Upload
blueiceland
View
231
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
1/7
As part of a study of the structural-functional correlations
o fe xc is ed h um a n lu ng s o bta in ed a t a uto ps y, t he p ar en ch ym a
and peripheral airw ays w ere exam ined by m eans of m or.
p ho me tric te ch niq ue s. A m on g th e 3 0 lu ng s c ha ra cte riz ed
b y th e a bse nc e o ffib ro sis , te n d iffe re d fro m th e n orm al a nd
em ph ysem ato us lu ng s b y a h om oge neo us d ilatatio n o f th e
airspaces, in excess of the dim ensions predicted on the
b asis o f ag e. S tu dy o f th e stan dard d eviatio ns o f th e m ea n
linear intercepts showed that the airspace dilatation was
m ore reg ular th an in em ph yse mato us lu ng s; in ad ditio n,
th ere w as n o cle ar-cu t destru ctio n, as estim ated from th e
number of alveolar attachm ents. These lungs were char
a cte ri ze d in a dd iti on b y a n in cr ea se d th ic ke nin g o f a lv eo la r
se pta , w ith ou t in fla mm atio n o r fib ro sis, n orm al s iz e o f th e
diam eter, and reduced density of the m em branous bron
ch io les. S in ce th ese lun gs w ere from p eo ple o ld er th an 6 0
y ea rs , it is a ss um e d th at th ey re pr es en t c as es o f e xa gg er ate d
airspace enlargement of the aging lung, differing from
e mp hy se ma b y th e a bs en ce o f d estru ctio n o f a lv eo la r w alls .
T he term senileungs p ropos ed f or t hi s cond it ion .
C h e s t 1 9 92 ; 1 0 1: 79 3 -9 9 )
AA = alveolar attachm ents; CLE centrilobular emphysema;
CV= coefficient of variation; J mean diameter; Lm m ean
linear intercept; Lm a Lm air; Lm w Lm wall m ean transec
tion length per airspace; n/sq cm density; N1 num ber of
intercepts; SDN ,standard deviation of N I
A recent report of the N ational H eart, Lung, and
Blood Institute' defines em physem a as a condi
tion ofthe lung characterized by abnorm al, perm anent
enlargem ent of airspaces, accom panied by the de
struction of their walls and without obvious fibrosis.
Destruction m ay be recognized by the disorder of the
respiratory a irsp aces. Singleirspace enlargement,
on the other hand, is described as an increase in
airspace size, distal to the term inal bronchioles, as
com pared w ith the airspaces of norm al lungs. There is
no evidence of destruction. The process m ay be
acquired, as in the uniform respiratory airspace en
largem ent of the aging lung.
In a study of the functional-m orphologic correlates
of em physem a, we exam ined a num ber of lungs
obtained at autopsy. Som e ofthese lungs were norm al;
others were clearly em physem atous. A third group of
lungs, however, demonstrated an enlargem ent of air
spaces, m arkedly larger than that expected on the
basis of aging alone. O riginally, our hypothesis w as
that these lungs dem onstrated panacinar em physem a.
However, the absence of any disorganization by low
power m agnification and of inflam mation at the level
of the airspaces and of the peripheral airways at the
m icroscopic level prom pted us to reconsider our
* F mm t he L a bo ra to ri um v oo r P n eu m ol og ie e n P at ho lo gi se he O n t
le ed ku nd e I U niv ersita ire Z ie ke nh uiz en S t. R afa el, G asth uisb erg ,
L eu ve n, B elg iu m.
S upported by a grant of the F onds voor G eneeskundig W eten
schappelijkOnderzoek.
M anuscript received February 14; revision accepted July 16.
R eprint requests: Dr. V arbeken,Laboratorium voor HLstopathologie ,
K a@ n jn en vo er 3 3, B -3 00 0 L , @ uv en ,Belgium
opinion. W e w ondered if w e w ere not dealing with
in stan ces o f ex ag gerated resp irato ry airsp ace enlarge
m ent rather than w ith em physem a. To substantiate
this im pression, we perform ed a system atic m orpho
m etric stud y o fairsp aces a nd m em bran ou s b ro nc hiole s
in an attem pt to distinguish on an objective basis these
lungs from norm al and truly em physem atous lungs.
M ATERIAL AND M ETHODS
Studies were performed on 17 right and 12 left human lungs and
one isolated left low er lobe (V 50), obtained a t autopsy. L ungs w ere
selected on the basis of absence of marked pleural adhesions and
l ea ks , g ro ss p ar en ch ym a l c on so lid at io ns , a nd /o r g en er al iz ed f ib ro sis .
M ost lungs w ere from patients w ho died of cardiovascular disease
or of m alignant neoplasm s. T he exa mined lungs represent a sam ple
that can be considered unselected at least from the population of
patients for whom an autopsy was being asked @ nour general
hospital. An exception was made for three lungs (V50, V51, V52)
th at w ere selected b eca use o f clin ica l sev ere ch ro nic o bstru ctiv e
l un g d is ea se a nd /o r th e p re su mp ti on o f a dv an ce d e mp hy se ma .
F ol lo win g t he f un ctio na l m ea su re me nts ( se e c om pa ni on a rti cle ),
t he l un gs w er e p er fu se d in tr ab ro nc hia lly f or a t l ea st 7 2 h w it h a 1 0
percent formalin solution, at a pressure of 2.5 to 3.0 kPa. W hole
lu ng sectio ns w ere p rep ared fro m 2 6 lu ng s fo llo win g th e tech niq ue
of Gough and W entworth.2 The lung was cut into 1.5-cm-thick
sagittal slices and a 0.4-m m-thic k w hole lung section w as prepare d
from the m idsa gittal slice. T he rem aining lung tissue of that section
w as also exam ined under the dissection m icroscope. The degree of
airspace enlargement was assessed on the whole lung section by
means of a plastic Ryder grid.@ This grid divides the lung in ten
equal radiating segm ents. To each segm ent an emp hysem ascore
from 0 (no enlargement) to 3 (severe enlargement) is given, the
m axim al score thus being 30. F inally, tis ie blocks w ere selected
according to the following protocol. Twelve to 15 random tissue
blocks w ere chosen from each lobe separately: the blocks w ere cut
from both upper and lower lobes parallel to and about 1 cm from
CHEST I 101 I 3 I M ARCH, 1992 793
TheSeni leLung*
Comparisonwith Normaland EmphysematousLungs
1 . Structural A spects
Erik K . Verbeken, M .D .; M ichel Cauberghs, B.S.; Ingrid M erten@ M .D .;
Jacques C lem ent, M .D .; Joseph M . L auw eryn@ s@ , .D ., P h.D .; and
K arel P Van de W oestijne, M . D . , P h.D .
wnloaded From: http://journal.publications.chestnet.org/ on 10/06/2013
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
2/7
ABCDuncan's
estAge,
yr49.1
20.369.94.861.36.5A,BB,CBody
le ng th , c m 16 6
1116691667A,
B,Emphysemascore1.21.69.14.614.35.4ABCLm,
mm0.2890.0390.4920.0940.5840.140ABCLm%predt105.69.5165.631.6203.047.2ABCNI5.490.723.260.552.84
CSDN,3.220.282.060.242.420.39ABCSDN/NI
x 100%59.34.264.07.487.5
11.0A,
CLma,
mm0.2650.0350.4530.0840.5300.123ABCLma%predt100.08.5156.028.8189.142.5ABCLmw,
mm0.0240.0050.0390.0110.0540.017ABCLmw%[email protected]@l,
mm0.800.090.850.140.510.09A,
Cn/sqcm0.850.110.700.150.640.11AB,CAA/mm6.720.876.750.915.760.72A,
BC
th e p leu ra l su rfac e. In co mp le te ly e xpa nd ed lu ng reg io ns w ere
carefully avo ided. P araffin sections, 4 @ tm hick, w ere prepared in a
standard way, and stained with M asson's trichrome. Since the
shrinka ge from fixe d lung to histologic slide is fairly constant even
in different pathologic conditions, a constant shrinkage factor of
0.61 w as used.' T he stained slices w ere exam ined by light m icros
c op y w it h a x 1 0 e ye pi ec e a nd a X 1 0 p Ia no -o bj ec ti ve ( m ag ni fi ca ti on
x 1 00).
T he m ean linear intercept, L m, w as m easured follow ing the
te ch niq ue o f D un nil l.' B ri efl y, c ro ss ed h ai r li ne s w ith k no wn l en gth
a re p ro je ct ed o n th e p ar en ch ym a, a nd t he i nte rs ec ti on s b et we en
lines and alveolar septa are counted.' The length ofthe line divided
by the num ber of intercepts (NI) yields Lm. To partition Lm into
its two com ponents, namely the m ean transection length, which
reflects the thickness of the septal wall (Lm wall:Lmw) and the
in te rn al d ia me te r o fth e a ir sp ac es (L m a ir :L ma ), D un nill's te ch niq ue
w as slightly m odified by adding a point counting m ethod. The hair
lin e w as d iv id ed in 1 00 eq ua lly d is ta nt p oin ts , w ith a p oin t sp acin g
o f t he la tt ic e ( Ze is s K pl W 1 0x / 18 ) o f 0 .0 09 55 m m a t a m ag ni fi
cation of 100 tim es. The sum of the points falling over the
parenchym a equa ls the tota l transection length of the parenchym a.
Dividing the latter by NI yields the m ean transection length per
airspace (Lmw). Two hundred points were counted for each of the
120 m icroscopic fields investigated per lung, thus ensuring a
s tatis tica lly re pre sen ta tiv e s am ple .@
Since Lm is known to be a hm ction of age in norm al lungs,6(b0
L m is expressed in percent predicted, using the regression of
Thurlbeck@ : Lm 0.0011 age+0.2174. In agreement with the data
of Thurlbeck, airspace enlargem ent w as considered to be exag
g er ate d w he n L m e xc ee de d 1 20 p e rc en t o fit s p re di ct ed v al ue .
T o e va lu ate o bje ctiv ely th e u nifo rm ity o f a ir sp ac e e nla rg em en t,
w e d ete rm in ed th e s ta nd ar d d ev ia ti on o f N I. T he l att er ( SD N ,)i s a
f un ct io n o f ( 1) t he i nh om og en ei ty o f t he a lv eo la r s iz es , a nd ( 2) t he
a ve ra ge a lv eo la r s iz e, th e la rg er t he a lv eo li , th e le ss th e n um b er o f
intersects (pro vided the optical m agn ification re mains constant),
and thus the sm aller S DN ,. A ccordingly , to estim ate the uniform ity
of airspace enlargem ent, w e used the coefficient of variation of N I:
S D N,d iv id ed b y t he m ea n v al ue o f N I. W it h t he e xc ep ti on o f t hr ee
l un gs . b ot h N I a nd S D N Iw e re a ls o d et er m in ed s ep ar at el y f or u pp er
a nd lo we r lo be s.
As an index for destruction, we counted the number of alveolar
a tta ch me nts o n m em bra no us b ro nc hio le s (th e n on alv eo la te d p erip h
eral airways w ithout cartilage or m ucous glands in their w alls) per
m il li me te r o fp er im e te r ( AA /m m ). 1 2 F or e ac h lu ng w e m e as ur ed
the internal diam eter and the corresponding A A from seven
m em branous bronchioles both in the upper and low er lobes. These
1 4 a ir wa ys , c ho se n a t r an do m, h ad to m ee t t he f oll ow in g c ri te ria :
their walls had not been sectioned because they were adjacent to
t he e dg e o ft he b lo ck , t he p or ti on b or de re d b y a cc om p an yi ng b lo od
vessels did not exceed 25 percent of the total perimeter, and the
s ec ti on w a s ( al m os t) c om p le te ly t ra ns ve rs al .
T h e i nt er na l d ia m et er o fa t l ea st 2 3 m e m br an ou s b ro nc hi ol es p er
lobe, with an internal diam eter of 2 m m or less, was m easured
f ol lo w in g t he t ec hn iq ue o fM a ts ub a a nd T h ur lb ec k. A ir wa y d en si ty
(n /s q cm ) w as def ined as t he num ber o f m em branous b ronch io le
a irw ays per square centim eter oflung tissue; n/sq cm w as m easured
b y a L eitz im age a nalysis system .
RESULTS
The lungs w ere divided into three groups on the
basis of the global aspect of the parenchym a on the
whole lung sections (exam ined by eye and under the
dissection m icroscope) and of the value of Lm . Lungs
of group A had a norm al aspect, the value of Lm did
not exceed 120 percent of expected. In the lungs of
groups B and C, the value of Lm w as higher than 120
percent. T he enlargem ent ofthe respiratory airspaces
w as hom ogeneous in group B, irregular in C. M or
phologically the lungs of group C were typical for
centrilobular em physem a (CLE). A ccording to the
clin ical histo ry , g ro up A co nsisted o f five n on sm ok ers,
four current sm okers, and one exsm oker. N one had a
history of chronic bronchitis. In group B, three sub
jects were sm okers, two w ere exsm okers, and one w as
a nonsm oker. The sm oking habits were not docu
m ented in three subjects. Two subjects had a history
ofchronic productive cough. Group C consisted of six
current sm okers, three exsm okers, one nonsm oker,
and one unknown. Eight subjects of group C had a
T ab le 1 B io me trica nd M o rp lso me tric D ata O ftlse T hre e G ro up s o flrn sg a: A N orm al,' B S en ile ;
C= Emphyseina tous b ings Mean ValuesStandard Deviat ion 5
*Duncan's multiple range test: the dashes indicate a significant (p
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
3/7
history ofchronic productive cough. The m ean values
(1 SD) of the biometr icand morphom etr icdataof
the three groups of lungs are listed in T able 1.
R es pira to ry A ir s p ac es
Liii: In agreem ent with Thurlbeck,6 Lm was found
to depend on age: a sim ilar age dependence was oh
served in the group of ten norm al lungs (Lm =
0.0014 age + 0.2202, p
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
4/7
a dd itio na l tio rin al lu ng s w e@ -c nc lu de d iii tlu ' n uh lti1 )lc
regression . ) Both Li@ a and Lin@ v a re sign ifican tl@
d ifferen t @ tfl1O I1 ghe threc g,oii@ )s of slil)jccts, @ tIS()
@@he nh e@ ' a rc ( o rrec te(l fo r ag e (L n@ a), u r fo r ag e,
height, and lung @ @ eightL iii@ @ )(T ab le 1 ). A tig ht
correlation @ @ sound l)et\v('('ll Lii@ a and L,ii@ @ f or the
three gronp@ of lungs coiisidered together (r: 0.95,
1)
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
5/7
relationship is found in em physematous lungs between
d and Lm a (r: 0.68; p
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
6/7
lungs. T he latter increase in thickness, also described
by Anderson et al,'@ '@in em physem atous lungs is not
easily observed by eye: it is only in advanced em phy
sem a th at a d iffu se th ick en in g o fth e w alls su rro un ding
large holes is noticed. S im ple histologic exam ination
does not reveal any differences betw een the increase
in Lm w in groups B and C.
T he d en sity ofm em bran ou s b ro nchioles is g en era lly
reduced in em physem atous lungs2@ ': this is in
agreement with our findings in CLE. A similar reduc
tion in density is observed in the lungs ofgroup B. On
the other hand, bronchiolar diam eter is norm al in
group B and decreased in em physem a. The latter
decrease accom panied by an excess of airways with a
diam eter of 0.6 mm or less has been docum ented
p re vio us ly b y o th er s.'3 '2 ' @@@@r on ch io la r d ia m et er
and density are negatively correlated in both groups
A and B. This relationship, observed by M atsuba and
Thurlbeck'4 in nonem physem atous lungs and by N agai
et aP@ in patients with airflow obstruction is not
observed in em physem atous lungs (Fig 4). In the
latter, we found in agreem ent with M itchell et aP'nd
H ale et aF n eg ativ e c orrelatio n b etw een b ro nch io lar
diam eter and the severity of em physem a, expressed
by the size of Lm .
The reduction of bronchiolar diam eter is m ore
pronounced in the lower than in the upper lobes in
CLE . In contrast, Lm is larger in the upper lobes.
This is in agreem ent with the data of Berend,37 who
observed m ore bronchiolar inflam fnation and narrow
ing in the lower lobes in CLE and suggested that
different m echanism s m ay he responsible for sm all
airways narrow ing and alveolar enlargem ent and/or
destruction. On the other hand, w e observed an
inverse relationship in CL E betw een L m and diam eter
in both upper and lower lobes, considered separately.
This, in turn, supports the classic idea of a direct
c ausal relatio nsh ip b etw een sm all airw ay ab no rm ality
and the occurrence of em physem a.@ '
In a study of 80 lungs from nonsm okers, A nderson
et al@ observed the presence of m ild to m oderate
em physem a of the panacinar type in 20 elderly sub
jects (60 years or older). T here w as a diffuse dilatation
of alveolar spaces, distributed m ore or less evenly
throughout secondary lobules and lobes or lung. A l
veolar walls were often thickened by subtle, diffuse
interstitial inflam mation. There w as rupture of alveolar
structures w ith occasional sim ple dilatation. W e sub
m it that a num ber of these lungs m ight be categorized
as senile lungs. The distinction between m ild panaci
nar em physem a and senile lungs is often very difficult
by v isu al insp ectio n.3 7 It is im portant th at qu an tita
tive techniques are developed further for separation
o fb or de rl in e c as es ( eq ui vo ca l m ph ysem ato us areas
ofThurlbeck@ ). W e suggest that the determ ination of
the CV of the num ber of intercepts, counted to
determ ine L m, is useful for this purpose: a value of
70 percent appears to separate quite well emphysem
atous from norm al and senile lungs.
REFERENCES
1 S nider G L, K leinerm an J, T hurlheck W M , B engali Z H. T he
definition ofem physem a: report ofa National H eart, Lung, and
B lood Institute, Division of Lung Diseases W orkshop. A m R ev
R es pi r D is 1 98 5; 1 32 :1 82 -8 5
2 G ough J, W entw orth JE. Thin sections ofentire organs m ounted
on paper. In: Recent advances in pathology London: J A
C hurchill L td, 1960:80-6, cha p 3
3 Ryder RC, Thurlbeck W M, Cough J. A study of interobserver
v aria tio n in th e a ssessm en t o f th e a mo un t o f p ulm on ary em ph y
sem a in papee.m ounted whole lung sections. Am R ev R espir Dis
1969;99:354-64
4 Van Brabandt H, Cauberghs M , V erbeken E, M oerm an P.
L auw eryns JM , V an de W oe stijne K P P artition ing of pulm onary
impedance in excised human and canine lungs. J AppI Physiol
1983 ; 85 :1733-42
5 Dunnill M S. Quantitative m ethods in the study of pulmonary
p ath ol og y. T ho ra x 1 96 2; 1 7:3 20 -2 8
6 T hu rlb ec k W M , T h e in te rn al su rf ac e a re a o f n on em ph yse ma to us
lu ng s. A m R ev R esp ir D is 1 96 7; 9 5:7 65 -7 3
7 W eibel ER. Stereological m ethods. London: Academ ic Press,
1980
8 G rea ve s IA , C oleb atc h H JH . E las tic be hav io r an d struc ture o f
norm al and em physem atous lungs post m ortem . Am R ev Respir
D is 1 98 0; 1 21 :1 27 -3 6
9 Niewoehner DE, Kleinerman J, Liotta L. Elastic behavior of
p os tm o rte m h um a n l un gs : e ffe cts o fa gin g a nd m ild e mp hy se ma .
J ApplPhysiol1975;39:943-49
10 W illem s L NA , K ram ps JA , S tijnen T , S terk P J, W eening JJ,
D ijkm an JH . R elation betw een sm all airw ays disease and
parenchym al destruction in surgical lung specim ens. Thorax
1990 ; 45 :89 -94
1 1 T hu rlb ee k W M . I nt er na l s ur fa ce a re a o fn or ma l a nd e mp hy se m
atous lu ngs. T enth A sp en E mphy sem a C onfere nce, 1967:37 9-93
12 Saetta M , Chezzo H, Kim W D, King M , Angus GE, W ang NS,
et a l. L oss o f a lv eo la r a tta ch me nts in s mo kers : a m orp ho metric
co rrela te o flu ng fu nctio n im pa irm en t. A m R ev R esp ir D is 1 98 5;
132:894-900
1 3 A nd er so n A EJ r, F or ak er A G . R ela tiv e d im en sio ns o f b r on ch io le s
and parenchym al spaces in lungs from norm al subjects and
em physem atous patients. A m J M ed 1962; 32:218-26
14 M atsuba K , T hurlbeck W M . T he num ber and dim ensions of
sm all airw ays in nonem physem atous lungs. A m R ev R espir Dis
1971 ; 194:516-24
1 5 S ae tta M , S hin er R J, An gu s G E, K im W D , W an g NS , K in g M ,
e t a l. D es tr uc tiv e i nd ex : a . m ea su re me nt o f lu ng p ar en ch ym al
de struction in sm okers. A m R ev R espir D is 1985; 131:764-69
16 M atsuba K, Ikeda T, Nagai A , Thurlbeck W M. The National
I ns tit ute s o f H ea lth I nte rm it te nt P os it iv e- Pr es su re B re at hin g
T ri al : p at ho lo gy s tu d ie s: I V. t he d es tr uc ti ve in d ex . A m R ev
R es pi r D is 1 98 9; 1 39 :1 43 9- 45
17 Saito K, Cagle P. Berend N, Thurlbeck W M . The destructive
in dex ' in n on em ph ysem ato us a nd em ph ysem ato us lu ng s: m or
phologic observations and correlation w ith function. A m R ev
R es pi r D is 1 98 9; 1 39 :3 08 -1 2
18 Thurlbeck W M . Internal surface area and other m easurem ents
in e mp hy se ma . T ho ra x 1 96 7; 2 2:4 83 -9 6
19 W est W W , N agai A , H odg kin JE , T hurlbeck W M. T he N ational
Institutes of H ealth Interm ittent Positive-Pressure Breathing
T ria l: p ath olo gy S tu dies: II I. th e d ia gno sis o f em ph ys em a. A m
R ev R esp ir D is 1 98 7; 1 35 :1 23 -2 9
20 Berend W , W oolcock AJ, M arlin GE. Correlation between the
79 8
The Sen il e Lung,Par t 1 :St ructu ra l Aspec t s (Wrbeken eta )
wnloaded From: http://journal.publications.chestnet.org/ on 10/06/2013
7/25/2019 1992 - The Senile Lung
7/7
function and structure of the lung in sm okers. Am Rev Respir
D is 1 97 9; 1 19 :6 95 -7 05
21 B ignon J, A ndre-Bougaran J, B rouet C . Parenchym al, bronchi
olar and bronchial m easure ments in centrilobular em physem a.
Thorax 1970; 25:556-67 @ .
22 Petty TL, Silvers GW , Stanford RE. Radial traction and small
airways disease in excised human lungs. Am Rev Respir Dis
1986 ; 133:132-35
23 Linhartova A , Anderson A E Jr. Foraker A G. R adial traction and
bronchiolar obstruction in pulm onary em physem a. A rch P athol
L ab M ed 1 97 1; 9 2:3 84 -9 1
24 Linhartova A , Anderson A E Jr, Foraker AG . Aflixm ent arrange
m en ts o f p er ib ro nc hio la r a lv eo li in n or ma l a nd e mp hy se ma to us
lungs. A rch Pathol Lab M ed 1982; 106:499-502
25 A nderson A E Jr, F urlaneto JA , F oraker A G. B ronchopulm ona ry
de rangem ents in nonsm okers. A m R ev R espir D is 1 970; 101:518-
27
26 Depierre A, Bignon J, Lebeau A, Brouet G. Quantitative study
of pa renchym a and sm all conductive airw ays in chronic nonspe
c ific lu ng d is ea se . C he st 1 97 2; 6 2:6 99 -7 06
27 M atsuba K, Thurlbeck W M . Disease of the small airways in
c hro nic b ro nc hitis. A m R ev R esp ir D is 1 97 3; 1 07 :5 52 -5 8
28 A nderson AE Jr. Foraker AG . Populations of nonrespiratory
bronchioles in pulm onary emphysema. Arch Pathol Lab M ed
1967 ; 83 :286-92
29 M atsuba K, Thurlbeck W M . The number and dim ensions of
sm all airways in em physem atous lungs. Am J Pathol 1972;
67:265-75
30 Linhartova A, Anderson AE Jr, Foraker AG. Further observa
tions on luminal deformity and stenosis of nonrespiratory
bronchioles in pulm ona ry em physem a. Thorax 1977; 32:53-9
31 Petty TL, Silvers GW , Stanford RE. M ild em physem a is
associated with seduced elastic recoil and increased lung size
but not w ith air'flow lim itation. A m R ev R espir D is 1987;
136:867-71
32 Cosio M G, Hale KA, Niewoehner DE. M orphologic and
m orphom etric effects of prolonged cigarette smoking on the
sm all a irw ay s. A m R ev B esp ir D is 1 98 0; 1 22 :2 65 -7 1
33 Hale KA, Ewing SL, Cosnell BA, Niewoehner DE. Lung
disease in long-term cigarette sm okers w ith and w ithout chronic
a ir .fl ow o bs tr uc tio n. A m R ev R es pi r D is 1 98 4; 1 30 :7 16 -2 1
34 Nagai A, W est W W , Paul JL, Thurlbeck W M . The National
I ns tit ute s o f H ea lt h I nte rm it te nt P os it iv e- Pr es su re B re ath in g
T rial: pathology studies: I. interrelationship betw een m orpho
lo gic le sio ns. A m R ev R es pir E M s 19 85 ; 1 32 :9 37 -4 5
35 Petty TL, Silvers GW , Stanford RE. The m orphology and
m orphom etry of sm all airways disease (relevance to chronic
obstructive pulm ona ry disease). Trans C lin C lim at A ssoc 1983;
94:130-40
36 M itchell RS, Stanford RE, Johnson JM , Silvers GW , Dart C,
George M S. The m orphologic features ofthe bronchi, bronchi
o les , a n d a lv e ol i in c h ro n ic a ir w a y o b st ru c tio n: a c lin ic o pa t ho lo g ic
study. A m R ev R espir D is 1976; 114:137-45
37 Berend N. Lobar distribution of bronchiolar inflam mation in
e m ph ys em a . A m R e v R e sp ir D i s 1 98 1; 1 24 :2 18 -2 0
38 Leopold JC, Cough J. The centrilobular form of hypertrophic
e m ph ys em a a nd i ts r el at io n t o c hr on ic b ro nc hi ti s. T h or ax 1 95 7;
12:219-35
39 Thurlbeck W M. Chronic airflow obstruction in lung disease.
P hiladelp hia: W B S aunde rs C o, 1976
CHEST I 101 I 3 I MARCH, 1992 799