51
Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks Summary

Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    21

  • Download
    4

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Artificial neural networks:

Introduction, or how the brain worksThe neuron as a simple computing elementThe perceptronMultilayer neural networksSummary

Page 2: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

How the brain works?

Intelligent machine: ‘The computer hasn’t proved anything

yet’, angry Garry Kasparov, the world chess champion, said after his defeat in New York in May 1997.

The greatest chess player was beaten by a computer.

Page 3: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Machine Learning (ML)Involves adaptive mechanisms that enable computers to learn from experience, learn by example and learn by analogyLearning capabilities can improve the performance of an intelligent system over timeAmong approaches to ML are ANNs and GAs.

Page 4: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Soma Soma

Synapse

Synapse

Dendrites

Axon

Synapse

DendritesAxon

Biological Neural Network

Page 5: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Biological Neural Network-Typical Neuron-Dendrites

Nucleus

Page 6: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Neural NetworkA neural network can be defined as a model of reasoning based on the human brain. The brain consists of a densely interconnected set of nerve cells, or basic information-processing units, called neurons. The human brain incorporates nearly 10 billion neurons and 60 trillion connections, synapses, between them. By using multiple neurons simultaneously, the brain can perform its functions much faster than the fastest computers in existence today.

Page 7: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Neural Network

Each neuron has a very simple structure, but an army of such elements constitutes a tremendous processing power. A neuron consists of a cell body, soma, a number of fibers called dendrites, and a single long fiber called the axon.Our brain can be considered as a highly complex, non-linear and parallel information-processing system.

Page 8: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Information is stored and processed in a neural network simultaneously throughout the whole network, rather than at specific locations. In other words, in neural networks, both data and its processing are global rather than local.Learning is a fundamental and essential characteristic of biological neural networks. The ease with which they can learn led to attempts to emulate a biological neural network in a computer.

Neural Network

Page 9: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Artificial Neural Network-Simple Neuron-

●●●

Neuron Y

Y

Y

Y

Input Signals Weights Output Signals

w1

w2

wn

Raw data/outputs of other neurons

Final solution/input of other neurons

Computes activation level

Page 10: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Artificial Neural NetworkAn artificial neural network consists of a number of very simple processors, also called neurons, which are analogous to the biological neurons in the brain.

The neurons are connected by weighted links passing signals from one neuron to another.

The output signal is transmitted through the neuron’s outgoing connection. The outgoing connection splits into a number of branches that transmit the same signal. The outgoing branches terminate at the incoming connections of other neurons in the network.

Page 11: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Architecture of a typical artificial neural network

Input Layer Output Layer

Middle Layer

I n p

u t

S i

g n

a l s

O u

t p

u t

S i

g n

a l s

Page 12: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Biological Neural Network Artificial Neural NetworkSomaDendriteAxonSynapse

NeuronInputOutputWeight

Analogy between biological and artificial neural networks

Page 13: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The neuron as a simple computing elementDiagram of a neuron

Neuron Y

Input Signals

x1

x2

xn

Output Signals

Y

Y

Y

w2

w1

wn

Weights

Page 14: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The neuron computes the weighted sum of the input signals and compares the result with a threshold value, θ. If the net input is less than the threshold, the neuron output is –1. But if the net input is greater than or equal to the threshold, the neuron becomes activated and its output attains a value +1.The neuron uses the following transfer or activationfunction:

This type of activation function is called a sign function.

∑=

=n

iiiwxX

1 ⎩⎨⎧

θ<−θ≥+

=XX

Y if ,1 if ,1

Page 15: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Activation functions of a neuron

Step function Sign function

+1

-10

+1

-10X

Y

X

Y+1

-10 X

Y

Sigmoid function

+1

-10 X

Y

Linear function

⎩⎨⎧

<≥

=0 if ,00 if ,1

XX

Ystep⎩⎨⎧

<−≥+

=0 if ,10 if ,1

XX

YsignX

sigmoid

eY

−+=

1

1 XYlinear=

Page 16: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Can a single neuron learn a task?

In 1958, Frank Rosenblatt introduced a training algorithm that provided the first procedure for training a simple ANN: a perceptron. The perceptron is the simplest form of a neural network. It consists of a single neuron with adjustable synaptic weights and a hard limiter.

Page 17: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Threshold

Inputs

x1

x2

OutputY∑

HardLimiter

w2

w1

LinearCombiner

θ

Single-layer two-input perceptron

Page 18: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The Perceptron

The operation of Rosenblatt’s perceptron is based on the McCulloch and Pitts neuron model. The model consists of a linear combiner followed by a hard limiter. The weighted sum of the inputs is applied to the hard limiter, which produces an output equal to +1 if its input is positive and −1 if it is negative.

Page 19: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The aim of the perceptron is to classify inputs, x1, x2, . . ., xn, into one of two classes, say A1 and A2. In the case of an elementary perceptron, the n-dimensional space is divided by a hyperplane into two decision regions. The hyperplane is defined by the linearly separable function:

01

=θ−∑=

n

iiiwx

Page 20: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Linear separability in the perceptrons

x1

x2

Class A2

Class A1

1

2

x1w1 + x2w2 − θ = 0

(a) Two-input perceptron. (b) Three-input perceptron.

x2

x1

x3x1w1 + x2w2 + x3w3 − θ = 0

1 2

Page 21: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Solving OR..AND problem0 or 0 = 00 or 1=11 or 0 = 11 or 1 =1X1 or x2 = y

0 and 0 = 00 and 1= 01 and 0 = 01 and 1 =1X1 and x2 =y

Page 22: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

This is done by making small adjustments in the weights to reduce the difference between the actual/estimated and desired/target outputs of the perceptron. The initial weights are randomly assigned, usually in the range [−0.5, 0.5], and then updated to obtain the output consistent with the training examples.

How does the perceptron learn its classification tasks?

Page 23: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

If at iteration p, the actual output is Y(p) and the desired output is Yd (p), then the error is given by:

where p = 1, 2, 3, . . .

Iteration p here refers to the pth training example presented to the perceptron.If the error, e(p), is positive, we need to increase perceptron output Y(p), but if it is negative, we need to decrease Y(p).

)()()( pYpYpe d −=

Page 24: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The perceptron learning rule

where p = 1, 2, 3, . . .α is the learning rate, a positive constant less thanunity.

The perceptron learning rule was first proposed byRosenblatt in 1960. Using this rule we can derive the perceptron training algorithm for classification tasks.

)()()()1( pepxpwpw iii ⋅⋅+=+ α

Page 25: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 1: InitialisationSet initial weights w1, w2,…, wn and threshold θto random numbers in the range [−0.5, 0.5].

If the error, e(p), is positive, we need to increase perceptron output Y(p), but if it is negative, we need to decrease Y(p).

Perceptron’s training algorithm

Page 26: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 2: ActivationActivate the perceptron by applying inputs x1(p), x2(p),…, xn(p) and desired output Yd (p). Calculate the actual output at iteration p = 1

where n is the number of the perceptron inputs, and step is a step activation function.

Perceptron’s training algorithm (continued)

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

⎡θ−= ∑

=

n

iii pwpxsteppY

1)( )()(

Page 27: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 3: Weight trainingUpdate the weights of the perceptron

where is the weight correction at iteration p.The weight correction is computed by the delta rule:

Step 4: IterationIncrease iteration p by one, go back to Step 2 and repeat the process until convergence.

)()()1( pwpwpw iii Δ+=+

Perceptron’s training algorithm (continued)

)()()( pepxpw ii ⋅⋅α=Δ

Page 28: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Example of perceptron learning: the logical operation ANDInputs

x1 x2

0011

0101

000

EpochDesiredoutput

Yd

1

Initialweights

w1 w2

1

0.30.30.30.2

−0.1−0.1−0.1−0.1

0010

Actualoutput

Y

Error

e00

−11

Finalweights

w1 w20.30.30.20.3

−0.1−0.1−0.1 0.0

0011

0101

000

2

1

0.30.30.30.2

0011

00−1

0

0.30.30.20.2

0.0 0.0

0.0 0.0

0011

0101

000

3

1

0.20.20.20.1

0.0 0.0

0.0 0.0

0.0 0.0

0.0 0.0

0010

00

−11

0.20.20.10.2

0.0 0.0

0.0 0.1

0011

0101

000

4

1

0.20.20.20.1

0.1 0.1

0.1 0.1

0011

00

−10

0.20.20.10.1

0.1 0.1

0.1 0.1

0011

0101

000

5

1

0.10.10.10.1

0.1 0.1

0.1 0.1

0001

00

0

0.10.10.10.1

0.1 0.1

0.1 0.1

0

Threshold: θ = 0.2; learning rate:α = 0.1

Final Weightis used

in the next pattern p (each line)

Page 29: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Two-dimensional plots of basic logical operations

x1

x2

1

(a) AND (x1 ∩ x2)

1

x1

x2

1

1

(b) OR (x1 ∪ x2)

x1

x2

1

1

(c) Exclusive-OR(x1 ⊕ x2)

00 0

A perceptron can learn the operations AND and OR, but not Exclusive-OR.

Page 30: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Multilayer neural networksA multilayer perceptron is a feedforward neural network with one or more hidden layers. The network consists of an input layer of source neurons, at least one middle or hidden layer of computational neurons, and an output layer of computational neurons. The input signals are propagated in a forward direction on a layer-by-layer basis.

Page 31: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Multilayer perceptron with two hidden layers

Inputlayer

Firsthiddenlayer

Secondhiddenlayer

Outputlayer

O u

t p

u t

S i

g n

a l s

I n p

u t

S i

g n

a l s

Page 32: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

What does the middle layer hide?A hidden layer “hides” its desired output. Neurons in the hidden layer cannot be observed through the input/output behaviour of the network. There is no obvious way to know what the desired output of the hidden layer should be. Commercial ANNs incorporate three and sometimes four layers, including one or two hidden layers. Each layer can contain from 10 to 1000 neurons. Experimental neural networks may have five or even six layers, including three or four hidden layers, and utilise millions of neurons.

Page 33: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Back-propagation neural networkLearning in a multilayer network proceeds the same way as for a perceptron. A training set of input patterns is presented to the network. The network computes its output pattern, and if there is an error − or in other words a difference between actual and desired output patterns − the weights are adjusted to reduce this error.

Page 34: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

In a back-propagation neural network, the learning algorithm has two phases. First, a training input pattern is presented to the network input layer. The network propagates the input pattern from layer to layer until the output pattern is generated by the output layer. If this pattern is different from the desired output, an error is calculated and then propagated backwards through the network from the output layer to the input layer. The weights are modified as the error is propagated.

Page 35: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Three-layer back-propagation neural network

Inputlayer

xi

x1

x2

xn

1

2

i

n

Outputlayer

1

2

k

l

yk

y1

y2

yl

Input signals

Error signals

wjk

Hiddenlayer

wij

1

2

j

m

Page 36: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 1: InitialisationSet all the weights and threshold levels of the network to random numbers uniformly distributed inside a small range:

where Fi is the total number of inputs of neuron iin the network. The weight initialisation is done on a neuron-by-neuron basis.

The back-propagation training algorithm

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛+−

ii FF4.2 ,4.2

Page 37: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 2: ActivationActivate the back-propagation neural network by applying inputs x1(p), x2(p),…, xn(p) and desired outputs yd,1(p), yd,2(p),…, yd,n(p).(a) Calculate the actual outputs of the neurons in the hidden layer:

where n is the number of inputs of neuron j in the hidden layer, and sigmoid is the sigmoid activation function.

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

⎡θ−⋅= ∑

=j

n

iijij pwpxsigmoidpy

1)()()(

Page 38: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

(b) Calculate the actual outputs of the neurons in the output layer:

where m is the number of inputs of neuron k in the output layer.

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

⎡θ−⋅= ∑

=k

m

jjkjkk pwpxsigmoidpy

1)()()(

Step 2: Activation (continued)

Page 39: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 3: Weight trainingUpdate the weights in the back-propagation network propagating backward the errors associated with output neurons.(a) Calculate the error gradient for the neurons in the output layer:

where

Calculate the weight corrections:

Update the weights at the output neurons:

[ ] )()(1)()( pepypyp kkkk ⋅−⋅=δ

)()()( , pypype kkdk −=

)()()( ppypw kjjk δα ⋅⋅=Δ

)()()1( pwpwpw jkjkjk Δ+=+

Page 40: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

(b) Calculate the error gradient for the neurons in the hidden layer:

Calculate the weight corrections:

Update the weights at the hidden neurons:

)()()(1)()(1

][ p wppypyp jk

l

kkjjj ∑

=⋅−⋅= δδ

)()()( ppxpw jiij δα ⋅⋅=Δ

)()()1( pwpwpw ijijij Δ+=+

Step 3: Weight training (continued)

Page 41: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Step 4: IterationIncrease iteration p by one, go back to Step 2 and repeat the process until the selected error criterion is satisfied.

As an example, we may consider the three-layerback-propagation network. Suppose that the network is required to perform logical operation Exclusive-OR. Recall that a single-layer perceptron could not do this operation. Now we will apply the three-layer net.

Page 42: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Three-layer network for solving the Exclusive-OR operation

y55

x1 31

x2

Input layer

Output layer

Hidden layer

42

θ3w13

w24

w23

w14

w35

w45

θ4

θ5

−1

−1

−1

Page 43: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The effect of the threshold applied to a neuron in the hidden or output layer is represented by its weight, θ, connected to a fixed input equal to −1.The initial weights and threshold levels are set randomly as follows:w13 = 0.5, w14 = 0.9, w23 = 0.4, w24 = 1.0, w35 = −1.2, w45 = 1.1, θ3 = 0.8, θ4 = −0.1 and θ5 = 0.3.

Page 44: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

We consider a training set where inputs x1 and x2 are equal to 1 and desired output yd,5 is 0. The actual outputs of neurons 3 and 4 in the hidden layer are calculated as

[ ] 5250.01 /1)( )8.014.015.01(32321313 =+=θ−+= ⋅−⋅+⋅−ewxwx sigmoidy

[ ] 8808.01 /1)( )1.010.119.01(42421414 =+=θ−+= ⋅+⋅+⋅−ewxwx sigmoidy

Now the actual output of neuron 5 in the output layer is determined as:

Thus, the following error is obtained:

[ ] 5097.01 /1)( )3.011.18808.02.15250.0(54543535 =+=θ−+= ⋅−⋅+⋅−−ewywy sigmoidy

5097.05097.0055, −=−=−= yye d

Page 45: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

The next step is weight training. To update the weights and threshold levels in our network, we propagate the error, e, from the output layer backward to the input layer.First, we calculate the error gradient for neuron 5 in the output layer:

1274.05097).0( 0.5097)(1 0.5097)1( 555 −=−⋅−⋅=−= e y yδ

Then we determine the weight corrections assuming that the learning rate parameter, α, is equal to 0.1:

0112.0)1274.0(8808.01.05445 −=−⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα yw0067.0)1274.0(5250.01.05335 −=−⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα yw

0127.0)1274.0()1(1.0)1( 55 −=−⋅−⋅=⋅−⋅=θΔ δα

Page 46: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Next we calculate the error gradients for neurons 3 and 4 in the hidden layer:

We then determine the weight corrections:

0381.0)2.1 (0.1274) (0.5250)(1 0.5250)1( 355333 =−⋅−⋅−⋅=⋅⋅−= wyy δδ

0.0147.11 4) 0.127 ( 0.8808)(10.8808)1( 455444 −=⋅−⋅−⋅=⋅⋅−= wyy δδ

0038.00381.011.03113 =⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα xw0038.00381.011.03223 =⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα xw

0038.00381.0)1(1.0)1( 33 −=⋅−⋅=⋅−⋅=θΔ δα0015.0)0147.0(11.04114 −=−⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα xw0015.0)0147.0(11.04224 −=−⋅⋅=⋅⋅=Δ δα xw

0015.0)0147.0()1(1.0)1( 44 =−⋅−⋅=⋅−⋅=θΔ δα

Page 47: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

At last, we update all weights and threshold:

5038.00038.05.0131313 =+=Δ+= www

8985.00015.09.0141414 =−=Δ+= www

4038.00038.04.0232323 =+=Δ+= www

9985.00015.00.1242424 =−=Δ+= www

2067.10067.02.1353535 −=−−=Δ+= www

0888.10112.01.1454545 =−=Δ+= www

7962.00038.08.0333 =−=θΔ+θ=θ

0985.00015.01.0444 −=+−=θΔ+θ=θ

3127.00127.03.0555 =+=θΔ+θ=θ

The training process is repeated until the sum of squared errors is less than 0.001.

Page 48: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Learning curve for operation Exclusive-OR

0 50 100 150 200

101

Epoch

Su

m-S

qu

ared

Err

or

Sum-Squared Network Error for 224 Epochs

100

10-1

10-2

10-3

10-4

Page 49: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Final results of three-layer network learning

Inputs

x1 x2

1010

1100

011

Desiredoutput

yd

0

0.0155

Actualoutput

y5

Error

e

Sum ofsquarederrors

0.9849 0.9849 0.0175

−0.0155 0.0151 0.0151−0.0175

0.0010

Page 50: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

Network represented by McCulloch-Pitts model for solving the Exclusive-OR operation

y55

x1 31

x2 42

+1.0

−1

−1

−1+1.0

+1.0

+1.0

+1.5

+1.0

+1.0

+0.5

+0.5

Page 51: Artificial neural networks · Artificial neural networks: Introduction, or how the brain works The neuron as a simple computing element The perceptron Multilayer neural networks

(a) Decision boundary constructed by hidden neuron 3;(b) Decision boundary constructed by hidden neuron 4; (c) Decision boundaries constructed by the complete

three-layer network

x1

x2

1

(a)

1

x2

1

1

(b)

00

x1 + x2 – 1.5 = 0 x1 + x2 – 0.5 = 0

x1 x1

x2

1

1

(c)

0

Decision boundaries