of an aura was not consistently included invideo-EEG reports so we cannot comment categorically onEEG correlates of auras However when auras were spe-cifically noted as present they were generally surface neg-ative Of the 14 patients with auras and IGE seven had apremonitoring diagnosis of complex partial seizures

Discussion We found a high prevalence of aurasin IGE (70) However an array of other data high-lights other focal characteristics of IGE Animal andhuman data suggest that so-called generalized sei-zures involve selective thalamocortical networks

while sparing others1 Dense-array EEG recordingtechniques in patients with absence seizures re-vealed that onset was typically focal to the dorsolat-eral or orbital frontal cortex2 In another study mostpatients with IGE (56) had some electrographic ev-idence of focality3 Detailed video reviews of general-ized seizures revealed focal features of ictalsemiology in seven of 10 subjects in one study4 andthree of three patients with IGE found in a series of300 monitored epilepsy patients in another despitean initially generalized EEG5 The most common fo-cal feature in both reports was head version Anearlier study that systematically queried patientswith juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME) for the pres-ence or absence of visual aura or conscious headversion found that these were not rare6 Among sub-jects from families with both JME and idiopathicphotosensitive occipital lobe epilepsy 10 of 12 had

Table 1 Clinical characteristics of epilepsy patients with and without auras (N 154)

All subjects Subjects with an aura Subjects without an aura p Value

Age y mean (range) 385 (19ndash75) 378 (19ndash74) 396 (19ndash75) 04184

Sex no ()

Male 62 (40) 35 (56) 27 (44) 01295

Female 92 (60) 63 (68) 29 (32)

Age at epilepsy onset y mean (range) 215 (0ndash73) 196 (2ndash66) 246 (0ndash73) 00668

Duration of seizure disorder y mean (range) 170 (0ndash55) 181 (0ndash53) 151 (0ndash53) 01614

Education y mean (range) 142 (8ndash20) 141 (8ndash20) 145 (10ndash20) 04353

Current medications mean (range) 18 (0-6) 19 (0-4) 17 (0-6) 03022

Epilepsy type no ()

Idiopathic generalized 20 (13) 14 (70) 6 (30) Ref

All focal epilepsy 104 (68) 73 (70) 31 (30) 09863

Temporal 83 (54) 63 (76) 20 (24) 05862

Other focal 21 (14) 10 (48) 11 (52) 01501

Undetermined 30 (19) 11 (37) 19 (63) 00241

Laterality no ()

Left 54 (52) 38 (70) 16 (30) Ref

Right 27 (26) 21 (78) 6 (22) 04816

Bilateral 23 (22) 14 (61) 9 (39) 04165

n 94 60 patients with missing data Subjects with missing data did not differ on other measures from subjects for whom data were available

dagger For patients with focal epilepsy only

Table 2 Characteristics of patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy with and without auras (n 19)

All subjects Subjects with an aura Subjects without an aura p Value

Age y mean (range) 301 (21ndash50) 268 (21ndash35) 370 (21ndash50) 00731

Sex no ()

Male 7 (37) 6 (86) 1 (14) 03331

Female 12 (63) 7 (58) 5 (42)

Age at epilepsy onset y mean (range) 122 (4ndash20) 130 (6ndash20) 103 (4ndash15) 02862

Duration of seizure disorder y mean (range) 179 (2ndash46) 138 (2ndash23) 267 (12ndash46) 00062

Seizure type no ()

GTC only 5 (26) 3 (60) 2 (40) Ref

GTC and absence 6 (32) 6 (100) 0 (0) 01818

GTC and myoclonic 3 (16) 2 (67) 1 (33) 05357

GTC absence and myoclonic 5 (26) 2 (40) 3 (60) 03968

All subjects had generalized tonic-clonic seizures

GTC generalized tonic clonic

344 NEUROLOGY 67 July (2 of 2) 2006

visual auras and six of 12 had conscious head ver-sion Even among patients with sporadic JME threeof 40 reported visual auras and two of 40 had con-scious head version

In our sample auras were found just as oftenamong those with IGE as among those withlocalization-related epilepsy Auditory olfactory andgustatory as well as deja vu auras were reportedcommonly by patients with TLE but not at all bythose with IGE In contrast symptoms that could becategorized under the rubric of a ldquorising epigastricsensationrdquo were seen in both IGE and TLE

Patients not reporting an aura were less likely tobe given an epilepsy characterization at the end ofmonitoring perhaps reflecting greater hesitancy ofdiagnosticians in these circumstances (table 1)Among patients with IGE those with an aura had asignificantly shorter duration of seizure disorderthan those without an aura (table 2) possibly reflect-ing earlier referral for monitoring among patientswith aura as patients with partial epilepsy may becandidates for surgical intervention Indeed half ofthe patients with auras and IGE were thought at thetime of admission to be having complex partial sei-zures The rates of aura are higher among men thanamong women and among those with both GTC andabsence seizures (table 2) but these differences did

not reach significance and further investigation isneeded

Even accounting for referral bias it is reasonableto conclude that the presence of auras is not rare inIGE and should not be relied on for diagnosis of typeof epilepsy The presence of auras in IGE suggests arole for focal hyperexcitability in the genesis of sei-zures characterized by generalized onset as mea-sured by conventional surface EEG Elucidation ofunderlying mechanisms of this focal activity maycontribute to the development of seizure predictionalgorithms and novel therapeutic approaches in IGE

References1 Blumenfeld H From molecules to networks corticalsubcortical interac-

tions in the pathophysiology of idiopathic generalized epilepsy Epilepsia200344(suppl 2)7ndash15

2 Holmes MD Brown M Tucker DM Are ldquogeneralizedrdquo seizures trulygeneralized Evidence of localized mesial frontal and frontopolar dis-charges in absence Epilepsia 2004451568ndash1579

3 Lombroso CT Consistent EEG focalities detected in subjects with pri-mary generalized epilepsies monitored for two decades Epilepsia 199738797ndash812

4 Niaz FE Abou-Khalil B Fakhoury T The generalized tonic-clonic sei-zure in partial versus generalized epilepsy semiologic differences Epi-lepsia 1999401664ndash1666

5 Casaubon L Pohlmann-Eden B Khosravani H Carlen PL Wennberg RVideo-EEG evidence of lateralized clinical features in primary general-ized epilepsy with tonic-clonic seizures Epileptic Disord 20035149ndash156

6 Taylor I Marini C Johnson MR Turner S Berkovic SF Scheffer IEJuvenile myoclonic epilepsy and idiopathic photosensitive occipital lobeepilepsy is there overlap Brain 20041271878ndash1886

ACCESS wwwneurologyorg NOWFOR FULL-TEXT ARTICLES

Neurology online is now available to all subscribers Our online version features extensive search capability by title keywords article key words and author names Subscribers can search full-text article Neurology archives to 1999 andcan access link references with PubMed The one-time activation requires only your subscriber number whichappears on your mailing label If this label is not available to you call 1-800-638-3030 (United States) or 1-301-714-2300 (outside United States) to obtain this number

July (2 of 2) 2006 NEUROLOGY 67 345

DOI 10121201wnl00002251853708197200667343-345 Neurology

L S Boylan D L Labovitz S C Jackson et al Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

This information is current as of July 24 2006

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlref-list-1

This article cites 5 articles 1 of which you can access for free at

Citations httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlotherarticles

This article has been cited by 1 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionclinical_neurology_historyClinical neurology history

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionantiepileptic_drugsAntiepileptic drugs

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionall_epilepsy_seizuresAll EpilepsySeizuresfollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaboutxhtmlpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaddirxhtmlreprintsusInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright All rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 3: Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

visual auras and six of 12 had conscious head ver-sion Even among patients with sporadic JME threeof 40 reported visual auras and two of 40 had con-scious head version

In our sample auras were found just as oftenamong those with IGE as among those withlocalization-related epilepsy Auditory olfactory andgustatory as well as deja vu auras were reportedcommonly by patients with TLE but not at all bythose with IGE In contrast symptoms that could becategorized under the rubric of a ldquorising epigastricsensationrdquo were seen in both IGE and TLE

Patients not reporting an aura were less likely tobe given an epilepsy characterization at the end ofmonitoring perhaps reflecting greater hesitancy ofdiagnosticians in these circumstances (table 1)Among patients with IGE those with an aura had asignificantly shorter duration of seizure disorderthan those without an aura (table 2) possibly reflect-ing earlier referral for monitoring among patientswith aura as patients with partial epilepsy may becandidates for surgical intervention Indeed half ofthe patients with auras and IGE were thought at thetime of admission to be having complex partial sei-zures The rates of aura are higher among men thanamong women and among those with both GTC andabsence seizures (table 2) but these differences did

not reach significance and further investigation isneeded

Even accounting for referral bias it is reasonableto conclude that the presence of auras is not rare inIGE and should not be relied on for diagnosis of typeof epilepsy The presence of auras in IGE suggests arole for focal hyperexcitability in the genesis of sei-zures characterized by generalized onset as mea-sured by conventional surface EEG Elucidation ofunderlying mechanisms of this focal activity maycontribute to the development of seizure predictionalgorithms and novel therapeutic approaches in IGE

References1 Blumenfeld H From molecules to networks corticalsubcortical interac-

tions in the pathophysiology of idiopathic generalized epilepsy Epilepsia200344(suppl 2)7ndash15

2 Holmes MD Brown M Tucker DM Are ldquogeneralizedrdquo seizures trulygeneralized Evidence of localized mesial frontal and frontopolar dis-charges in absence Epilepsia 2004451568ndash1579

3 Lombroso CT Consistent EEG focalities detected in subjects with pri-mary generalized epilepsies monitored for two decades Epilepsia 199738797ndash812

4 Niaz FE Abou-Khalil B Fakhoury T The generalized tonic-clonic sei-zure in partial versus generalized epilepsy semiologic differences Epi-lepsia 1999401664ndash1666

5 Casaubon L Pohlmann-Eden B Khosravani H Carlen PL Wennberg RVideo-EEG evidence of lateralized clinical features in primary general-ized epilepsy with tonic-clonic seizures Epileptic Disord 20035149ndash156

6 Taylor I Marini C Johnson MR Turner S Berkovic SF Scheffer IEJuvenile myoclonic epilepsy and idiopathic photosensitive occipital lobeepilepsy is there overlap Brain 20041271878ndash1886

ACCESS wwwneurologyorg NOWFOR FULL-TEXT ARTICLES

Neurology online is now available to all subscribers Our online version features extensive search capability by title keywords article key words and author names Subscribers can search full-text article Neurology archives to 1999 andcan access link references with PubMed The one-time activation requires only your subscriber number whichappears on your mailing label If this label is not available to you call 1-800-638-3030 (United States) or 1-301-714-2300 (outside United States) to obtain this number

July (2 of 2) 2006 NEUROLOGY 67 345

DOI 10121201wnl00002251853708197200667343-345 Neurology

L S Boylan D L Labovitz S C Jackson et al Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

This information is current as of July 24 2006

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlref-list-1

This article cites 5 articles 1 of which you can access for free at

Citations httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlotherarticles

This article has been cited by 1 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionclinical_neurology_historyClinical neurology history

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionantiepileptic_drugsAntiepileptic drugs

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionall_epilepsy_seizuresAll EpilepsySeizuresfollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaboutxhtmlpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaddirxhtmlreprintsusInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright All rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 4: Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

DOI 10121201wnl00002251853708197200667343-345 Neurology

L S Boylan D L Labovitz S C Jackson et al Auras are frequent in idiopathic generalized epilepsy

This information is current as of July 24 2006

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlref-list-1

This article cites 5 articles 1 of which you can access for free at

Citations httpwwwneurologyorgcontent672343fullhtmlotherarticles

This article has been cited by 1 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionclinical_neurology_historyClinical neurology history

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionantiepileptic_drugsAntiepileptic drugs

httpwwwneurologyorgcgicollectionall_epilepsy_seizuresAll EpilepsySeizuresfollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaboutxhtmlpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpwwwneurologyorgmiscaddirxhtmlreprintsusInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright All rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology